Where Can You Find the Best Cookies Online?
When you think of what goes into a cookie, often the ingredients are nothing special on their own. Flour, sugar, butter, eggs, baking soda or powder, salt, and vanilla extract provide the basic building blocks for a cookie. There's something special that occurs when these essential components are mixed together and baked into a small treat. It makes us want to declare, as the Sesame Street character Cookie Monster often did, "Me want cookie!”
Ordering cookies online is a great idea because it's easy, convenient, and offers lots of choices. You can find all kinds of cookies that might not be available near you, and it's simple to compare prices and read reviews before buying. You don't have to leave your home, so you save time and effort. Plus, many websites deliver the cookies straight to your door, and some even let you customize your order to make the perfect cookie for you or as a gift to someone you care about.
Tuesday, March 25th
2025 Cookie Reviews
Bake Me A Wish!
With over a dozen cookies to choose from, Bake Me A Wish! ranks high with its customers. Geared toward gift-giving, the company curates assortments of treats, starting with twelve cookies for $34, and going up to a platinum tower of a variety of tasty goods for $108. Customer reviews are typically excellent for this company, which ships nationwide, including Alaska and Hawaii. We think you'll love any cookie you try from Bake Me a Wish!, our #1 pick among online cookie-shippers.
David's Cookies
In business for over 40 years, David's Cookies has 14 kinds of cookies to satisfy your sweet tooth, including gluten-free, dairy-free, and nut-free made in a dedicated facility. With options starting at $29.95, this company is an affordable cookie-lover's delight. Additionally, David's offers a satisfaction guarantee. Put all of that together, and you get our #2 cookie delivery company.
Feed Your Soul
Feed Your Soul offers its customers 10 fanciful flavors of cookies shipped nationwide starting with a dozen individually wrapped cookies for $44.95. If you're going to splurge on sweets, this is a pricier option to consider because it uses some of its profits for good. Cookies can feel like an indulgence, but spending money on a treat that also donates meals to feed those in need might make you feel like you're doing something bigger than just satisfying your sweet tooth. That earns Feed Your Soul a big thumbs-up from us.
Harry & David
When it comes to mail order gifts, Harry & David has been a well-known name for close to a century. With its monthly clubs and assorted gifts, it offers something for all price ranges. It is one of the few places to offer vegan cookies, gluten-free cookies, and sugar-free cookies, in addition to traditional treats. However, recent complaints about customer service and shipping have brought this reputation into question. Still, Harry & David has always been responsive to customers over the years, and we trust them enough to give them a strong rating for cookie delivery.
Edible Arrangements
For a sweet treat, Edible Arrangements offers more affordable baked goods with same-day delivery to limited areas within the range of its franchise locations. Starting at three cookies for $14.99, it provides a budget-friendly option for sending treats, though varieties are limited. Combine its limited delivery area with its high ratings on BBB, and we rank Edible Arrangements just above average for ordering cookies online.
Dirty Cookie
When you want a cookie but you also want something different, Dirty Cookie offers its unique cookie shots and stuffed cookies to satisfy your craving for sweets. Starting at six for $34.99, these treats aren't cheap but they are an experience. With four cookie shot flavors and five stuffed cookie varieties, dessert-lovers are bound to find something to enjoy. Dirty Cookie gets an above-average rating for its unique offerings and because a portion of the proceeds are donated to educational programs.
Cookies By Design
The vibrant, colorful custom cookie bouquets and assortments at Cookies By Design offer a unique way to celebrate someone. With a sweet treats sampler box starting at $29.99, there are options here for all gift-giving budgets. Gourmet varieties are also available in addition to the hand-decorated sugar cookies, so those seeking a different flavor may find what they are looking for here. Concerns about Cookies By Design's delivery and customer service leave us wondering which locations are worth the risk, however, leading us to just rank this company in the middle of the pack.
