Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Cheryl's Cookies Review

Saturday, April 20th

2024 Cookie Club Reviews

Cheryl's Cookies Review 3 Star Rating

Cheryl's Cookies

3 Star Rating
  • 10% off with email signup
  • Satisfaction guarantee
  • Pay-as-you-go or prepay options
  • Holiday-specific cookie boxes

Cheryl's Cookies began in 1981 in Columbus Ohio. The online store is named after the founder, Cheryl Krueger, who became an overnight sensation when on Valentine's Day, she introduced her signature buttercream cut-outs. Over time they've added more flavors to their buttercream frosting, keeping customers coming back for more. Cheryl's Cookies' sister companies are also dedicated to delivering goodies to people including 1800Flowers, Shari's Berries, Fruit Bouquets, Wolferman's Bakery, 1800Baskets and others.

5 gourmet dessert clubs to choose from

The cookie club programs from Cheryl's Cookies include The Buttercream Frosted Cut-Out Cookie Club, Gourmet Cookie Club, Sugar-Free Cookie Club, Gourmet Brownie Club and Best of Holiday Club that ship the first week of every month. It probably won't be hard to determine which of these clubs sounds the most appealing, but the details of delivery can get slightly confusing.

Buy more, save more

Most clubs allow you to select deliveries of 3, 6, or 12 months and pay-as-you-go. However, there is a prepay option and if you go this route, it will save you the most money. For example, if you want the 24 cut-out cookies for six months, you'll pay $19.99/month. But if you choose to pre-pay for the 6 months, the total is $99, which makes each delivery only $16.70. In short, the more cookies you buy at once, the more deliveries you select, and the choice to prepay will give you the best value here.

Shipping prices aren't straightforward

Deliveries that include more treats like Cookies and Treats Club start at $39.99 for a 3-month subscription of 28 items or $14.99 for a pay-as-you-go order. Gourmet brownies (10 count) start at $19.99/delivery and gourmet cookies (12 count) are $12.99/delivery. To complicate things, shipping prices are not straightforward at all, because they're determined by how much you buy and where you live. For us to purchase a 6-month subscription of 28 cut-out cookies, shipping was $20. It's frustrating to have to go through the checkout process before knowing how much shipping will cost.

Best Cookie Clubs

Loyalty program = free shipping

Something to consider is the Celebrations Passport, which guarantees free shipping for a year from any of the Cheryl's Cookies sister brands with no minimum purchase. If you plan on shopping with these other companies, it would be well-worth worth paying the $19 to sign up. However, in the past we found fine print indicating that monthly memberships weren't included in that free shipping deal, so we encourage you to double-check before getting your hopes up. You can also sign up for Cheryl's Cookies email list and save 10% on your first order with them.

Festive cookie selections

You don't have to wonder what will come in each month's cookie box, since it's all spelled out on the Cheryl's Cookies site. Since the cut-out cookies are more decorative, they list what will come with each delivery. In March your box will include shamrock cookies, April will come with egg-shaped cookies, October will have pumpkin cut-outs, and so on.

Mediocre ratings at best

The Better Business Bureau gives Cheryl's Cookies a "B-" rating. This isn't terrible, but it's really nothing to be impressed with either. We like that Cheryl's Cookies gives a variety of dessert options to choose from since we all have different preferences. However, they could do some updating to their website to make everything more uniform and straightforward to simplify decisions for customers. Cheryl's Cookies has a good selection but we are concerned about the reported delivery issues and complaints against customer service from people who have shopped here. They say that if you aren't 100% satisfied with your order, they'll do their best to make it right, but this is too vague to be reassuring. To be safe, check out a higher-rated cookie club first.

Where Can You Find the Best Cookie Clubs?

Calling all sweet tooths! If you want to indulge in unique flavors of delicious, fresh cookies without having to even leave your couch, then boy do we have news for you! Cookie clubs are available to bring you anything from a simple chocolate chip cookie to a sweet sugar cookie to enjoy - on the regular. You could also have them delivered to a loved one and win yourself the spot as their favorite person ever.

With cookie club memberships you can arrange for cookies to be delivered monthly, every other month, or every three months depending on your budget and self-restraint to not devour such gooey, amazing cookies all at once! The selection of cookies in each box is pre-determined by the company and they're always packaged for freshness. You'll usually receive more than one flavor of gourmet cookies in each delivery, so you are sure to always get a kind you love.

