Cookies Reviews

Who's better?

Feed Your Soul vs Cookies by Design

We've analyzed the best Cookies to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Cookie Reviews

Here you can see how Feed Your Soul and Cookies By Design match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Cookies in 2026.

Winner

Feed Your Soul

  • Prices range from $25 for a 3-pack of crispy mini cookies to 60 cookies of a chosen variety for $105.95
  • Ten unique flavors, including a mystery flavor
  • Shipping fees range from $14.16 UPS ground for the crispy cookie three-pack to $71.25 for the UPS Next Day Air on the largest variety tin available.

Feed Your Soul offers its customers 10 fanciful flavors of cookies shipped nationwide starting with a dozen individually wrapped cookies for $44.95. If you're going to splurge on sweets, this is a pricier option to consider because it uses some of its profits for good. Cookies can feel like an indulgence, but spending money on a treat that also donates meals to feed those in need might make you feel like you're doing something bigger than just satisfying your sweet tooth. That earns Feed Your Soul a big thumbs-up from us.

Cookies By Design

  • Prices start at $29.99 for a treats sampler but increase to $39.99 for a cookie cake or even $109.99 for a large cookie bouquet
  • Sugar cookies are the primary treat for the hand-decorated bouquets, BouTrays, and baskets, though they also offer six gourmet flavor varieties
  • Same-day delivery offered with fees ranging from $19 to $24

The vibrant, colorful custom cookie bouquets and assortments at Cookies By Design offer a unique way to celebrate someone. With a sweet treats sampler box starting at $29.99, there are options here for all gift-giving budgets. Gourmet varieties are also available in addition to the hand-decorated sugar cookies, so those seeking a different flavor may find what they are looking for here. Concerns about Cookies By Design's delivery and customer service leave us wondering which locations are worth the risk, however, leading us to just rank this company in the middle of the pack.

On their own, the parts of a cookie aren't anything remarkable: flour, sugar, butter, eggs, a pinch of salt, baking soda or powder, and a splash of vanilla. But mix them together and slide the dough into a hot oven, and something quietly magical happens. It's kitchen alchemy - heat and time turn the basics into a little treat that's hard to resist. The moment that warm, buttery aroma drifts through the house, you know what's coming. It makes us want to shout, just like Sesame Street's Cookie Monster, "Me want cookie!"

Ordering cookies online makes the whole experience easy and convenient, with way more variety than you'll find on local shelves. It's simple to compare prices, skim reviews, and stumble on flavors you can't get nearby, all without leaving home - which saves time and effort. Most shops ship straight to your door, and many let you customize the order to match your taste or personalize it as a gift. You can even schedule deliveries for special occasions or set up a subscription so fresh treats keep coming. In short, buying cookies online gives you more options with less hassle.

Whether you're after a quick sweet bite or a show-stopping dessert, cookies adapt to whatever taste, texture, or occasion you have in mind. They can morph into celebration cakes, sandwich a scoop of ice cream, or even serve as drink-ready vessels - think cookie shots. Keep a jar on the counter and they're there whenever the craving hits. They travel well, freeze beautifully, and welcome endless mix-ins, so it's easy to make a batch that's truly your own.

Cookies trace their roots to seventh-century Persia - modern-day Iran - where some of the earliest sugar cultivation made sweet baking possible. Long before glass cases in chic bakeries, people were forming simple sustenance: the ancient Egyptians even pressed plain cakes from grain, water, and dates to carry with them into the afterlife. As trade routes and migration spread ingredients and techniques, the idea of a sweet, portable bite traveled too, picking up new textures, spices, and shapes along the way. Over the centuries, those humble beginnings became the countless styles we enjoy now, from rustic biscuits to glossy gourmet confections in big-city shops. And no matter the recipe, it's hard to find someone who doesn't love a cookie.

Shopping for a gift or planning a party? You can't go wrong with cookies. They're fuss-free - no knives, plates, or servers - and loved by kids and adults alike. Every culture has its own cookie traditions, and those recipes inspire endless riffs as bakers put their spin on classics from around the world. From chewy to crisp, spiced to chocolate-studded, the combinations seem limitless, and there's truly a cookie for every palate. They also pack and travel beautifully, making them an easy win for hosts and guests.

