Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Michaels vs Ornament Shop

Wednesday, September 18th

2024 Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

Michaels Review 2.5 Star Rating

Michaels

2.5 Star Rating
  • Thousands of Christmas ornaments to choose from
  • Free shipping on orders of $49+
  • 60-day return window

At Michaels, you'll find a wide selection of Christmas ornaments, though navigating their website may leave you feeling a bit frustrated. While they offer thousands of options and free shipping on orders over $49, finding holiday-appropriate decorations can be challenging amidst unrelated items (like wooden beetles and water fountains). Pricing can also be steep, with sets of plastic ornaments reaching upwards of $143.99, though occasional discounts are available. While Michaels does offer a generous 60-day return policy, the lack of reviews on Christmas ornaments doesn't make it easier to see which ones are worth buying. With a lower rating, Michaels may not be your top choice for Christmas ornament shopping, as there are better options available elsewhere.

Ornament Shop Review 2 Star Rating

Ornament Shop

2 Star Rating
  • Large selection of cute, customizable ornaments
  • Free shipping on orders of $99+
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • "A+” rated by the BBB
  • In business for over 40 years

Ornament Shop used to be one of the best places to get personalized Christmas ornaments. But, despite being in business for over 40 years, this store isn't one of our favorites anymore. The website has typos, some popular categories of ornaments have no products in stock, and recent customer reviews are too mixed to give us much confidence in the retailer's promise of 100% satisfaction. Ornament Shop has dropped to a lower rating, and we'd recommend going higher on our list for your customized Christmas ornaments.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Christmas Ornaments?

The world of Christmas ornaments is incredibly diverse. From traditional glass baubles to quirky, novelty ornaments, there's something for everyone. Many modern ornaments feature popular characters from movies, TV shows, and cartoons, adding a touch of pop culture to the holiday season.

The tradition of decorating trees, particularly during Christmas, dates back centuries. However, the concept of hanging ornaments on trees is believed to have originated in 16th century Germany. Back then, people decorated their trees with fruits, nuts, and other edible items. Over time, this evolved into using more decorative items like candles, paper decorations, and small trinkets.

The Best Christmas Ornament Stores Compare Christmas Ornament Stores Compare Christmas Ornament Store Reviews What are the best Christmas Ornament Stores Best Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

Christmas Ornament Store FAQ

While no one knows for certain exactly when the tradition of decorating Christmas trees began, it's believed to have its origins in 16th century Germany. Almost 300 years later, it became popular in the United States as well, and the tradition really gained steam when the department store Woolworth's started importing hand-blown glass ornaments from Germany.
Glass ornaments have been around the longest and still convey a nostalgic feel when used to decorate a tree. But, as personalization options increased, bespoke ornaments became the most popular way to make the holidays shine - from sports-themed trees to baubles commemorating everything from a new home to a graduation.
You can buy Christmas ornament assortments with 10-20 in a box for $20 or less. Individual ornaments are usually priced anywhere from $2 to $20 or more, depending on what they're made of and how much personalization is involved.
Many Christmas ornament retailers include complimentary delivery with your order. You might have to purchase a certain number of ornaments or meet a minimum dollar amount to qualify.
Lots! Photo ornaments are really popular: you can get a set with all of your favorite memories from the year's travel adventures, your pets, or anything you can imagine. Personalized ornaments with important dates and names are also very common, to recognize an accomplishment that happened during the year, to celebrate a baby's first Christmas, and so on.
Some Christmas ornament stores are open year-round, and that can make it easy to shop in advance. The closer you get to Thanksgiving (when a lot of people put up the decorations), the more likely it is that an ornament you want might be out of stock. The selection in brick-and-mortar stores can be pretty sparse between Thanksgiving and Christmas, but you will probably have more luck shopping online.
That depends on the store! Some pride themselves on being your one-stop Christmas shop, letting you get all of your lights, garland, tree toppers, stockings and ornaments in one online order. Others stay laser-focused on providing the best selection of Christmas ornaments alone.
Return policies vary. If you purchased personalized ornaments, the policy may be strict - and if you spelled a name wrong, you probably won't get your money back. Otherwise, many stores give you 30 days or more to send your ornaments back if you get them and they're not what you expected.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

As this tradition spread throughout Europe and eventually to other parts of the world, the ornaments themselves evolved. Handcrafted glass ornaments became popular in the 19th century, particularly in regions like Germany and Czechoslovakia. These delicate decorations were often intricately painted and adorned with glitter. In the 20th century, with the advent of mass production, Christmas ornaments became more accessible to the general public. Materials such as plastic, metal, and fabric were used to create a wide array of ornaments, though traditionalists still looked for the old-world styles in glass too.

