Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Gotham Cigar Club Review

Monday, April 15th

2024 Cigar Club Reviews

Gotham Cigar Club Review 2.5 Star Rating

Gotham Cigar Club

2.5 Star Rating
  • Prices from $29.95 to $299
  • 1-12 month options
  • 5 cigars per shipment
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

If you heard "Gotham" and asked "Where's Batman?" , you might be a little disappointed - but if you're ready for a solid selection of cigars, you're in luck. In 2001, Gotham Cigar Club emerged as an option for aficionados seeking a comprehensive array of cigar offerings, showcasing an extensive selection of popular cigar brands. The Gotham Cigar Club website functions as a gateway to a diverse array of cigar options, spanning premium cigars, machine-made variants, filtered selections, and much more, thereby catering to a wide spectrum of preferences and tastes.

Know the history of your cigars

Gotham Cigar Club delivers a curated selection of five premium cigars on a monthly basis. The meticulous selection process is undertaken by Gotham Cigar Club's resident cigar experts, who handpick cigars that showcase top quality and good craftsmanship. Each monthly shipment comes with a newsletter, designed to provide insights into the origin and flavor profile of each cigar and how it was selected by Gotham Cigar Club.

Pricing differences are confusing

On top of the selection of individual cigars and cigar-related gifts offered by Gotham Cigar Club, the company offers 8 different ways to get involved with the Gotham Cigar of the Month Club. There are technically four tiers - Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Diamond - but there are two pricing options for each tier. However, based on the description, we're not sure why the prices between silver and gold are different, other than some of them have a "Groupon" button on them and others don't.

Best Cigar Clubs

Plan pricing

Here are the tiers laid out for you in case you're curious how it all shakes out:

  • Silver Membership: 1 month for $29.95
  • Silver Gotham Cigar of the Month Club: 1 month for $50
  • Gold Membership: 3 months for $79.99
  • Gold Gotham Cigar of the Month Club: 3 months for $99
  • Platinum Membership: 6 months for $149.99
  • Platinum Gotham Cigar of the Month Club: 6 months for $199
  • Diamond Membership: 12 months for $299
  • Diamond Gotham Cigar of the Month Club: 12 months for $299

Gotham lacks transparency

While Gotham Cigar Club tries to offer competitive options, a notable void emerges in terms of club details. Each delivery includes five cigars, but that's about all we can find out. When compared to the comprehensive approach embraced by other cigar clubs, the absence of clarity regarding Gotham Cigar Club's cigar selection process raises questions about what goes into each delivery and how carefully those cigars are selected. A lack of transparency makes it hard to make a direct comparison to other companies and could leave potential members seeking a more comprehensive service.

UI could use an update

While the site is okay overall and isn't too hard to navigate, it still feels a little out of date. And, because the Gotham Cigar Club is set up as separate products for each membership style, it comes across as a clunky way to shop. Customers can figure it out, but there are much more seamless ways to offer different tiers and make them easier to compare side by side.

Best Cigar Clubs

Gotham doesn't have much buzz

In terms of reputation, there isn't a lot of buzz about the Gotham Cigar Club. There aren't many reviews out there except on Google, and that's just over 100 total. The star rating average is around 3.7 stars and isn't what we'd call impressive. On the other hand, Gotham Cigar Club does have a full "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, though there aren't any reviews for the service on the BBB site at all. According to a few blog reviews, the company is "legit" , but there aren't many specific reviews regarding quality or customer service, which is somewhat frustrating for customers looking for feedback from cigar fans like themselves.

Limitations knock Gotham lower

Despite the variety of club options, Gotham Cigar Club has some limitations that influence its rating. The absence of comprehensive delivery frequencies, like the ones offered by rival subscription services, serves as a notable drawback. Plus, Gotham Cigar Club is missing details for its selection process which can either confuse customers or make them feel less confident about the depth of its commitment to quality and expertise. As a result, these factors contribute to the club's comparatively lower rating overall, especially given that many other cigar services have competitive reviews and even better prices.

Where Can You Find the Best Cigar Club?

Whether you're a seasoned aficionado, a curious novice, or somewhere in between, joining a cigar club can significantly elevate your cigar experience. The surge in popularity of cigar clubs in recent years has introduced a variety of exciting options to the market. Being part of a cigar club allows you to enjoy these premium cigars at a discounted price compared to purchasing them individually.

But, a premium cigar club goes beyond just delivering cigars; they provide detailed information about each unique selection and its manufacturer. On top of that, the best cigar clubs offer flexibility, allowing you to tailor your membership to your preferences in terms of cigar types or shipment frequency. As the popularity of cigar clubs continues to grow, competition among them is fierce, so it's essential to be an informed consumer before making a decision.

The Best Cigar Clubs Compare Cigar Clubs Compare Cigar Club Reviews What are the best Cigar Clubs Best Cigar Club Reviews

