Gearharts Fine Chocolates Review: Chocolate Stores

We've analyzed the best Chocolate Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Chocolate Store Reviews

Where Can You Find the Best Chocolate?  Chocolate is more than just a sweet treat; it's a global phenomenon deeply entrenched in cultures worldwide. Its popularity transcends borders and generations, captivating taste buds for centuries. But what makes chocolate so beloved, and what factors contribute to its widespread appeal?

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Small family-owned chocolatier
  • Signature line of hand-dipped chocolates includes novel flavor pairings
  • Selection also includes chocolate bars, truffles, candied nuts, and more
  • Great for gift-giving
  • Free shipping on orders $75+
  • $12.50 flat-rate shipping on orders under $75
  • Save 10% on your first order when you sign up for the mailing list
  • 30-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Over 1,000 5-star reviews
  • In business since 2001

GREAT

4.5

On the Gearharts Fine Chocolates website

When Tim Gearhart founded Gearharts Fine Chocolates in 2001, artisan chocolate was a rarity in the United States. Drawing from his extensive culinary background, including training at The Culinary Institute of America and experiences in professional kitchens across the globe, Tim established his Charlottesville shop. Today, Gearharts Chocolates is celebrated for its distinctive artisan creations enjoyed by customers near and far.

16 incredible flavors

Gearharts' flagship product is the 32-piece assortment of their signature line chocolates, priced at $68. Start browsing the flavor list of the 16 different types of chocolate and you'll feel that "wow" factor right away. There are some more traditional selections, like Maple Pecan or even Vanilla Bean Brulee, but most of the flavors will have you wondering why you ever settled for a boring supermarket-shelf assortment. You won't find Tequila Lime, Apricot Brandy, Earl Grey, or Pistachio Toffee Orange in those boxes, that's for sure. Gearharts Fine Chocolates also allows you to create a custom assortment for $1 more; the flavor possibilities are the same, but you can opt to leave any of them out if they're not to your liking. Enter any quantity requests in the comment box (maybe you want 5 Michigan Cherry pieces instead of just 1 or 2).

Spend $75 to get free shipping

Gearharts has a wide range of specialty chocolates and chocolate-adjacent items to choose from as well. Popular options include the Chocolate-Dipped Pistachio Toffee ($12), Chai-Spiced Chocolate Dipped Pecans ($10), Brownie Mix ($12), and even a UVa Cavalier chocolate assortment ($30). You may want to add one of those to your 32-piece assortment, if that's what you're ordering, so that your order meets the $75 threshold to qualify for free shipping.

Best Chocolate Stores

2 gift arrangements

If you're looking to give Gearharts Fine Chocolates as a gift, but you don't have the time to select each item one by one, look in the Gift Box section. Both options come with an assortment of the signature line chocolates and several selections from the specialty collection; your only decision is if you'd like to send the regular gift box ($125) or the large one ($175).

Get discounts when you sign up for emails

When you sign up for the Gearharts Fine Chocolates email list, you'll be notified of special events and promotions, and you'll get a 10% discount on your first order. We saw comments from customers who had gotten even bigger discounts at different times of the year, so it's worth it to subscribe to the mailing list if you're thinking of ordering chocolates from Gearharts sometime in the future.

Has a very loyal following

People are enthusiastic and effusive in their praise for Gearharts Fine Chocolates. Over 1,000 independently-verified reviews, this chocolate store has earned an impressive average of 4.92 stars, with 99% of customers offering their most positive recommendation. From the Maya Drinking Chocolate to the Virginia Straight Bourbon Whiskey Truffles, there's nothing but love: reviews often use superlatives like "best I've ever found" and "most delicious we've ever tasted". One of our favorite comments was "this company is a good friend to know for ALL husbands", from a customer who gives his wife these chocolates every year. Compliments also extend to the packaging - "beautiful presentation", "gorgeous bow" - and the delivery that ensures that the chocolates arrive on time and are still well-chilled.

Best Chocolate Stores

30-day satisfaction guarantee

And, even though you probably won't ever need it, Gearharts Fine Chocolates offers a 30-day refund policy, giving you a refund or replacement if anything isn't right with your order. They do prefer that you reach out right away, though, so that they can fix the problem sooner rather than later.

