The Best Cookie Clubs

Thursday, February 9th

2023 Cookie Club Reviews

COOKIE... take a bite!

COOKIE... take a bite! is based out of California and was started by a professionally trained pastry chef. On their online store you can purchase cookie tins, platters, plates, or sign up for their Cookie of the Month Club. This club can be delivered 3, 6, or 12 times per year and comes with a gluten-free option. Each box contains two dozen cookies with different flavors in each collection. Shipping is free on all subscription boxes and prices are competitive. Customers rave about COOKIE... take a bite!, and this is our favorite route to go when choosing a cookie club.

Amazing Clubs

Amazing Clubs has over 42 types of auto-delivery programs to choose from featuring items like gourmet BBQ sauces, jerky, neckties, pasta, salsa, and of course, cookies. Their cookie club can be delivered every month, every other month, or every four months depending on what the customer prefers. They allow customers to pay in full or per delivery and guarantee that their prices are lower than all their competitors since they offer free shipping throughout the United States. Customers are extremely happy with the quality of cookies, freshness, timeliness of delivery and customer service at Amazing Clubs. This is definitely one of the best cookie clubs out there.

David's Cookies

David's Cookies began in 1987 and has been delighting customers ever since. They offer subscriptions for cookies, cookie dough, brownies, and cheesecake. Their cookie clubs are affordable and come with a 30-day guarantee. If you're not happy for any reason, you can get your money back. Customers are happy with the flavors each month and quality of David's Cookies, earning this cookie club a high rating.

Goldbelly

Goldbelly has a unique purpose of connecting people with foods they love from all around the US. You can buy from specific restaurants or regions and have popular foods delivered straight to your door. Their monthly cookie subscription features different bakeries each month, so the diversity of flavors will be unmatched. You can view your upcoming selection via email each month: you always know what to expect. Each cookie order feeds 6-8 people and ships for free. Goldbelly receives high ratings from customers, making this a fun and novel shop to check out online if you're interested in unique foods from popular restaurants around the US.

Mrs. Chips Cookies

Mrs. Chips offers quarterly delivery of their chocolate chip cookies and options for other flavors like s'mores and rainbow birthday cake. Each box includes 24 cookies and free shipping. Mrs. Chips Cookies provide cookies just like you had as a kid: all the best ingredients and none of the "healthy" alternative stuff. Their subscription includes a full refund guarantee in case you aren't satisfied, so you have nothing to lose by trying out this gourmet cookie club.

Feed Your Soul

Feed Your Soul is an organization dedicated to bringing happiness to people through their gourmet cookies and spreading the love to those in need through generous donations. They offer 3, 6, or 12-month cookie subscriptions that come with 12 cookies each. The pricing of each box is affordable, but they get slightly more expensive when shipping is factored in. We aren't positive of the monthly delivery schedule from Feed Your Soul and they don't offer refunds or returns on their products. Still, we feel that Feed Your Sould provides a decent cookie club for your consideration.

Mrs. Fields

Mrs. Fields is a well-known brand that signals warm, gooey cookies and delectable desserts. They offer a 3, 6, or 12-month subscription of their Treat of the Month Club that features seasonal cookies and brownie bites with every box. Details as to how often boxes are shipped, what part of the month, what their return policy is, and how many dessert items are given in each box are unclear, so we aren't as excited about jumping on board with this company as we wanted to be.

Cheryl's Cookies

Cheryl's Cookies provides subscriptions for cookies, brownies, and pretzel clusters in their pay-as-you-go or prepaid delivery boxes. They have a wide variety of treats to choose from. Their cookie prices are affordable, especially if you choose to prepay, but shipping can quickly get out of hand if you're on a budget. The Better Business Bureau gives Cheryl's Cookies a "B-" rating: there are some reports of cookies not showing up when they were supposed to and having difficulties working with customer service. Although their cookies look delicious, this might not be the most reliable place to get your sugar fix.

Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies

Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies specializes in cookies that are crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Every box includes a dozen individually wrapped cookies. Each month includes all the same flavors, which could either be exciting or repetitive based on your preferences. Boxes are delivered on a month-to-month basis, so no long-term subscriptions are available. Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies are sold through Cratejoy and they don't show the cost for taxes and shipping before providing credit card information, which is a big reason we aren't a fan of them Cratejoy also has an "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Diva Cookies

Diva Cookies specializes in chocolate chip cookies, but sometimes changes things up with their ingredients or flavors. You get one dozen cookies each month, but won't know the flavors ahead of time. Boxes are delivered monthly, so there is not a lot of flexibility with scheduling. We also weren't able to see the cost for taxes and shipping before providing credit card information, which we weren't happy with. Diva Cookies is sold through Cratejoy, a company with an "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau. All told, we think there are better options available.