Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs Cheryl's Cookies

Wednesday, December 11th

2024 Cookie Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 4.5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4.5 Star Rating
  • 2 pounds of cookies in every delivery
  • 2 flavors in every shipment
  • Pricing ranges from $47.95 to $49.95/month, depending on the subscription length
  • Shipping is free on all cookie clubs
  • Deliveries can be every month or every other month
  • Subscribe for 3, 4 (quarterly), 6, or 12 months, or make it ongoing
  • Mix-and-match with other clubs
  • Comes with a fun monthly newsletter
  • Great gift-giving features
  • Exceptional customer service

When it comes to subscriptions, Amazing Clubs is a standout choice, beloved by both our experts and over 3 million customers. Offering over 40 diverse options, from neckties to gourmet foods like cheese and wine, Amazing Clubs stands out for its mix-and-match capability, allowing you to combine their cookie club with any other subscription. The cookie club itself earns high praise for its generous deliveries, including two pounds of cookies in two flavors per shipment, and the flexibility to customize deliveries according to your preferred schedule. Because of its exceptional customer service and a "They'll Love It!" guarantee, Amazing Clubs delivers a delightful experience every time, with delicious treats and a fun monthly newsletter, making it an ideal choice for gifting or indulging yourself. With nearly 500 reviews averaging 4.5 out of 5 stars, it's no wonder this cookie club earns one of our highest ratings.

Cheryl's Cookies Review 2 Star Rating

Cheryl's Cookies

2 Star Rating
  • 2 options: Flavor of the Month and Buttercream Frosted Cut-Out Cookie of the Month
  • 12 or 24 cookies in each box
  • Prices start at $19.99/delivery
  • $12.99 shipping fee per delivery (discounted on prepaid clubs)
  • Can subscribe to Celebrations Passport to save money on shipping
  • Prepay or pay as you go
  • Great gift-giving features
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • "A-” rated by the BBB
  • In business for over 40 years
  • Part of the 1-800 Flowers family of brands

If you're already a big fan of the 1-800 Flowers family of gift-giving specialty brands, Cheryl's Cookies has probably crossed your radar. There are two cookie club options here, both of which have a big emphasis on frosted sugar cookies, but you get to choose between seasonally-shaped cut-outs and more traditional round cookies with seasonal flavors. People tend to love the cookies but hate the customer service at Cheryl's, with deliveries often missing the mark for the holiday or occasion they were intended for, and not the kind of helpful response you'd expect from a company that's been around for 40+ years. Tack on some pretty hefty shipping fees, and it's no wonder that Cheryl's Cookies earns a low rating from us for its cookie clubs.

Where Can You Find the Best Cookie Clubs?

Imagine the sheer delight of receiving a package every month filled with an assortment of freshly baked, gourmet cookies delivered right to your doorstep. This is the magic of cookie clubs or subscriptions - the ideal treat for anyone with an insatiable love for cookies or for those eager to gift a delicious surprise to someone special.

Variety is the spice of life, they say, and what better way to experience it than through a plethora of cookie flavors? From classic chocolate chip and chewy oatmeal raisin to exotic flavors like salted caramel, peanut butter and jelly, or even lavender shortbread, the options are endless. Each month brings a new adventure as you eagerly anticipate the discovery of unique and tantalizing flavors crafted by skilled bakers.

The Best Cookie Clubs Compare Cookie Clubs Compare Cookie Club Reviews What are the best Cookie Clubs Best Cookie Club Reviews

Cookie Club FAQ

Most cookie clubs get their cookies from top-notch small businesses around the country. You won't get the same old thing you could find at any supermarket near you. It's like having a bakery come directly to you!
That's up to you. Cookie subscriptions can be set to arrive each month, every other month, or even quarterly. You can have your membership last for three months, six months, or a full year.
They'll cost more than buying a mass-produced package of cookies at the grocery store, but probably less than buying cookies from a specialty bakery. Costs average from $12 to $30 per month for up to three pounds of cookies.
Some cookie clubs include delivery fees in their monthly costs, while others tack them on at checkout. That can definitely add to what you'll be spending, so be sure to read the details before you sign up for a subscription.
Most of the time, yes. What company wants bad reviews for delivering subpar treats? If your cookies arrive in less-than-perfect condition, it shouldn't be hard to get a replacement or a refund.
Definitely! Some of the most popular cookie clubs have been around for two decades or longer, bringing delight to lovers of sweets everywhere. Even some of the newer monthly subscription plans have already earned a loyal fan base with their delicious treats.
It's rare for any subscription box to just send the products and nothing more. Your cookie club membership will probably come with an entertaining newsletter that tells you where your treats were made and gives you fun cookie trivia to share with your friends.
Of course! Who doesn't love cookies?! Cookie clubs make it really easy to give as a gift for any occasion: enter your greeting and it'll be included with your first shipment, or have it emailed directly on any date you wish. Cookie club providers vary with what they offer in terms of gift-giving features, so choose the one that gives you the most bells and whistles for your lucky recipient.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Convenience is key in our fast-paced world, and cookie subscriptions offer just that. No more rushing to the store to satisfy your cookie cravings or spending hours in the kitchen baking batch after batch. With a subscription, simply sit back, relax, and let the cookies come to you. It's like having your own personal cookie concierge, ready to indulge your sweet tooth on the regular.

