Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Mystery Chocolate Box Review

Saturday, December 4th

2021 Chocolate Club Reviews

Mystery Chocolate Box Review 4 Star Rating

Mystery Chocolate Box

4 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $17.08 to $18.97 per month

From Oreos to Pringles, it seems like one of the biggest trends in food is to have a mystery flavor. What better way to spark interest in an everyday edible? Well, we don't think chocolate needs much to catch our attention, but we love the idea of having a guessing game built into our treat. You too? If so, you may agree with us when we say that Mystery Chocolate Box is one of our favorites!

Guessing game

How does it work? Each box has three full-sized chocolate bars with the outside wrappers removed, with labels of A, B and C. You get to guess what ingredients are inside - and for the truly competitive, you can enter your guesses on the Mystery Chocolate Box site to see if you make the leaderboard for most correct answers! Do you think your taste buds could identify kumquat, cashew butter, or mulled wine crystals? Those are just a few of the unique ingredients in the chocolate bars included in previous Mystery Chocolate Box selections.

List of ingredients

The inner wrappers are left untouched, keeping your chocolate in perfect condition, and each box comes with a list of ingredients in case allergies are a concern. At the time of our review, the company was also planning on releasing an Allergy-Free mystery box, with chocolates free of the "Top 14" allergens (celery, gluten, crustaceans, eggs, fish, lupin, milk, mollusks, mustard, nuts, peanuts, sesame seeds, soya, and sulphites). Keep your eyes peeled if that applies to you.

Best Chocolate Clubs

Extremely affordable

For such a fun approach to chocolate, we find this club to be extremely affordable. For a 3-month plan, you'll pay $56.95 - or just $18.98/month. Given that you get three full-sized bars of gourmet chocolate, that's a better price than you'd likely find at your local candy shop. There are also 6- and 12-month plans available, which bring your monthly cost down slightly ($17.99 and $17.08, respectively).

Membership Overview:

  • Chocolate Selection: 3 chocolate bars per month, flavors vary
  • Duration: 3, 6 or 12 months
  • Frequency: monthly
  • Shipping: approximately $8.20 per delivery

Shipping charges extra

To keep your mystery chocolates in perfect condition, every box is lined with insulated bubble wrap and includes a cold pack. That cost is added to your delivery fees. On the shipping and handling page, it'll tell you what you'll pay for the cost of shipping for the whole term of your subscription; in our case, for a 12-month plan, we paid $98.28: approximately $8.20 per delivery. On the Mystery Chocolate Box site, it said that the actual costs vary by month (probably factoring in months that don't need a cold pack), but the link that promised a detailed breakdown didn't have any information on it. That's not a deal-breaker, given that it's not more expensive than most of their rivals.

Gift giving options could be better

Your gift-giving options are slightly limited with Mystery Chocolate Box. If you'd like your recipient to get a gift card, it'll cost $1.99 whether you have it mailed directly to them or sent to you (so you can give it to them in person). There's no option for an emailed announcement. On the other hand, you can choose a start date for your deliveries, up to 6 months in advance.

Fighting hunger with every box

One nice feature of this chocolate club is that they donate two meals to fight hunger for every box they deliver (and no, it's not a meal that consists solely of chocolate!). If you're sending this club as a gift, and you decide to have the company send a gift announcement, that information will be printed on the card along with your personalized gift message. The company works with donation partners within the US and worldwide, helping to end hunger around the globe.

Cacao points rewards program

Another cool extra is their Cacao Points rewards program. You'll get points by becoming a subscriber, referring friends, leaving a review, and even guessing chocolate flavors accurately. You can redeem those points in their a la carte chocolate shop, or apply them towards a free monthly box.

Responsive customer service

Mystery Chocolate Box doesn't have a satisfaction guarantee per se, but they do allow you to cancel your membership at any time and receive a prorated refund for any boxes that haven't been shipped. They don't offer any refunds on boxes you may receive but don't find to your liking (probably because that would defeat the purpose of a mystery box). However, we found their customer service team to be really responsive, and our guess is that if you encountered a quality issue (like melted or spoiled chocolate), you'd get some friendly help to fix the problem.

