Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs Cometeer

Wednesday, November 13th

2024 Coffee Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 4 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4 Star Rating
  • Pricing: $36.95 per month for two 12 oz bags ($18.47 per bag)
  • 100% Arabica beans from specialty roasters worldwide
  • Free shipping
  • "They'll Love It!" Guarantee for every bag
  • Flexible subscription options: 3, 6, 12 months, seasonal, monthly, or bi-monthly
  • Excellent customer service and consistent quality
  • "A+" rating from Better Business Bureau

Amazing Clubs' Coffee of the Month Club is best for those who care more about reliability than glitz. You won't be able to choose your own selections, and they keep their sources mysterious, but you'll still enjoy a wide variety of high-quality coffees from around the world. Each month, they surprise you with two new coffee selections, carefully chosen by their experts. This means you get to explore different flavors and roasts without having to do any research yourself. At $18.47 per 12 oz bag with free shipping, it's pricier than some alternatives, but comes with flexible subscription options and a strong satisfaction guarantee. The overwhelmingly positive customer reviews suggest most subscribers are satisfied here, and you likely will be too.

Cometeer Review 3.5 Star Rating

Cometeer

3.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing: $2 per cup, with one-time purchases available for $84
  • Single-serving frozen coffee pods brewed at 10x strength
  • Fully recyclable aluminum cups
  • Customizable box options with various roasters and blends
  • 4-week delivery schedule with flexibility to adjust

Imagine having the perfect cup of coffee every time, right at home. With Cometeer, you can. This innovative coffee club ships you frozen, single-serving pods that are brewed at 10x strength and flash-frozen with liquid nitrogen. Just add hot water for a barista-quality cup, or get creative with iced lattes and affogatos. Customize your coffee experience by choosing from the nation's best roasters and building your own box. Pricier than some alternatives, Cometeer could still save you money if you're buying coffee shop drinks daily. However, due to some customer service concerns and the lack of a Better Business Bureau listing, we can't give Cometeer our top recommendation just yet.

Which Coffee Club is the Best?

For centuries, coffee has been more than just a vehicle for your caffeine fix - it's been a catalyst for connection, creativity, and culture around the world. From elegant cafes in Paris to quiet mountain villages in Colombia, this beloved beverage has brought people together and fueled countless conversations, ideas, and dreams.

But for many of us, our daily cup has become routine instead of a moment to savor. If you find yourself stuck in a coffee rut, reaching for the same familiar-but-”meh” blend day after day, it might be time to shake things up with a coffee club subscription. Coffee clubs are perfect for coffee drinkers who want to explore flavors (and freshness) beyond what's available at their local grocery store.

The Best Coffee Clubs Compare Coffee Clubs Compare Coffee Club Reviews What are the best Coffee Clubs Best Coffee Club Reviews

Coffee Club FAQ

That depends on the club you select. Some offer a wide range of both ground and whole bean coffee from around the world, while others limit their selections to just one or two varieties from a single country of origin.
You decide! Need your supply replenished every week? No problem. Just looking to try something new once a month? You can do that too. Just choose the club that offers the frequency you want.
They're surprisingly affordable. You'll pay anywhere from $9 to $28 per delivery. Shipping is included in the price of most coffee clubs.
Most coffee clubs want you to love what you get - and keep coming back for more! You'll usually be covered by some kind of satisfaction guarantee, with a replacement or refund if you're not happy for any reason.
You're in luck! There are a few coffee clubs that offer plans with K-Cups.
Yes, and they're a great way to make sure your coffee is fresh and flavorful. While new clubs are always popping up, there are many providers that have been around for decades - and have the positive customer feedback to prove it.
It would be nice to see add-ons like unique mugs or creamers, but most coffee clubs just stick to what they do best: the coffee itself. A few clubs include a fun newsletter with each delivery, giving you in-depth information about each selection you receive, coffee facts, and maybe even a recipe or two for brewing your next cup in a different way.
Of course! What java addict wouldn't love to get something new and delicious for their morning cup? Coffee clubs let you show your love and appreciation for a lucky gift recipient - for as long as you like!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Coffee clubs are also great for busy professionals who don't have time to hunt down specialty beans or for those who simply want the convenience of having freshly roasted coffee delivered right to their doorstep. Coffee clubs take the guesswork out of choosing new coffees - you get to benefit from expert curators' knowledge about tasting notes and brewing tips for the perfect morning cup of joe.