The Best Cookie Clubs Compare Cookie Clubs Compare Cookie Club Reviews What are the best Cookie Clubs Best Cookie Club Reviews

Cookie Club FAQ

Most cookie clubs get their cookies from top-notch small businesses around the country. You won't get the same old thing you could find at any supermarket near you. It's like having a bakery come directly to you!
That's up to you. Cookie subscriptions can be set to arrive each month, every other month, or even quarterly. You can have your membership last for three months, six months, or a full year.
They'll cost more than buying a mass-produced package of cookies at the grocery store, but probably less than buying cookies from a specialty bakery. Costs average from $12 to $30 per month for up to three pounds of cookies.
Some cookie clubs include delivery fees in their monthly costs, while others tack them on at checkout. That can definitely add to what you'll be spending, so be sure to read the details before you sign up for a subscription.
Most of the time, yes. What company wants bad reviews for delivering subpar treats? If your cookies arrive in less-than-perfect condition, it shouldn't be hard to get a replacement or a refund.
Definitely! Some of the most popular cookie clubs have been around for two decades or longer, bringing delight to lovers of sweets everywhere. Even some of the newer monthly subscription plans have already earned a loyal fan base with their delicious treats.
It's rare for any subscription box to just send the products and nothing more. Your cookie club membership will probably come with an entertaining newsletter that tells you where your treats were made and gives you fun cookie trivia to share with your friends.
Of course! Who doesn't love cookies?! Cookie clubs make it really easy to give as a gift for any occasion: enter your greeting and it'll be included with your first shipment, or have it emailed directly on any date you wish. Cookie club providers vary with what they offer in terms of gift-giving features, so choose the one that gives you the most bells and whistles for your lucky recipient.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you're looking for a new and exciting way to treat yourself or a friend or family member, you can't go wrong with a cookie club membership. They are surprisingly affordable and a gift you know you can't go wrong with. Although not all cookie clubs work exactly the same way, you're in for a delightful experience and you can cancel at any time: you aren't locked into anything.

As you browse different cookie club companies, there are some important things to consider:

  • Flexibility. Do you have the ability to specify the membership length and frequency of deliveries that will cater to your preferences? Can you take a break from cookie deliveries and then start back up again later?
  • Cost. How does the cost of one cookie club compare to another? Do you pay a flat fee upfront or can you pay month-to-month? Is delivery included in the monthly price or will you pay extra for shipping?
  • Satisfaction Policy. What if you aren't happy with the cookie quality, taste, or timeliness of your monthly delivery? Can you get a refund if there is an issue with freshness upon delivery?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best cookie clubs available today. We hope this information helps you indulge in a delicious club you or a loved one can enjoy all year long!

Compare Cookie Clubs

Select any 2 Cookie Clubs to compare them head to head

  • COOKIE... take a bite!
  • Amazing Clubs
  • David's Cookies
  • Goldbelly
  • Mrs. Chips Cookies
  • Feed Your Soul
  • Mrs. Fields
  • Cheryl's Cookies
  • Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies
  • Diva Cookies
COOKIE... take a bite! vs Amazing Clubs COOKIE... take a bite! vs David's Cookies COOKIE... take a bite! vs Goldbelly COOKIE... take a bite! vs Mrs. Chips Cookies COOKIE... take a bite! vs Feed Your Soul COOKIE... take a bite! vs Mrs. Fields COOKIE... take a bite! vs Cheryl's Cookies COOKIE... take a bite! vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies COOKIE... take a bite! vs Diva Cookies Amazing Clubs vs David's Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Goldbelly Amazing Clubs vs Mrs. Chips Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Feed Your Soul Amazing Clubs vs Mrs. Fields Amazing Clubs vs Cheryl's Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Amazing Clubs vs Diva Cookies David's Cookies vs Goldbelly David's Cookies vs Mrs. Chips Cookies David's Cookies vs Feed Your Soul David's Cookies vs Mrs. Fields David's Cookies vs Cheryl's Cookies David's Cookies vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies David's Cookies vs Diva Cookies Goldbelly vs Mrs. Chips Cookies Goldbelly vs Feed Your Soul Goldbelly vs Mrs. Fields Goldbelly vs Cheryl's Cookies Goldbelly vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Goldbelly vs Diva Cookies Mrs. Chips Cookies vs Feed Your Soul Mrs. Chips Cookies vs Mrs. Fields Mrs. Chips Cookies vs Cheryl's Cookies Mrs. Chips Cookies vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Mrs. Chips Cookies vs Diva Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Mrs. Fields Feed Your Soul vs Cheryl's Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Diva Cookies Mrs. Fields vs Cheryl's Cookies Mrs. Fields vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Mrs. Fields vs Diva Cookies Cheryl's Cookies vs Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies Cheryl's Cookies vs Diva Cookies Mollie B's Gourmet Cookies vs Diva Cookies
Compare the Best Cookie Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Cookie Clubs
See the Best Cookie Club
The Best Reviews of Cookie Clubs