Which cigar clubs are the best? If cigars are one of your favorite ways to relax, you're in luck. Instead of stocking up at your local smoke shop, you can grab your favorite flavors and brands on the regular with a cigar club. These subscription services offer you selections of all your favorites. Whether you're looking for Parejo or Figurado cigars, you can find everything you want (and have it shipped directly to your door). Even for the top brands like Cohiba, Montecristo, Romeo y Julieta, or Arturo Fuente, there's a cigar club out there that will get you your favorites.
Best Option
Read Full Review
Amazing Clubs is a popular subscription service with 38 unique clubs, including a cigar club that features five premium cigars each month. The cigar club comes with flexible plan lengths, free shipping, and extras like a humidity control packet and a cigar cutter, making it a standout gift option or personal treat. With high customer ratings, an "A-" BBB score, and a satisfaction guarantee that offers refunds, Amazing Clubs earns the top spot in our review of cigar subscriptions.
Very Good
Read Full Review
Rare Cigar Club is a monthly subscription from MonthlyClubs that delivers four premium cigars, featuring selections like Drew Estate Blackened Shade to Black and Gurkha Centurian Double Perfecto. The club costs $49.95 per month plus $5 shipping and comes with a satisfaction guarantee that allows for a replacement or refund if the cigars don't meet expectations. While Rare Cigar Club earned praise in blog reviews for quality and flavor, the lack of third-party verified feedback kept it from the top spot. However, if you want rare cigars, this is worth a look.
Premium Cigar of the Month Club, part of the MonthlyClubs family, offers two monthly subscription options featuring hand-rolled cigars from regions like Nicaragua, Honduras, and the Dominican Republic. Premium Cigar of the Month Club comes with a satisfaction guarantee and high marks for its parent company, but the lack of verified customer reviews for this cigar club makes it harder to gauge compared to other cigar subscriptions, earning it a more balanced rating for now.
Average
Read Full Review
Cigar of the Month Club, part of the Clubs of America lineup, delivers hand-rolled cigars each month from places like Nicaragua, Jamaica, and the Canary Islands in its subscription boxes. The club offers prepaid plans ranging from two to twelve months with free shipping, but it does not provide ongoing subscriptions or refunds. While Cigar of the Month Club benefits from the parent company's "A+" BBB rating, the lack of verified customer reviews makes this cigar club less competitive than other subscription options in our review.
Average
Read Full Review
Southern Cigar Company offers a cigar club that delivers four mystery cigars each month, with options for monthly or prepaid plans. The service stands out for its low pricing and occasional gifts, but it has strict no-refund policies and little verified customer feedback, making its reputation harder to confirm. While the mystery delivery element may appeal to adventurous cigar fans, the lack of transparency and recent reviews means Southern Cigar Company is best suited for those willing to take a chance.
Subpar
Read Full Review
Cigars International has been offering cigar subscriptions since 1996, with options for either 4 or 8 cigars per month. The service includes free shipping, members-only discounts, and a free cigar cutter for first-time club members, plus the option to buy more cigars a-la-carte from over 248 choices. While Cigars International holds an "A+" BBB rating, the company's poor Trustpilot scores, reports of stale cigars, and unclear refund policies make this cigar club a risky choice for cigar lovers despite its wide selection.
Holt's Cigar Company has been in the cigar business since 1989 and offers a simple monthly cigar club that delivers five premium cigars with tasting notes, ratings, and a Boveda humidification pack. The subscription includes free shipping and discounts for a-la-carte purchases from a selection of over 550 brands. While Holt's Cigar Company earns an "A+" from the BBB, older third-party reviews and reports of stale cigars make it a less reliable choice compared to clubs with much more recent feedback.
Weak
Read Full Review
Thompson Cigar offers a cigar club with five different subscription lengths, delivering five cigars per box from well-known brands like Montecristo and Cohiba. The company has an affordable price range and includes perks like free shipping and a cigar cutter with the first order. While Thompson Cigar holds an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, recent customer reviews reveal many issues with missing shipments and poor customer service, making this club a risky choice despite the low prices.
Poor
Read Full Review
JR Cigar has been around since 1971 and offers a monthly cigar club that delivers five premium cigars from well-known brands like Montecristo and Alec Bradley. The subscription includes loyalty points and offers special discounts for certain professionals, but returns are only allowed for unopened boxes. Despite its long history and large selection, JR Cigar holds low ratings on the BBB and Trustpilot, with many customers reporting dried-out cigars, slow shipping, and unhelpful service, making it a cigar club to avoid.
Flawed
Read Full Review
Mike's Cigars offers prepaid cigar club memberships ranging from 3-18 months, with each shipment including five cigars and perks like luxury items, discounts, and, in higher tiers, a humidor. However, subscriptions cannot be returned, and cancellations come with a fee. While Mike's Cigars has a long history in the industry, its low BBB ratings, poor Trustpilot reviews, and frequent customer complaints about missing shipments and unresponsive service make it a risky option compared to other cigar clubs.
Continued from above...
If cigars are one of your favorite ways to relax, you're in luck. Instead of stocking up at your local smoke shop, you can grab your favorite flavors and brands on the regular with a cigar club. These subscription services offer you selections of all your favorites. Whether you're looking for Parejo or Figurado cigars, you can find everything you want (and have it shipped directly to your door). Even for the top brands like Cohiba, Montecristo, Romeo y Julieta, or Arturo Fuente, there's a cigar club out there that will get you your favorites.
Cigars are a timeless and luxurious way to unwind at the end of the day, and a pastime with a rich history. Cigars date back to the Mayan empire, which used tobacco in ritual practices and for medicinal purposes long before anyone else had discovered the benefits. Expeditions brought tobacco to Europe in the late 1400's. When tobacco made its way to Spain, cigars became popular there, and led to the establishment of cigar factories in Seville and in Cuba. Today, cigars are enjoyed worldwide and come with a sense of classic appeal, since the more recent association of cigars with literature or writers like Ernest Hemingway.
The convenience of a cigar club can't be beat. While sometimes you have to wait for restocks at your local store, subscriptions will handle everything for you, so you don't have to search for cigars even when your favorites are running out. Plus, if you're the adventurous sort, cigar clubs can allow you to try new flavors, more full-bodied options, or just a different international variety than you might find locally. Even if you like shopping online, the completely hands-off shipments with a subscription let you enjoy your cigars without needing to remember to stock up.
Plus, the best cigar clubs offer more than just shipments of cigars. They offer a social opportunity to connect with other like-minded fans. You can get access to unique varieties alongside educational materials and social events surrounding cigars. Plus, a lot of cigar clubs offer savings and discounts on a-la-carte purchases (outside of the club shipments) on cigars and accessories. So, if you're looking for rare or unique cigars, to make friends with other cigar lovers, and to learn more about the cigar experience, finding a top cigar club is going to be your next step.
If you're ready to jump on board with your cigar club subscription, we've got your back. There are tons of services out there, so picking the best one for your next cigar experience can be difficult. To make it easier for you to find your new home for enjoying cigars, we made a quick list of factors to guide your decision:
Subscribing to a cigar club is a great way to relax, socialize, and let loose a little. So, to help you get on your way to cloud nine, Top Consumer Reviews has done the work to research and rank some of today's most popular cigar club subscriptions. This way, you can sit back and enjoy your cigars without any stress of finding the right one or the right flavor. Enjoy!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
