Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Macy's Review

Saturday, September 14th

2024 Cufflink Store Reviews

Macy's Review 4 Star Rating

Macy's

4 Star Rating
  • Huge variety and reasonable-to-luxury offerings ($50 to $1,000)
  • In-store pickup offered for online orders
  • Competitive pricing with rival retailers
  • Free shipping with orders of $49 or more
  • Returns within 30 days accepted both online and in-store

A shorthand for large department stores, and a symbol of luxury for years, Macy's has long cemented itself as an American staple (complete with movie representation and Thanksgiving Day parades). As an iconic brand and a solid spot in the collective unconscious of consumer America, how does Macy's hold up to the more specialized cufflink purveyors on our list?

Good range of mid-tier cufflinks

While it's a tough market for department stores more generally, we are impressed with Macy's cufflinks offerings. With around 900 cufflinks on offer, about 500 of which fall in the $50 to $100 price range, Macy's is one of the best mid-price cufflink purveyors on our list. On a closer look, many of its branded designer cufflinks are cheaper than the best on our list when bought on sale (which we appreciate). As far as a diversity of mid-price cufflinks goes, Macy's does an excellent job, even though they offer fewer high-end cufflinks than competitors.

Best Cufflink Stores

Generally good shipping and return policies

As an added bonus, their retail locations mean you can pick up your order in store or mail to your home, with free shipping on orders of $49 or more. We also appreciate Macy's generous return policy. Even if you order online, as long as you return within 30 days, Macy's accepts all returns for full refund, swaps, or in-store credit. While their shipping and returns aren't the best on our list, we appreciate the flexibility of both.

Overall, a fine choice for mid-price cufflinks

While they do not offer a myriad of flashy ultra-high-end cufflinks or any customization options, Macy's does an excellent job providing a good variety of sensible and stylish cufflinks (many sourced from another wholesaler featured on this list). If there is a Macy's close to you, or you are a fan of their frequent sales and rewards programs, then Macy's can be a good choice for your cufflinks.

Where Can You Buy the Best Cufflinks Online?

It's a good question, as men's formal wear can sometimes feel limiting. After all, there are only so many acceptable colors of suits and blazers. However, cufflinks are a popular accessory for men that can express style and sophistication in a single glance. And the convenience and accessibility offered by online shopping has made shopping for cufflinks easier than ever.

One of the key benefits of online cufflink stores is the vast array of options available. Online stores provide a wide range of cufflinks to choose from, catering to different styles, tastes, and occasions. From classic designs, to contemporary and quirky ones, customers can easily explore numerous options with just a few clicks. Moreover, online stores often collaborate with brands and designers, giving shoppers access to a diverse selection of cufflinks from around the world.

The Best Cufflink Stores Compare Cufflink Stores Compare Cufflink Store Reviews What are the best Cufflink Stores Best Cufflink Store Reviews

Cufflink Store FAQ

Cufflinks are essentially removable buttons, used to keep shirt cuffs closed. They come in a wide range of styles, materials and price points.
If you're wearing a dress shirt with French cuffs - the traditional style for black tie events, for example - you'll definitely need cufflinks. Why? These cuffs don't come with buttons sewn in, making cufflinks a must to keep your cuffs closed and tidy. You can wear cufflinks with cuffs that do have buttons, if you like the way they look!
That's entirely up to your preferences. Most cufflinks come in sizes ranging from 0.5” to 1”.
Metals used in cufflinks tend to be .925 sterling silver, stainless steel, palladium, 14k or 18k gold. Some may use gemstones for added elegance, or have intricate, eye-catching designs. You can also get cufflinks made of silk, leather, or bone.
Start by having your cuffs long and unfolded. Next, fold the cuffs back so that the holes are lined up. Place your cufflinks through all four layers of fabric (i.e. the folded-back cuffs on both sides of your wrists) and secure the backing mechanism. It's that easy!
Cufflinks should be considered as pieces of jewelry, and as such you may want to consider having them professionally cleaned from time to time by a jeweler. Otherwise, metal cufflinks can be kept tidy with a soft-bristled toothbrush, mild soap, and a cotton cloth to dry them before storage. If your cufflinks have gemstones, you want to avoid moisture and abrasives and just polish them with a soft, dry cloth.
A cufflink box is a nice way to store and organize them. These boxes have separate compartments to prevent scratches, and they keep your cufflinks out of direct sunlight and heat that can damage them. Even if you don't buy a specific box for your cufflinks, store them in a dry place and avoid using plastic bags or containers that can make them tarnish more quickly.
That's easy: you want the world's best selection at the best prices. It can be hard to find cufflinks in your typical brick-and-mortar jewelry store or department store, especially if you're looking for a novel design or something extremely high-end. There are many reputable retailers of cufflinks online today, who deliver an amazing array of cufflinks and offer an impressive level of customer service. Be sure to see what other clients have to say about any cufflink store you're considering, as well as the retailer's BBB listing, if you want added reassurance that you've chosen a reliable company for your purchase.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Another advantage of online cufflink stores is the convenience they offer. With online shopping, you can browse and purchase cufflinks from the comfort of your own home - or any location with internet access. This eliminates the need to visit traditional, physical stores and saves valuable time and effort. Additionally, online stores are open 24/7, allowing you to shop at your convenience. This flexibility is particularly advantageous for individuals with limited mobility or those residing in remote areas with limited access to physical retail stores.

Additionally, online cufflink stores often provide competitive pricing due to their lower overhead costs compared to brick-and-mortar stores. They eliminate expenses associated with physical retail spaces, such as rent, utilities, and staffing. These savings are often passed on to their customers in the form of reduced prices and special promotions. Moreover, online stores frequently offer exclusive discounts, seasonal sales, and loyalty programs, enhancing the affordability and value for customers.

Cufflinks actually didn't become a popular part of the modern wardrobe until the advent of the men's collared shirt and suit as the de-facto uniform of 19th century professionals. With buttons simply too flimsy to hold the thick and heavily-starched clothes of the time, and mass-production affording the streamlined creation of simple accessories, cufflinks became a menswear staple until cultural changes of the 60's led to less-professional menswear. As they are no longer an everyday sight, a good set of cufflinks can be a unique way to set your wardrobe apart.

While online cufflink stores offer numerous benefits to their customers, it can be a chore wading through the fly-by-night websites and deceptive marketing practices in search of quality cufflinks. As you start looking for the perfect accent to your wrist, here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Metal and quality. What are your cufflinks made of? Are they gold-plated or gold? Rose-gold or brass? Be sure to check, as some less-scrupulous providers may not specify.
  • Hobby and vanity cufflinks. Many cufflinks range from high-fashion to playfully specific: an alma-mater or sport-themed cufflink can make an excellent and surprising gift.
  • Customization. Many of the best providers on our list provide customizable and engravable cufflinks. Whether a photo, phrase, or 3D image,, reputable companies on our list can bring your vision into life with their customization plans.
  • Return Policy. Return policies with retailers of cufflinks range from the generous to the frustratingly restrictive. Especially if you are purchasing cufflinks as a gift, be sure to browse the return policies before purchasing cufflinks (or any product) online.

Here at Top Consumer Reviews we've done the heavy lifting of locating and reviewing the best cufflink purveyors on the web. By winnowing the wheat from the chaff, you can rest assured that the retailer you choose will have the appropriate price range and style for your choice of cufflinks.

The Best Reviews of Cufflink Stores