Fantastic chocolate store

Gearharts Fine Chocolates is one of our new favorites. We love the incredible variety of flavors in the signature selection, the specialty products definitely caught our attention, and the chocolatier's reputation is practically flawless. If you're ready to take your love of chocolate to the next level, you won't want to miss what Gearharts delivers.

On the Gearharts Fine Chocolates website

Continued from above...

Where Can You Find the Best Chocolate?

Chocolate is more than just a sweet treat; it's a global phenomenon deeply entrenched in cultures worldwide. Its popularity transcends borders and generations, captivating taste buds for centuries. But what makes chocolate so beloved, and what factors contribute to its widespread appeal?

First and foremost, chocolate's allure can be attributed to its irresistible taste. The combination of sweetness, bitterness, and creaminess creates a sensory experience like no other. This flavor profile stems from the main ingredient: cocoa beans. These beans undergo a complex process of fermentation, drying, roasting, and grinding to produce cocoa solids and cocoa butter, the building blocks of chocolate.

Nowadays, chocolate production and consumption are staggering. According to the International Cocoa Organization, global cocoa production recently reached over 4.8 million metric tons, with the top producers being Ivory Coast, Ghana, and Indonesia. As for consumption, Switzerland tops the charts, with an average annual consumption of over 8.8 kilograms per capita.

Furthermore, chocolate is associated with indulgence and comfort. Many people turn to chocolate during times of stress or as a reward for a job well done. Its mood-boosting properties are attributed to various compounds, including phenylethylamine, which is believed to promote feelings of happiness and euphoria.

From a cultural perspective, chocolate holds significant symbolism. It's a staple in celebrations and rituals worldwide, from Valentine's Day to religious holidays like Easter. Additionally, chocolate has a rich history intertwined with ancient civilizations like the Maya and Aztecs, who revered cocoa as a divine gift.

As for trends in the world of chocolate, several exciting developments are worth noting. Consumers are increasingly interested in the bean-to-bar process, where chocolatiers oversee every step of production, from sourcing beans to crafting the final product.

There's also a growing demand for artisanal and craft chocolates made in small batches with high-quality ingredients. These chocolates often showcase unique flavor combinations (like spices, herbs, and exotic fruits) and innovative techniques. And, with a renewed focus on wellness in general, there's a rise in demand for healthier chocolate alternatives, such as sugar-free, dairy-free, and vegan options made with alternative sweeteners and plant-based milk.

Luckily for the sweet tooth in all of us, it's never been easier to access the world's best chocolates. All it takes is a few clicks and you're there. But, when purchasing chocolate online, there are several factors to consider to ensure you're getting the best quality and smoothest shopping experience:

Chocolate's enduring popularity is a testament to its irresistible taste, cultural significance, and mood-boosting properties. The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have meticulously evaluated and ranked some of today's most popular chocolate stores, to help guide you on your journey towards an exceptional chocolate experience. We hope you'll enjoy discovering new flavors and savoring traditional favorites!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Chocolate Store FAQ

Just how popular is chocolate, exactly?
According to the World Cocoa Foundation, people around the world - mostly in the US and Europe, not surprisingly - eat enough chocolate to equal three million cocoa beans every year! Chocolate is the most popular sweet tooth-satisfying dessert almost everywhere.
What kinds of chocolates can I buy online?
The sky's the limit. Do you have a favorite brand like Godiva or Hershey's? You'll find every imaginable variety when you shop online. Are you looking for a unique flavor combination or a gorgeous assortment of hand-dipped caramels and truffles? You can get that too. The difficult thing will be holding yourself back from buying all of them!
Why would I order chocolates from a website instead of a store nearby?
Supporting small businesses and shopping local is great - and your closest candy shop may even sell their products online too. But, there's no guarantee you'll get the kind of chocolate you want if you limit yourself to brick-and-mortar retailers you can drive to. And, if you're ordering chocolate to give as a gift, you'll probably have more options for gift packaging and shipping when you buy from an online chocolate store.
What should I look for in a good chocolate store?
Chocolate! (Just kidding.) The best chocolate stores make it easy to see the different types of sweets they sell and how much you'll pay, plus any shipping costs you should expect. Some stores have fun promotions that can save you money or double the amount of chocolate in your order. You can also consider what other customers have said about their experience with the chocolate retailer: how the treats taste, if the deliveries arrive on time and in good condition, and how any problems were resolved by the customer service team.
Is it expensive to buy chocolates online?
It can be - but it doesn't have to be. If you're buying chocolates in large quantities and exotic flavors, of course you should expect to pay more. But, chocolate stores usually have plenty of options for people shopping on a budget too.
Will I have to pay extra for shipping?
That depends on the chocolate store. Some give you free shipping to earn your business, but you might have to place a minimum order amount to qualify. It should be fairly easy to determine what, if anything, you'll pay for delivery as you browse their website.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Yes, most of the time. Online chocolate stores want you to be thrilled with the sweets you get - after all, word of mouth is great for advertising, and they'd love for you to tell everyone you know about the amazing chocolates they sell. If your chocolate doesn't arrive in perfect condition, or something is just off with the taste, contact the customer service team. It shouldn't be hard to get a refund or replacement order.
Can I send chocolate as a gift?
Yes, yes and yes! Some chocolate shops provide numerous options for gifting, from mixed assortments to hard-to-find varieties in beautiful gift wrapping. You could even choose a chocolate club membership that will literally be a gift that keeps on giving, with new packages arriving every month for three months to a year.

