Who's better?

Coffee of the Month Club vs Bean Box

We've analyzed the best Coffee Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Coffee Club Reviews

Here you can see how Coffee of the Month Club and Bean Box match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Coffee Clubs in 2025.

Winner

Coffee of the Month Club

  • Pricing: $37.95 to $40.95 per month, with free shipping
  • Two 12-ounce bags of 100% Arabica coffee per delivery
  • Subscription lengths from 2 to 12 months

Coffee of the Month Club has been around for over 30 years and has a great track record, but it's not quite as stylish or customizable as the other coffee clubs at the top of our list. These days, coffee lovers like you want more personal choices, special blends, and ethically-sourced beans. Coffee of the Month Club's old-fashioned approach struggles to keep up with newer, more flexible options. If you're after a coffee experience that's truly tailored to your taste, you'll probably find better choices elsewhere in the market.

Bean Box

  • Pricing: $19.23 per 12 oz bag, free shipping
  • Experienced curation by judges who have participated in coffee competitions
  • Sourced from independent US-based coffee roasters

Based in Seattle, Bean Box's curation is handled by experienced judges, and they source from independent US roasters. You'll start with a personalized quiz, then receive freshly roasted coffee every 2 or 4 weeks with free shipping. There aren't many customer reviews, but there are complaints about customer service and quality issues. At $19.23 per 12 oz bag, Bean Box is a tad too expensive for there to be doubts about how they handle complaints. They're not our first choice for coffee clubs.

For centuries, coffee has been more than just a vehicle for your caffeine fix - it's been a catalyst for connection, creativity, and culture around the world. From elegant cafes in Paris to quiet mountain villages in Colombia, this beloved beverage has brought people together and fueled countless conversations, ideas, and dreams.

But for many of us, our daily cup has become routine instead of a moment to savor. If you find yourself stuck in a coffee rut, reaching for the same familiar-but-"meh" blend day after day, it might be time to shake things up with a coffee club subscription. Coffee clubs are perfect for coffee drinkers who want to explore flavors (and freshness) beyond what's available at their local grocery store.

Coffee clubs are also great for busy professionals who don't have time to hunt down specialty beans or for those who simply want the convenience of having freshly roasted coffee delivered right to their doorstep. Coffee clubs take the guesswork out of choosing new coffees - you get to benefit from expert curators' knowledge about tasting notes and brewing tips for the perfect morning cup of joe.

Coffee clubs range from specialized to generic. Some take pride in sourcing single-origin beans from a particular country, like Costa Rica. Others act as a middle-man for US-based independent roasters, helping you discover a new business or award-winning coffee every month. However, some are a bit one-note and lacking in customization options or variety.

The frequency of deliveries can vary too. Some clubs ship weekly, so you'll never run out of fresh beans. Others operate on a monthly basis, which might be better if you don't go through coffee as quickly. You'll also find differences in customization options - some clubs let you choose every coffee you receive, while others surprise you with new selections based on your taste preferences. Most coffee clubs have a quiz to help you figure out what those preferences are.

When shopping for a coffee club online, here are some things to keep in mind:

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best coffee clubs available online. We hope this information helps you find the perfect service to elevate your daily coffee ritual and discover new favorites from around the world.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Coffee Club FAQ

