Monday, May 19th
2025 Cookie Club Reviews
Feed Your Soul
- 12 individually-wrapped cookies in each box
- $134.95 for a 3-month subscription
- $263.70 for a 6-month subscription
- $515.40 for a 12-month subscription
- Shipping is free on all cookie clubs
- Pay upfront (no pay-as-you-go)
- Donations are made to Feeding America and Coalition for the Homeless
- Woman-owned, Certified B Corporation
Feed Your Soul's founder and owner, Mya Zoracki, did a hard pivot from being a trader on the American Stock Exchange and attending law school to creating a bakery that's putting good (and goodies) out into the world as a Certified B Corporation. Every purchase made at Feed Your Soul results in a donation made to Feeding America, and the bakery ships cookies monthly to Coalition for the Homeless in New York City. Since its founding, Feed Your Soul has donated over 100,000 cookies and 350,000 meals. This is absolutely a cookie club that spreads the love.
Expensive but worth it
We're going to say it upfront: you're going to pay more for this cookie club than most of its rivals on our list. Pricing ranges from $134.95 for a 3-month subscription to $515.40 for a 1-year plan, and there are only 12 individually-wrapped cookies in each box. But, those cookies are made with high-quality, simple ingredients with no artificial colors or preservatives, made to be eaten within 5 days of delivery (or frozen for up to 3 months), so you do get the quality you'd expect for the price.
No delivery preview but recipes look tasty
While Feed Your Soul doesn't tell you in advance which flavors will come in each cookie club delivery, they show you some of the tasty treats that have been on the roster in the past. Those include Lemonberry (lemon zest, dried cranberries, premium white chocolate, real butter), Snickerdoodle (their recipe includes white chocolate), Simply Sublime (fresh lime juice, real butter, pure cane sugar), and the classic chocolate chip recipe they call "The First Batch”.
Decent for gift-giving
You can keep this cookie club to yourself or send it as a gift. If you want to include a physical greeting card, though, you'll have to check the box and pay an extra $3 for the service. Whether you're buying for yourself or someone else, your cookies will always be shipped out around the same day of the month as the first delivery. Unfortunately, there doesn't seem to be a way to specify a future date during Feed Your Soul's checkout, so expect your first cookie club to ship shortly after you place your order.
Wonderful cookies and customer service
Shoppers have lovely things to say about the Feed Your Soul cookies and about the customer service. They assure prospective customers that the cookies are delicious and well worth the money, with some being pleasantly surprised at how fresh they are even after being stored for a while in the freezer after delivery. One person described the customer service rep with whom they spoke as being the most pleasant CSR they'd ever encountered in their life. And, of course, there's the feel-good aspect of knowing that every purchase helps feed people in need.
Get great treats while doing good for others
Feed Your Soul is definitely worth considering when you're looking for a solid cookie club. It doesn't offer some of the bells and whistles found with some rival subscriptions we evaluated (like making it easy to know which flavors are coming ahead of time or robust gift-giving features), but that's easily balanced out by the high-quality cookies and the wholesomeness of the company in general. We're happy to give Feed Your Soul's cookie club an excellent rating.
More Cookie Club Reviews
Where Can You Find the Best Cookie Clubs?
Imagine the sheer delight of receiving a package every month filled with an assortment of freshly baked, gourmet cookies delivered right to your doorstep. This is the magic of cookie clubs or subscriptions - the ideal treat for anyone with an insatiable love for cookies or for those eager to gift a delicious surprise to someone special.
Variety is the spice of life, they say, and what better way to experience it than through a plethora of cookie flavors? From classic chocolate chip and chewy oatmeal raisin to exotic flavors like salted caramel, peanut butter and jelly, or even lavender shortbread, the options are endless. Each month brings a new adventure as you eagerly anticipate the discovery of unique and tantalizing flavors crafted by skilled bakers.
Cookie Club FAQ
Continued from above...
Convenience is key in our fast-paced world, and cookie subscriptions offer just that. No more rushing to the store to satisfy your cookie cravings or spending hours in the kitchen baking batch after batch. With a subscription, simply sit back, relax, and let the cookies come to you. It's like having your own personal cookie concierge, ready to indulge your sweet tooth on the regular.
And let's not overlook the sheer brilliance of giving a cookie subscription as a gift. Picture the joy on your loved one's face as they unwrap their first box of cookies, a delectable surprise at their door after a long day at work or school. It's a gift that keeps on giving, spreading happiness and indulgence month after month. Whether it's for a birthday, anniversary, or just because, a cookie subscription is a thoughtful and memorable way to show someone you care.
Which cookie club is going to best satisfy your sweet tooth? As you consider the tempting variety of cookie clubs out there, here are five factors to help you compare your options:
- Variety of flavors. Look for clubs that offer a diverse selection of cookie flavors, so that each month brings a new and exciting experience. We love it when a cookie subscription shows you what previous boxes have included, so that you can see for yourself if you're likely to get flavors you'll enjoy.
- Flexibility. Some cookie clubs offer the ability to customize your subscription based on dietary needs (like gluten-free) or flavor preferences. You might also be able to skip a month, if the subscription lets you preview what's coming. Consider whether this option is important to you or to the recipient of your gift.
- Payment options. Do you want to pay for your cookie club upfront (which can be spendy) or would you like the ability to pay month-to-month?
- Value. Notice we didn't say "cost”. The value of your cookie subscription depends on several things: the monthly price, whether or not shipping is included, how many cookies you get in each delivery, and if there are any fun perks (like a newsletter or fancy gift packaging).
- Reputation. This may be the most important way to choose the right cookie club. Do people rave about the subscription, from the cookies themselves to the customer service? Look for glowing reviews from loyal subscribers as your clue that it's a club worth choosing.
To help you find the perfect cookie club to satisfy your cravings for delicious treats, the cookie fanatics at Top Consumer Reviews have happily evaluated and ranked today's most popular options. Anyone have a glass of milk?
Compare Cookie Clubs
Select any 2 Cookie Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Cookie Club News
Related Cookie Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Cookie Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