Fun and delicious

We all know chocolate is delicious - but Mystery Chocolate Box takes "tasty" to a whole new level by adding a guessing game to the mix. Whether you keep them all for yourself, share the mystery with friends and family, or see how flavor-savvy your coworkers are, the chocolates included in this club are sure to be a hit. When it comes to chocolate bars, Mystery Chocolate Club scores high on our list.

Where Can You Find the Best Chocolate Clubs?

To answer that question, you should first have an idea of what kind of chocolate you'd prefer to receive or to gift. Does it make your mouth water just thinking about a beautifully-boxed assortment of milk and dark chocolates? Or maybe you're a proud, self-proclaimed foodie who thrills at the idea of single-source bars that can melt on your tongue and deliver sweet notes hinting at their origin? Let's face it: there's no "bad" kind of chocolate! Is it any wonder that the Aztecs believed that cacao seeds were a gift from the god of wisdom himself?

Given that the average American eats 11 pounds of chocolate per year, it's easy to see why Chocolate Clubs have become so popular. These subscription plans deliver the world's best truffles, bars and bite-sized treats right to your doorstep. The best plans are carefully curated by chocolate experts who scour the planet to find the most delectable, novel flavors for your tasting pleasure.

The Best Chocolate Clubs Compare Chocolate Clubs Compare Chocolate Club Reviews What are the best Chocolate Clubs Best Chocolate Club Reviews

Chocolate Club FAQ

That depends on the club you select. Some chocolate clubs specialize in single-source, small-batch chocolates that are hand-crafted by artisans around the world. Others provide a more traditional experience with boxed chocolates or bars you might find in a specialty store near you.
Most chocolate clubs give you a range of options: monthly, every other month, or quarterly. You can usually choose how many total deliveries you would like as well, from three-month plans to a full year.
They can be, but you'll find affordable options too. On average, your chocolate club will cost somewhere between $17 and $59 per month. Most clubs include shipping in those prices.
Many chocolate clubs go the extra mile to make sure that you - or your lucky gift recipient - are 100% satisfied with every delivery, giving you a full refund or shipping a replacement if something isn't right. However, not every company provides this level of customer service. It's a good idea to check out the policies (and reputation) of each club before making your purchase.
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
Absolutely! Some of the top chocolate clubs have been around for decades, with a long track record of customer satisfaction.
That's a great question. If you or your recipient have food allergies, you'll need to consider the options very carefully. Unfortunately, most clubs don't let you customize your deliveries beforehand: "you get what you get". There are a few that let you preview each month's delivery and skip it for any reason, and some are developing an "allergy-free" club membership that avoids the top known allergens.
Of course: who doesn't love chocolate? Chocolate clubs are a great way to send a little taste of joy for months to come. Your selected club may have gift options like emailed or printed announcements, gift wrapping, or add-on treats and toys to make your deliveries even more special. Many chocolate clubs also include a fun newsletter, providing interesting facts about chocolate, the background of the specific chocolates in the box, and even recipes!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

And, giving a chocolate club membership is bound to be well-received: with flexible delivery options ranging from monthly to quarterly, your lucky recipient gets a gift that keeps on giving for as long as you wish. It's hard to imagine anyone being unhappy with getting chocolate on a regular schedule!

Of course, no two chocolate clubs are alike. Some specialize in wrapped bars, while others focus on mixed assortment boxes that you might associate with Valentine's Day or other holiday occasions. As you consider all of the delicious possibilities, here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Selection. What's included in your chocolate club? Will you get a good variety of chocolates? Are there options for people with allergies, gluten sensitivities, or any other preferences?
  • Flexibility. Some clubs offer a wide range of choices, like monthly vs. every-other-month deliveries, delayed start dates (for perfectly-timed gift-giving), pay-in-full vs. pay-as-you-go, and so on. Make sure that the chocolate club you select is a good match for your needs.
  • Value. Does the chocolate club make you feel like you're getting what you pay for? Or could you get something comparable from another retailer - or even at your local chocolatier - at a better price? It's worth paying extra for a superior taste experience, but not all clubs deliver.
  • Reputation. What do previous customers say about the chocolate club? Does the company have strong policies in place to guarantee your satisfaction?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Chocolate Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you choose the chocolate club that will delight you or your gift recipient for many months to come!

See the Best Chocolate Club
The Best Reviews of Chocolate Clubs