Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Edible Arrangements vs Magnolia Bakery

Saturday, March 15th

2025 Cookie Reviews

Edible Arrangements Review 3.5 Star Rating

Edible Arrangements

3.5 Star Rating
  • Prices start at three cookies for $14.99 and increase to $44.99 for a dozen
  • Three year-round cookie varieties offered, plus premium seasonal flavors
  • Low delivery fees starting at free for next-day or $9.99 for same day delivery
  • Fruit or flowers can be ordered with your cookies
  • Offers 100% guarantee
  • "A+” rated by the BBB
  • In business since 1999

For a sweet treat, Edible Arrangements offers more affordable baked goods with same-day delivery to limited areas within the range of its franchise locations. Starting at three cookies for $14.99, it provides a budget-friendly option for sending treats, though varieties are limited. Combine its limited delivery area with its high ratings on BBB, and we rank Edible Arrangements just above average for ordering cookies online.

Magnolia Bakery Review 2 Star Rating

Magnolia Bakery

2 Star Rating
  • Prices start at $21 for six cookies and go up to $84 for a pudding and cookie combination
  • Offers unique flavor of banana pudding cookies
  • Priority overnight shipping is only option at $35, and delivery insurance is strongly encouraged
  • In business since 1996

While some bakeries overwhelm you with their options, Magnolia Bakery ships just three types of cookies nationwide. The famous banana pudding is baked into a cookie for one of those varieties. Prices start at $21 for six cookies, making them one of the lower-priced options, yet the only shipping option is priority overnight with optional delivery insurance, which must be taken into cost considerations. When compared to other online cookie options on our list, we rate Magnolia Bakery below average.

Where Can You Find the Best Cookies Online?

When you think of what goes into a cookie, often the ingredients are nothing special on their own. Flour, sugar, butter, eggs, baking soda or powder, salt, and vanilla extract provide the basic building blocks for a cookie. There's something special that occurs when these essential components are mixed together and baked into a small treat. It makes us want to declare, as the Sesame Street character Cookie Monster often did, "Me want cookie!”

Ordering cookies online is a great idea because it's easy, convenient, and offers lots of choices. You can find all kinds of cookies that might not be available near you, and it's simple to compare prices and read reviews before buying. You don't have to leave your home, so you save time and effort. Plus, many websites deliver the cookies straight to your door, and some even let you customize your order to make the perfect cookie for you or as a gift to someone you care about.

The Best Cookies Compare Cookies Compare Cookie Reviews What are the best Cookies Best Cookie Reviews

Cookie FAQ

Most bakeries have a statement testifying to the freshness of their product. In addition to making them fresh before shipping, many individually wrap their cookies.
Shipping fees vary by company and location, but they usually range from $6.95 to a percentage of the total order. Some bakeries may offer free shipping promotions for stated order amounts or during special events.
Delivery times depend on the bakery and shipping method. Many offer next-day or even same-day delivery for certain locations, but it's always good to order in advance for special occasions.
Yes, most online cookie shops let you include a personalized gift note. Some even include fancy tins or wrapping to make it more like a gift. And, don't forget upgrades - some companies offer the option to include a card, a teddy bear, or even flowers, at checkout.
Upon arrival, check the packaging for specific storage instructions. Each cookie bakery has its own directions online. Some suggest refrigeration while others nix that idea and say that they should be kept at room temperature in an airtight container, depending on the type. Regarding freezing, some cookie bakers encourage it while others reject that method of storage.
Yes! Some bakeries offer kosher, gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, or sugar-free cookies. Be sure to read the product descriptions or use site filters to find the right options.
A few online bakeries offer customers the option to customize a message on a cookie cake. Others offer you a decision of which flavors to include in an assortment. But, for the most part, cookie deliveries fall under the "what you see is what you get” category, so you might have to look a little harder if you need something tailored to your event or special occasion.
Fortunately, many online bakeries guarantee their deliveries and will refund or replace your order if it arrives damaged or late. Read the notes at checkout though. Some companies require you to have delivery insurance or they don't take any responsibility for delivery problems. Promptly contact your cookie company's customer service team and be sure to take photos before you throw anything away - they may require those images before you can get a refund or replacement.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Perfect for a sweet snack or an elaborate dessert, cookies can be simple or elaborate to meet your desired taste, texture, and even purpose. Cookies can even be made into cakes for celebrations, combined with ice cream for a creative dessert sandwich, and even become a vessel for a drink (think cookie shots). These sweet treats typically can reside in a jar on your kitchen counter, ready for you to indulge as the fancy strikes.