Compare Any 2 Products

Z Chocolat
Gearharts Fine Chocolates
Ethel M
Simply Chocolate
Vosges Haut-Chocolat
Lindt
Ghirardelli
Astor Chocolate
Russell Stover
Godiva
vs
Z Chocolat vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesZ Chocolat vs Ethel MZ Chocolat vs Simply ChocolateZ Chocolat vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatZ Chocolat vs LindtZ Chocolat vs GhirardelliZ Chocolat vs Astor ChocolateZ Chocolat vs Russell StoverZ Chocolat vs GodivaGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Ethel MGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Simply ChocolateGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatGearharts Fine Chocolates vs LindtGearharts Fine Chocolates vs GhirardelliGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Astor ChocolateGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Russell StoverGearharts Fine Chocolates vs GodivaEthel M vs Simply ChocolateEthel M vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatEthel M vs LindtEthel M vs GhirardelliEthel M vs Astor ChocolateEthel M vs Russell StoverEthel M vs GodivaSimply Chocolate vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatSimply Chocolate vs LindtSimply Chocolate vs GhirardelliSimply Chocolate vs Astor ChocolateSimply Chocolate vs Russell StoverSimply Chocolate vs GodivaVosges Haut-Chocolat vs LindtVosges Haut-Chocolat vs GhirardelliVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Astor ChocolateVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Russell StoverVosges Haut-Chocolat vs GodivaLindt vs GhirardelliLindt vs Astor ChocolateLindt vs Russell StoverLindt vs GodivaGhirardelli vs Astor ChocolateGhirardelli vs Russell StoverGhirardelli vs GodivaAstor Chocolate vs Russell StoverAstor Chocolate vs GodivaRussell Stover vs Godiva Godiva vs Russell StoverGodiva vs Astor ChocolateGodiva vs GhirardelliGodiva vs LindtGodiva vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatGodiva vs Simply ChocolateGodiva vs Ethel MGodiva vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesGodiva vs Z ChocolatRussell Stover vs Astor ChocolateRussell Stover vs GhirardelliRussell Stover vs LindtRussell Stover vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatRussell Stover vs Simply ChocolateRussell Stover vs Ethel MRussell Stover vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesRussell Stover vs Z ChocolatAstor Chocolate vs GhirardelliAstor Chocolate vs LindtAstor Chocolate vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatAstor Chocolate vs Simply ChocolateAstor Chocolate vs Ethel MAstor Chocolate vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesAstor Chocolate vs Z ChocolatGhirardelli vs LindtGhirardelli vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatGhirardelli vs Simply ChocolateGhirardelli vs Ethel MGhirardelli vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesGhirardelli vs Z ChocolatLindt vs Vosges Haut-ChocolatLindt vs Simply ChocolateLindt vs Ethel MLindt vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesLindt vs Z ChocolatVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Simply ChocolateVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Ethel MVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesVosges Haut-Chocolat vs Z ChocolatSimply Chocolate vs Ethel MSimply Chocolate vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesSimply Chocolate vs Z ChocolatEthel M vs Gearharts Fine ChocolatesEthel M vs Z ChocolatGearharts Fine Chocolates vs Z Chocolat
See the Best Chocolate Stores in Your State

