Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Carnegie Deli Review

Wednesday, February 12th

2025 Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

Carnegie Deli Review 3.5 Star Rating

Carnegie Deli

3.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $79 to $109 for a single cheesecake
  • 6 cheesecakes in stock
  • Mini cheesecakes offered
  • New York-style
  • A one-stop shop with New York goodies
  • Some refunds for damaged goods
  • 4.5-star average rating

Carnegie Deli started out as a place to grab corned beef and pastrami in New York City. This deli has an impressive 80-year history and remains a family-owned shop downtown. On top of deli favorites, like franks and mustard or potato knish, Carnegie Deli offers a range of desserts, including black and white cookies as well as New York Cheesecake and cheesecake bites. Carnegie Deli is a favorite of stars, authors, and icons all over New York and has served major names like Robin Williams and Stevie Wonder.

Detailed listings, but missing allergy details

Shopping for cheesecake on Carnegie Deli's website is simple. You can jump right into browsing cheesecake under the bestsellers menu or select the "desserts” tab on the top navigation bar. The cheesecake listings on Carnegie Deli include helpful photos (and some of them have animations) as well as star ratings for each cheesecake and the pricing. When you click through to an individual cheesecake, you'll see a full description of each cheesecake, including the flavors, crust type, and storage instructions (for freezing or refrigerating). However, the site doesn't have details for allergies.

Best Cheesecakes

Pick from 6 flavors and mini-sizes

There are 6 flavors of cheesecake at Carnegie Deli. This is pretty limited compared to other sites in our review. You can find a basic New York Cheesecake in full size rounds (8” or 10”) and mini cheesecakes (4”). The rest of the flavors are pretty basic with Chocolate Marble and Birthday Cake standing out as the most exciting flavors. There was one seasonal flavor at the time of our review (Pumpkin), but nothing unique compared to other candy-themed or "hot cocoa” cheesecakes seen at other bakeries.

Prices from $79 to $109 for a single cheesecake

All of the 8-inch cheesecakes at Carnegie Deli are $79. The mini cheesecakes (which come in a pack of four) are also $79. The most expensive cheesecake is the pre-sliced 10-inch New York-style cheesecake that serves up to 16 people for $109. This can be a little pricey, but if you're planning to feed a lot of folks, this may be a great place to try. On the bright side, shipping is free at Carnegie Deli, which can help keep costs down if you pick one of the more costly cheesecakes.

Refund options when cheesecakes have defects

While there isn't a refund guarantee at Carnegie Deli, the site notes that you can email their customer service if there are any problems with your orders. If your cheesecake comes damaged or defective, you can request a refund or replacement. You'll need to provide an image of the cheesecake as proof when you contact customer service to be eligible for a reship or refund.

Best Cheesecakes

Not a lot of buzz for cheesecake specifically

Carnegie Deli doesn't have a page with the Better Business Bureau or trusted third-party review sites like Trustpilot, but there are some reviews for Carnegie Deli on Tripadvisor and Yelp. Customers on Trustpilot rated it a 4.5-star rating overall. On Yelp, the feedback is more balanced with a 3.3-star average. While most of the reviews are for the pastrami sandwiches, there are a few mentions of the "delicious” cheesecake that customers tried while they were at Carnegie Deli.

Fun mom-and-pop bakery with history

Carnegie Deli is a great place to try if you want a mom-and-pop feel and traditional homemade New York Cheesecake. However, if you're looking for a ton of unique cheesecakes or different styles, you'll be disappointed by the limited flavors at Carnegie Deli. With so few reviews for the cheesecake itself, Carnegie Deli comes in about average for cheesecakes, but its free shipping earns it a slightly higher rating overall. It's a great stop if you love a traditional New York Cheesecake.

Where is the Best Place to Find Cheesecake?

Imagine this: you're curled up on the couch after a long day, dinner is done, your favorite show is on, and all you can think about is sinking your fork into a slice of rich, creamy cheesecake. Sounds like a dream, right? But where do you get your delectable treat?

