Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Cupcake Clubs

Who Offers the Best Cupcake Club?

Where is the best cupcake club? From a classic vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting, to a more unique Pink Lemonade flavor, to elaborate and theme-focused creations, cupcakes have been delighting tastebuds since the late 1700s. Popular with young children, as a hot trend at wedding receptions, and even just to enjoy in the work break room; the time is never wrong to indulge in these scrumptious, individual-sized cake treats.

There's no better way to indulge and celebrate the artistic creativity of baked goods, than through a Cupcake Club membership. A gift that keeps on giving, you or a loved one can choose between plans that will deliver several cupcakes in a variety of flavors, straight to your door.

Thursday, February 9th

2023 Cupcake Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $55.95 per shipment (12 cupcakes)
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Amazing Clubs has been delivering high quality and classic cupcakes of the month since 2003, and they continue to impress and exceed expectations. Provided at an affordable cost, customers are sent a dozen scrumptious and delicious cupcakes of the month, in a variety of flavors that surprise and delight the eyes and tastebuds. Amazing Clubs not only delivers quality products however, they also advertise the most flexible and thoughtful customer-service touches compared to any other website reviewed on our list. With that winning combination, it's no wonder the Wall Street Journal has rated Amazing Clubs the #1 monthly gift club for the last 7 years in a row!

Fun flourishes

A few fun flourishes added by Amazing Clubs includes free shipping on all orders; a "They'll Love It!" guarantee - which ensures customer satisfaction or your money back; and a 'Cupcake Chronicles' newsletter included in gift delivery with facts and tips explaining that month's delivery to the recipient. Cupcakes are outsourced from some of the country's most renowned bakeries, and each delivery includes 4 different flavors to mouth-water over, hand-chosen by tasting professionals, and never once repeated throughout the recipient's duration. In fact, previous shipments have included flavors like: Mocha Nutella, Creme Brulee, Siesta Key Lime, Lemon Raspberry, and Chocolate Champagne. Now that's a whole lotta YUM delivered right to the door each month.

Best Cupcake Clubs

Protective packaging

Amazing Clubs sends their heavenly baked goods not only with love and joy, but in specially designed packaging that help prevent damage, in order to ensure fresh and safe delivery for recipients. Other reviewing agencies commend Amazing Club's ability to send premium cupcakes that are customer-forward; and the reputable BBB gives Amazing Clubs a solid A- rating. We looked into any complaints posited by customers, which appeared to mainly concern delivery questions. We noticed Amazing Clubs did an excellent job responding to any and all concerns, and worked efficiently to resolve these.

Cupcake Club Membership Overview

  • Cupcake Selection: 12 cupcakes in 4 different flavors
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo, seasonal (4 total deliveries)
  • Frequency: Monthly or once every 3 months (pre-pay in full or per shipment)
  • Shipping: Free (International shipping not available)

Best in class

Choosing Amazing Clubs for your monthly cupcake fix is one of the easiest decisions you'll ever make. The classic cupcake style, variety of flavors delivered each month, free shipping, and guaranteed customer satisfaction, create the finest cupcake club company reviewed on our site. The most difficult decision to make with Amazing Clubs? Which cupcake to bite into first!

Baked by Melissa Review 4.5 Star Rating

Baked by Melissa

4.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $36.50 per shipment, plus another $15.95 for shipping (25 bite-sized cupcakes)

With Baked by Melissa, cupcake recipients receive the most bang for buck - hands down. What started as a coping mechanism for Melissa when she lost her job as an Assistant Media Planner some odd years ago, eventually turned into an entrepreneurial dream for her and her older brother, Matt. Now Melissa and Matt manage 14 different locations and ship Melissa's yummy cupcakes nationwide.

Bite-sied cupcakes

Melissa sets herself apart from the crowd by not supplying your average cupcakes - but rather supplying large quantities of bite-sized amounts of cupcakes. This allows cupcake club recipients to taste test several varieties of flavors; and in this business, we believe more is more. While bite sized amounts of lots of cupcakes could turn off potential customers who are really intent on purchasing classic, full-sized cupcakes, we think most consumers will likely appreciate the ability to try up to 50 different cupcakes in as many as 10 different delectable flavors. There might not even by any leftovers by the time that first bite is taken!

Best Cupcake Clubs

Variety of Cupcake Club options

Baked By Melissa also offers multiple different club packages to choose from. These should cater to the particular needs of each client, which we love. However, it was a little confusing to navigate all the ins and outs of each club on the website. We wish each plan had a more straightforward way of listing its components, so that consumers understand just how far their dollar is going with each plan. And speaking of dollars: Baked by Melissa does range from cost effective to costly, depending on the plan and frequency opted for. With such a substantially greater amount of product delivered, however, we can understand why prices might peak a bit higher.

