Amazing Clubs Review: Cookie Clubs

When it comes to all kinds of subscriptions, Amazing Clubs is a regular favorite with our experts (and, of course, with over 3 million customers too). There are over 40 different options here, ranging from neckties and teddy bears to gourmet food like cheese and wine. Amazing Clubs' cookie club, while a winner in its own right, can easily be combined with any of the subscriptions on offer here. You won't find that kind of mix-and-match with any other cookie club on our list.

You'll know exactly what they've sent...

But, let's take a look at why the cookie club itself earns our highest rating. To start, every delivery with Amazing Clubs' subscription comes with a full two pounds of cookies in two different flavors. The company tells you exactly what they've sent over the last 12 months, so you can know right away if it's the kind of cookie club for you. For example, flavors from recent months included traditional faves like Chocolate Chunk and Oatmeal Raisin, but also novel flavors like Blueberry Muffin and Lemon White Chocolate Chip.

...and you'll know what's coming

It doesn't stop there. Once you've subscribed, you'll get an email every month letting you know what flavors are slated for the next delivery. See something you don't like? We get it: someone we gifted with an Amazing Clubs' cookie subscription wouldn't touch peanut butter with a ten-foot pole. She was thrilled that she knew exactly when any kind of peanut butter cookie was scheduled to come, and all it took was a quick call to Amazing Clubs to ask them to skip that month and add a delivery on to the end of the subscription.

Unparalleled customer service

Speaking of customer service, Amazing Clubs is really the best. They back everything they ship, from cookies to candles, with an ironclad "They'll Love It!" guarantee. We've put it to the test more than once, and we've been nothing but, well, amazed by how we've been treated. It doesn't happen often, but when something doesn't line up with your expectations (maybe the cookies come in bad shape or they don't come at all), you can expect a prompt, even a little over-the-top-with-kindness response. Whether you want a refund, a replacement, or even to switch to a different club, the attitude at Amazing Clubs is "we can absolutely do that".

Tons of flexibility

But, let's jump back to the cookie club. You've got a lot of flexibility with how you set it up. You can pay as you go or pay upfront; it's always the same price, ranging from $47.95 to $49.95 per month, depending on the length of the subscription term. You can opt for 3, 4 (quarterly), 6, or 12 deliveries, and you can have them come monthly or every other month. You can also go for ongoing-until-you-cancel cookie shipments.

Gift-giving couldn't be easier

All of that flexibility is part of the reason why Amazing Clubs' cookies are awesome for gift-giving. We also think that the monthly newsletter, The Crumbled Cookie, adds a fun touch you won't necessarily see with other subscriptions: it tells you where the cookies came from, shares some fun facts, offers serving suggestions, and more. Plus, when you set up your cookie club here as a gift, you can choose a free gift message to send via email on the date of your choosing, to print out yourself and present in person, or have it mailed to you or your recipient for $2.99. However, keep in mind that regardless of when you want the announcement sent, the cookies themselves (as with the rest of the subscriptions at Amazing Clubs) will always ship out during the last week of the month.

Well-loved cookie club

And that's the only area where we've found any complaints: some people would like to be able to have cookies delivered at other times of the month. Beyond that, though, this cookie club has almost 500 reviews averaging 4.5 out of 5 stars. The shipments are described as generous, with enough to satisfy 12 people in the office breakroom with cookies to spare. "Best cookies I've ever had" is a comment that pops up in more than one review.

Earns our highest rating

What's the downside? There really isn't one. Amazing Clubs deserves our highest rating. We've given a rival cookie club our #1 spot on the list simply because we want to highlight a small business, but the two subscriptions share our enthusiastic recommendation.

Learn More  ➜

On the Amazing Clubs website