Where does the Coffee come from?
That depends on the club you select. Some offer a wide range of both ground and whole bean coffee from around the world, while others limit their selections to just one or two varieties from a single country of origin.
How often will the Coffee be delivered?
You decide! Need your supply replenished every week? No problem. Just looking to try something new once a month? You can do that too. Just choose the club that offers the frequency you want.
Are Coffee clubs expensive?
They're surprisingly affordable. You'll pay anywhere from $9 to $28 per delivery. Shipping is included in the price of most coffee clubs.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Most coffee clubs want you to love what you get - and keep coming back for more! You'll usually be covered by some kind of satisfaction guarantee, with a replacement or refund if you're not happy for any reason.
What if I only have a Keurig?
You're in luck! There are a few coffee clubs that offer plans with K-Cups.
Are Coffee clubs legitimate?
Yes, and they're a great way to make sure your coffee is fresh and flavorful. While new clubs are always popping up, there are many providers that have been around for decades - and have the positive customer feedback to prove it.
Do you get anything extra with the deliveries?
It would be nice to see add-ons like unique mugs or creamers, but most coffee clubs just stick to what they do best: the coffee itself. A few clubs include a fun newsletter with each delivery, giving you in-depth information about each selection you receive, coffee facts, and maybe even a recipe or two for brewing your next cup in a different way.
Do Coffee clubs make good gifts?
Of course! What java addict wouldn't love to get something new and delicious for their morning cup? Coffee clubs let you show your love and appreciation for a lucky gift recipient - for as long as you like!

Compare Any 2 Products

Trade
Driftaway
Grounds & Hounds
Amazing Clubs
Cometeer
Coffee Bros
Cafe Britt
Coffee of the Month Club
Bean Box
Black Rifle Coffee Company
vs
Trade vs DriftawayTrade vs Grounds & HoundsTrade vs Amazing ClubsTrade vs CometeerTrade vs Coffee BrosTrade vs Cafe BrittTrade vs Coffee of the Month ClubTrade vs Bean BoxTrade vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyDriftaway vs Grounds & HoundsDriftaway vs Amazing ClubsDriftaway vs CometeerDriftaway vs Coffee BrosDriftaway vs Cafe BrittDriftaway vs Coffee of the Month ClubDriftaway vs Bean BoxDriftaway vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyGrounds & Hounds vs Amazing ClubsGrounds & Hounds vs CometeerGrounds & Hounds vs Coffee BrosGrounds & Hounds vs Cafe BrittGrounds & Hounds vs Coffee of the Month ClubGrounds & Hounds vs Bean BoxGrounds & Hounds vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyAmazing Clubs vs CometeerAmazing Clubs vs Coffee BrosAmazing Clubs vs Cafe BrittAmazing Clubs vs Coffee of the Month ClubAmazing Clubs vs Bean BoxAmazing Clubs vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyCometeer vs Coffee BrosCometeer vs Cafe BrittCometeer vs Coffee of the Month ClubCometeer vs Bean BoxCometeer vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyCoffee Bros vs Cafe BrittCoffee Bros vs Coffee of the Month ClubCoffee Bros vs Bean BoxCoffee Bros vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyCafe Britt vs Coffee of the Month ClubCafe Britt vs Bean BoxCafe Britt vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyCoffee of the Month Club vs Bean BoxCoffee of the Month Club vs Black Rifle Coffee CompanyBean Box vs Black Rifle Coffee Company Black Rifle Coffee Company vs Bean BoxBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs Coffee of the Month ClubBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs Cafe BrittBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs Coffee BrosBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs CometeerBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs Amazing ClubsBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs Grounds & HoundsBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs DriftawayBlack Rifle Coffee Company vs TradeBean Box vs Coffee of the Month ClubBean Box vs Cafe BrittBean Box vs Coffee BrosBean Box vs CometeerBean Box vs Amazing ClubsBean Box vs Grounds & HoundsBean Box vs DriftawayBean Box vs TradeCoffee of the Month Club vs Cafe BrittCoffee of the Month Club vs Coffee BrosCoffee of the Month Club vs CometeerCoffee of the Month Club vs Amazing ClubsCoffee of the Month Club vs Grounds & HoundsCoffee of the Month Club vs DriftawayCoffee of the Month Club vs TradeCafe Britt vs Coffee BrosCafe Britt vs CometeerCafe Britt vs Amazing ClubsCafe Britt vs Grounds & HoundsCafe Britt vs DriftawayCafe Britt vs TradeCoffee Bros vs CometeerCoffee Bros vs Amazing ClubsCoffee Bros vs Grounds & HoundsCoffee Bros vs DriftawayCoffee Bros vs TradeCometeer vs Amazing ClubsCometeer vs Grounds & HoundsCometeer vs DriftawayCometeer vs TradeAmazing Clubs vs Grounds & HoundsAmazing Clubs vs DriftawayAmazing Clubs vs TradeGrounds & Hounds vs DriftawayGrounds & Hounds vs TradeDriftaway vs Trade
See the Best Coffee Clubs in Your State

Why do people love coffee?