Cupcake Club Membership Overview

  • Cupcake Selection: YOLO package (3 seasonal flavors, 6 original flavors, + a changing mini of the month flavor); FOMO package (6 seasonal, 3 mini of the month, + 8 additional flavors); Notta Nut Package (7 original flavors delivered without nuts). All plans available in a 25-pack, or 50-pack. FOMO can opt for 25/50-pack + mini of the month.
  • Duration: Monthly for 12 months, or once every 3 months. Pre-pay in full.
  • Frequency: YOLO - Quarterly, FOMO - Monthly (x12), Notta Nut - Monthly or Quarterly
  • Shipping: Flat rate shipping: Standard- $15.95, Expedited $24.95, Saturday Arrival $34.95. No international shipping available.

Delightful membership

With Baked by Melissa, you are guaranteed to have a full belly and a satisfying experience. We do wish Melissa would clean up the website a bit to clarify so many different options offered, and that free shipping was offered to customers who are often already being asked to pay a big price. However, a cupcake club subscription with Baked by Melissa is sure to delight all senses and all people - whether as gift for someone else, or just to indulge yourself!

Wicked Good Cupcakes Review 4 Star Rating

Wicked Good Cupcakes

4 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $15.35 per shipment, plus another $5.00 for shipping (2 cupcakes)

Wicked Good Cupcakes is more than a Nor' Eastern attention-grabbing slogan for mother-daughter duo Tracey and Dani: it's a company name that perfectly describes the Cohasset, Massachusetts based family's wickedly, sinfully, beautifully, exquisitely, good cupcakes. You may recognize this company as being featured on ABC's 'Shark Tank', but these cupcakes have been busy making a name all on their own.

Cupcakes in a jar

When Tracey and Dani started cake decorating classes in 2010, they soon discovered that their fun way to bond with one another, had serious business and serious flavorful potential. They opened their first store in 2011, and as they began attempting to ship their wicked good cupcakes, they discovered a serious barrier to ensuring continuity of quality for customers: limited packaging options. Thus, cupcakes in a jar was born and has been the cause of much head-scratching and happy taste buds ever since. "Mr. Wonderful", Kevin O'Leary from 'Shark Tank', has even been known to refer to Wicked Good Cupcakes as "the best investment [he's] ever made on Shark Tank!". That's pretty darn good.

Best Cupcake Clubs

Gluten-free options

With Wicked Good Cupcakes, everything is baked and made from scratch, and the jars can last up to 10 days without refrigeration, or can be frozen for up to 6 months. While you can't specify any dietary requests in the packages, the store itself sells gluten free options. Wicked Good Cupcakes has an A rating from the BBB, and maintains good reviews online. Not to mention, we love the sparkly, silver bow that adorns each jar upon delivery.

Cupcake Club Membership Overview

  • Cupcake Selection: 2 Jars (4 cupcakes), 4 Jars (8 cupcakes), 6 Jars (12 cupcakes)
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo
  • Frequency: Once per month. Pre-pay in full.
  • Shipping: $5 for the 2 Jar Plan; Free for all other plans

Highly satisfying

Wicked Good Cupcakes offers a highly satisfying option for many customers seeking a cupcake club subscription service. We did take note that the unique nature of cupcake jars may not appeal to consumers seeking a more classic cupcake experience. Additionally, while their website felt very personable, it could use a more professional appearing make-over to help elevate their appeal and status. Ultimately, we think you'll be incredibly pleased with any of Wicked Good Cupcakes delicious cupcake jars.

Not Pie Review 3.5 Star Rating

Not Pie

3.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $25 per shipment (6 cupcakes)

Not Pie offers quality and standard cupcake subscription plans for customers seeking a simpler and more classic cupcake experience. When entrepreneurial couple, Joshua and Amanda, tried and failed to find a way to deliver a birthday for Amanda's aging father, the two decided to utilize their skills for business and micro-commerce, to find a bakery that would help all people from all places be able to celebrate whenever and wherever!

Signature marshmallow frosting

While Not Pie was named by Joshua and Amanda's then high-school son, aptly for their choice to not sell pie on the menu - the couple leaned into the metaphor that baked goods created by their company, unlike pie , would never run out. Ingredients are marketed as being responsibly sourced by Not Pie, and of the highest quality. Plus, not only do you feel good about your Not Pie cupcakes, but each cupcake tastes heavenly, especially when topped with their signature marshmallow frosting dipped in ganache (typically chocolate!).

Best Cupcake Clubs

Lack of Cupcake Club options

We only wish that customers could access more than 6 cupcakes per shipment; or that they could at least choose from more customizing options! Each pack of gourmet cupcakes includes a standard number of 6 cakes in a flavor of the month chosen by the company. While customers may happily finish each bite of cupcake delivered, having preference options to choose from, or even an ability to list dietary concerns and/or allergies, would be supremely helpful for customers. That being said, the price is certainly right for a lower number of cupcakes delivered, and subscription packages are advertised to include exclusive flavors, new ideas, and even perks such as cookbooks or cupcake coasters.

Cupcake Club Membership Overview

  • Cupcake Selection: 6-pack of gourmet cupcakes delivered in a uniform flavor of the month.
  • Duration: Monthly- may cancel at any time, 3mo, 6mo (discounted price subtracts one month's worth of cost), 12mo (discounted price subtracts two months' worth of cost), Quarterly.
  • Frequency: Delivered monthly, or quarterly (4 shipments total). Must pre-pay in full.
  • Shipping: Free

Good value

Not Pie offers a valuable product at an affordable price. They could benefit to incorporate some more customization into plan options for customers; but at the price point they offer, Not Pie is still a fair option to consider. We hope the company will continue to expand, and their supply with it!

