Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Mystery Chocolate Box Review

Wednesday, February 12th

2025 Chocolate Club Reviews

Mystery Chocolate Box Review 4 Star Rating

Mystery Chocolate Box

4 Star Rating
  • Priced from $63.95 to $224.95, depending on club length
  • $19.95/month on recurring subscription
  • Chocolate Selection: 3 chocolate bars per month, flavors vary
  • Duration: 3, 6 or 12 months, or month-to-month recurring
  • Frequency: monthly
  • Shipping: approximately $16.75 per delivery

Are you intrigued by mystery flavors when you spot them on the shelf at the store? From Mountain Dew to Twizzlers, it's a trend sweeping the food scene. But what if we told you there's a chocolate club that turns this concept into a delectable guessing game? Welcome to the world of Mystery Chocolate Box, our favorite chocolate bar-focused club.

Are you up for a guessing game?

How does it work? With three full-sized chocolate bars in each box, the outer wrappers are removed and labeled A, B, and C. Your task? Uncover the ingredients within. For those up for a challenge, you can submit your guesses on the club's site and vie for a spot on the leaderboard. Imagine identifying unique elements like goji berries, lemongrass and cardamom, or champagne - just a glimpse of what past Mystery Chocolate Box selections have featured.

Gift-giving features are a little limited

While Mystery Chocolate Box shines in creativity, it's important to note some limitations in its gift-giving options. If you'd like a gift card, it's available at $1.99, whether mailed directly or sent to you to be given in person. Unfortunately, email announcements aren't on the menu. On the plus side, you can choose a start date for deliveries, up to 6 months ahead.

Best Chocolate Clubs

Not ideal if you suffer from common food allergies

What about allergies? In the past, Mystery Chocolate Box used to leave the original product label intact under the A-B-C wrapper, but since they've added a guessing leaderboard to their features, that's no longer the case. They recommend that if you have food allergies to any ingredients common to chocolate (like nuts or gluten), you pass on buying a subscription here. But, if you have minor allergies that go beyond the top 8, you can request a replacement of any chocolate bars that wind up having ingredients you can't have. The easiest way to find out what's in the bars? Submit your guesses to the leaderboard.

Meals donated to charity for every box sold

One standout aspect is the club's commitment to charity. For each box delivered, two meals are donated to fight hunger, bridging the gap between enjoying chocolates and making a difference. The company partners with organizations both within the US and worldwide, contributing to global hunger relief.

Rewards for the taking

Adding to the appeal here is the Cacao Points rewards program. Points can be earned by subscribing, referring friends, leaving reviews, and accurately guessing those chocolate flavors. These points can be redeemed in Mystery Chocolate Box's a la carte chocolate shop or put towards a free monthly box.

Best Chocolate Clubs

Go month-to-month or prepay for a set timeframe

You can set up this chocolate club as a non-recurring plan lasting 3, 6, or 12 months; these are priced at $63.95, $118.95, and $224.95, respectively. Or, if you know that you just want to keep the treats coming nonstop, Mystery Chocolate Box also offers a month-to-month option for $19.95.

Shipping is super-spendy but total price is still on par

Shipping is where you're really going to spend a lot with this chocolate club. It varies by month and by delivery location (because of the need to include cold packs to warmer destinations, especially in the summer), but in subscribing to the 12-month plan with shipment to Florida, we were charged a hefty $201 on top of our membership price of $224.95 - bringing our total to $425.95 for a year of chocolate. On the one hand, that's not much different from most of Mystery Chocolate Bar's rivals - it just feels like more when you get the initial shock of seeing the shipping fees almost equal to the subscription cost. On the other hand, it's up to you to determine if that price is worth getting just three chocolate bars per month, when many competitors give you more for the same price.

Cancel anytime for a prorated refund

While a satisfaction guarantee isn't explicitly stated here, you have the flexibility to cancel your Mystery Chocolate Box membership anytime and receive a prorated refund for undelivered boxes. Although we don't love that the only way to do so is via email or online form, we've found that the customer service team is responsive and helpful, making sure any issues are addressed promptly.