Are you one of the millions of Americans who start your day with a cup of coffee? This delicious beverage has been enjoyed around the globe for thousands of years. In fact, the history of coffee dates back to ancient Ethiopia. There, a goat herder observed his goats' sleeplessness at night after they ate the fruit from a specific tree. This ultimately led to the discovery that the fruit, which was coffee beans, provided a long-lasting energy boost to humans as well as animals. As word spread through the Arabian Peninsula and far beyond about the energy boost the beans provided, the popularity of coffee soared. The beverage was part of a morning ritual in many homes by the 15th century, and it was even enjoyed in public coffee houses hundreds of years ago.

While the popularity of foods and beverages waxes and wanes, coffee has proven that it has true staying power in cultures around the world. What has contributed to the continued popularity of coffee? This beverage has several notable traits that combine to make it unlike any other.

A Boost of Energy

Do you reach for a cup of coffee first thing in the morning to get your juices flowing? The average cup of coffee has far more caffeine than a cup of tea, so it is the perfect pick-me-up that enables you to hit the ground running. As a natural stimulant, the caffeine in a cup of coffee can give you a much-needed boost of energy. This may be why many people reach for their coffeepot first thing in the morning. They may also enjoy a copy of coffee immediately after lunch to have energy for the rest of their workday.

Notably, the caffeine in coffee does more than help you to feel more energetic. It can improve focus and alertness so that coffee drinkers can perform better at work and in other areas of life. The caffeine in a cup of coffee also plays a role in overall mental function, memory, mood and even metabolism. Because of the wide range of effects, many people simply have become accustomed to performing at a certain level and to deriving some of their daily energy from their morning or midday cup of coffee.

Caffeine can be addictive, but it is completely safe for most people to drink. If you enjoy the effects that coffee has on your energy level, mood and more on a daily basis, you may have developed an addiction to it. However, because of how positive the effects of coffee are on many aspects of your health and life, this is an addiction that you can feel great about satisfying on a daily basis.

A Daily Ritual

Humans are generally creatures of habit. We find comfort in routine. For many people who drink coffee, preparing coffee each morning is part of a daily ritual. This extends to smelling the coffee beans or grounds before the coffee starts to brew, listening to the familiar sounds from your coffeemaker and preparing the perfect cup with all of your favorite accompaniments. Well before the coffee hits your lips, you may derive pleasure from the ritual.

Of course, the practice of drinking coffee is also a part of many people's routines. Do you enjoy your steaming cup of coffee while you navigate through traffic on the way to work, while you are reading the morning paper or while you are browsing through emails and gearing up for a busy day at the office? If you are like many people, drinking coffee is as much a part of your daily routine as brushing your teeth, making the bed and putting your shoes on.

The ritual of drinking coffee may extend to the late afternoon and evening for some people. Because of the caffeine in coffee, some people avoid drinking it later in the day. However, the availability of decaffeinated coffee means that people can enjoy the many benefits of coffee at any hour of the day without concern.

Delicious Flavors

While some people prefer their coffee strong and black, there are many ways to dress up your favorite drink. Coffee beans are grown in areas around the world. Everything from where they are grown to how they are roasted, ground up and brewed will affect their flavor. On top of that, there are numerous types of coffee drinks that you can enjoy. Some people simply enjoy adding milk, cream or sugar to black coffee. Others love lattes, mochas, espressos and other beverages that are specially prepared. While warm or hot coffee is common, iced coffee is increasingly popular as well.

