Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Simply Chocolate Review

Monday, February 10th

2025 Chocolate Gift Box Reviews

Simply Chocolate Review 2 Star Rating

Simply Chocolate

2 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $24.99 to $199.99
  • 67 listed packages to choose from
  • Tons of flavors
  • Chocolates, truffles, snacks, and more
  • Tray-style presentation and individually-wrapped
  • Free shipping for members
  • 100% Smile Guarantee

Chocolate, chocolate, and more chocolate. If you can imagine it, this one-stop shop has it. From confection tins to Lindt novelty characters to holiday snack boxes, there's so much to look at when you first hit the Simply Chocolate home page. You could spend hours looking at the Trending Gifts category alone. Unlike other chocolatiers in our review, Simply Chocolate is a site that curates chocolate gifts from a range of different chocolatiers. You'll find chocolate brands you love including Ghirardelli, Godiva, Chuao, Vosges, and Jacques Torres. Simply Chocolate also has its own line of products. With 50+ years of experience, Simply Chocolate makes sure to find unique flavor profiles and artisanal chocolates for a mixture of fresh cremes, caramels, and ganaches.

Tons of chocolates and treats to choose from

To find chocolate gift boxes, you'll want to jump right to the "Boxed Chocolate” tab. From there, you can see colorful photos of chocolate gift boxes with a range of both individually-wrapped chocolates and chocolates arranged in trays. Each listing shows a clear photo of the box and everything inside, the name of the listing, and the price. You can also see what products are "Passport Eligible”, which is Simply Chocolate's yearly membership that offers free shipping on any eligible item (and across the other brands in the 1-800-FLOWERS family). When you click through to a particular box of chocolates, you'll see a full description of the contents and any reviews for individual boxes left by previous shoppers.

Best Chocolate Gift Boxes

67 boxes and tons of flavors

Simply Chocolate has 67 different results for chocolate gift boxes. These include those by Simply Chocolate, Neuhaus, Godiva, and more. There are so many different boxes from different manufacturers and chocolatiers that it's hard to say how many chocolate flavor options you'll find. Our research showed a collection of Belgian chocolates, terrapins, peanut butter cups, classic truffles, bars, and squares. Some of the standout flavors we saw from just one of the many chocolatiers (Norman Love) include:

  • Cookies ‘n' Cream
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly
  • Sea Salt Caramel Truffle
  • Key Lime Shell
  • New York Cheesecake
  • Tiramisu
  • Pistachio
  • Tahitian Caramel

Pricing from $24.99 to $199.99

The prices at Simply Chocolate are a mix of affordable chocolate gift boxes and high-end selections. The lowest cost boxes are $24.99 for the Greenport Unique Luxury Collection (4pc). This box includes Chocolate Coconut Toffee Macadamia, Dark Chocolate Almonds, Dark Chocolate Salted Cashews, and Maple Bourbon Pecans. The most costly chocolate gift box at Simply Chocolate is The Easthampton Gourmet Delights Collection for $199.99. This includes 5 oz of 12 different treats like Peanut Butter Caramels, Pure Dark Chocolate Blueberries, Premium Espresso Beans and more.

Shipping free with a membership

The cost of shipping isn't cheap at Simply Chocolate, and seeing your cart total change before you buy can be a bit shocking. We were quoted $24.98 for shipping in our area, and there were no other options for different shipping speeds. When tax was added on top of that, our $49.99 box of chocolates was updated to $79.84 in total. But, you can get free shipping at Simply Chocolate with the Passport membership we referenced earlier. This costs $19.99 the first year (still less costly than the price of shipping) and you'll get free shipping on every order. This applies to most items at Simply Chocolate, but not all, so make sure you check that the chocolate box you want qualifies before subscribing.

100% Smile Guarantee

Simply Chocolate offers a guarantee that your chocolates will arrive fresh and with perfect presentation. If you are not 100% satisfied, the company promises to "do what it takes to make it right.” This is the Simply Chocolate 100% Smile Guarantee. To get recourse for a problem in your order, you are invited to talk with Simply Chocolate through the online chat feature on the website. Make sure you have your order information ready when you start chatting.

Best Chocolate Gift Boxes

No buzz for Simply Chocolate

Regrettably, Simply Chocolate currently holds an "NR” rating from the Better Business Bureau (meaning it isn't rated at this time). We also couldn't find reviews for this all-in-one site on Trustpilot or Sitejabber. There was a UK site under the same name on Trustpilot, but this isn't related to the US Simply Chocolate. The few individual listings that do have reviews on Simply Chocolate's website are almost all uniformly 5 stars, so we're not sure how curated those reviews are. At the moment, Simply Chocolate falls behind the pack by not having any reliable third-party reviews to support its reputation. Of course, as part of the 1-800-FLOWERS group (that also includes big names like The Popcorn Factory and Harry & David), you know that this chocolatier is backed by a larger corporation - but we'd still prefer to see more buzz about how well Simply Chocolate itself is doing.

