What is the best place to order cheesecake delivery?  If you have ever found yourself raiding the fridge after dinner in search of something sweet, creamy, and full of flavor, you know that a sudden craving for cheesecake is a fix that needs a very specific treat. We're right there with you.
Cheesy Eddie's is a family-owned bakery that offers cheesecake delivery. Based in Rochester, New York, Cheesy Eddie's has been around since 1976 and is known for its all-natural cheesecakes, cakes, and novelty desserts. All of the treats at Cheesy Eddie's are baked from scratch, so you know there are no additives, and everything has a yummy personal touch.
Order regular, gluten-free, or sugar-free
Cheesy Eddie's has plenty of cheesecakes to explore, with 26 total cheesecakes on the menu for cheesecake delivery. Some of these are repeat flavors with different baking styles, like gluten-free or sugar-free, for those who want something sweet without any worries about health concerns. Cheesy Eddie's also offers samplers with 4 flavors in one, so if you just can't decide (same), you can grab a variety with your order. Some of our favorite flavors we saw at Cheesy Eddie's include:
Pick your size and ship
Once you've decided on a tasty option for your cheesecake delivery, finishing your order is a piece of (cheese) cake (wink, wink). First, you choose your size between a 1 lb cheesecake, which serves 3-4 people, or a 2 lb cheesecake, which serves 7-10. Once you pick your size, you'll be directed to check out through the Shop app. Shipping costs are separate at Cheesy Eddie's, so make sure you check out the fees for your area. 2-day shipping was offered for $35.92 to our location, and 1-day shipping was $78.90. (Ouch...)
$39.95 to $64.95 per cheesecake
Pricing for the cheesecakes themselves makes up for the hefty shipping costs. The 1 lb option for cheesecake delivery ranges from $28.95 to $30.95, and the 2 lb option ranges from $39.95 to $43.95. There are some options that come in 4 lb sizes (like the samplers), which go up to $64.95 total. Once you add shipping, prices can be anywhere from $70 to $140, depending on how fast you want your cheesecake.
No listed refund policy
Cheesy Eddie's does not have a listed refund policy for its cheesecake delivery. The Shop app sometimes provides a return or refund policy itself, but for this retailer, there wasn't one listed. So, if something goes wrong with your order, you'll need to contact Cheesy Eddie's to get things sorted out.
Rave reviews for cheesecake
Cheesy Eddie's, like many of the mom-and-pop cheesecake delivery sites in our review, does not have a page with the Better Business Bureau or on Trustpilot. Instead, we had to focus our research on sites like TripAdvisor and Yelp, since most feedback for Cheesy Eddie's is from customers who have visited the bakery in person. Currently, Cheesy Eddie's has an impressive 4.8-star average out of 5. Customers leave rave reviews for this bakery, with particularly high praise for the cheesecake. There were even a few customers on Yelp who left reviews for the delivery service. One customer who ordered a sampler said that the order was prompt and had zero problems with shipping or spoilage.
Best family-owned cheesecake delivery
If you're looking for a mom-and-pop place that has reviews for its cheesecake delivery and rave reviews for flavors, you'll definitely want to check out Cheesy Eddie's. This is a fantastic spot if you're craving traditional New York cheesecake, and it supports dietary restrictions, so you won't be left out if you're watching your sugar intake or can't have gluten. Overall, Cheesy Eddie's is a top-notch pick, with lower prices per cheesecake and impressive reviews across the board.
Continued from above...
If you have ever found yourself raiding the fridge after dinner in search of something sweet, creamy, and full of flavor, you know that a sudden craving for cheesecake is a fix that needs a very specific treat. We're right there with you.
Sometimes a standard grocery store slice of cheesecake just won't cut it when your heart is set on that perfect, velvety texture and tasty baked crust. Whether you are dreaming of a traditional New York-style cheesecake or a double chocolate fudge, there is a dedicated world of cheesecake delivery services ready to satisfy your sweet tooth.
The best part about these digital dessert shops is the variety of ways you can indulge, tailored to exactly how much sweetness you need. If you are a true cheesecake fan, you might join a "Cheesecake of the Month" club, which is a cheesecake delivery option that ships a fresh, seasonal flavor to your doorstep on a recurring subscription. For those who find it impossible to pick just one topping, many sites offer "sampler" wheels or tasting arrays that combine four or more distinct flavors, like White Chocolate Raspberry, Turtle, and Key Lime, into a single cheesecake. Of course, if you're planning a quiet night in or a celebration for a group of friends, you can always opt for a one-time order to make your dessert a standout that everyone will be talking about.
Scheduling your cheesecake delivery is faster and more reliable than ever, thanks to shipping practices that are now designed specifically for perishable goods. You no longer have to worry about your dessert melting in transit; most top-tier sites use custom-insulated coolers and dry ice to ensure your cheesecake arrives perfectly chilled or frozen, even during the peak of summer (yes, even for you Floridians, Texans, and Arizonians who have oven-like temperatures).
Shopping online allows you to browse live inventory, select your preferred delivery date weeks in advance, and track your package in real-time. Many platforms even offer next-day air options, meaning that a last-minute realization that you forgot a birthday dessert doesn't have to end in disaster.
To ensure you are getting the absolute best deals, check for cheesecake delivery sites that have seasonal savings or discounts if you pre-order a certain number of months in your subscription. Many of the most trustworthy sellers will provide helpful instructions on the best way to defrost your cheesecake so it tastes exactly like it was just freshly-baked in your kitchen. Yum.
To make sure you satisfy your sweet tooth with the best possible cheesecake delivery service, we've put together a few tips to consider as you narrow down the tastiest options:
So, if you can't kick that cheesecake craving, don't worry - we've got your back. Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cheesecake delivery services out there, so you don't have to run to the grocery store: you can get top-notch cheesecakes sent right to your door. Now you can relax and enjoy a sweet treat (or a surprise cheesecake every month). Save a piece for us!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.