Who's better?

Chocolate of the Month Club vs Amazing Clubs

We've analyzed the best Chocolate Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Chocolate Club Reviews

Here you can see how Chocolate of the Month Club and Amazing Clubs match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Chocolate Clubs in 2026.

Chocolate of the Month Club

  • Pricing from $119.90 to $683.40 per subscription
  • Free shipping
  • 1 pound of chocolate per shipment

Chocolate of the Month Club is run by Clubs of America and specializes in sending a full pound of gourmet chocolate clusters, barks, and truffles with each shipment. Subscribers can pick from 2- to 12-month plans, and while the cost is on the higher side, all deliveries include free shipping. This chocolate club has an "A+" BBB rating, but limited variety and no refund policy, which keeps it from earning a higher rating in our review.

Winner

Amazing Clubs

  • Pricing from $42.95 to $54.95 per month
  • Free shipping
  • 1 pound of chocolate per shipment

Amazing Clubs is our top pick for chocolate subscriptions, offering over a pound of hand-crafted treats each month, along with a newsletter that explains what's inside. The chocolate club at Amazing Clubs gives you total control over your subscription, making it a great option for gifts. With prices starting at $42.95 per month, free shipping, and a refund policy for unused months, this highly-rated service is a favorite for chocolate fans looking for quality and flexibility, earning the #1 spot in our review.

Sweet and creamy or rich and dark, chocolate is the go-to confection when you want a dessert to remember. Maybe you crave bonbons with surprise centers, a classic bar, or strawberries dipped in chocolate - there's a treat for every taste. From mellow milk and silky white to that gloriously bitter-yet-smooth bite of dark, you can indulge whenever the mood strikes. It's perfect for gifting a loved one - anniversary ideas, anyone? - and just as good for sneaking a little pick-me-up for yourself during the day. It even pairs beautifully with a cup of coffee or a glass of red, turning an ordinary moment into something special. We get it - chocolate's where it's at.

Finding truly exceptional chocolate can feel like a small adventure. Maybe you're craving German bars that melt in your mouth, Russian squares with that clean snap and silky finish, or bonbons hiding praline, raspberry, or caramel - either way, getting the treat you want matters. The trouble is, grocery aisles lean toward candy, which is tasty but not always what you need when you're after the good stuff. Hunting down a local chocolatier can be fun, sure, yet ordering online - or better yet, joining a chocolate club - makes it easy to score great prices, discover standout flavors, and get exactly what you're after without extra effort. Many clubs even curate limited releases and seasonal boxes so you can sample what small-batch makers are creating right now.

If you're serious about chocolate, a club membership is a game changer - regular deliveries keep your stash stocked while rotating selections make every box feel new. Whether you're after a steady supply or itching to sample different flavors and brands each month, these subscriptions have you covered. You choose how often boxes arrive, when they start, and the schedule that fits your routine, so you get your treats on your terms with total flexibility. Many clubs even include tasting notes, pairing tips, or limited-edition bars to elevate the experience, making each shipment something delicious to anticipate.

Beyond keeping you stocked with sweets, a chocolate club introduces you to flavors from around the world, from single-origin bars to unexpected pairings. If you're bored with the usual store offerings - or another basic heart-shaped box - a monthly subscription is an easy way to stretch your palate and find new favorites. Prefer the classics? Many clubs let you stick to familiar treats, so your pantry's always filled with the bars you crave. Some even include tasting notes and maker stories, turning a simple snack into a small adventure.