Coffee clubs range from specialized to generic. Some take pride in sourcing single-origin beans from a particular country, like Costa Rica. Others act as a middle-man for US-based independent roasters, helping you discover a new business or award-winning coffee every month. However, some are a bit one-note and lacking in customization options or variety.

The frequency of deliveries can vary too. Some clubs ship weekly, so you'll never run out of fresh beans. Others operate on a monthly basis, which might be better if you don't go through coffee as quickly. You'll also find differences in customization options - some clubs let you choose every coffee you receive, while others surprise you with new selections based on your taste preferences. Most coffee clubs have a quiz to help you figure out what those preferences are.

When shopping for a coffee club online, here are some things to keep in mind:

  • Variety. How many different coffees does the club offer? Look for a club with a large selection to keep things interesting. A good club should introduce you to new origins and roast levels regularly to prevent flavor fatigue.
  • Customization. Can you set the selections to align with your preferences? The best clubs allow you to specify things like roast level, whole bean or ground, and even flavor notes you enjoy. This makes it more likely that you'll love every coffee you receive.
  • Frequency and quantity. How often do they ship, and how much coffee do you get? Make sure the club's shipping schedule and amounts match your consumption habits. You don't want to end up with too much coffee going stale or to run out before your next shipment.
  • Educational content. Do they provide information about the coffee? Look for clubs that offer details about the coffee's origin, tasting notes, and brewing recommendations.
  • Price and value. How does the cost compare to buying coffee locally? While coffee clubs often charge a premium for their service, the selection and convenience should justify the price. Compare a few options to find the best value for your budget.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best coffee clubs available online. We hope this information helps you find the perfect service to elevate your daily coffee ritual and discover new favorites from around the world.

Compare Coffee Clubs

Select any 2 Coffee Clubs to compare them head to head

best-coffee-clubs
  • Trade
  • Driftaway
  • Grounds & Hounds
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Cometeer
  • Coffee Bros
  • Cafe Britt
  • Coffee of the Month Club
  • Bean Box
  • Black Rifle Coffee Company
Trade vs Driftaway Trade vs Grounds & Hounds Trade vs Amazing Clubs Trade vs Cometeer Trade vs Coffee Bros Trade vs Cafe Britt Trade vs Coffee of the Month Club Trade vs Bean Box Trade vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Driftaway vs Grounds & Hounds Driftaway vs Amazing Clubs Driftaway vs Cometeer Driftaway vs Coffee Bros Driftaway vs Cafe Britt Driftaway vs Coffee of the Month Club Driftaway vs Bean Box Driftaway vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Grounds & Hounds vs Amazing Clubs Grounds & Hounds vs Cometeer Grounds & Hounds vs Coffee Bros Grounds & Hounds vs Cafe Britt Grounds & Hounds vs Coffee of the Month Club Grounds & Hounds vs Bean Box Grounds & Hounds vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Amazing Clubs vs Cometeer Amazing Clubs vs Coffee Bros Amazing Clubs vs Cafe Britt Amazing Clubs vs Coffee of the Month Club Amazing Clubs vs Bean Box Amazing Clubs vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Cometeer vs Coffee Bros Cometeer vs Cafe Britt Cometeer vs Coffee of the Month Club Cometeer vs Bean Box Cometeer vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Coffee Bros vs Cafe Britt Coffee Bros vs Coffee of the Month Club Coffee Bros vs Bean Box Coffee Bros vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Cafe Britt vs Coffee of the Month Club Cafe Britt vs Bean Box Cafe Britt vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Coffee of the Month Club vs Bean Box Coffee of the Month Club vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Bean Box vs Black Rifle Coffee Company
Compare the Best Coffee Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Coffee Clubs
See the Best Coffee Club
The Best Reviews of Coffee Clubs