Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

My Supplement Store Review

Friday, September 22nd

2023 Creatine Supplement Store Reviews

My Supplement Store Review 4.5 Star Rating

My Supplement Store

4.5 Star Rating
  • Prices from $12.99 to $74.99
  • Individual reviews on listings
  • Free shipping on $99+
  • 30-day limited returns
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

Since its establishment in 2001, My Supplement Store has gained an excellent reputation as a fitness retailer. They have a team of knowledgeable associates who are passionate about various forms of fitness and provide exceptional customer service that fulfills orders quickly from Chicago, and ships to over 150 countries around the world. With a competitive list of creatine supplements (65 individual products), they are a competitive and worthwhile option to explore when buying your next creatine supplement.

Clean website, but could use more filters

In terms of user experience, the website is modern and clean and provides easy access to a wide variety of supplements. Customers can easily find the creatine supplements from the Sports Nutrition tab or by searching directly on the search bar. We loved that My Supplement Store had a dedicated page just for creatine supplements, as it makes it much easier to explore just those listings. Additionally, the listings provide clear at-a-glance information including the number of stars an individual product has according to buyers as well as general pricing information and whether or not a particular product is on sale. While we would like more filters to make it easier to find options like powder supplements vs. capsule supplements, the user experience at My Supplement Store is an overall positive one.

Competitive pricing when in stock

To compare prices at My Supplement Store with other competitors, we analyzed the prices of three types of creatine supplements. My Supplement Store's powder creatine ranged in price from $15.99 to $74.99 (for 2000g) which is highly competitive. For creatine capsules, the prices ranged from $12.99 for 100 capsules to $39.99 for 200 capsules in a different brand. And, it doesn't appear that My Supplement Store offers its own proprietary brand. However, we did notice that several of the items, especially in the lower price tiers, weren't in stock, which could be frustrating for shoppers who are excited about the good deals but can't purchase them.

Free shipping on orders $99+

In terms of shipping policies at My Supplement Store, customers can expect a standard shipping time of 2-5 business days for orders within the United States. Depending on the location of the recipient, delivery can take as little as 1-2 days on average, but most arrive in about 4 days. Customers who spend under $99 can expect a flat $5 shipping fee for their order (unless otherwise stated), while orders over $99 are shipped for free through the standard shipping - except those that contain RTDs, energy drinks, and bars.

Best Creatine Supplements

Limited 30-day return policy

But what about returns? The policy here is fairly limited, though they do allow returns. At My Supplement Store, you can return any unopened or unused product within 30 days of shipment for a refund. The product must be in its original condition and packaging, and unfortunately, the customer will be responsible for the original shipping cost as well as the return shipping cost unless the product was defective. Unfortunately, clearance items and mystery/subscription boxes cannot be returned.

Top-rated for quality and timeliness

My Supplement Store has established a reputation as a reliable and affordable source for supplements, with an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and an average star rating of 4.2 out of 5 across multiple third-party review sites. Many reviewers praise the company's competitive prices, timely shipping, and quality products. One customer says they order from My Supplement Store frequently and recommend it to others. Another customer has been buying from the company for two years and plans to continue doing so. On the other hand, some reviewers have experienced issues with shipping times, with one customer noting that their order took 10 days to process. Overall, My Supplement Store has a positive reputation among supplement users for its affordable prices and reliable products.

Solid choice

My Supplement Store is a reputable fitness supplement company that provides quality products and exceptional customer service. Their website is user-friendly, with clear information on pricing, product reviews, and shipping policies. The company has an overall positive reputation for timely shipping and quality products as well as a stellar "A+" rating from the BBB. Only the limited return policy and lack of filters on the site knock this down from being tied with our top option. Overall, My Supplement Store deserves its high spot in our ratings for creatine supplements.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Creatine Supplements?

Whether you're a hardcore gym rat trying to get "swole" , a hardcore athlete trying to build muscle for an upcoming meet, or if you just want a little extra definition in your quads after spin classes, you've probably heard of creatine. This substance occurs naturally in muscle cells and is one of the few nutritional supplements that is regularly recommended by personal trainers, sports nutritionists, and experienced athletes alike.

Creatine supplementation has been shown to increase muscle mass, strength, and power in athletes, particularly in short-term, high-intensity exercise. It may also improve recovery time and reduce muscle damage and soreness after exercise. It supports your gains through three amino acids: L-arginine, glycine, and L-methionine.