Cigar Club FAQ

All over the world! Most are made in Central and South America and the Caribbean. You can also find clubs with cigars originating in the Canary Islands and the US.
Most cigar clubs are shipped monthly, and you choose how long you'd like the membership to last - usually anywhere from 2-12 months. A few clubs give you the option to have cigars delivered quarterly, if you prefer not to receive them every month.
Not necessarily. Expect a monthly price ranging from $20 to $45 for a cigar club with 4-5 cigars in each package.
That depends on the cigar club you select. Some include the delivery fees in the monthly price, while others tack on shipping costs of approximately $5 per shipment.
Sometimes. Most cigar clubs have been around for many years, with thousands of happy customers - so you're unlikely to be disappointed. But yes, some providers go the extra mile by offering a refund or replacement if your cigars arrive in less-than-perfect condition for any reason.
Yes, although the club you select may verify your age to make sure you are old enough to smoke according to the laws where you live. Since most cigar clubs don't include products from Cuba, they avoid any trade restrictions that might otherwise limit their selection.
Many cigar clubs include an informative newsletter, describing the origin of each cigar, the process by which they were made, and even recommended alcohol pairings. You might also receive a reusable humidification device that will keep your cigars in top condition both in transit and while being stored at the home or office.
For any true tobacco aficionado, could there be anything better? Most cigar clubs provide gift-giving options, from personalized notes included in the first shipment to an announcement that can be sent via email on the date of your choice.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Cigars continue to be valued for their complex flavors, aromas, and the sense of relaxation and luxury they offer during leisurely moments or social gatherings. The United States stands as one of the largest consumers of cigars worldwide, contributing significantly to global cigar sales. When it comes to cigar production, the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Honduras lead the way, renowned for their expertise in crafting high-quality premium cigars.

Cigars come in two main types: premium hand-rolled cigars and machine-made cigars. Premium cigars are often made by skilled artisans, resulting in a superior smoking experience. On the other hand, machine-made cigars are produced using automated processes, allowing for mass production at a more affordable price point. While both types offer unique smoking experiences, a newcomer to the cigar world might not know where to find or try new ones. That's where a cigar club comes into play.

In order to get a taste of the wide variety of cigars, a club offers you a luxury experience and curated cigar choices from all over the world. There's no need to compare top name-brands and limited production labels; the club's experts take care of that for you (or for anyone you want to send a cigar as a gift). Plus, the convenience offered by top cigar clubs is unparalleled. Instead of tirelessly searching for cigars from different regions around the world, the club will deliver a curated selection right to your doorstep.

When selecting the right cigar club for you, it's important to check out their best features. If you're not sure where to start, we've made a quick list for you to help you narrow down your best options:

  • Cost. There are lots of cigar companies that sell a variety of products. Whether you're looking for rare cigars, hand-rolled cigars, or you just want something rolled by a machine, your budget can change where you shop and what you're shopping for. Keeping an eye on who offers good deals, discounts, and competitive prices can help you decide which one gets your membership.
  • Club length. Not all cigar clubs are structured in the same way. Some offer only one shipping frequency at month-to-month while others let you prepay for up to a year of shipments. Keep in mind how long you want cigars to help you decide where to buy.
  • Guarantees. Not all cigar clubs offer guarantees or price matching, but some of them do, and keeping an eye out for them can help you decide which options make you feel most secure when making a purchase. A 100% satisfaction guarantee is a great way to know that a company stands by the quality of its cigars.
  • Reputation. If you finish your research and still feel unsure, it's a good idea to look into the company's reputation. Read what other customers have said in reviews or see how the Better Business Bureau rates them. This helps you know if the company is trustworthy and offers the cigar experience you and other enthusiasts are looking for.

Top Consumer Reviews has searched out the best cigar clubs out there and ranked them for you, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy your first (or favorite) cigar. So whether you'd like a Robusto, Toro, Churchill, or Corona, or maybe you'd like to try them all, we hope this information helps you select the best Cigar Club for your smoking experience.

Compare Cigar Clubs

Select any 2 Cigar Clubs to compare them head to head

  • Premium Cigar of the Month Club
  • Rare Cigar Club
  • Cigar of the Month Club
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Holt's Cigar Company
  • Thompson Cigar
  • Gotham Cigar Club
  • Cigars International
  • JR Cigar
  • Southern Cigar Company
Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Rare Cigar Club Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Cigar of the Month Club Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Amazing Clubs Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Holt's Cigar Company Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Thompson Cigar Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Gotham Cigar Club Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Cigars International Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs JR Cigar Premium Cigar of the Month Club vs Southern Cigar Company Rare Cigar Club vs Cigar of the Month Club Rare Cigar Club vs Amazing Clubs Rare Cigar Club vs Holt's Cigar Company Rare Cigar Club vs Thompson Cigar Rare Cigar Club vs Gotham Cigar Club Rare Cigar Club vs Cigars International Rare Cigar Club vs JR Cigar Rare Cigar Club vs Southern Cigar Company Cigar of the Month Club vs Amazing Clubs Cigar of the Month Club vs Holt's Cigar Company Cigar of the Month Club vs Thompson Cigar Cigar of the Month Club vs Gotham Cigar Club Cigar of the Month Club vs Cigars International Cigar of the Month Club vs JR Cigar Cigar of the Month Club vs Southern Cigar Company Amazing Clubs vs Holt's Cigar Company Amazing Clubs vs Thompson Cigar Amazing Clubs vs Gotham Cigar Club Amazing Clubs vs Cigars International Amazing Clubs vs JR Cigar Amazing Clubs vs Southern Cigar Company Holt's Cigar Company vs Thompson Cigar Holt's Cigar Company vs Gotham Cigar Club Holt's Cigar Company vs Cigars International Holt's Cigar Company vs JR Cigar Holt's Cigar Company vs Southern Cigar Company Thompson Cigar vs Gotham Cigar Club Thompson Cigar vs Cigars International Thompson Cigar vs JR Cigar Thompson Cigar vs Southern Cigar Company Gotham Cigar Club vs Cigars International Gotham Cigar Club vs JR Cigar Gotham Cigar Club vs Southern Cigar Company Cigars International vs JR Cigar Cigars International vs Southern Cigar Company JR Cigar vs Southern Cigar Company
Compare the Best Cigar Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Cigar Clubs
See the Best Cigar Club
The Best Reviews of Cigar Clubs