There are so many reasons to subscribe to a chocolate club: as a gift, as a snack, as an "I'm thinking of you," or just a way to treat yourself. But, with so many sites offering chocolate clubs, it can be hard to find the best pick. To make it easier, we simplified things with a quick list of factors that can help you decide:

No matter what your reasons are for grabbing some, you can't go wrong with chocolate (yes, that's our completely unbiased opinion). So, don't stress about finding the best chocolate clubs out there. That's what we're here for. Top Consumer Reviews has done the work to research and rank some of today's most popular subscriptions. This way, you can sit back and enjoy your chocolate treats with zero stress, just like you deserve. Bon appétit!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Chocolate Club FAQ

Where does the Chocolate come from?
That depends on the club you select. Some chocolate clubs specialize in single-source, small-batch chocolates that are hand-crafted by artisans around the world. Others provide a more traditional experience with boxed chocolates or bars you might find in a specialty store near you.
How often will the Chocolate be delivered?
Most chocolate clubs give you a range of options: monthly, every other month, or quarterly. You can usually choose how many total deliveries you would like as well, from three-month plans to a full year.
Are Chocolate clubs expensive?
They can be, but you'll find affordable options too. On average, your chocolate club will cost somewhere between $17 and $59 per month. Most clubs include shipping in those prices.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Many chocolate clubs go the extra mile to make sure that you - or your lucky gift recipient - are 100% satisfied with every delivery, giving you a full refund or shipping a replacement if something isn't right. However, not every company provides this level of customer service. It's a good idea to check out the policies (and reputation) of each club before making your purchase.
My chocolate is going someplace warm. Will it melt?
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
Are Chocolate clubs legitimate?
Absolutely! Some of the top chocolate clubs have been around for decades, with a long track record of customer satisfaction.
What about allergies? Can I customize my deliveries if there's something I can't have?
That's a great question. If you or your recipient have food allergies, you'll need to consider the options very carefully. Unfortunately, most clubs don't let you customize your deliveries beforehand: "you get what you get". There are a few that let you preview each month's delivery and skip it for any reason, and some are developing an "allergy-free" club membership that avoids the top known allergens.
Do Chocolate clubs make good gifts?
Of course: who doesn't love chocolate? Chocolate clubs are a great way to send a little taste of joy for months to come. Your selected club may have gift options like emailed or printed announcements, gift wrapping, or add-on treats and toys to make your deliveries even more special. Many chocolate clubs also include a fun newsletter, providing interesting facts about chocolate, the background of the specific chocolates in the box, and even recipes!