Best Chocolate Clubs

Customers are fans of this fun way to try new chocolate flavors

And, the good news is that you'll probably not need to test out the customer service here, because across the board people love this chocolate club. Out of nearly 200 reviews, the rating average is a near-perfect 4.8 out of 5 stars. Many of those who get Mystery Chocolate Box as a gift wind up loving it so much, they subscribe for themselves after their plan runs out - or they turn around and gift it to someone else. And, of course, the mystery aspect gets lots of compliments for bringing a new level of fun to chocolate-tasting, even when they're flavors that aren't a big hit in and of themselves (like that lemongrass one we mentioned).

Unique among chocolate clubs

Mystery Chocolate Box elevates the chocolate experience by infusing it with an element of intrigue. Whether you savor them solo, share the fun with loved ones, or challenge coworkers, the chocolates in this club are bound to delight. When it comes to chocolate bars, Mystery Chocolate Box's club earns our strong recommendation.

Which Chocolate Club is the Best?

Chocolate clubs are more popular now than ever before - and it's easy to see why. These clubs offer a delightful experience that goes way beyond just eating chocolate.

First and foremost, the universal love for chocolate is a central driver of chocolate club popularity. Chocolate has been a beloved treat for centuries, transcending age, gender, and cultural boundaries. Its rich, indulgent flavor provides a comforting escape from the ordinary, making it a universal pleasure. Chocolate subscription clubs tap into this passion, transforming it into a regular, eagerly anticipated event, offering a dependable source of joy in the subscribers' lives.

The Best Chocolate Clubs Compare Chocolate Clubs Compare Chocolate Club Reviews What are the best Chocolate Clubs Best Chocolate Club Reviews

Chocolate Club FAQ

That depends on the club you select. Some chocolate clubs specialize in single-source, small-batch chocolates that are hand-crafted by artisans around the world. Others provide a more traditional experience with boxed chocolates or bars you might find in a specialty store near you.
Most chocolate clubs give you a range of options: monthly, every other month, or quarterly. You can usually choose how many total deliveries you would like as well, from three-month plans to a full year.
They can be, but you'll find affordable options too. On average, your chocolate club will cost somewhere between $17 and $59 per month. Most clubs include shipping in those prices.
Many chocolate clubs go the extra mile to make sure that you - or your lucky gift recipient - are 100% satisfied with every delivery, giving you a full refund or shipping a replacement if something isn't right. However, not every company provides this level of customer service. It's a good idea to check out the policies (and reputation) of each club before making your purchase.
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
Absolutely! Some of the top chocolate clubs have been around for decades, with a long track record of customer satisfaction.
That's a great question. If you or your recipient have food allergies, you'll need to consider the options very carefully. Unfortunately, most clubs don't let you customize your deliveries beforehand: "you get what you get". There are a few that let you preview each month's delivery and skip it for any reason, and some are developing an "allergy-free" club membership that avoids the top known allergens.
Of course: who doesn't love chocolate? Chocolate clubs are a great way to send a little taste of joy for months to come. Your selected club may have gift options like emailed or printed announcements, gift wrapping, or add-on treats and toys to make your deliveries even more special. Many chocolate clubs also include a fun newsletter, providing interesting facts about chocolate, the background of the specific chocolates in the box, and even recipes!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Variety is another important part of a chocolate club. Many chocolate subscription clubs carefully curate diverse selections of high-quality chocolates. These selections often include chocolates with varying cocoa percentages, origins, flavor profiles, and forms, such as bars, truffles, and pralines. The promise of new and diverse chocolate flavors and textures with each delivery keeps subscribers engaged and excited. This continuous variety fosters a sense of anticipation and curiosity.

Another reason why chocolate clubs are so popular is their convenience. In our fast-paced modern world, convenience is a highly prized commodity. Chocolate subscription clubs offer a hassle-free solution for accessing gourmet chocolates. Subscribers receive their personally selected chocolates at regular intervals, eliminating the need to shop for high-quality chocolates or search for unique, artisanal brands. This ease of access aligns with the preferences of busy individuals who want to savor life's finer pleasures.

Before diving in, it's important to figure out what kind of chocolate you're into. Do you find yourself craving a beautiful mix of milk and dark chocolates all wrapped up? Or are you more of a connoisseur, excited about single-source bars that melt in your mouth and bring out unique flavors? Chocolate is so universally-loved that even the Aztecs thought cacao seeds were a gift from a wise god.