Mrs. Fields Cookies
With five classic cookies available for online orders with in-store pickup or for shipping nationwide, Mrs. Fields has options for all budgets and tastes. From a single chocolate chip cookie for $2.99 picked up from a local shop to a $199.99 tower of treats delivered to your door, you're likely to find something to fill your craving. Online reviews are mixed, though, mostly relating to shipping and customer service issues. Compared with your other tasty options for ordering cookies online, Mrs. Fields comes in as "just average.”
Milk Bar
Comfort flavors with a twist are the specialty at Milk Bar. With nine types of cookies, customers are able to have sweet and savory tastes at a cost of six for $27. Unfortunately, this cookie shop ranks below average for its low customer satisfaction, online customer complaints, and lack of guarantee. We recommend getting your cookies from one of Milk Bar's rivals instead.
Magnolia Bakery
While some bakeries overwhelm you with their options, Magnolia Bakery ships just three types of cookies nationwide. The famous banana pudding is baked into a cookie for one of those varieties. Prices start at $21 for six cookies, making them one of the lower-priced options, yet the only shipping option is priority overnight with optional delivery insurance, which must be taken into cost considerations. When compared to other online cookie options on our list, we rate Magnolia Bakery below average.
Continued from above...
Perfect for a sweet snack or an elaborate dessert, cookies can be simple or elaborate to meet your desired taste, texture, and even purpose. Cookies can even be made into cakes for celebrations, combined with ice cream for a creative dessert sandwich, and even become a vessel for a drink (think cookie shots). These sweet treats typically can reside in a jar on your kitchen counter, ready for you to indulge as the fancy strikes.
Cookies can trace their origin back to 7th Century AD Persia. Now modern-day Iran, this area was the one of the first known to cultivate sugar, thus providing an essential part of the sweet treat. Evolving over the centuries from something simple made from grains, water, and dates for the Egyptians to sustain their journey in the afterlife, to the gourmet goods now sold in the fancy bakeries of big cities, everyone loves cookies.
When looking for a gift or party treat, look no further than the cookie. It does not require serving utensils and is enjoyed by people of all ages. There are countless types of cookie combinations and traditions throughout all cultures. Each country has its favored variations of these baked goods, and then other bakers take those and make their own versions. There is literally a cookie to satisfy everyone's taste buds.
While dietary restrictions can keep some people from readily indulging, advances in baking techniques have allowed those with allergies to enjoy these hand-held desserts in more ways than ever. Gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, kosher, nut-free, sugar-free--the accommodations are in place to make cookies available to anyone with a sweet tooth if you know where to look.
So where can you get the best cookies online? There are several factors to consider to ensure you get the best cookies for your money with the smoothest shopping experience possible:
- Overall selection. There are countless cookie varieties which can be baked, so it's important to look for the flavor combination to suit your mood.
- Taste and quality. You want to get the best cookie, whether it's the humble chocolate chip or a more creative combination of unique ingredients to tantalize your taste buds. It's also imperative that the cookies be soft when you expect soft, or crispy when that's the texture you're expecting.
- Gift-giving options. Since you know your recipient loves cookies, it's important to find the perfect package to convey your heartfelt message. Look for the best presentation or decoration which meets your standards.
- Customization options. While you can't necessarily tell the bakers what to put in the cookies, you might want to be able to have them decorated a particular way or combine varieties to make a perfect assortment for your intended recipient.
- Name recognition and reputation. Some names immediately jump to mind when you think of cookies, while others are new on the scene. Consider reviews and reputation when weighing your options.
- Dietary concerns. While the options are expanding for those who have allergies, not all bakeries are equipped to safely produce cookies to meet those needs. Read the information to make sure your cookies not only taste good and arrive on time but also keep your belly happy.
There are dozens of great options available for ordering cookies online, so the dessert-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have narrowed down, reviewed, and ranked some of today's most popular cookie bakeries. Make the decision easier by using our helpful reviews to make the right choice to satisfy your sweet tooth or fulfill your cookie-gifting occasion.
Cookie FAQ
Compare Cookies
Select any 2 Cookies to compare them head to head
Trending Cookies News
Related Cookie Reviews
Since you're interested in Cookies, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
