The Cravory Review

Thursday, March 27th

2025 Cookie Club Reviews

The Cravory

• 6 new cookie flavors in each box
• Subscription can include 6, 12, or 24 cookies
• Subscriptions are prepaid and last 3, 6, or 12 months
• Prices start at $44.85 for a 3-month subscription of 6 cookies
• $6.95/box shipping fee on 6- and 12-cookie boxes
• Free shipping on the 24-cookie box
• Over 2,000 5-star reviews
• "A+” rated by the BBB
• In business since 2009

The Cravory is based in San Diego and has been crafting cookies since 2009. They've created over 5,000 flavors since then, serving more than 10,000 customers nationwide. Best of all, you can get these cookies no matter where you live through The Cravory's cookie club.

6 unique flavors in every delivery

Every month, you'll get to try 6 new cookie flavors from The Cravory. And believe us when we tell you that they're not your mama's oatmeal raisin. For example, here's what was released for the upcoming month at the time of our visit to the site:

• Almond Strawberry
• Cherry Cobbler
• Coconut Cream Pie
• Dulce de Leche Churro
• Mango Con Chili
• Maple Donut

Great value for what you get

How many cookies would you like in each box? The Cravory lets you decide if you want a half-dozen, a dozen, or two dozen in your subscription. All subscriptions are prepaid, and you can get deliveries for 3, 6, or 12 months. What does it cost? You'll pay $6.95 in shipping fees on each box when you subscribe to the 6- or 12-cookie box, but it's free when you choose the 24-cookie plan. Pricing starts at $44.85 for a 3-month subscription of the half-dozen cookies option, and goes up to $539.40 for a year-long subscription with two dozen cookies in each box. That makes this one of the best values in cookie clubs that we've found.

No problem to send as a gift

It's also really easy to set up this subscription as a gift. You'll follow the same process as subscribing for yourself; just select your desired delivery date and add a gift message during checkout.

Want free cookies?

When you first visit The Cravory's website, look for a tasty pop-up: by providing your birthdate, email, and phone number (to subscribe to their marketing messages), you'll get a free half-dozen birthday cake cookies on your special day when it rolls around. It also promised a 15% discount on our first order, but we're not sure that applies to the cookie club. Try it and see!

Responsive customer service

We gladly sing the praises of The Cravory's customer service department. We popped open a chat to ask the question we pose to all of the clubs on our list: "if someone hates peanut butter, will they know in advance if there are cookies scheduled that they're going to dislike, and can they skip that month?” We were pleasantly surprised to get a response right away, and although it took the rep a little while to track down the answer, she worked hard to make sure we had all the info we needed.

You can skip flavors you don't like, if you're careful

And, for reference, here's the response: this cookie club does let subscribers know which flavors will be shipped out each month. And, while there's no formal "skip this month” button based on flavor alone, you can absolutely reach out to The Cravory to have them give you a pass on a particular delivery. That can be if you're going out of town or for any reason. Here's the one tricky part: you determine which date of the month your cookies are going to ship when you place your order, and they need at least a week of advance notice if you'd like to skip a delivery. So, if you're sending cookies to a picky eater (like yourself?), it would be smart to have your deliveries coming on a date a little later on in the month. That gives you enough time to see which flavors are coming and reach out a week ahead of time. Whew, got all that?!

Lots of love from people who like new flavors

What do customers say about The Cravory's cookie club? The most popular subscription, the 6-cookie plan, had almost 150 reviews at the time of our most recent visit, and they averaged an impressive 4.7 stars out of 5. If you really enjoy trying unique cookie flavors, you'll probably give this club a 5-star score too. Frequent compliments mention the novel combos, like Almond Strawberry or Cherry Cobbler, and lots of people have great things to say about the customer service. Even the Better Business Bureau gives The Cravory a perfect "A+”.

Not everyone is a fan

On the other hand, we found more than one comment that said that these cookies "aren't that great”. It's hard to tell if that "ho-hum” reaction is because they just didn't like the beyond-chocolate-chip varieties of the cookies, but seeing that from more than one person was enough to drop The Cravory's cookie club a little bit in our rankings.

Good for foodies who like trying new cookies

The Cravory's cookie subscription is, overall, one well worth trying. It's a great gift, especially for more adventurous eaters, and you'll never be bored when you unbox the six new flavors from one month to the next. It's not our absolute favorite, but it's still a company we can get behind for offering wonderful customer service.