Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Ornament Shop vs Pier 1

Friday, March 5th

2021 Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

Ornament Shop Review 5 Star Rating

Ornament Shop

5 Star Rating
  • Personalization: Yes
  • Cost: From $8.95 to $28.95
  • Shipping: $6.95 for 4 items or less, free for orders of 5+ ornaments
TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Ornament Shop should be your first stop for buying Christmas ornaments. With over 5,000 different varieties to choose from, personalization options galore, and free shipping on all orders of five ornaments or more, it's easy to see why Ornament Shop is the largest online retailer of personalized Christmas ornaments. They are our top pick for Christmas ornaments.

Pier 1 Review 3 Star Rating

Pier 1

3 Star Rating
  • Personalization: No
  • Cost: From $1.00 to $99.95
  • Shipping: Free on orders of $49+ with promo code, starting at $5 for regular orders

Well known for its cute and trendy finds from around the world, Pier 1 has a variety of styles of Christmas ornaments in its small collection. Prices are very competitive, but there are no options for personalization on any of the ornaments they sell. Returns are allowed within 45 days by mail or to any local Pier 1 store.

Where Can You Find the Best Christmas Ornaments?

When decorating for the holidays, a beautiful Christmas tree is a must. And what does every Christmas tree need to be complete? Ornaments, of course! Whether your style is classic with white or multi-colored lights and metallic round ornaments, or you go all-in to support your favorite sports team, you'll need the right Christmas ornaments to match your theme.

One popular trend in Christmas ornaments is personalization: instead of a plain store-bought design, many shoppers prefer to have an ornament that reflects something about themselves or their loved ones. For example, some families have the tradition of giving each child in the family a new ornament every Christmas - perhaps a soccer ball in the year their team won the championship, or a graduation cap to commemorate finishing high school.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Being able to customize these ornaments with a name, date, or other details creates a keepsake to treasure well into the future. Unfortunately, shopping at big-box retailers and even mall kiosks can be a hassle. Fighting the holiday crowds in multiple stores while trying to find the perfect Christmas ornaments for your tree can leave you feeling more like a Scrooge than a Santa.

For this reason, today's shoppers frequently turn to online retailers to buy their Christmas ornaments, getting the very best selection and personalization options without ever having to leave home. What should you look for when deciding where to buy your Christmas ornaments? Consider these five criteria:

  • Selection. Does the store give you a wide variety of options to choose from, or just a handful of products in a limited range of styles and colors?
  • Price. Can you buy ornaments at affordable prices? Does the retailer offer any discounts, such as free shipping or a buy-one, get-one free promotion?
  • Quality. Are the ornaments made to last, or are they likely to break or fade after a few seasons on your tree? Are there any customer reviews provided on individual ornaments that can give you an idea of how well they are made?
  • Personalization. Can you add a name, date, or other message to the Christmas ornaments you choose?
  • Customer Service. Does the store have a good track record for keeping customers happy? What is their return policy and satisfaction guarantee?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Christmas Ornament stores available online. We hope these reviews help you find the perfect decorations for your Christmas tree at the best possible price!

The Best Reviews of Christmas Ornament Stores