Dietary restrictions can make it tough to indulge, but modern baking has opened the door for people with allergies to enjoy cookies again. From gluten-free and dairy-free to vegan, kosher, nut-free, and sugar-free, there are choices everywhere - if you know where to look. Many bakeries and online shops now spotlight ingredient lists and cross-contact practices, so it's easier to find something that fits your needs. Clever swaps - think oat flour blends, aquafaba, and plant-based butter - mean the classic hand-held dessert is more inclusive than ever.

So where can you get the best cookies online? There are several factors to consider to ensure you get the best cookies for your money with the smoothest shopping experience possible:

There are dozens of great options available for ordering cookies online, so the dessert-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have narrowed down, reviewed, and ranked some of today's most popular cookie bakeries. Make the decision easier by using our helpful reviews to make the right choice to satisfy your sweet tooth or fulfill your cookie-gifting occasion.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Cookie FAQ

How do cookies stay fresh during shipping?
Most bakeries have a statement testifying to the freshness of their product. In addition to making them fresh before shipping, many individually wrap their cookies.
How much does cookie delivery cost?
Shipping fees vary by company and location, but they usually range from $6.95 to a percentage of the total order. Some bakeries may offer free shipping promotions for stated order amounts or during special events.
What's the delivery timeframe for cookies ordered online?
Delivery times depend on the bakery and shipping method. Many offer next-day or even same-day delivery for certain locations, but it's always good to order in advance for special occasions.
Can I include a gift message with my order?
Yes, most online cookie shops let you include a personalized gift note. Some even include fancy tins or wrapping to make it more like a gift. And, don't forget upgrades - some companies offer the option to include a card, a teddy bear, or even flowers, at checkout.
What's the best way to store delivered cookies?
Upon arrival, check the packaging for specific storage instructions. Each cookie bakery has its own directions online. Some suggest refrigeration while others nix that idea and say that they should be kept at room temperature in an airtight container, depending on the type. Regarding freezing, some cookie bakers encourage it while others reject that method of storage.
Are there cookie delivery options for people with dietary restrictions?
Yes! Some bakeries offer kosher, gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, or sugar-free cookies. Be sure to read the product descriptions or use site filters to find the right options.
Can I customize my cookie order?
A few online bakeries offer customers the option to customize a message on a cookie cake. Others offer you a decision of which flavors to include in an assortment. But, for the most part, cookie deliveries fall under the "what you see is what you get" category, so you might have to look a little harder if you need something tailored to your event or special occasion.
What if my cookies arrive damaged?
Fortunately, many online bakeries guarantee their deliveries and will refund or replace your order if it arrives damaged or late. Read the notes at checkout though. Some companies require you to have delivery insurance or they don't take any responsibility for delivery problems. Promptly contact your cookie company's customer service team and be sure to take photos before you throw anything away - they may require those images before you can get a refund or replacement.