While you can run to your local grocery store for a decent cheesecake, if you're looking for that top-tier smooth and creamy experience, you want to go to the experts. Whether you're a die-hard fan of classic New York-style cheesecake or looking for a brand new flavor to try, there are plenty of services online that deliver cheesecakes right to your door.

The Best Cheesecake Delivery Compare Cheesecake Delivery Compare Cheesecake Delivery Reviews What are the best Cheesecake Delivery Best Cheesecake Delivery Reviews

Cheesecake Delivery FAQ

Online cheesecake shops and bakeries make it easy to order tasty treats and have them delivered right to your door - or someone else's, if you're feeling generous. It works like any other shopping spree (just tastier!), and in as little as two days, you'll have cheesecake on your doorstep. Ordering cheesecake online is a great way to satisfy your cravings or spice up a special occasion.
Most bakeries use insulated packaging and fast shipping (which can get expensive). This keeps the cheesecake chilled during transit. Some bakeries will flash-freeze your cheesecake before shipping it to make extra sure it doesn't go bad if you live in a warmer climate.
Definitely! While this depends on the site you buy from, most bakeries allow you to choose extra add-ons or toppings for your cheesecake. Some sites have pre-made designs, but others have drizzles, crumbles, and different crusts you can change out. A few bakeries even offer a "design your own cheesecake” option.
Yes! Many cheesecake services offer gluten-free, sugar-free, or keto-friendly cheesecakes. Just check your favorite cheesecake bakery's website to see what accommodations they have. Not all bakeries are the same, so it's always best to dive into the ingredients.
Go right ahead! Most bakery sites make gifting easy with options to include a personalized message or extras to make your cheesecake gift special. Some sites are even designed for gifting or offer clubs that you can use to send multiple cheesecakes per year to a loved one's door.
Delivery times may vary from bakery to bakery. Some allow you to schedule your shipping date, so you know exactly when it will arrive. Standard shipping for most bakeries is 2-5 days. However, the shipping is generally expedited to make sure your treats don't spoil in the mail. This can make it extra costly, though.
The final cost of your cheesecake will depend on the size, flavor, and where you buy from. In general, most cheesecakes cost between $30-$100. Shipping is generally where the price goes up, so keep an eye out for bakeries that offer lower-cost shipping to keep your cheesecake treat within budget.
Most cheesecakes arrive frozen or semi-frozen, so you'll want to thaw them in the fridge for a few hours before serving. If you get multiple, you can put the ones you don't want directly in the freezer to keep for months if you need to. The packaging usually includes clear instructions for the best thawing results.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Cheesecake is a baked custard, and its origins trace back to ancient Greece. Modern cheesecake has four main "styles”: New York, which relies on cream cheese for its rich texture, Italian, which uses cottage cheese or ricotta as its base, German cheesecakes which are made with quark (a soft dairy), and French, which is unbaked and served chilled. Most of the sites in our review cover New York cheesecake, which is considered the creamiest and most decadent of the four.

From classic vanilla bean to red velvet, or unique flavors like holiday hot cocoa, there are hundreds of flavors you can try. Whether you're hunting for a specific cheesecake for your holiday get-together or you just want to try new cheesecakes you can't get at your local shops, choosing a bakery that offers delivery services is a great way to expand your cheesecake horizons. These businesses bring gourmet-quality bakes straight to your door so you can enjoy your favorite dessert without the hassle.

Back in the day, if you wanted high-quality baked goods, you'd have to hope that a decent bakery opened in your area. Now, online bake stores make it easier than ever to enjoy cheesecake without needing to drive for hours (or rely on your local Cheesecake Factory location to have an open table). With just a few clicks, you'll have rich, creamy, professionally-made cheesecakes delivered fresh to your door. What could be better than that?

