Thursday, April 22nd
2021 Cookie Club Reviews
Cheryl's Cookies
- Cost: $89.94 to $359.88 plus shipping
Originally begun as a boutique cookie shop in Columbus, Ohio, Cheryl's Cookies evolved to become a well-rounded source of treats of many kinds. However, cookies are still their main focus, including a signature buttercream frosting for cut-out sugar cookies. In 2005, the business merged with the 1-800-Flowers family of brands while still providing freshly-baked goods according to the highest possible quality standards.
Membership Overview:
- Cookie Selection: 8-24 individually wrapped cookies or brownies
- Duration: 6 or 12 months
- Frequency: Monthly
- Shipping: Not included
Cheryl's Cookies blew us away with the variety of Cookie Clubs that they offer: Buttercream Frosted, Kids' Cookies/Books/Plushies, Gourmet Cookie, Gluten Free Cookie/Brownie, Classic Brownie, and Sugar-Free Cookie. No other club in our review gives customers such a wide range of options, allowing customers to get just the right delivery for their special someone - especially for those with dietary needs like gluten- or sugar-free.
On the other hand, their Cookie Clubs have much less flexibility in terms of their delivery options: no matter which club you choose, you're limited to 6 or 12 months. Each shipment includes an average of 8-12 individually-wrapped cookies or brownies, working out to be $1 to $2+ per cookie or brownie.
Also, Cheryl's Cookies doesn't offer free shipping on every order. For example, on the Butter Cookie monthly club, we were charged $6.99 per shipment. That's 33% of the cost of the actual monthly shipment at $19.99 per month. It may be worth considering the Celebrations Passport: for an annual membership fee of $29.99, you'll get free shipping from a family of brands that includes The Popcorn Factory, 1-800-Flowers, and Harry & David. Given that you could be spending nearly $85 just to ship a one-year subscription to the Cookie Club, it might be worth the money - especially if your gift-giving regularly includes the other companies in the Passport program.
On the positive side, Cheryl's Cookies guarantees that you will be 100% satisfied with the quality of your Cookie Club deliveries. If something comes in less-than-perfect condition, their customer service representatives are dedicated to doing whatever it takes to make it right.
Although the clubs offered by Cheryl's Cookies are higher-priced than the higher-rated clubs in our review, their variety of options (particularly for those who need gluten-free or diabetic-friendly treats) may make it worth the extra money for your extra-special gift recipients.
More Cookie Club Reviews
The 5 Best Cookie Clubs
Who Has the Best Cookie Club?
Cookies are an all time favorite of most children and adults. From a simple chocolate chip to an elaborate macadamia nut, it's hard to find a cookie that doesn't beg to be devoured and shared. Even better - you can give fresh, delicious cookies that are delivered each month to a person who will truly appreciate your thoughtful gift.
The purchase of a Cookie Club membership means delicious cookies are delivered directly to the recipient's door each month. The cookie selection changes with each delivery, and the variety is usually chosen by the cookie club company. This ensures a unique and tasty gift will appear throughout the year, to be enjoyed time and time again.
Cookie Club FAQ
Continued from above...
But, not all cookie clubs are alike. It's important to understand the cookie club membership options and policies before you sign up. Some of the important features to watch for include:
- Flexibility. Will you be able to select the length of cookie club membership and frequency that fits your needs and budget?
- Cost. What can you expect to pay for the cookie club? How does that compare to the competition?
- Satisfaction Policy. If you aren't happy with the timeliness, quality or taste that your cookie club delivers, are you able to stop the membership and receive any portion of the cost back?
TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cookie Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the right cookie club that meets your needs!
Compare Cookie Clubs
Select any 2 Cookie Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Cookie Club News
Related Cookie Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Cookie Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