Why Chocolate Is Such an Amazing Gift

Few sweets have as much widespread popularity as chocolate. If you like a certain sweet, then there is probably some kind of chocolate version of it. You can have chocolate on cake, with fruit, on its own, and in so many other fun and exciting ways. Thus, it's no wonder that chocolate is such a common gift for all kinds of occasions. The holiday season is rolling around, and you might have a few birthdays to get ready for. You're probably stressing out about finding the right gift for at least a few people, but it doesn't have to be so complicated. If you've been racking your brain for the best way to dazzle your friends, family, and acquaintances this holiday season, then check out these six major reasons why chocolate is such an awesome gift.

Broad Appeal

Many people have very specific preferences, so it can be difficult to find good gifts for them. However, you would be hard-pressed to find someone who isn't a fan of chocolate. Chocolate's rich, sweet taste leaves little to be desired. Because different chocolates have such a wide variety of complex flavors, chocolate can satisfy the simple lover of sweets and the sophisticated connoisseur alike. No matter who you're buying a gift for, you can be pretty sure that they will like chocolate, so it's a pretty safe bet.

Appropriate for All Contexts and Relationships

When you're buying a present for someone, you have to consider a lot of social minutiae. Would that nice tie seem a bit extravagant for a co-worker? Could that motorcycle helmet somehow imply that you think that your father-in-law is a bad rider? What if your spouse doesn't find that stationery set thoughtful enough? Unlike other gifts, chocolate is not bound by so many social norms and implications. People love chocolate for so many reasons, so nobody is going to see your chocolate-related gift as a social faux pas.

Many Unique Chocolate-Based Gifts

You don't just have to buy someone a chocolate bar. Chocolate comes in many shapes and sizes, and you can give your loved ones several unique chocolate-based presents this holiday season. Several wacky and interesting products incorporate chocolate, and the following list details a few of the most interesting chocolate-related gifts.

Assorted Chocolates

A box of assorted chocolates allows the recipient to enjoy a variety of flavors. They can find their favorite treats in a box of chocolates, and they can give their least favorite varieties to friends, co-workers, and passers-by. They get to enjoy tasty chocolate morsels, and they also get to share the love and build brownie points by sharing. It's the best of both worlds.

Subscriptions and Clubs

Do you want to give your loved one the gift that keeps on giving? A chocolate subscription will allow the recipient to enjoy new chocolate treats at regular intervals. Every time they receive a delivery, they will think of you and feel thankful for your thoughtful gift.

Edible Art

Who doesn't like art? Chocolatiers create many different kinds of art with chocolate, and you can find the right piece of chocolate art for almost anyone. Do you have a friend who loves Paris? They would probably really enjoy a chocolate Eiffel Tower. If you want to impress your spouse, then you might want to get a chocolate bouquet. Many chocolatiers take custom orders, so you can easily commission the perfect piece of chocolate art for even the pickiest person at your holiday gathering.

Hot Chocolate

Nothing beats a good cup of hot chocolate on a chilly winter day. Many vendors offer an array of flavors and toppings, so you won't have a problem finding the perfect mix for your loved one. You can even buy hot chocolate kits in packs with fancy mugs so that the recipient of your gift can drink their next cup of hot chocolate in style.

Novelty Products

Whether you want to buy spicy chocolate, a chocolate pizza, or chocolate in a funny shape, there is likely just the right product out there for your needs. Chocolate comes in all shapes and sizes, so you should be able to find something unique for the person in your life who enjoys a little novelty. Of course, if you plan to buy an edgier novelty product, then you should be 100% certain that the recipient will find it funny. Otherwise, you may put a damper on someone's holiday spirit.

Foreign Products

There's something magical about unboxing a chocolate treat from another country. Foreign chocolate products are a great gift for anyone, but they're especially good for someone who loves other cultures or misses their home country. A foreign chocolate product might introduce you to flavors that you would have never imagined. Have you ever tasted spicy chocolate or chocolate with green tea powder? While such flavor combinations may not be common where you live, they're a staple in other countries. Thus, when you buy a foreign chocolate product for a friend, you're allowing them to capture a small glimpse of another culture without ever having to leave home.