The Best Creatine Supplement Stores Compare Creatine Supplement Stores Compare Creatine Supplement Store Reviews What are the best Creatine Supplement Stores Best Creatine Supplement Store Reviews

Creatine Supplement Store FAQ

Creatine is a naturally-occuring nutrient in your body, a combination of the amino acids methionine, arginine and glycine. It is also one of the most well-researched supplements in the fitness industry.
When you need to move in a quick, explosive way, creatine is what helps your muscles have the energy to get it done. Without getting overly scientific, adding creatine to your regimen gives you more power to get through your workout by increasing your muscle capacity temporarily and making muscles more efficient. Creatine has been clinically shown to help you train more intensely and recover more quickly.
Creatine is a fantastic option for anyone looking to improve their athletic performance, especially with respect to strength training. The supplement can give you the extra boost you need to lift heavier and for more reps, which will make you stronger over time. You still have to do the work to see the results - it's not a magic powder or pill - but creatine can help you make progress.
Creatine isn't recommended for people with diabetes, kidney disease or liver disease. If you take any supplements or medications that impact your blood sugar, you may also want to avoid creatine because it can affect your blood sugar levels. The supplement is also not recommended for people under the age of 18 or women who are pregnant or nursing.
The good news is that creatine is one of the most affordable supplements on the market. You can get a two-month supply for under $10! There are many different ways to take creatine - pills, capsules, powder that you mix with liquid or food, and so on - and the price will vary depending on the format you choose.
This question is often hotly debated. Most researchers agree that a daily dose of 5 grams is enough to see benefits without overdoing it, but your physician, trainer or dietician may have other thoughts. The same goes for timing: some say you should take it right after your workout, while others say that the only thing that matters is taking it consistently so that the amount stored in your muscles remains relatively static.
As long as you're staying well hydrated, probably not. Otherwise, you could experience some muscle cramping. Also be aware that regular use of creatine can affect certain blood test results, so be sure your healthcare provider is aware of your usage if they order any lab work for you.
That depends on where you buy it. Many retailers have a satisfaction guarantee allowing you to get a replacement or refund. But, you'll need to use creatine consistently for several weeks before seeing any noticeable impact on your workouts: don't get discouraged if you're not getting results right away.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Around 95% of creatine in the body is stored in skeletal muscle, where it is used to provide energy during short bursts of intense activity such as weightlifting, sprinting, or jumping. The remaining 5% of creatine is stored in the brain, kidneys, and other organs. Creatine has been repeatedly demonstrated to deliver improvements in muscle mass, power, and strength with little to no side effects.

While anyone can enjoy the benefits of creatine, it can be particularly essential for vegetarians who lift weights, as meat is the most common natural source of creatine. However, even for those who consume meat, it can be challenging to eat enough to get the amount of creatine necessary for building muscle. In small doses (3-5 grams of creatine per day), most athletes see significant gains in a short period of time.

Interestingly, creatine has been shown to have additional health benefits beyond muscle gains. For example, some studies have shown that creatine supplements can improve many neurological conditions like Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's as well as brain and spinal cord injuries. Since 5% of creatine is stored in the brain, this could be a reason why it can have positive effects on neurological functions.

If you're looking to add creatine to your workout regimen, keep in mind that not all creatine products and retailers are equal. When deciding which creatine supplier to choose, you should consider factors such as product quality, safety, and pricing. By keeping these criteria in mind, you can ensure that you are getting the best creatine supplements at the most reasonable prices from a trustworthy retailer.

If you're still not sure where to start, don't worry. We've created this list of key factors that might help you narrow down the many options for buying creatine:

  • Price: How much are you looking to spend on supplements? Do you want to buy in bulk or just try something new for a little while? Keeping your budget in mind and checking on sales will help you find the best creatine supplement retailer for you.
  • Style: Not all creatine supplements are made the same. Some have different delivery mechanisms like powder, capsules, or even gummies. Others have different flavors or textures. Keep in mind what format will be best suited for your muscle-building needs.
  • Website: Is the website easy to use? Can you easily find what you need while you're shopping? Can you easily understand what the products are at a glance? These are all important when choosing a creatine retailer to ensure the best shopping experience.
  • Shipping: How much does shipping cost? Does the retailer offer free shipping? How hard is it to qualify for free or low-cost shipping? This may affect the overall price of your purchase, so keep an eye on shipping and deals at different retailers.
  • Return Policy: If you're spending money on creatine supplements, it's probably one of many costs on your fitness journey. With that said, you want some confidence that a company stands behind its products if you're giving them your money. It's important to double-check the return policies for supplement retailers before you buy. If you don't like something, you don't want to swallow the cost yourself.

To help you find the best support for your gym sesh, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best creatine supplement retailers on the market today. Now you can focus on getting those gains with the best creatine supplement for your needs.

The Best Reviews of Creatine Supplement Stores