Compare Any 2 Products

Amazing Clubs
Bar & Cocoa
Kekao
The Secret Chocolatier
Phillips Chocolates
Chocolate of the Month Club
Mystery Chocolate Box
Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club
Harry & David
Jackie's Chocolate
vs
Amazing Clubs vs Bar & CocoaAmazing Clubs vs KekaoAmazing Clubs vs The Secret ChocolatierAmazing Clubs vs Phillips ChocolatesAmazing Clubs vs Chocolate of the Month ClubAmazing Clubs vs Mystery Chocolate BoxAmazing Clubs vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubAmazing Clubs vs Harry & DavidAmazing Clubs vs Jackie's ChocolateBar & Cocoa vs KekaoBar & Cocoa vs The Secret ChocolatierBar & Cocoa vs Phillips ChocolatesBar & Cocoa vs Chocolate of the Month ClubBar & Cocoa vs Mystery Chocolate BoxBar & Cocoa vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubBar & Cocoa vs Harry & DavidBar & Cocoa vs Jackie's ChocolateKekao vs The Secret ChocolatierKekao vs Phillips ChocolatesKekao vs Chocolate of the Month ClubKekao vs Mystery Chocolate BoxKekao vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubKekao vs Harry & DavidKekao vs Jackie's ChocolateThe Secret Chocolatier vs Phillips ChocolatesThe Secret Chocolatier vs Chocolate of the Month ClubThe Secret Chocolatier vs Mystery Chocolate BoxThe Secret Chocolatier vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubThe Secret Chocolatier vs Harry & DavidThe Secret Chocolatier vs Jackie's ChocolatePhillips Chocolates vs Chocolate of the Month ClubPhillips Chocolates vs Mystery Chocolate BoxPhillips Chocolates vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubPhillips Chocolates vs Harry & DavidPhillips Chocolates vs Jackie's ChocolateChocolate of the Month Club vs Mystery Chocolate BoxChocolate of the Month Club vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubChocolate of the Month Club vs Harry & DavidChocolate of the Month Club vs Jackie's ChocolateMystery Chocolate Box vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubMystery Chocolate Box vs Harry & DavidMystery Chocolate Box vs Jackie's ChocolateGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Harry & DavidGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Jackie's ChocolateHarry & David vs Jackie's Chocolate Jackie's Chocolate vs Harry & DavidJackie's Chocolate vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubJackie's Chocolate vs Mystery Chocolate BoxJackie's Chocolate vs Chocolate of the Month ClubJackie's Chocolate vs Phillips ChocolatesJackie's Chocolate vs The Secret ChocolatierJackie's Chocolate vs KekaoJackie's Chocolate vs Bar & CocoaJackie's Chocolate vs Amazing ClubsHarry & David vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month ClubHarry & David vs Mystery Chocolate BoxHarry & David vs Chocolate of the Month ClubHarry & David vs Phillips ChocolatesHarry & David vs The Secret ChocolatierHarry & David vs KekaoHarry & David vs Bar & CocoaHarry & David vs Amazing ClubsGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Mystery Chocolate BoxGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Chocolate of the Month ClubGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Phillips ChocolatesGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs The Secret ChocolatierGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs KekaoGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Bar & CocoaGourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Amazing ClubsMystery Chocolate Box vs Chocolate of the Month ClubMystery Chocolate Box vs Phillips ChocolatesMystery Chocolate Box vs The Secret ChocolatierMystery Chocolate Box vs KekaoMystery Chocolate Box vs Bar & CocoaMystery Chocolate Box vs Amazing ClubsChocolate of the Month Club vs Phillips ChocolatesChocolate of the Month Club vs The Secret ChocolatierChocolate of the Month Club vs KekaoChocolate of the Month Club vs Bar & CocoaChocolate of the Month Club vs Amazing ClubsPhillips Chocolates vs The Secret ChocolatierPhillips Chocolates vs KekaoPhillips Chocolates vs Bar & CocoaPhillips Chocolates vs Amazing ClubsThe Secret Chocolatier vs KekaoThe Secret Chocolatier vs Bar & CocoaThe Secret Chocolatier vs Amazing ClubsKekao vs Bar & CocoaKekao vs Amazing ClubsBar & Cocoa vs Amazing Clubs
See the Best Chocolate Clubs in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Mug Cake Recipe | Ree Drummond

Mug Cake Recipe | Ree Drummond | Food Network

Learn how to make a single serving of chocolate cake in the microwave with Ree Drummond’s easy mug cake recipe. Plus, discover our best mug cake recipes including gluten-free mug cake and hot ...

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Chocolate-Covered Strawberries

Chocolate-Covered Strawberries - Food Network

Strawberries covered with chocolate are elegant and easy to make. Get Food Network Kitchen’s chocolate-covered strawberries recipe, strawberry decorating tips and more.

Wed, 04 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Chocolate Lava Cakes Recipe |

Chocolate Lava Cakes Recipe | Ree Drummond | Food Network

Microwave the butter, bittersweet chocolate and semisweet chocolate in a large bowl on high until the butter is melted, about 1 minute. Whisk until the chocolate is also melted.

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cooki

Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies - Food Network Kitchen

Stir chocolate chips and walnuts, if using, and stir to distribute evenly. For cookies: Drop dough by tablespoonfuls onto greased baking sheets and bake about 10 minutes. Cool on a baking rack.

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The Best Chocolate Mousse - Fo

The Best Chocolate Mousse - Food Network Kitchen

The best chocolate mousse must be perfect. It should taste rich, indulgent and not too sweet, with a texture that is both light-and-airy and silky-and-smooth. After many attempts we nailed it and ...

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Chocolate Pots de Crème Recip

Chocolate Pots de Crème Recipe | Geoffrey Zakarian | Food Network

Shut off the heat and add the chocolate, vanilla bean paste and salt. Allow the mixture to sit for about 30 seconds, then whisk to combine. Immediately pour into four espresso cups or 4-ounce ...

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.