Some coffee beans are flavored, but there are other ways to add flavor to the beverage. For example, some coffeehouses add flavored syrups to warm or iced coffee upon request. There are also a seemingly endless number of flavored creamers that you can enjoy at home or at a coffee house. Some flavors are seasonal, such as peppermint cream or pumpkin spice. Others are popular year-round, such as Irish cream and hazelnut. With so many different ways to enjoy coffee, most people may easily have at least a few favorites that enjoy treating themselves to regularly.

A Social Community

Coffee has become such an important aspect of millions of people's daily lives that it has been adopted as part of the culture in many countries. This may have started hundreds of years ago at the first public coffeehouses, but it continues in a wide range of social environments today. For example, you and your coworkers may regularly meet up in the break room to enjoy a cup of java and good conversation. For some people, grabbing a cup of coffee is the perfect first date. It is casual, enjoyable and promotes a get-to-know-you conversation. Coffee is also enjoyed among friends, neighbors, and business partners at local coffee joints.

Of course, you do not need to step out of the house to enjoy the social aspect of coffee. Families may enjoy chatting over their morning coffee before they start their day. Dinner with extended family members may not be complete without coffee and dessert. The drink can be enjoyed over a deep conversation between great friends or over casual, light-hearted banter, so it is the perfect drink for camaraderie.

Health Benefits

While some of the benefits or attributes of coffee have been well-known for hundreds of years, the health benefits of coffee have only been discovered relatively recently. Coffee beans are loaded with potassium, magnesium, riboflavin and antioxidants. While some foods and beverages lose the potency of their nutritional benefits during the cooking or preparation process, this is not the case with coffee. A cup of coffee is packed with these same nutrients. Together, the benefits can do everything from promoting cardiovascular health and reducing depression to staving off a wide range of serious diseases. These include liver disease and cancer, Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, diabetes and more. While many people may drink coffee for the pick-me-up it delivers and because they love the taste, the health benefits make this a beverage that you can feel good about enjoying on a daily basis.

While coffee is not universally enjoyed by all, it has been wildly popular in the U.S. and far beyond for centuries. Because of its extensive range of benefits and the wide range of prep methods available, it likely will continue to be both a quiet aspect of daily rituals and an important aspect of broader social interactions for many centuries to come.

Only the Best Reviews

Wired

Atlas Coffee Club's Prime Day Deal Cuts the Price In Half

Atlas Coffee Club collects single-origin beans from more than 50 countries and roasts them itself in Austin, Texas, before shipping them to your door. That means your coffee is incredibly fresh, which ...

Fri, 08 Jul 2022

Only the Best Reviews

New York Magazine

One of Our Favorite Coffee Subscriptions Is Half Off Right Now

Atlas Coffee Club, which we named one of our favorite coffee subscriptions, makes it easy (and not at all overwhelming) to access beans from all over the world. And right now, the brand is offering 50 ...

Tue, 31 Jan 2023

Only the Best Reviews

Observer

Travel the World With a Monthly Coffee Club Subscription

If you’re a daily coffee drinker but can never remember to buy a new bag of beans, a monthly subscription service wants to make your mornings much easier. Austin-based start-up Atlas Coffee Club was ...

Fri, 19 Jan 2018

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

The 8 Best Coffee Subscriptions That’ll Have You Canceling Your ...

There’s no better feeling than when you take your first sip of coffee in the morning. Everyone gets their caffeine fix in different ways. Some pick up their cup of joe at Starbucks, while others make ...

Tue, 28 Feb 2023

Only the Best Reviews

CNN

Get an exclusive look at Atlas Coffee Club’s new single-serve pods ...

For a lot of us, a complicated brewing process isn’t ideal first thing in the morning. Now, thanks to a new launch from Atlas Coffee Club, you get the best of both worlds: a fresh cup of coffee in ...

Wed, 09 Nov 2022

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

The Atlas Coffee Club subscription is perfect for people seeking ...

Select independently determines what we cover and recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more. I cherish my morning coffee routine. It’s simple, pour-over coffee ...

Sun, 20 Oct 2024

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.