Who's better?

Holt's Cigar Company vs Gotham Cigar Club

We've analyzed the best Cigar Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Cigar Club Reviews

Here you can see how Holt's Cigar Company and Gotham Cigar Club match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Cigar Clubs in 2025.

Winner

Holt's Cigar Company

  • Costs $29.95 per delivery
  • 5 cigars per shipment
  • Free shipping

Holt's Cigar Company stands out as the most minimalist cigar club in this review. They offer the Holt's Cigar of the Month Club with a single month-to-month option for $29.95. In-person shoppers gave positive reviews, but online users rated the company lower. Although the club is basic, it's budget-friendly and holds an "A+" BBB rating, making it a decent company for those seeking affordability. Balancing the mixed reviews and low customizability with the low price and discounts, Holt's Cigar Company earns just above average rating from us.

Gotham Cigar Club

  • Prices from $29.95 to $299
  • 1-12 month options
  • 5 cigars per shipment

Gotham Cigar Club, established in 2001, offers a diverse range of cigars via monthly deliveries of five curated premium selections with accompanying newsletters. The website's design feels outdated, and while the Cigar Club has multiple pricing tiers, confusion arises due to differing prices between similar tiers. Despite an "A+" BBB rating, there's limited customer buzz and reviews, making it challenging for potential members to gauge the service's quality. The absence of transparency in its selection process and limited delivery frequency options contribute to Gotham Cigar Club's lower rating compared to rivals in our evaluation.

Whether you're a seasoned aficionado, a curious novice, or somewhere in between, joining a cigar club can significantly elevate your cigar experience. The surge in popularity of cigar clubs in recent years has introduced a variety of exciting options to the market. Being part of a cigar club allows you to enjoy these premium cigars at a discounted price compared to purchasing them individually.

But, a premium cigar club goes beyond just delivering cigars; they provide detailed information about each unique selection and its manufacturer. On top of that, the best cigar clubs offer flexibility, allowing you to tailor your membership to your preferences in terms of cigar types or shipment frequency. As the popularity of cigar clubs continues to grow, competition among them is fierce, so it's essential to be an informed consumer before making a decision.

Cigars continue to be valued for their complex flavors, aromas, and the sense of relaxation and luxury they offer during leisurely moments or social gatherings. The United States stands as one of the largest consumers of cigars worldwide, contributing significantly to global cigar sales. When it comes to cigar production, the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Honduras lead the way, renowned for their expertise in crafting high-quality premium cigars.

Cigars come in two main types: premium hand-rolled cigars and machine-made cigars. Premium cigars are often made by skilled artisans, resulting in a superior smoking experience. On the other hand, machine-made cigars are produced using automated processes, allowing for mass production at a more affordable price point. While both types offer unique smoking experiences, a newcomer to the cigar world might not know where to find or try new ones. That's where a cigar club comes into play.

In order to get a taste of the wide variety of cigars, a club offers you a luxury experience and curated cigar choices from all over the world. There's no need to compare top name-brands and limited production labels; the club's experts take care of that for you (or for anyone you want to send a cigar as a gift). Plus, the convenience offered by top cigar clubs is unparalleled. Instead of tirelessly searching for cigars from different regions around the world, the club will deliver a curated selection right to your doorstep.

When selecting the right cigar club for you, it's important to check out their best features. If you're not sure where to start, we've made a quick list for you to help you narrow down your best options:

Top Consumer Reviews has searched out the best cigar clubs out there and ranked them for you, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy your first (or favorite) cigar. So whether you'd like a Robusto, Toro, Churchill, or Corona, or maybe you'd like to try them all, we hope this information helps you select the best Cigar Club for your smoking experience.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Cigar Club FAQ

Where do the cigars come from?
All over the world! Most are made in Central and South America and the Caribbean. You can also find clubs with cigars originating in the Canary Islands and the US.
How often will the cigars be delivered?
Most cigar clubs are shipped monthly, and you choose how long you'd like the membership to last - usually anywhere from 2-12 months. A few clubs give you the option to have cigars delivered quarterly, if you prefer not to receive them every month.
Are cigar clubs expensive?
Not necessarily. Expect a monthly price ranging from $20 to $45 for a cigar club with 4-5 cigars in each package.
Do I have to pay extra for shipping?
That depends on the cigar club you select. Some include the delivery fees in the monthly price, while others tack on shipping costs of approximately $5 per shipment.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Sometimes. Most cigar clubs have been around for many years, with thousands of happy customers - so you're unlikely to be disappointed. But yes, some providers go the extra mile by offering a refund or replacement if your cigars arrive in less-than-perfect condition for any reason.
Is it legal to buy cigars through a club?
Yes, although the club you select may verify your age to make sure you are old enough to smoke according to the laws where you live. Since most cigar clubs don't include products from Cuba, they avoid any trade restrictions that might otherwise limit their selection.
Do I get anything extra with the deliveries?
Many cigar clubs include an informative newsletter, describing the origin of each cigar, the process by which they were made, and even recommended alcohol pairings. You might also receive a reusable humidification device that will keep your cigars in top condition both in transit and while being stored at the home or office.
Do cigar clubs make good gifts?
For any true tobacco aficionado, could there be anything better? Most cigar clubs provide gift-giving options, from personalized notes included in the first shipment to an announcement that can be sent via email on the date of your choice.

