Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Contessa the Bakery vs Sugar Coated Cupcakes

Wednesday, December 11th

2024 Cupcake Club Reviews

Contessa the Bakery Review 2 Star Rating

Contessa the Bakery

2 Star Rating
  • Costs $540 one-time
  • 6-month commitment
  • Surprise cupcakes each month
  • 12 full-size cupcakes in each shipment
  • 12 flavors per shipment
  • Great for gifting

Contessa the Bakery offers a cupcake subscription that sends you 12 different cupcakes every month. While the cupcakes are unique, the subscription is a bit costly for just 6 months and there are no options for shorter or longer subscriptions. Unfortunately, with limited reviews and no refunds, Contessa the Bakery has room for improvement in its customer service.

Sugar Coated Cupcakes Review 1.5 Star Rating

Sugar Coated Cupcakes

1.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $81 to $309 per period
  • Pay one-time
  • Menu is offered before shipment
  • 6 full-size cupcakes in each shipment
  • Two flavors per shipment
  • Extremely limited shipping area
  • "A+” rating from the BBB

Sugar Coated Cupcakes is a mobile bakery offering a cupcake subscription club that features six cupcakes in each shipment. While the flavors at Sugar Coated Cupcakes are creative and there are enough flavors to keep you occupied for multiple years, the bakery's limited shipping area and strict no-refunds policy may be a drawback for some. So, while the company shows glowing reviews on Facebook, shipping issues earn Sugar Coated Cupcakes' subscription one of our lowest ratings overall.

Where Can You Find the Best Cupcake Subscription Clubs?

Watching the latest episode of Cupcake Wars and starting to feel left out of the fun? While you can get some tasty treats from your local grocery store or go out to a specialty bake shop to get your sugar fix, it's harder to get those really good cupcakes from the comfort of your home (we get it, baking it from a boxed mix just isn't the same).

Cupcake subscription clubs also make fantastic gifts for a sweet-lover in your life. Whether you're looking to give them cupcakes from boutique bakeries, award-winning cupcakeries, or a chance to try as many frostings as they can, this gift will be a winner.

The Best Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Club Reviews What are the best Cupcake Clubs Best Cupcake Club Reviews

Cupcake Club FAQ

Cupcakes are usually baked and shipped on the same day to make sure you get the best-tasting experience possible. Most clubs will use special packaging to keep the treats fresh for you. You'll see everything from cupcake-shaped plastic containers to glass jars. Most clubs will ship their cupcakes with some kind of ice or refrigeration too.
Not from the stale selection at your local grocery store! Cupcake clubs specialize in sourcing tasty treats from artisan bakers around the nation, bringing you flavors you likely won't find anywhere else. How does Dark Chocolate Passion Fruit or Vanilla Pomegranate sound? Those are just two of the mouth-watering selections you might get when you sign up for a cupcake club.
Most clubs offer monthly deliveries. From there, you choose whether you want the membership to last anywhere from three months to a year. Some providers also let you specify if you'd like your cupcake club to come every other month or even once per quarter.
You'll pay between $7.50 to $56 per delivery, depending on the cupcake club provider you choose. On the lower end of the price range, you might get two cupcakes in each shipment, while the higher end comes with a dozen treats.
Totally! Many cupcake subscription clubs offer one-time payment options specifically for this purpose. The goal is to allow you to prepay for a specific period so that you can easily send cupcakes as a gift to someone you love without committing yourself (or them) to recurring payments. Most services will also let you add a personal note to send to your loved one.
That depends on the cupcake club. Some include delivery costs in the monthly price, while others charge per delivery - as much as $15 each time! You'll definitely want to take that into account as you decide which plan is the best one for you.
Most specialty memberships - like cupcake clubs- gain a lot of business through word of mouth. That means they want you to be thrilled with all of the treats you get! If you get a delivery with cupcakes that didn't survive the trip or aren't 100% amazing for any other reason, you can almost always request a refund, credit, or reshipment if you reach out to customer service.
One of the most entertaining parts of a monthly cupcake club - besides the actual eating, of course! - is finding out more about where they came from. Most clubs include a fun newsletter that gives you more details about your cupcakes: which bakery made them, how the flavor choices were dreamed up, and maybe even recommended beverage pairings!
Definitely! Some cupcake clubs have been around for many years, going to great lengths to keep finding new bakeries and flavors to delight their loyal subscribers. As subscription clubs have grown in popularity, the choices have expanded too. It's never a bad idea to see what other customers have to say about a club before committing to a membership.
Who doesn't love a good cupcake? More often than not, cupcake clubs are purchased as a gift, offering tasty treats that keep the happy moments coming for months at a time. You can usually include an announcement or special message when purchasing the club for someone else.
It's simple. You sign up online, choose a plan (usually in monthly payments or one-time payments), choose how many months of cupcakes you want, and subscribe. After that, cupcakes show up at your door. Most clubs include surprise flavors and seasonal specials.
This depends on the club, but most will offer you alternatives. Some prefer to surprise you each month, but you'll get an email letting you know what your shipment will be. If something is in the shipment that you don't like (or can't have), you can reach out and most cupcake subscription clubs will change it.
The pricing varies by club, but most range between $25 to $70 per month, depending on how many cupcakes you receive or the number of months you commit to. Many clubs offer discounted prices if you commit to a longer subscription or offer one-time payments that take a portion of the price off as a discount.
Most cupcake subscription clubs have options for different dietary needs. Some of the prominent upgrades include gluten-free cupcakes, vegan, or keto. Be sure to check each club, though, as every bakery has a different recipe, and some may offer more dietary options than others.
While it's rare for you to receive treats in poor condition, some cupcake subscription clubs offer refunds if your cupcakes are damaged during shipping. Many companies don't offer any recourse though, so make sure you check the company's policy on refunds or reships to see how each service handles problems. You might find reshipment is the common response if something is wrong with your cupcakes.
Yes, most clubs allow you to cancel at any time or skip a month if you need to. However, some cupcake subscription clubs require you to prepay for a minimum commitment (like three months). In some cases, the company will refund you for unused months if you cancel, but for the sites with no refund policy, you'll be committed for the duration. Always check out the policies before you subscribe.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