Chocolate Is Thoughtful and Affordable

You have a budget to stick to, but the holiday season can put a serious strain on your finances. Good gifts are often expensive, but you don't want your loved ones to think that you're cheap. Consequently, you may feel pressured to spend beyond your means to show your friends and family members how much you care about them. However, such reckless spending can put you in a precarious situation when the holidays are over. Luckily, you don't have to break the bank to impress someone with a quality chocolate-related gift. A piece of chocolate art or any other chocolate product will have the same impact as a more expensive gift without depleting your bank account.

No Clutter

These days, more and more people are wary of clutter. Less is more, and nobody wants to fill their home with gifts that they'll never use. While you may feel tempted to buy a loved one the newest gadget or gizmo, such a gift might prove more frustrating than valuable. Unless the recipient uses the gift regularly, it will be nothing but an expensive paperweight that will take up valuable space in a cupboard or closet. Chocolate, on the other hand, is compact and lightweight. Plus, once someone eats a piece of chocolate, they don't have to worry about finding a place to store it.

Long Shelf Life

Unlike other food products, chocolate doesn't spoil easily. This means that you can buy chocolate-based gifts ahead of time and give out large quantities of the stuff without worrying about it going bad. During the holidays, most people are drowning in a myriad of unhealthy meals and desserts. Because of this, they may not want to eat your chocolate gift right away. Thankfully, dark chocolate will keep for about a year, and light chocolate and white chocolate are both good for about six months. Once the holidays pass, the recipient of your gift can guiltlessly reach into the cupboard for a tasty chocolate treat, and they'll remember your kindness as they enjoy the sweet flavor.

You Can't Go Wrong With Chocolate

The holidays can be stressful, and you might not know what to get for that special someone in your life. Chocolate never fails, so it's a great gift for everyone who wants to look good without breaking the bank this holiday season. After all, who doesn't like chocolate? While other gifts may flop, chocolate will always impress. Thus, if you want to show someone how much you care, then you should consider getting them a special chocolate-based gift that they'll surely enjoy.

Only the Best Reviews

Plant Based News

Will We Run Out Of Chocolate? Sustainable Alternatives And The ...

Chocolate is the ultimate comfort food, but between cocoa shortages and the climate crisis, it's possible that humanity might run out one day ...

Thu, 06 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

Skip The Candy Aisle: No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars Call For ...

Want candy but don't want to drag yourself all the way to the store? Chances are that you have these three pantry staples and can whip up your own.

Sat, 08 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Taste of Home on MSN

Baking with Chocolate? Here’s How to Do It Right, According to Mr. ...

As summer memories fade and the leaves begin to fall, the holiday baking season is almost here. It’s now time to dust off all those holiday baking recipes and get ready to make some festive sweets. Of ...

Sat, 08 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

USA TODAY on MSN

Is Nutella good for you? A closer look at this beloved ...

Indeed, people do love Nutella for its rich texture and sweet cocoa-hazelnut flavor. “As a creamy and smooth spread, it has great versatility and is commonly served alongside fruit on pancakes, toast, ...

Wed, 05 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Food & Wine on MSN

How to Pair Chocolate and Wine Without Overthinking It

Wine and chocolate is a notoriously tricky pairing. Wine expert Leslie Sbrocco demystifies the challenge of pairing this duo by focusing on balance and texture rather than rigid rules. Here is her ...

Fri, 07 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Scrumdiddlyumptious ...

Chocolate Chip Cake: Easy Recipe for Beginners

Pour the batter into the prepared pan and evenly spread it. Sprinkle with chocolate chips and a bit of sugar (about 1 tablespoon). Bake for about 35 minutes, or until a wooden skewer inserted into the ...

Thu, 06 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Philadelphia ...

How Hershey’s chocolate survived an attack from Mars − and ...

In the 1960, Forrest Mars’ aggressive tactics stole market share from Hershey. The Pa. company was in crisis and was forced to modernize its business practices.

Fri, 31 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Tasting Table on MSN

Use These 3 Ingredients For Rich, Bakery-Style Chocolate Chip Cookies ...

Making better chocolate chip cookies is all in the details. Rather than opt for a myriad of extras, focus on the key ingredients and select them carefully.

Thu, 06 Nov 2025

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.