Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, February 5th
Kay Jewelers is likely not one of the places you first think of when you're looking for a class ring. They're most known for their engagement rings and other sentimental jewelry. Kay Jewelers began in 1916 and originally sold music boxes, silverware, appliances, razors, and eyeglasses among some jewelry pieces. They are now one of the leading jewelry stores in America with over 1,000 stores and a big online presence, with a selection that includes class rings.
46 ring choices
There are 46 styles of class rings to choose from at Kay. Some of the designs are big and bold, while others are small and simple. You can narrow down your options by gender (30 rings for women and 16 for men), price, ring size, metal type, metal color, stone type, and stone color.
Customization similar to other retailers
The cost of class rings from Kay Jewelers is comparable to what class rings are priced at from other retailers. Most of them start around $200 and the most expensive ring starts at $399. Once you've selected a ring style you like, you can instantly begin customizing it the way you want by choosing whether you want real or CZ diamonds, which type of metal you prefer, the stone color, side design, and engraving message. The process for creating rings at Kay Jewelers is similar to most other jewelry stores.
Specific delivery dates
Each product description includes an estimated delivery date, which is nice. Rather than saying "manufacturing usually takes between 4 and 6 weeks" , Kay gives a specific estimated delivery date. Most of them are about 2 months out. They offer free shipping on all orders, which is a nice perk.
Read item reviews
Something we like about Kay Jewelers is that customers can leave reviews on individual items. This means that many of the class rings have helpful feedback from customers about how easy it is to read engravings based on the size of the ring, how high of quality you can expect, if delivery times were accurate, and more.
Questionable class ring return policy
Kay Jewelers has a 30-day return policy that states as long as your items are in new, unused condition, they can be sent back for a full refund via the original payment method. However, since class rings are customized, it is unclear as to whether or not they fall under this policy. Depending on the issue with your order and why you're needing to return it, you may or may not be able to get a refund. We recommend reaching out to their customer service team by phone to discuss your situation with them if you find yourself wanting to send your class ring back.
Class rings aren't their bread and butter
Kay Jewelers doesn't have as big of a selection of class rings as some other retailers do, but they are a high-quality jewelry store that has been around a long time. Class rings are definitely not their bread and butter, so you might not find all the bells and whistles and customization options here that some other places offer. Kay has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, but they have mixed reviews from customers. They cover a myriad of issues, most of them being unrelated to class rings but people often complain about their customer service. Kay Jewelers isn't a bad place to look for class rings, but their return policy is lacking, lead times are long, and they don't have as big of a selection as you can find elsewhere.
It's a long-standing tradition for high school and college graduates to get a class ring to symbolize their achievement. It represents the hard work and dedication you put into getting an education, your alma mater, any extracurricular activities you participated in, and the people who changed your life along the way.
Class rings have never been so customizable. It used to be that there were only a couple of ring designs to choose from and they were usually sold by just one or two companies. Now you can compare pricing online among different retailers and browse a variety of band colors, stones, engraving options, and sizes that reflect your educational experience and personal style.
Once you see how many appealing class ring choices there are online, you'll want to start designing your own right away. Whether you're rewarding yourself with a class ring or giving it as a gift to a loved one, it will be a cherished possession for years to come.
There are quite a few companies that offer class rings, so we have provided important information for you to consider when deciding who to buy from:
TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best class ring stores available today. We hope this information helps you find a company that provides a seamless and enjoyable experience - letting you design a ring you're excited about that will forever represent your years in school!
Select any 2 Class Ring Companies to compare them head to head