Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

Bake Me a Wish Review: Cheesecake Delivery

We've analyzed the best Cheesecake Delivery to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

What is the best place to order cheesecake delivery?  If you have ever found yourself raiding the fridge after dinner in search of something sweet, creamy, and full of flavor, you know that a sudden craving for cheesecake is a fix that needs a very specific treat. We're right there with you.

2.5

FAIR

7

Fair

  • Prices from $52 to $58 per cheesecake
  • 11 flavors to choose from
  • Refunds for damaged goods
  • Happiness guarantee
  • and 2-day shipping
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

FAIR

2.5

On the Bake Me a Wish website

Bake Me a Wish is a gourmet dessert shop known for providing cheesecake delivery across the US. The bakery was founded in 2005, and specializes in birthday cakes, cupcakes, and (of course) cheesecakes. Bake Me a Wish is located in New York and offers its high-quality desserts and treats with reliable overnight shipping, so you know the items will arrive fresh and ready. Whether you want a variety gift basket or a full-size cheesecake, you can definitely get your cheesecake fix here.

Choose from 11 flavors

When you dive into the flavors offered at Bake Me a Wish, you'll find lots of fun staples as well as some holiday flavors, too. From classic New York cheesecake to holiday specials like eggnog or pumpkin, you can get cheesecakes for any time of the year. Some of the best treat flavors include mango, apple pie, peanut butter cup, and brownie (with fudgy brownies as the topping... yum). There are a total of 11 cheesecake flavors to choose from for your cheesecake delivery at this bakery.

Shipping costs from $15.99 to $27.99

To order a cheesecake from Bake Me a Wish, click on the flavor you want and choose your cheesecake delivery date. The closest upcoming delivery date will be listed already (usually one day from when you order), but you can order ahead for a special occasion, too. Next-day shipping costs $22.99, and 2-day shipping costs $15.99 on top of the cost of your cheesecake. If you want your cheesecake delivered on a Saturday, there will be a $5 upcharge for next-day shipping and a $2 upcharge for 2-day shipping.

Best Cheesecakes

$52 to $58 per cheesecake

Bake Me a Wish's cheesecakes range from $52 to $58 depending on which cheesecake you get. There aren't any special deals for ordering multiple or a subscription plan for regular cheesecake deliveries at this site. But, make sure you keep the shipping charges in mind: most shipments will be between $70 and $80 at the final price.

Refunds for damaged orders

This cheesecake delivery site requires that all orders be placed by 4:30 PM (ET) to ship the following day. You will receive notifications as soon as your cheesecake delivery is at the door, so you or the lucky recipient can pick it up and put it in the fridge. As an added bonus, Bake Me a Wish offers a "happiness guarantee," which offers a full or partial refund if you have a damaged or late delivery. You'll need to contact customer support with images within 14 days of receiving your dessert.

Good quality, but some shipments go missing

Bake Me a Wish has an outstanding "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, on third-party review sites like Trustpilot, the feedback is a little more mid-tier. Bake Me a Wish has a 3.7-star average out of 5 on Trustpilot: while most recent reviews within the last few weeks are a full 5 stars (with high praise for fast delivery and taste of the treats), there were also a comparable number of 1-star ratings. Customers had troubles with cheesecake deliveries not arriving when scheduled, and they were frustrated when Bake Me a Wish blamed UPS rather than taking responsibility. The main complaint is that items never arrive, and customers do not receive refunds for their trouble.

Amazing flavor, but not reliable

If you want true, authentic New York cheesecake delivery, Bake Me a Wish is a fun choice. However, with some increasing issues with shipping reliability, it doesn't score as high as it could if we were just considering how tasty their cheesecakes look (and are reviewed as). Due to the shipping concerns (since cheesecake delivery honestly can't work without good delivery), it earns a below average score in our review. But if you live in New York, you should check out Bake Me a Wish for tasty treats.

On the Bake Me a Wish website

Continued from above...

What is the Best Place to Order Cheesecake Delivery?

If you have ever found yourself raiding the fridge after dinner in search of something sweet, creamy, and full of flavor, you know that a sudden craving for cheesecake is a fix that needs a very specific treat. We're right there with you.

Sometimes a standard grocery store slice of cheesecake just won't cut it when your heart is set on that perfect, velvety texture and tasty baked crust. Whether you are dreaming of a traditional New York-style cheesecake or a double chocolate fudge, there is a dedicated world of cheesecake delivery services ready to satisfy your sweet tooth.