Cookies can trace their origin back to 7th Century AD Persia. Now modern-day Iran, this area was the one of the first known to cultivate sugar, thus providing an essential part of the sweet treat. Evolving over the centuries from something simple made from grains, water, and dates for the Egyptians to sustain their journey in the afterlife, to the gourmet goods now sold in the fancy bakeries of big cities, everyone loves cookies.

When looking for a gift or party treat, look no further than the cookie. It does not require serving utensils and is enjoyed by people of all ages. There are countless types of cookie combinations and traditions throughout all cultures. Each country has its favored variations of these baked goods, and then other bakers take those and make their own versions. There is literally a cookie to satisfy everyone's taste buds.

While dietary restrictions can keep some people from readily indulging, advances in baking techniques have allowed those with allergies to enjoy these hand-held desserts in more ways than ever. Gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, kosher, nut-free, sugar-free--the accommodations are in place to make cookies available to anyone with a sweet tooth if you know where to look.

So where can you get the best cookies online? There are several factors to consider to ensure you get the best cookies for your money with the smoothest shopping experience possible:

  • Overall selection. There are countless cookie varieties which can be baked, so it's important to look for the flavor combination to suit your mood.
  • Taste and quality. You want to get the best cookie, whether it's the humble chocolate chip or a more creative combination of unique ingredients to tantalize your taste buds. It's also imperative that the cookies be soft when you expect soft, or crispy when that's the texture you're expecting.
  • Gift-giving options. Since you know your recipient loves cookies, it's important to find the perfect package to convey your heartfelt message. Look for the best presentation or decoration which meets your standards.
  • Customization options. While you can't necessarily tell the bakers what to put in the cookies, you might want to be able to have them decorated a particular way or combine varieties to make a perfect assortment for your intended recipient.
  • Name recognition and reputation. Some names immediately jump to mind when you think of cookies, while others are new on the scene. Consider reviews and reputation when weighing your options.
  • Dietary concerns. While the options are expanding for those who have allergies, not all bakeries are equipped to safely produce cookies to meet those needs. Read the information to make sure your cookies not only taste good and arrive on time but also keep your belly happy.

There are dozens of great options available for ordering cookies online, so the dessert-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have narrowed down, reviewed, and ranked some of today's most popular cookie bakeries. Make the decision easier by using our helpful reviews to make the right choice to satisfy your sweet tooth or fulfill your cookie-gifting occasion.

Compare Cookies

Select any 2 Cookies to compare them head to head

best-cookies
  • Bake Me A Wish!
  • David's Cookies
  • Feed Your Soul
  • Harry & David
  • Edible Arrangements
  • Dirty Cookie
  • Cookies By Design
  • Mrs. Fields Cookies
  • Milk Bar
  • Magnolia Bakery
Bake Me A Wish! vs David's Cookies Bake Me A Wish! vs Feed Your Soul Bake Me A Wish! vs Harry & David Bake Me A Wish! vs Edible Arrangements Bake Me A Wish! vs Dirty Cookie Bake Me A Wish! vs Cookies By Design Bake Me A Wish! vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Bake Me A Wish! vs Milk Bar Bake Me A Wish! vs Magnolia Bakery David's Cookies vs Feed Your Soul David's Cookies vs Harry & David David's Cookies vs Edible Arrangements David's Cookies vs Dirty Cookie David's Cookies vs Cookies By Design David's Cookies vs Mrs. Fields Cookies David's Cookies vs Milk Bar David's Cookies vs Magnolia Bakery Feed Your Soul vs Harry & David Feed Your Soul vs Edible Arrangements Feed Your Soul vs Dirty Cookie Feed Your Soul vs Cookies By Design Feed Your Soul vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Feed Your Soul vs Milk Bar Feed Your Soul vs Magnolia Bakery Harry & David vs Edible Arrangements Harry & David vs Dirty Cookie Harry & David vs Cookies By Design Harry & David vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Harry & David vs Milk Bar Harry & David vs Magnolia Bakery Edible Arrangements vs Dirty Cookie Edible Arrangements vs Cookies By Design Edible Arrangements vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Edible Arrangements vs Milk Bar Edible Arrangements vs Magnolia Bakery Dirty Cookie vs Cookies By Design Dirty Cookie vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Dirty Cookie vs Milk Bar Dirty Cookie vs Magnolia Bakery Cookies By Design vs Mrs. Fields Cookies Cookies By Design vs Milk Bar Cookies By Design vs Magnolia Bakery Mrs. Fields Cookies vs Milk Bar Mrs. Fields Cookies vs Magnolia Bakery Milk Bar vs Magnolia Bakery
Compare the Best Cookies
- VS -
Review the Best Cookies
The Best Reviews of Cookies