Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Not Pie vs Sweet Belmar

Monday, January 25th

2021 Cupcake Club Reviews

Not Pie Review 3.5 Star Rating

Not Pie

3.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $25 per shipment (6 cupcakes)

Not Pie is a dependable and reputable option to consider for cupcake club memberships. They deliver cupcakes that both taste good with a signature marshmallow topping dipped in ganache; and that you can feel good about with their ethically sourced ingredients. Prices are extremely reasonable. Not Pie does offer a low amount of product per shipment, however, and all cupcakes delivered are of a uniform flavor each month. This lack of variety or preference specificity is unusual compared to our higher rated companies.

Sweet Belmar Review 3 Star Rating

Sweet Belmar

3 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $7.50/month, plus another $9.99 for shipping (2 cupcakes)

Sweet Belmar is a standard cupcake club membership to consider. Their sweets and treats are award-winning and high quality, but there is no way to customize the experience or indicate preferences. Additionally, customers are delivered the least number of cupcakes out of any other website reviewed on our list. Prices are reasonable, but with fixed shipping on all orders there are superior membership plans to consider.

Who Offers the Best Cupcake Club?

Where is the best cupcake club? From a classic vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting, to a more unique Pink Lemonade flavor, to elaborate and theme-focused creations, cupcakes have been delighting tastebuds since the late 1700s. Popular with young children, as a hot trend at wedding receptions, and even just to enjoy in the work break room; the time is never wrong to indulge in these scrumptious, individual-sized cake treats.

There's no better way to indulge and celebrate the artistic creativity of baked goods, than through a Cupcake Club membership. A gift that keeps on giving, you or a loved one can choose between plans that will deliver several cupcakes in a variety of flavors, straight to your door.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Savor the delicate notes of a white wedding cake cupcake, delight in every bite of a Creme brulee flavored cupcake, or even explore unusual sounding flavors like PB&J. Some cupcake cake clubs even incorporate unique and fun twists, such as delivering tons of bite-sized amounts of cupcakes, or even cupcakes in a jar!

Finding the right cupcake club for you might include several factors to consider. Whether the company includes shipping, how many cupcakes are delivered, what perks may be included in club plans, are all important to reflect on. Are you looking for a classic cupcake experience, or are you feeling more whimsical in your desire for the sweet, sugary treat? Do you want company options that will sell other confectionary goods, along with cupcakes? There are a variety of companies that will continue to address these questions and support your choices.

With consumers wanting choices and so many great options to choose from, it's not surprising that cupcake clubs have become more and more popular over the past few years. Equally unsurprising is the fact that cupcake club features vary almost as much as the flavors themselves. Do your research to select the perfect club for you. Some points to consider are:

  • Price. What is the subscription cost and will you need to pay for shipping? Are there any discounts or coupons available? Are refunds guaranteed?
  • Frequency. How often will a shipment be sent? Do you have choices or is there only one option? Can you pay as you receive deliveries, or do you need to pre pay in full?
  • Flexibility. Are there different subscription types? Can you choose the to have several flavors delivered, specify the amount of product shipped, or other customizations?
  • Selection. What comes in each shipment? Is it the same cupcake each time or are you able to try other styles?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cupcake Clubs available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right Cupcake Club membership to suit your needs!

The Best Reviews of Cupcake Clubs