And let's not overlook the sheer brilliance of giving a cookie subscription as a gift. Picture the joy on your loved one's face as they unwrap their first box of cookies, a delectable surprise at their door after a long day at work or school. It's a gift that keeps on giving, spreading happiness and indulgence month after month. Whether it's for a birthday, anniversary, or just because, a cookie subscription is a thoughtful and memorable way to show someone you care.

Which cookie club is going to best satisfy your sweet tooth? As you consider the tempting variety of cookie clubs out there, here are five factors to help you compare your options:

  • Variety of flavors. Look for clubs that offer a diverse selection of cookie flavors, so that each month brings a new and exciting experience. We love it when a cookie subscription shows you what previous boxes have included, so that you can see for yourself if you're likely to get flavors you'll enjoy.
  • Flexibility. Some cookie clubs offer the ability to customize your subscription based on dietary needs (like gluten-free) or flavor preferences. You might also be able to skip a month, if the subscription lets you preview what's coming. Consider whether this option is important to you or to the recipient of your gift.
  • Payment options. Do you want to pay for your cookie club upfront (which can be spendy) or would you like the ability to pay month-to-month?
  • Value. Notice we didn't say "cost”. The value of your cookie subscription depends on several things: the monthly price, whether or not shipping is included, how many cookies you get in each delivery, and if there are any fun perks (like a newsletter or fancy gift packaging).
  • Reputation. This may be the most important way to choose the right cookie club. Do people rave about the subscription, from the cookies themselves to the customer service? Look for glowing reviews from loyal subscribers as your clue that it's a club worth choosing.

To help you find the perfect cookie club to satisfy your cravings for delicious treats, the cookie fanatics at Top Consumer Reviews have happily evaluated and ranked today's most popular options. Anyone have a glass of milk?

Compare Cookie Clubs

Select any 2 Cookie Clubs to compare them head to head

best-cookie-clubs
  • COOKIE... take a bite!
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Feed Your Soul
  • Levain Bakery
  • The Cravory
  • David's Cookies
  • Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop
  • My Cookie Box
  • Goldbelly
  • Cheryl's Cookies
COOKIE... take a bite! vs Amazing Clubs COOKIE... take a bite! vs Feed Your Soul COOKIE... take a bite! vs Levain Bakery COOKIE... take a bite! vs The Cravory COOKIE... take a bite! vs David's Cookies COOKIE... take a bite! vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop COOKIE... take a bite! vs My Cookie Box COOKIE... take a bite! vs Goldbelly COOKIE... take a bite! vs Cheryl's Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Feed Your Soul Amazing Clubs vs Levain Bakery Amazing Clubs vs The Cravory Amazing Clubs vs David's Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop Amazing Clubs vs My Cookie Box Amazing Clubs vs Goldbelly Amazing Clubs vs Cheryl's Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Levain Bakery Feed Your Soul vs The Cravory Feed Your Soul vs David's Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop Feed Your Soul vs My Cookie Box Feed Your Soul vs Goldbelly Feed Your Soul vs Cheryl's Cookies Levain Bakery vs The Cravory Levain Bakery vs David's Cookies Levain Bakery vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop Levain Bakery vs My Cookie Box Levain Bakery vs Goldbelly Levain Bakery vs Cheryl's Cookies The Cravory vs David's Cookies The Cravory vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop The Cravory vs My Cookie Box The Cravory vs Goldbelly The Cravory vs Cheryl's Cookies David's Cookies vs Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop David's Cookies vs My Cookie Box David's Cookies vs Goldbelly David's Cookies vs Cheryl's Cookies Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop vs My Cookie Box Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop vs Goldbelly Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop vs Cheryl's Cookies My Cookie Box vs Goldbelly My Cookie Box vs Cheryl's Cookies Goldbelly vs Cheryl's Cookies
Compare the Best Cookie Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Cookie Clubs
See the Best Cookie Club
The Best Reviews of Cookie Clubs