Compare Any 2 Products

Bake Me A Wish!
David's Cookies
Feed Your Soul
Harry & David
Edible Arrangements
Dirty Cookie
Cookies By Design
Mrs. Fields Cookies
Milk Bar
Magnolia Bakery
vs
Bake Me A Wish! vs David's CookiesBake Me A Wish! vs Feed Your SoulBake Me A Wish! vs Harry & DavidBake Me A Wish! vs Edible ArrangementsBake Me A Wish! vs Dirty CookieBake Me A Wish! vs Cookies By DesignBake Me A Wish! vs Mrs. Fields CookiesBake Me A Wish! vs Milk BarBake Me A Wish! vs Magnolia BakeryDavid's Cookies vs Feed Your SoulDavid's Cookies vs Harry & DavidDavid's Cookies vs Edible ArrangementsDavid's Cookies vs Dirty CookieDavid's Cookies vs Cookies By DesignDavid's Cookies vs Mrs. Fields CookiesDavid's Cookies vs Milk BarDavid's Cookies vs Magnolia BakeryFeed Your Soul vs Harry & DavidFeed Your Soul vs Edible ArrangementsFeed Your Soul vs Dirty CookieFeed Your Soul vs Cookies By DesignFeed Your Soul vs Mrs. Fields CookiesFeed Your Soul vs Milk BarFeed Your Soul vs Magnolia BakeryHarry & David vs Edible ArrangementsHarry & David vs Dirty CookieHarry & David vs Cookies By DesignHarry & David vs Mrs. Fields CookiesHarry & David vs Milk BarHarry & David vs Magnolia BakeryEdible Arrangements vs Dirty CookieEdible Arrangements vs Cookies By DesignEdible Arrangements vs Mrs. Fields CookiesEdible Arrangements vs Milk BarEdible Arrangements vs Magnolia BakeryDirty Cookie vs Cookies By DesignDirty Cookie vs Mrs. Fields CookiesDirty Cookie vs Milk BarDirty Cookie vs Magnolia BakeryCookies By Design vs Mrs. Fields CookiesCookies By Design vs Milk BarCookies By Design vs Magnolia BakeryMrs. Fields Cookies vs Milk BarMrs. Fields Cookies vs Magnolia BakeryMilk Bar vs Magnolia Bakery Magnolia Bakery vs Milk BarMagnolia Bakery vs Mrs. Fields CookiesMagnolia Bakery vs Cookies By DesignMagnolia Bakery vs Dirty CookieMagnolia Bakery vs Edible ArrangementsMagnolia Bakery vs Harry & DavidMagnolia Bakery vs Feed Your SoulMagnolia Bakery vs David's CookiesMagnolia Bakery vs Bake Me A Wish!Milk Bar vs Mrs. Fields CookiesMilk Bar vs Cookies By DesignMilk Bar vs Dirty CookieMilk Bar vs Edible ArrangementsMilk Bar vs Harry & DavidMilk Bar vs Feed Your SoulMilk Bar vs David's CookiesMilk Bar vs Bake Me A Wish!Mrs. Fields Cookies vs Cookies By DesignMrs. Fields Cookies vs Dirty CookieMrs. Fields Cookies vs Edible ArrangementsMrs. Fields Cookies vs Harry & DavidMrs. Fields Cookies vs Feed Your SoulMrs. Fields Cookies vs David's CookiesMrs. Fields Cookies vs Bake Me A Wish!Cookies By Design vs Dirty CookieCookies By Design vs Edible ArrangementsCookies By Design vs Harry & DavidCookies By Design vs Feed Your SoulCookies By Design vs David's CookiesCookies By Design vs Bake Me A Wish!Dirty Cookie vs Edible ArrangementsDirty Cookie vs Harry & DavidDirty Cookie vs Feed Your SoulDirty Cookie vs David's CookiesDirty Cookie vs Bake Me A Wish!Edible Arrangements vs Harry & DavidEdible Arrangements vs Feed Your SoulEdible Arrangements vs David's CookiesEdible Arrangements vs Bake Me A Wish!Harry & David vs Feed Your SoulHarry & David vs David's CookiesHarry & David vs Bake Me A Wish!Feed Your Soul vs David's CookiesFeed Your Soul vs Bake Me A Wish!David's Cookies vs Bake Me A Wish!
See the Best Cookies in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Southern Living

20 Classic Cookies Our Readers Bake Again And Again

Go beyond just the classics like chocolate chip with our collection of the most popular types of cookies, and recipes for how to make each.

Mon, 09 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

'Best Cookies Ever': You Can Snag This Fan-Favorite Aldi Treat For ...

Looking for a sweet treat? This Aldi product is a fan-favorite way to get a baked treat that is also plenty easy on your grocery shopping budget.

Thu, 05 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The Cincinnati ...

What happens to Girl Scout Cookies that don't get sold? What to know

Girl Scout Cookie season typically begins in January and lasts until mid-April. So, what happens to all the leftover cookies that don’t get sold?

Tue, 03 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Cook What You Love ...

25 cookies you’ll want to hide from the kids after the first batch

Some cookies are just too irresistible to share. Explore recipes that turn simple ingredients into sweet bites you’ll want to keep for yourself. The post 25 Cookies You’ll Want to Hide From the Kids ...

Wed, 04 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

6 cookies, 1 winner: We taste-tested the best cookie delivery ...

If you’re looking for something that has a bit of everything, we recommend the Sweets and Treats Gift Basket ($45), which comes with an assortment of brownies and cookies for every taste. The With ...

Wed, 28 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

FOX 5 San Diego

Local vegan cookie shop bakes celebratory cookies to honor Black ...

Maya’s Cookies, a Black-owned vegan cookie company in San Diego, has launched its 2026 Black History Month Collection, ‘The Continuity of Culture’, featuring three specially ...

Thu, 29 Jan 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.