Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Pier 1 Review

Tuesday, February 7th

2023 Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

Pier 1 Review 1.5 Star Rating

Pier 1

1.5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping on orders $99+
  • Well-known partner brands
  • Over 50 years of retail experience
  • 30-day returns for store credit only
  • All ornaments on sale

Pier 1 Imports was established in 1962. They sell indoor and outdoor furniture, candles, pillows, dining furniture, light fixtures, curtains, rugs, home decor, seasonal products, and everything in between. The company has experienced a rough go the last few years and is closing the majority of their brick-and-mortar stores after filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2020. Their partner brands include Farmerscart, RadioShack, MentorBox, SteinMart, Dress Barn, and other recognizable brands.

Odd selection

To put it frankly, the Christmas ornaments at Pier 1 are a little weird. The first ornaments we found were of dragons, skulls, elephants, octopi, and llamas with Santa hats. This wasn't exactly what we expected when looking for items that are supposed to spread holiday cheer and usher in the spirit of Christmas. Mixed in with the Christmas ornaments is a selection of table decor, tree collars, and Christmas trees. In total there were barely over 60 ornaments to choose from. Our guess is that they aren't restocking any items, so they are trying to clear out the remainder of whatever they have left, hence the odd selection.

All ornaments on sale

Since Pier 1 is ostensibly clearing out their selection of ornaments, they are all on sale. All of them started at $29.95 and were marked down to $19. Even the sale price seems too expensive for many of the items, so you won't be scoring any sweet deals there.

Best Christmas Ornaments

No refunds, just store credit

If you are unhappy with the Christmas ornaments you buy from Pier 1 and need to return them, you're out of luck - kind of. You can pay the return shipping to send your ornaments back, but rather than getting a refund, you'll only get a store credit. You have 30 days to change your mind about the ornaments in order to qualify for the store credit and everything must be in its original condition and packaging.

Free shipping on orders of $99+

If you want to subscribe to their email list and stay updated with alerts and discounts, Pier 1 will give you $15 off your next order. In addition, you qualify for free shipping if you spend $99 or more. Any orders of less than $35 incur a $4.95 shipping fee, $35.01 - $50 costs $6.95 to ship, and purchases of $50.01 - $99 cost $9.95 to ship.

Not worth your time

The Better Business Bureau only gives Pier 1 a "C" rating. Going off customer reviews alone, things do not look good for Pier 1. The majority of responses from their customers about the buying experience include frequent complaints about seemingly non-existent customer service, low quality, issues with returns and refunds, and more. Sadly, it's rare to find a customer review that has good things to say about Pier 1. We are definitely leery of shopping online here, not to mention the fact that their selection is painfully dismal. Look elsewhere when shopping for Christmas ornaments.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Christmas Ornaments?

For most people, putting up the Christmas tree and decorating it each year is a big event. Some people string popcorn or berries around the tree and hang ribbon, tinsel, or garland. Others hang bright, sparkly lights of all colors. However, the most meaningful decorations on a Christmas tree are the ornaments. They are what differentiate one's Christmas tree from all the rest and can tell a family story.

Many people choose to have all of their Christmas ornaments color-coordinated or stick to a theme like snowmen, Disney, animals, or something else they love. There are usually a few handmade ornaments made by children and loved ones that are given as gifts. Sometimes families treasure antique ornaments that have been handed down for generations. Each ornament means something to the person who owns it and together they make a statement about your style, traditions, and memories.

The Best Christmas Ornament Stores Compare Christmas Ornament Stores Compare Christmas Ornament Store Reviews What are the best Christmas Ornament Stores Best Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

Christmas Ornament Store FAQ

While no one knows for certain exactly when the tradition of decorating Christmas trees began, it's believed to have its origins in 16th century Germany. Almost 300 years later, it became popular in the United States as well, and the tradition really gained steam when the department store Woolworth's started importing hand-blown glass ornaments from Germany.
Glass ornaments have been around the longest and still convey a nostalgic feel when used to decorate a tree. But, as personalization options increased, bespoke ornaments became the most popular way to make the holidays shine - from sports-themed trees to baubles commemorating everything from a new home to a graduation.
You can buy Christmas ornament assortments with 10-20 in a box for $20 or less. Individual ornaments are usually priced anywhere from $2 to $20 or more, depending on what they're made of and how much personalization is involved.
Many Christmas ornament retailers include complimentary delivery with your order. You might have to purchase a certain number of ornaments or meet a minimum dollar amount to qualify.
Lots! Photo ornaments are really popular: you can get a set with all of your favorite memories from the year's travel adventures, your pets, or anything you can imagine. Personalized ornaments with important dates and names are also very common, to recognize an accomplishment that happened during the year, to celebrate a baby's first Christmas, and so on.
Some Christmas ornament stores are open year-round, and that can make it easy to shop in advance. The closer you get to Thanksgiving (when a lot of people put up the decorations), the more likely it is that an ornament you want might be out of stock. The selection in brick-and-mortar stores can be pretty sparse between Thanksgiving and Christmas, but you will probably have more luck shopping online.
That depends on the store! Some pride themselves on being your one-stop Christmas shop, letting you get all of your lights, garland, tree toppers, stockings and ornaments in one online order. Others stay laser-focused on providing the best selection of Christmas ornaments alone.
Return policies vary. If you purchased personalized ornaments, the policy may be strict - and if you spelled a name wrong, you probably won't get your money back. Otherwise, many stores give you 30 days or more to send your ornaments back if you get them and they're not what you expected.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you're moving away from home for the first time, newly married and excited to start new traditions, or just looking for some fresh new ornaments to add some holiday spirit to your Christmas tree, you can easily find ones you love online. You can browse thousands of Christmas ornament categories, colors, and styles with the click of a few buttons. The ornaments you choose will be a big part of your Christmas memories for years to come!

As you browse Christmas ornament stores, there are some important things to keep in mind:

  • Selection: Does the retailer sell a range of designs, themes, and colors of Christmas ornaments to choose from? Can you buy sets that come with multiple coordinated ornaments?
  • Pricing: How does the cost of Christmas ornaments at one retailer compare with another? How much will you be charged for shipping?
  • Return Policy: If the Christmas ornaments don't look as good as you'd hoped on your tree or you change your mind about the theme you want, can you easily return the ornaments you purchased? Will you have to pay restocking fees?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Christmas ornament stores available online. We hope this information helps you find the right Christmas tree decor to set the tone for a wonderful holiday season!

The Best Reviews of Christmas Ornament Stores