The best part about these digital dessert shops is the variety of ways you can indulge, tailored to exactly how much sweetness you need. If you are a true cheesecake fan, you might join a "Cheesecake of the Month" club, which is a cheesecake delivery option that ships a fresh, seasonal flavor to your doorstep on a recurring subscription. For those who find it impossible to pick just one topping, many sites offer "sampler" wheels or tasting arrays that combine four or more distinct flavors, like White Chocolate Raspberry, Turtle, and Key Lime, into a single cheesecake. Of course, if you're planning a quiet night in or a celebration for a group of friends, you can always opt for a one-time order to make your dessert a standout that everyone will be talking about.

Scheduling your cheesecake delivery is faster and more reliable than ever, thanks to shipping practices that are now designed specifically for perishable goods. You no longer have to worry about your dessert melting in transit; most top-tier sites use custom-insulated coolers and dry ice to ensure your cheesecake arrives perfectly chilled or frozen, even during the peak of summer (yes, even for you Floridians, Texans, and Arizonians who have oven-like temperatures).

Shopping online allows you to browse live inventory, select your preferred delivery date weeks in advance, and track your package in real-time. Many platforms even offer next-day air options, meaning that a last-minute realization that you forgot a birthday dessert doesn't have to end in disaster.

To ensure you are getting the absolute best deals, check for cheesecake delivery sites that have seasonal savings or discounts if you pre-order a certain number of months in your subscription. Many of the most trustworthy sellers will provide helpful instructions on the best way to defrost your cheesecake so it tastes exactly like it was just freshly-baked in your kitchen. Yum.

To make sure you satisfy your sweet tooth with the best possible cheesecake delivery service, we've put together a few tips to consider as you narrow down the tastiest options:

So, if you can't kick that cheesecake craving, don't worry - we've got your back. Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake delivery services out there, so you don't have to run to the grocery store: you can get top-notch cheesecakes sent right to your door. Now you can relax and enjoy a sweet treat (or a surprise cheesecake every month). Save a piece for us!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Cheesecake Delivery FAQ

How does ordering cheesecake online work?
Online cheesecake shops and bakeries make it easy to order tasty treats and have them delivered right to your door - or someone else's, if you're feeling generous. It works like any other shopping spree (just tastier!), and in as little as two days, you'll have cheesecake on your doorstep. Ordering cheesecake online is a great way to satisfy your cravings or spice up a special occasion.
How does the cheesecake stay fresh during shipping?
Most bakeries use insulated packaging and fast shipping (which can get expensive). This keeps the cheesecake chilled during transit. Some bakeries will flash-freeze your cheesecake before shipping it to make extra sure it doesn't go bad if you live in a warmer climate.
Can I customize the cheesecake flavors or toppings?
Definitely! While this depends on the site you buy from, most bakeries allow you to choose extra add-ons or toppings for your cheesecake. Some sites have pre-made designs, but others have drizzles, crumbles, and different crusts you can change out. A few bakeries even offer a "design your own cheesecake" option.
Are there options for dietary restrictions?
Yes! Many cheesecake services offer gluten-free, sugar-free, or keto-friendly cheesecakes. Just check your favorite cheesecake bakery's website to see what accommodations they have. Not all bakeries are the same, so it's always best to dive into the ingredients.
What if you want to send cheesecake as a gift?
Go right ahead! Most bakery sites make gifting easy with options to include a personalized message or extras to make your cheesecake gift special. Some sites are even designed for gifting or offer clubs that you can use to send multiple cheesecakes per year to a loved one's door.
How long does it take to get my cheesecake?
Delivery times may vary from bakery to bakery. Some allow you to schedule your shipping date, so you know exactly when it will arrive. Standard shipping for most bakeries is 2-5 days. However, the shipping is generally expedited to make sure your treats don't spoil in the mail. This can make it extra costly, though.
Is it expensive to order cheesecake online?
The final cost of your cheesecake will depend on the size, flavor, and where you buy from. In general, most cheesecakes cost between $30-$100. Shipping is generally where the price goes up, so keep an eye out for bakeries that offer lower-cost shipping to keep your cheesecake treat within budget.
Will you need to thaw the cheesecake before eating it?
Most cheesecakes arrive frozen or semi-frozen, so you'll want to thaw them in the fridge for a few hours before serving. If you get multiple, you can put the ones you don't want directly in the freezer to keep for months if you need to. The packaging usually includes clear instructions for the best thawing results.