Simply... not our favorite

Simply Chocolate seems like a great option at first, but without more details on its reputation, it's hard to know if this company is doing a consistently great job on delivering chocolate gift boxes. It's true that there are lots of different chocolate brands to choose from here, which may appeal to those who want a variety or don't know exactly which chocolate assortment to grab. However, without a concrete customer service policy or third-party reviews, Simply Chocolate falls behind the pack.

Where is the Best Place to Get Chocolate Gift Boxes?

Whether you want a traditional chocolate, something like a holiday Ferrero Rocher, or a new confection with unique flavors like lavender or orange, there's a box of chocolates out there for you. With online ordering, you have access to far more assortments and flavors than you would at a local sweet shop, and you can easily send chocolates to your loved ones anywhere in the country (or the world).

If you choose to indulge in this cacao-based confection, you'll be in good company. Americans spend an estimated $22 billion on chocolate each year, and 90% of recent consumers said that chocolate is their favorite category of treat. Milk chocolate, unsurprisingly, is a popular favorite, especially in the US. Around the world, dark chocolate is generally preferred. Chocolate is something that brings people together. So, why not enjoy it?

The Best Chocolate Gift Boxes Compare Chocolate Gift Boxes Compare Chocolate Gift Box Reviews What are the best Chocolate Gift Boxes Best Chocolate Gift Box Reviews

Chocolate Gift Box FAQ

You'll find everything from classic milk and dark chocolates to truffles, caramels, pralines, and even exotic flavors like sea salt or chili-infused chocolate. Many sites offer curated gift boxes with a variety of options. A few chocolatiers let you build your own box to make the gift extra personal.
Yes, many chocolate delivery services cater to dietary needs like vegan, dairy-free, sugar-free, or gluten-free chocolates. Some chocolates also highlight ethically-sourced, organic, or fair trade ingredients for a more conscientious sweet treat. Always check the product details or use filters when searching for chocolates to make sure you get the sweets that fit your needs.
You can rely on your chocolates to be freshly made before they're shipped to you. Chocolate gift box services package the chocolates carefully to maintain the quality and flavor of your sweets. Some packages even include cooling packs to prevent your chocolates from melting during transit.
This depends on the service you purchase from and your location. Most chocolate gift box sites offer standard shipping from 3-5 days. You can also look for expedited shipping or next-day shipping from some vendors if you're in a hurry. Always check the estimated delivery dates during checkout so you can plan accordingly. If you're sending the chocolates as a gift, you can schedule ahead for your specific delivery date too.
Prices can vary widely depending on the type and size of the gift box. You can find small boxes for around $5, while more high-end assortments with premium chocolates can go for over $100. Many sites offer a range of chocolate gift boxes that suit multiple budgets, so you're sure to find something that fits what you're looking for.
Chocolate gift boxes are usually packaged in sturdy containers and sometimes wrapped in additional protective layers to keep your chocolates from breaking during shipping. With many chocolates situated in plastic trays that hold the sweets away from one another, you shouldn't need to worry about anything sticking or breaking before it gets to your door.
Most reliable chocolate gift box delivery services have a satisfaction guarantee or refund policy. In some cases, you will be eligible for a refund or reshipment of your order. The exact terms will depend on where you buy your chocolate from. You may need to take photos of your chocolates as proof in case of any concerns.
There are definitely chocolates out there free of allergens. Avoiding any sites that work with peanuts or nuts in their facilities will be a great start. Most reputable chocolatiers will list allergens on the site if there's anything to be worried about. Always read the ingredients closely before you purchase to ensure your safety.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

When we say chocolate is a classic sweet, we don't just mean in the last few decades. Chocolate has one of the most interesting stories out there. The discovery of chocolate (specifically cacao beans) can be traced back to Mesoamerican civilizations. The beans were so precious, they were once used as a form of currency.

Our word for chocolate comes from the Aztecs who called the bean "xocoatl”. Originally, chocolate was made into a drink, similar to the hot cocoa we drink today, but a lot spicier (try Mexican Hot Chocolate sometime, if you want a more authentic flavor). Supposedly the Aztec emperor Montezuma drank 50 cups of chocolate per day.