If you're ready to stock your fridge with cheesecake but aren't sure where to start, we've got you covered. Here are some factors that can help you pick the best cheesecake service:

  • Cost. Cheesecake is a world-class treat, and you'll want to get your money's worth. See if the service you're shopping with offers bundles or deals to get as much cheesecake as you need without breaking the bank. Make sure you take into account things like shipping to make sure you're getting a good deal for the cheesecake you order.
  • Variety. There are so many cheesecake flavors to try, and you don't want to miss out. Make sure you pick a cheesecake bakery with plenty of styles and flavors, so when you want to try something new, you can stay with a baker you already trust.
  • Dietary restrictions. If you're on a special diet, don't worry. Plenty of cheesecake services offer gluten-free, keto, or sugar-free options. There are even a few vegan desserts depending on where you buy. Make sure your chosen bakery offers the right type of cheesecake for you.
  • Reputation. Check your preferred cheesecake bakery and delivery service with trusted third-party review sites like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Other cheesecake lovers can help you decide if a site is worth your time and money or if you want to stay away from high prices and low-quality treats.

There's no better time to dive into the world of delicious cheesecakes than right now. To help you satisfy your sweet tooth, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake services out there today. From classic flavors to creative new twists, you're sure to discover your next creamy favorite. Bon appetit!

Compare Cheesecake Delivery

Select any 2 Cheesecake Delivery to compare them head to head

best-cheesecake-delivery
  • The New York Cheesecake Company
  • Juniors Cheesecake
  • Bake Me a Wish!
  • Muddy Paws Cheesecake
  • Carnegie Deli
  • Eli's Cheesecake
  • Cheesy Eddie's
  • David's Cookies
  • Harry & David
  • The Swiss Colony
The New York Cheesecake Company vs Juniors Cheesecake The New York Cheesecake Company vs Bake Me a Wish! The New York Cheesecake Company vs Muddy Paws Cheesecake The New York Cheesecake Company vs Carnegie Deli The New York Cheesecake Company vs Eli's Cheesecake The New York Cheesecake Company vs Cheesy Eddie's The New York Cheesecake Company vs David's Cookies The New York Cheesecake Company vs Harry & David The New York Cheesecake Company vs The Swiss Colony Juniors Cheesecake vs Bake Me a Wish! Juniors Cheesecake vs Muddy Paws Cheesecake Juniors Cheesecake vs Carnegie Deli Juniors Cheesecake vs Eli's Cheesecake Juniors Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie's Juniors Cheesecake vs David's Cookies Juniors Cheesecake vs Harry & David Juniors Cheesecake vs The Swiss Colony Bake Me a Wish! vs Muddy Paws Cheesecake Bake Me a Wish! vs Carnegie Deli Bake Me a Wish! vs Eli's Cheesecake Bake Me a Wish! vs Cheesy Eddie's Bake Me a Wish! vs David's Cookies Bake Me a Wish! vs Harry & David Bake Me a Wish! vs The Swiss Colony Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs Carnegie Deli Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs Eli's Cheesecake Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie's Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs David's Cookies Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs Harry & David Muddy Paws Cheesecake vs The Swiss Colony Carnegie Deli vs Eli's Cheesecake Carnegie Deli vs Cheesy Eddie's Carnegie Deli vs David's Cookies Carnegie Deli vs Harry & David Carnegie Deli vs The Swiss Colony Eli's Cheesecake vs Cheesy Eddie's Eli's Cheesecake vs David's Cookies Eli's Cheesecake vs Harry & David Eli's Cheesecake vs The Swiss Colony Cheesy Eddie's vs David's Cookies Cheesy Eddie's vs Harry & David Cheesy Eddie's vs The Swiss Colony David's Cookies vs Harry & David David's Cookies vs The Swiss Colony Harry & David vs The Swiss Colony
Compare the Best Cheesecake Delivery
- VS -
Review the Best Cheesecake Delivery
The Best Reviews of Cheesecake Delivery