Compare Any 2 Products

The New York Cheesecake Company
Cheesy Eddie's
Muddy Paws Cheesecake
Eli's Cheesecake
Junior's Cheesecake
Carnegie Deli
Bake Me a Wish
David's Cookies
Harry & David
vs
The New York Cheesecake Company vs Cheesy Eddie'sThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Eli's CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Junior's CheesecakeThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Carnegie DeliThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Bake Me a WishThe New York Cheesecake Company vs David's CookiesThe New York Cheesecake Company vs Harry & DavidCheesy Eddie's vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Eli's CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Junior's CheesecakeCheesy Eddie's vs Carnegie DeliCheesy Eddie's vs Bake Me a WishCheesy Eddie's vs David's CookiesCheesy Eddie's vs Harry & DavidMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Eli's CheesecakeMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Junior's CheesecakeMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs David's CookiesMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidEli's Cheesecake vs Junior's CheesecakeEli's Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliEli's Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishEli's Cheesecake vs David's CookiesEli's Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidJunior's Cheesecake vs Carnegie DeliJunior's Cheesecake vs Bake Me a WishJunior's Cheesecake vs David's CookiesJunior's Cheesecake vs Harry & DavidCarnegie Deli vs Bake Me a WishCarnegie Deli vs David's CookiesCarnegie Deli vs Harry & DavidBake Me a Wish vs David's CookiesBake Me a Wish vs Harry & DavidDavid's Cookies vs Harry & David Harry & David vs David's CookiesHarry & David vs Bake Me a WishHarry & David vs Carnegie DeliHarry & David vs Junior's CheesecakeHarry & David vs Eli's CheesecakeHarry & David vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeHarry & David vs Cheesy Eddie'sHarry & David vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyDavid's Cookies vs Bake Me a WishDavid's Cookies vs Carnegie DeliDavid's Cookies vs Junior's CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Eli's CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeDavid's Cookies vs Cheesy Eddie'sDavid's Cookies vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyBake Me a Wish vs Carnegie DeliBake Me a Wish vs Junior's CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Eli's CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeBake Me a Wish vs Cheesy Eddie'sBake Me a Wish vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyCarnegie Deli vs Junior's CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Eli's CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeCarnegie Deli vs Cheesy Eddie'sCarnegie Deli vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyJunior's Cheesecake vs Eli's CheesecakeJunior's Cheesecake vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeJunior's Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sJunior's Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyEli's Cheesecake vs Muddy Paws CheesecakeEli's Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sEli's Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie'sMuddy Paws Cheesecake vs The New York Cheesecake CompanyCheesy Eddie's vs The New York Cheesecake Company
See the Best Cheesecake Delivery in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Cheesecake | Delivery Near Me

Cheesecake | Delivery Near Me - Doordash

Get Cheesecake products delivered to your door in as fast as 1 hour. Shop your favorite products online and enjoy the same-day speed and reliability of DoorDash.

Sun, 09 Aug 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Mason's Cheesecake Co (@masons

Mason's Cheesecake Co (@masonscheesecakeco) - Instagram

1,969 Followers, 1,164 Following, 919 Posts - Mason's Cheesecake Co (@masonscheesecakeco) on Instagram: "⭐️Voted The Best Cheesecakes In PNW⭐️ 📍 Puyallup & Proctor Farmers Market, Every Saturday at 9am to 2pm 📦Ship & Delivery #everycheesecakehasastory"

Mon, 20 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Cheesecake Products Near Me -

Cheesecake Products Near Me - Delivery or Pickup | Instacart

Buy your favorite Cheesecake online with Instacart. Order Cheesecake from local and national retailers near you and enjoy on-demand, contactless delivery or pickup within 2 hours.

Sun, 02 Aug 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The Cheesecake Factory | Menu,

The Cheesecake Factory | Menu, Locations & Reservations

Over 250 menu items, freshly prepared and from scratch, to order, every day. Over 30 legendary cheesecakes and desserts. There's something for everyone! Order online today!

Mon, 10 Aug 2026

Only the Best Reviews

TOP 10 BEST Cheesecake Bakery

TOP 10 BEST Cheesecake Bakery in Puyallup, WA - Yelp

Top 10 Best Cheesecake Bakery in Puyallup, WA - Last Updated June 2026 - Yelp - The Cat & Rabbitt Cake Shop, Fika, Corina Bakery, Wanna Cupcake? Bakery Cafe, Lulu’s Bakery Shop, Spilled Butter Desserts, 85°C Bakery Cafe-Federal Way, Side Piece Kitchen, Celebrity Cake Studio, GoodBelly

Fri, 10 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

TOP 10 BEST Cheesecakes in Puy

TOP 10 BEST Cheesecakes in Puyallup, WA - Updated 2026 - Yelp

Top 10 Best Cheesecakes in Puyallup, WA - Last Updated July 2026 - Yelp - Puyallup Valley Jam Factory, The Cat & Rabbitt Cake Shop, Nothing Bundt Cakes, Fika, Corina Bakery, The Cheesecake Factory, The Shortcake Bar, Emish Market, Wanna Cupcake?

Sun, 02 Aug 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.