While you might not be as much of a chocolate superfan as the emperor, we can definitely see the appeal. Chocolate, as we know it (the chocolate bar and chocolate confections), started being made around 1847. There are tons of benefits to enjoying chocolate too. Cacao can lower your blood pressure, and dark chocolate has a range of health benefits including improved brain health, improved mood, and promotion of your good (HDL) cholesterol. Bottom line? You can enjoy your sweets without any guilt.

There's no limit to what you might find in a chocolate gift box online. If you're ready to get that delightful melt-in-your-mouth chocolate treat, but aren't sure which confectionary to choose, don't sweat it. We've put together some factors that can help you pick the best vendors for chocolate gift boxes:

  • Cost. When buying chocolate gift boxes online, you'll want to make sure you're getting the best deal for the price. How many chocolates are included in the box? Are the flavors unique enough to warrant the price? What is the quality of the chocolate? Keep in mind any costs for shipping too, as that might change your total during checkout.
  • Variety. Chocolate is such a versatile confection that you'll want to make sure the chocolate gift boxes you choose have a competitive variety of flavors, chocolate types (milk, dark, and white), and add-ins. Once you find a chocolatier you like, it's frustrating to need to find another spot to shop if your favorite flavors are missing. Looking for a one-stop chocolate shop can ensure that you know exactly where to shop every time.
  • Dietary restrictions. If you're on a special diet, there are tons of sites that cater to your needs. With the right chocolatier, you can find vegan, sugar-free, and gluten-free options. Make sure you check out the ingredients list for dietary changes and allergens.
  • Reputation. When searching for chocolate gift boxes online, it's smart to check trusted review platforms like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Feedback from other chocolate enthusiasts can help you find the best deals, best quality, and best customer service out there for your next chocolate purchase.

"Life is like a box of chocolates"... or it could be as soon as you grab these gift boxes for yourself, your friends, and family. To help you find the best chocolatier to satisfy your cravings, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top chocolate gift boxes out there today. Now, crack open those sweets and pick one. Like they said in Forrest Gump, you never know what you're going to get!

Compare Chocolate Gift Boxes

Select any 2 Chocolate Gift Boxes to compare them head to head

best-chocolate-gift-boxes
  • Compartes
  • Z Chocolat
  • Ghirardelli
  • Russell Stover
  • Astor Chocolate
  • Vosges Haut-Chocolat
  • Hotel Chocolat
  • La Maison Du Chocolat
  • Godiva
  • Simply Chocolate
Compartes vs Z Chocolat Compartes vs Ghirardelli Compartes vs Russell Stover Compartes vs Astor Chocolate Compartes vs Vosges Haut-Chocolat Compartes vs Hotel Chocolat Compartes vs La Maison Du Chocolat Compartes vs Godiva Compartes vs Simply Chocolate Z Chocolat vs Ghirardelli Z Chocolat vs Russell Stover Z Chocolat vs Astor Chocolate Z Chocolat vs Vosges Haut-Chocolat Z Chocolat vs Hotel Chocolat Z Chocolat vs La Maison Du Chocolat Z Chocolat vs Godiva Z Chocolat vs Simply Chocolate Ghirardelli vs Russell Stover Ghirardelli vs Astor Chocolate Ghirardelli vs Vosges Haut-Chocolat Ghirardelli vs Hotel Chocolat Ghirardelli vs La Maison Du Chocolat Ghirardelli vs Godiva Ghirardelli vs Simply Chocolate Russell Stover vs Astor Chocolate Russell Stover vs Vosges Haut-Chocolat Russell Stover vs Hotel Chocolat Russell Stover vs La Maison Du Chocolat Russell Stover vs Godiva Russell Stover vs Simply Chocolate Astor Chocolate vs Vosges Haut-Chocolat Astor Chocolate vs Hotel Chocolat Astor Chocolate vs La Maison Du Chocolat Astor Chocolate vs Godiva Astor Chocolate vs Simply Chocolate Vosges Haut-Chocolat vs Hotel Chocolat Vosges Haut-Chocolat vs La Maison Du Chocolat Vosges Haut-Chocolat vs Godiva Vosges Haut-Chocolat vs Simply Chocolate Hotel Chocolat vs La Maison Du Chocolat Hotel Chocolat vs Godiva Hotel Chocolat vs Simply Chocolate La Maison Du Chocolat vs Godiva La Maison Du Chocolat vs Simply Chocolate Godiva vs Simply Chocolate
Compare the Best Chocolate Gift Boxes
- VS -
Review the Best Chocolate Gift Boxes
The Best Reviews of Chocolate Gift Boxes