Compare Any 2 Products

Premium Cigar of the Month Club
Rare Cigar Club
Cigar of the Month Club
Amazing Clubs
Holt's Cigar Company
Thompson Cigar
Gotham Cigar Club
Cigars International
JR Cigar
Southern Cigar Company
vs
Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Rare Cigar ClubPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Cigar of the Month ClubPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Amazing ClubsPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Holt's Cigar CompanyPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Thompson CigarPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Gotham Cigar ClubPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Cigars InternationalPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs JR CigarPremium Cigar of the Month Club vs Southern Cigar CompanyRare Cigar Club vs Cigar of the Month ClubRare Cigar Club vs Amazing ClubsRare Cigar Club vs Holt's Cigar CompanyRare Cigar Club vs Thompson CigarRare Cigar Club vs Gotham Cigar ClubRare Cigar Club vs Cigars InternationalRare Cigar Club vs JR CigarRare Cigar Club vs Southern Cigar CompanyCigar of the Month Club vs Amazing ClubsCigar of the Month Club vs Holt's Cigar CompanyCigar of the Month Club vs Thompson CigarCigar of the Month Club vs Gotham Cigar ClubCigar of the Month Club vs Cigars InternationalCigar of the Month Club vs JR CigarCigar of the Month Club vs Southern Cigar CompanyAmazing Clubs vs Holt's Cigar CompanyAmazing Clubs vs Thompson CigarAmazing Clubs vs Gotham Cigar ClubAmazing Clubs vs Cigars InternationalAmazing Clubs vs JR CigarAmazing Clubs vs Southern Cigar CompanyHolt's Cigar Company vs Thompson CigarHolt's Cigar Company vs Gotham Cigar ClubHolt's Cigar Company vs Cigars InternationalHolt's Cigar Company vs JR CigarHolt's Cigar Company vs Southern Cigar CompanyThompson Cigar vs Gotham Cigar ClubThompson Cigar vs Cigars InternationalThompson Cigar vs JR CigarThompson Cigar vs Southern Cigar CompanyGotham Cigar Club vs Cigars InternationalGotham Cigar Club vs JR CigarGotham Cigar Club vs Southern Cigar CompanyCigars International vs JR CigarCigars International vs Southern Cigar CompanyJR Cigar vs Southern Cigar Company Southern Cigar Company vs JR CigarSouthern Cigar Company vs Cigars InternationalSouthern Cigar Company vs Gotham Cigar ClubSouthern Cigar Company vs Thompson CigarSouthern Cigar Company vs Holt's Cigar CompanySouthern Cigar Company vs Amazing ClubsSouthern Cigar Company vs Cigar of the Month ClubSouthern Cigar Company vs Rare Cigar ClubSouthern Cigar Company vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubJR Cigar vs Cigars InternationalJR Cigar vs Gotham Cigar ClubJR Cigar vs Thompson CigarJR Cigar vs Holt's Cigar CompanyJR Cigar vs Amazing ClubsJR Cigar vs Cigar of the Month ClubJR Cigar vs Rare Cigar ClubJR Cigar vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubCigars International vs Gotham Cigar ClubCigars International vs Thompson CigarCigars International vs Holt's Cigar CompanyCigars International vs Amazing ClubsCigars International vs Cigar of the Month ClubCigars International vs Rare Cigar ClubCigars International vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubGotham Cigar Club vs Thompson CigarGotham Cigar Club vs Holt's Cigar CompanyGotham Cigar Club vs Amazing ClubsGotham Cigar Club vs Cigar of the Month ClubGotham Cigar Club vs Rare Cigar ClubGotham Cigar Club vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubThompson Cigar vs Holt's Cigar CompanyThompson Cigar vs Amazing ClubsThompson Cigar vs Cigar of the Month ClubThompson Cigar vs Rare Cigar ClubThompson Cigar vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubHolt's Cigar Company vs Amazing ClubsHolt's Cigar Company vs Cigar of the Month ClubHolt's Cigar Company vs Rare Cigar ClubHolt's Cigar Company vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubAmazing Clubs vs Cigar of the Month ClubAmazing Clubs vs Rare Cigar ClubAmazing Clubs vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubCigar of the Month Club vs Rare Cigar ClubCigar of the Month Club vs Premium Cigar of the Month ClubRare Cigar Club vs Premium Cigar of the Month Club
Only the Best Reviews

mlive

Historic train depot transformed into Italian steakhouse after $13 ...

The train depot originally opened nearly 100 years ago and has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

Wed, 16 Jul 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Detroit Free Press

Birmingham's Big Rock Italian Chophouse set to open July 15 with ...

Big Rock Italian Chophouse in Birmingham, a more than $13 million restaurant project two years in the making, will open July 15.

Thu, 10 Jul 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Business ...

Big Rock Italian Chophouse is Cameron Mitchell Restaurants' newest ...

Cameron Mitchell Restaurants opened a new steakhouse and cigar club – but it will be a drive for local fans. Cameron Mitchell opens German Village restaurant Columbus food hall welcomes pair of new ...

Tue, 15 Jul 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Crain's Detroit ...

$13M remake of Birmingham chophouse a 'calculated gamble' for ...

Illinois-based design firm Knauer Inc. is handling the design work. Knauer locally has also designed Parc restaurant at Campus Martius in downtown Detroit and is working on Presley's Kitchen + Bar, a ...

Mon, 07 Jul 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Daily Journal

Tupelo Smokes Cigar Club celebrates 10 years of tobacco and ...

Amy Whatley rests her light-bodied cigar on her leg as she and other members of the Tupelo Smokes Cigar Club celebrate their 10-year anniversary in downtown Tupelo in May 2023.

Fri, 23 Jun 2023

Only the Best Reviews

St. Cloud Times

St. Cloud business owner creates Cigar Club, meeting weekly

Cigar Club is set to convene at 6 p.m. Monday, Oct. 21, (when the forecast is for partly cloudy skies and early evening temperatures in the 60s) and again on Oct. 28 ...

Thu, 17 Oct 2024

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.