Personalization has also become increasingly popular. People now look for ornaments that can be customized with names, dates, or special messages, making them unique keepsakes for families and loved ones. Many families have the tradition of buying a new ornament every year to reflect their interests, hobbies, or significant life events. For example, newlyweds may look for ornaments that celebrate their first Christmas together, while pet owners may seek out ornaments shaped like their furry companions.

Are you ready to deck out your Christmas tree? The world's best selection is, of course, online, but where should you shop? Here are a few things to look for that can help you get started:

  • Variety. Look for online stores that offer a wide range of Christmas ornaments to choose from. Whether you're into traditional designs or modern, quirky styles, a diverse selection makes it more likely that you'll find something you love.
  • Quality. Pay attention to the materials and craftsmanship of the ornaments. High-quality ornaments are not only more durable but also look more elegant on your tree. You want your ornaments to look great when you take them out of the box next year.
  • Personalization options. If you're interested in personalized ornaments, choose a retailer that offers customization services. This allows you to add names, dates, or special messages to create meaningful keepsakes.
  • Reviews and reputation. Before making a purchase, check reviews and ratings of the online retailer (and maybe on the ornaments themselves). Positive feedback from previous customers can give you confidence in the quality of their products and service.
  • Shipping and returns policy. Consider the shipping costs and delivery times, especially if you're ordering close to the holidays. Additionally, double-check that the online store has a clear return policy in case you're not satisfied with your Christmas ornaments.

To help you find the perfect Christmas ornaments to adorn your tree and create lasting memories for years to come, the elves at Top Consumer Reviews have shopped the selection at some of today's most popular retailers, ranking them from best to worst so that you know which ones are on Santa's "nice” and "naughty” lists. Happy decorating!

Compare Christmas Ornament Stores

Select any 2 Christmas Ornament Stores to compare them head to head

best-christmas-ornaments
  • Wayfair
  • Etsy
  • Personalization Mall
  • Christmas Central
  • Target
  • Lowe's
  • Walmart
  • Home Depot
  • The Christmas Sleigh
  • Michaels
  • Ornament Shop
  • King of Christmas
Wayfair vs Etsy Wayfair vs Personalization Mall Wayfair vs Christmas Central Wayfair vs Target Wayfair vs Lowe's Wayfair vs Walmart Wayfair vs Home Depot Wayfair vs The Christmas Sleigh Wayfair vs Michaels Wayfair vs Ornament Shop Wayfair vs King of Christmas Etsy vs Personalization Mall Etsy vs Christmas Central Etsy vs Target Etsy vs Lowe's Etsy vs Walmart Etsy vs Home Depot Etsy vs The Christmas Sleigh Etsy vs Michaels Etsy vs Ornament Shop Etsy vs King of Christmas Personalization Mall vs Christmas Central Personalization Mall vs Target Personalization Mall vs Lowe's Personalization Mall vs Walmart Personalization Mall vs Home Depot Personalization Mall vs The Christmas Sleigh Personalization Mall vs Michaels Personalization Mall vs Ornament Shop Personalization Mall vs King of Christmas Christmas Central vs Target Christmas Central vs Lowe's Christmas Central vs Walmart Christmas Central vs Home Depot Christmas Central vs The Christmas Sleigh Christmas Central vs Michaels Christmas Central vs Ornament Shop Christmas Central vs King of Christmas Target vs Lowe's Target vs Walmart Target vs Home Depot Target vs The Christmas Sleigh Target vs Michaels Target vs Ornament Shop Target vs King of Christmas Lowe's vs Walmart Lowe's vs Home Depot Lowe's vs The Christmas Sleigh Lowe's vs Michaels Lowe's vs Ornament Shop Lowe's vs King of Christmas Walmart vs Home Depot Walmart vs The Christmas Sleigh Walmart vs Michaels Walmart vs Ornament Shop Walmart vs King of Christmas Home Depot vs The Christmas Sleigh Home Depot vs Michaels Home Depot vs Ornament Shop Home Depot vs King of Christmas The Christmas Sleigh vs Michaels The Christmas Sleigh vs Ornament Shop The Christmas Sleigh vs King of Christmas Michaels vs Ornament Shop Michaels vs King of Christmas Ornament Shop vs King of Christmas
Compare the Best Christmas Ornament Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Christmas Ornament Stores
The Best Reviews of Christmas Ornament Stores