These subscription-based services send you regular shipments of cupcakes right to the comfort of your home. The number of cupcakes and frequency is totally up to you in most services. So whether you want a sampler with tons of flavors or a pack of favorites for an upcoming birthday bash, a cupcake subscription club is a great way to get more sweets into your life pronto. You don't need to worry about ordering every month: once you sign up, you just need to sit back, relax, and let the cupcakes come to you.

After all, sometimes, you don't have time to hunt down your local novelty bakery. Don't worry, you won't need to run out and buy piping bags and cupcake tins to have that hand-made quality cupcake you're craving - you can join a cupcake club instead.

Cupcakes come in as many varieties as cake (just smaller). Whether you're a frosting fiend or a red velvet superfan, there are tons of cupcakes to try. With increasingly exciting flavors and combos - we've seen those maple-bacon bourbon treats on baking competitions, yum! - you've got to try them all. From classic flavors like creamy chocolate, confetti, or just vanilla or the next great flavor like key lime, s'mores, or a rum-soaked Bahama Mama cupcake, there's a cupcake subscription club out there that can deliver.

If you're excited to have a batch of cupcakes ready to go every single month but aren't sure where to start, don't worry. We've checked out all the best cupcake subscription clubs to help you find the best way to narrow the field. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Cost. Cupcake subscription boxes usually ship every month, and it's important to weigh the price against the number of cupcakes you'll receive or how unique and high-quality the flavors are. Some services also offer discounts for longer commitments, like quarterly or annual plans, so keep an eye out for those.
  • Variety. Not all cupcakes are created equal. Choose a cupcake subscription club that offers plenty of variety in flavors and designs to keep things interesting. Look for options with a rotating menu or seasonal additions to make sure you're not stuck with repeat flavors if you don't want them. Plus, finding a bake shop with unique flavors (like whiskey soaked cake) can really expand your sweets palate during your cupcake journey.
  • Reputation. Before subscribing to a cupcake club, take a minute to check out the reviews and ratings on trusted third-party review sites. Checking out feedback on places like Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau can show you honest feedback (not curated by a company) so you can judge the quality of the cupcakes and customer service based on foodies just like you.

If you're craving something sweet, now's the perfect time to dive into a fantastic cupcake subscription club. To help you spend more time enjoying your well-deserved tasty treats, Top Consumer Reviews has done the hard work for you by researching and ranking the best cupcake subscription clubs online today. It's time to treat yourself to your favorite flavors and discover some new ones along the way. Bon Appetit!

The Best Reviews of Cupcake Clubs