Considering how much chocolate we all eat - about 11 pounds per person per year in America alone - is it any surprise that chocolate clubs have become a huge hit? These memberships deliver amazing truffles, bars, and tasty bites right to your door. The best part? Experts in chocolate hunt down the most delicious and interesting flavors for you to enjoy, and all you have to do is sit back and wait not-so-patiently for your box to arrive.

And if you're thinking about giving a chocolate club membership as a gift, you're on the right track. You can choose how often the chocolates are delivered, whether it's every month or every few months, usually for up to a year. Imagine getting chocolate regularly - that sounds like a pretty sweet deal.

Of course, not all chocolate clubs are the same. Some focus on bars, others put together mixed boxes similar to what you'd find for special occasions like Valentine's Day, and some are a surprise each time. As you think about your options, here are a few things to consider:

  • Variety. What kinds of chocolates are in the club? Will you get a mix of different ones? And if you have allergies or specific preferences, does the club have options for you?
  • Flexibility. Can you choose how often you receive chocolates? Some clubs offer different delivery choices, like every month or every other month, and most will let you choose when you'd like the deliveries to start (right away or for a special future date on the calendar). Do you need to pay in full or can you pay as you go?
  • Value. Is the chocolate club worth the money? Maybe you could find something similar at a local shop or from another online subscription. It's okay to spend more for amazing chocolates, but not all clubs are worth the cost.
  • Reputation. What do people who've tried the chocolate club say? Does the company guarantee that you'll be happy with what you get?

At Top Consumer Reviews, we've looked at and ranked the best chocolate clubs out there. We hope this info helps you choose the perfect club: whether it's for you or someone else, a chocolate club can bring months of delightful chocolatey moments.

Compare Chocolate Clubs

Select any 2 Chocolate Clubs to compare them head to head

best-chocolate-clubs
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club
  • Chocolate of the Month Club
  • Mystery Chocolate Box
  • Bar & Cocoa
  • Harry & David
  • Kekao
  • Vosges
  • Fine Chocolate Club
  • Jackie's Chocolate
Amazing Clubs vs Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club Amazing Clubs vs Chocolate of the Month Club Amazing Clubs vs Mystery Chocolate Box Amazing Clubs vs Bar & Cocoa Amazing Clubs vs Harry & David Amazing Clubs vs Kekao Amazing Clubs vs Vosges Amazing Clubs vs Fine Chocolate Club Amazing Clubs vs Jackie's Chocolate Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Chocolate of the Month Club Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Mystery Chocolate Box Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Bar & Cocoa Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Harry & David Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Kekao Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Vosges Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Fine Chocolate Club Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club vs Jackie's Chocolate Chocolate of the Month Club vs Mystery Chocolate Box Chocolate of the Month Club vs Bar & Cocoa Chocolate of the Month Club vs Harry & David Chocolate of the Month Club vs Kekao Chocolate of the Month Club vs Vosges Chocolate of the Month Club vs Fine Chocolate Club Chocolate of the Month Club vs Jackie's Chocolate Mystery Chocolate Box vs Bar & Cocoa Mystery Chocolate Box vs Harry & David Mystery Chocolate Box vs Kekao Mystery Chocolate Box vs Vosges Mystery Chocolate Box vs Fine Chocolate Club Mystery Chocolate Box vs Jackie's Chocolate Bar & Cocoa vs Harry & David Bar & Cocoa vs Kekao Bar & Cocoa vs Vosges Bar & Cocoa vs Fine Chocolate Club Bar & Cocoa vs Jackie's Chocolate Harry & David vs Kekao Harry & David vs Vosges Harry & David vs Fine Chocolate Club Harry & David vs Jackie's Chocolate Kekao vs Vosges Kekao vs Fine Chocolate Club Kekao vs Jackie's Chocolate Vosges vs Fine Chocolate Club Vosges vs Jackie's Chocolate Fine Chocolate Club vs Jackie's Chocolate
Compare the Best Chocolate Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Chocolate Clubs
See the Best Chocolate Club
The Best Reviews of Chocolate Clubs