Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Not Pie vs Baked by Melissa

Thursday, May 23rd

2024 Cupcake Club Reviews

Not Pie Review 4 Star Rating

Not Pie

4 Star Rating
  • 6-pack of gourmet cupcakes in each delivery
  • Most cupcakes topped with signature marshmallow
  • $33 for one delivery
  • $95 for three months
  • $130 for quarterly deliveries
  • $165 for six months
  • $330 for one year
  • Free delivery on all subscription boxes
  • Gluten-free, vegan, and gluten-free + vegan subscriptions available
  • Contact the store to reschedule deliveries or make special requests

Not Pie is a cute cupcake club with some features you won't find with other memberships. For one, gluten-free and vegan customers are welcome here - with no surcharge for following a special diet. Most of these gourmet cupcakes come with a marshmallow topping, flavored to match the cake base. You'll only get six per delivery, but they're priced accordingly. Not Pie goes the extra mile in customer service too, allowing you to reschedule a delivery if you need it on time for a special occasion or after you get back from vacay. This is a great choice for your cupcake club.

Baked by Melissa Review 2 Star Rating

Baked by Melissa

2 Star Rating
  • 25 or 50 mini-cupcakes in each delivery
  • Prices start at $168.48 for quarterly club and $466.56 for 12-month club
  • One-time shipping fee of $15.95
  • Many different cupcake flavors in each box
  • Nut-free subscription available

Baked by Melissa specializes in mini-cupcakes. If you'd like to get a bite-size taste in several different flavors, this subscription will probably appeal to you. However, this company has had a sharp drop in customer satisfaction since our last evaluation: recently, shoppers have said that deliveries go missing or arrive past the important occasion they were celebrating, and that customer service is AWOL more often than not. We recommend that you check out the higher-ranked cupcake clubs we've reviewed instead of signing up for Baked by Melissa's.

Which Cupcake Club is the Best?

Cupcakes have been enjoyed as a sweet treat since the late 1700s, with today's flavors ranging from classic yellow cake with vanilla frosting to unique variations such as Maple Cinnamon and Lemon-Lime Vanilla Bean or elaborate, theme-focused creations. These individual-sized cakes are popular among people of all ages and are perfect for a variety of occasions, from baby showers to potluck picnics.

If you're looking for a way to indulge in the artistic creativity of baked goods on a regular basis, a cupcake club membership is an excellent option. With various plans to choose from, you or a loved one can receive several cupcakes in different flavors delivered straight to your door.

The Best Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Club Reviews What are the best Cupcake Clubs Best Cupcake Club Reviews

Cupcake Club FAQ

Not from the stale selection at your local grocery store! Cupcake clubs specialize in sourcing tasty treats from artisan bakers around the nation, bringing you flavors you likely won't find anywhere else. How does Dark Chocolate Passion Fruit or Vanilla Pomegranate sound? Those are just two of the mouth-watering selections you might get when you sign up for a cupcake club.
Most clubs offer monthly deliveries. From there, you choose whether you want the membership to last anywhere from three months to a year. Some providers also let you specify if you'd like your cupcake club to come every other month or even once per quarter.
You'll pay between $7.50 to $56 per delivery, depending on the cupcake club provider you choose. On the lower end of the price range, you might get two cupcakes in each shipment, while the higher end comes with a dozen treats.
That depends on the cupcake club. Some include delivery costs in the monthly price, while others charge per delivery - as much as $15 each time! You'll definitely want to take that into account as you decide which plan is the best one for you.
Most specialty memberships - like cupcake clubs- gain a lot of business through word of mouth. That means they want you to be thrilled with all of the treats you get! If you get a delivery with cupcakes that didn't survive the trip or aren't 100% amazing for any other reason, you can almost always request a refund, credit, or reshipment if you reach out to customer service.
Definitely! Some cupcake clubs have been around for many years, going to great lengths to keep finding new bakeries and flavors to delight their loyal subscribers. As subscription clubs have grown in popularity, the choices have expanded too. It's never a bad idea to see what other customers have to say about a club before committing to a membership.
One of the most entertaining parts of a monthly cupcake club - besides the actual eating, of course! - is finding out more about where they came from. Most clubs include a fun newsletter that gives you more details about your cupcakes: which bakery made them, how the flavor choices were dreamed up, and maybe even recommended beverage pairings!
Who doesn't love a good cupcake? More often than not, cupcake clubs are purchased as a gift, offering tasty treats that keep the happy moments coming for months at a time. You can usually include an announcement or special message when purchasing the club for someone else.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Whether you savor the delicate notes of a white chocolate raspberry cupcake, delight in the rich flavors of German chocolate, or want to explore unusual creations like tie-dye, there are many options to choose from. Some cupcake clubs even incorporate unique and fun twists, such as delivering bite-sized amounts of cupcakes or even cupcakes in a jar..

One of the main reasons why cupcake clubs have become so popular is convenience. You can enjoy freshly baked cupcakes without having to go out to a bakery or spend time baking them yourself. This is especially good for people with busy schedules who may not have the time or energy to bake their own cupcakes. Cupcake clubs can also be a great gift idea for friends and family members who live far away or who are difficult to shop for.

Another reason why people love cupcake clubs is the variety of flavors and styles of cupcakes that you can try. Each month, you can look forward to a new selection of cupcakes that are carefully curated by the cupcake club. These cupcakes may include traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla, as well as more unique and adventurous flavors like lavender and honey or raspberry cheesecake. This variety can be especially appealing for people who enjoy trying new foods and flavors.

Cupcake clubs also provide an opportunity for people to develop their taste preferences and discover new flavors and styles of cupcakes that they may not have tried before. For example, someone who typically prefers chocolate cupcakes may discover a new love for lemon or coconut cupcakes through their subscription. This can be a fun and exciting way to expand culinary horizons and try new things.

With consumers wanting choices and so many great options to choose from, it's not surprising that cupcake clubs have become more and more popular over the past few years. However, cupcake club features vary almost as much as the flavors themselves. You may want to think about whether the company includes shipping, how many cupcakes are delivered, and what perks are included in club plans. Additionally, you'll need to decide whether you are looking for a classic cupcake experience or a more whimsical treat. A few cupcake clubs also have menu options that meet the needs of gluten-free and vegan customers.

In general, when selecting the right Cupcake Club for you, there are several factors to consider:

  • Variety. Are you (or your lucky recipient) a foodie through and through? Then choose a cupcake club that gives you several different flavors - either over the course of your membership or, better yet, within each delivery.
  • Cost. What will you pay for each monthly shipment of cupcakes? Is shipping included in the price? How many cupcakes will you get? Also, take note on whether you'll have to pay for the entire subscription in full when you place your order or if you can pay as you go.
  • Club length. How long would you like to receive cupcakes? Most clubs let you choose 3-, 6-, or 12-month plans. You may also be able to modify the frequency to every other month, essentially doubling the length of time you get your sweet treats delivered.
  • Gift-giving features. If you're sending a cupcake club to a special someone, look for a company that makes it extra-nice. This could include a gift announcement, a fun newsletter, and so on.
  • Reputation. Have many people purchased this cupcake club? Are there any customer reviews you can check out? Some smaller businesses might not have thousands of ratings to consider, so you might need to look at their social media accounts for more feedback.

If you're a self-proclaimed cupcake fanatic (no shame, we are too!), you need to join a cupcake club. To help, Top Consumer Reviews has done the hard work for you and ranked the best clubs available today. You can find the perfect cupcake club membership that fits your cravings and sweet tooth needs. So what are you waiting for? Let's get this cupcake party started!

The Best Reviews of Cupcake Clubs