Sweet Belmar Review 3 Star Rating

Sweet Belmar

3 Star Rating
  • Cost: Starting from $7.50/month, plus another $9.99 for shipping (2 cupcakes)

Sweet Belmar is an adequate cupcake club to consider for either yourself or a loved one. As a 2019 Monmouth Health & Life Magazine Reader's Choice Award recipient for "BEST CUPCAKES" and "BEST CHOCOLATES", the New Jersey based company delivers scrumptious goodies that have been reviewed to delight and impress.

Mystery cupcakes?

Although the quality of product is reviewed to be high, we discovered that Sweet Belmar delivers the least amount of product per shipment compared to any other company reviewed on our site; and that their signature delivery method seems to copy another company's (also rated on this list). Instead of delivering full-sized cupcakes each month, recipients are sent a "mystery cupcake jar". These jars include 2 fresh-baked and award-winning cupcakes: filled either with the regular cupcakes made at Sweet!, or with limited edition cupcakes made only for club members.

Only 2 cupcakes per shipment

This is a unique idea, that overall sets Sweet Belmar apart from the crowd - even if it is slightly reminiscent of another company reviewed on our list. Despite this, we find that it's rather limiting for customers to be delivered only 2 cupcakes (1 jar) per shipment. The price is comparable to our less expensive options, but not much less for such a small amount of product being delivered. Additionally, Sweet Belmar has a bland website that feels unremarkable and unable to capture attention. While a baker has no need to be a technology aficionado, this conveys a lack of creativity and care from Sweet Belmar, which other companies have afforded their customers.

Best Cupcake Clubs

Cupcake Club Membership Overview

  • Cupcake Selection: 1 jar containing 2 cupcakes: either 2 regular or 2 limited edition cupcakes
  • Duration: 3mo, 6mo, 12mo
  • Frequency: Delivered monthly, pre-pay in full
  • Shipping: Fixed $9.99 shipping

Affordable, but better options are available

Sweet Belmar is an acceptable option for a cupcake club, delivering a quality product at an affordable price. But it delivers so much less product each shipment, in a method that feels more like a knock-off of one of our higher rated companies than it feels ingenious; and, at a price not much lower than our comparable lowest price cupcake club. Sweet Belmar may sell sweet treats, but we think it'd be sweeter and more worthwhile to check out some of our other cupcake club subscription services.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Savor the delicate notes of a white wedding cake cupcake, delight in every bite of a Creme brulee flavored cupcake, or even explore unusual sounding flavors like PB&J. Some cupcake cake clubs even incorporate unique and fun twists, such as delivering tons of bite-sized amounts of cupcakes, or even cupcakes in a jar!

Finding the right cupcake club for you might include several factors to consider. Whether the company includes shipping, how many cupcakes are delivered, what perks may be included in club plans, are all important to reflect on. Are you looking for a classic cupcake experience, or are you feeling more whimsical in your desire for the sweet, sugary treat? Do you want company options that will sell other confectionary goods, along with cupcakes? There are a variety of companies that will continue to address these questions and support your choices.

With consumers wanting choices and so many great options to choose from, it's not surprising that cupcake clubs have become more and more popular over the past few years. Equally unsurprising is the fact that cupcake club features vary almost as much as the flavors themselves. Do your research to select the perfect club for you. Some points to consider are:

  • Price. What is the subscription cost and will you need to pay for shipping? Are there any discounts or coupons available? Are refunds guaranteed?
  • Frequency. How often will a shipment be sent? Do you have choices or is there only one option? Can you pay as you receive deliveries, or do you need to pre pay in full?
  • Flexibility. Are there different subscription types? Can you choose the to have several flavors delivered, specify the amount of product shipped, or other customizations?
  • Selection. What comes in each shipment? Is it the same cupcake each time or are you able to try other styles?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Cupcake Clubs available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right Cupcake Club membership to suit your needs!

The Best Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Clubs Compare Cupcake Club Reviews What are the best Cupcake Clubs Best Cupcake Club Reviews

Cupcake Club FAQ

Not from the stale selection at your local grocery store! Cupcake clubs specialize in sourcing tasty treats from artisan bakers around the nation, bringing you flavors you likely won't find anywhere else. How does Dark Chocolate Passion Fruit or Vanilla Pomegranate sound? Those are just two of the mouth-watering selections you might get when you sign up for a cupcake club.
Most clubs offer monthly deliveries. From there, you choose whether you want the membership to last anywhere from three months to a year. Some providers also let you specify if you'd like your cupcake club to come every other month or even once per quarter.
You'll pay between $7.50 to $56 per delivery, depending on the cupcake club provider you choose. On the lower end of the price range, you might get two cupcakes in each shipment, while the higher end comes with a dozen treats.
That depends on the cupcake club. Some include delivery costs in the monthly price, while others charge per delivery - as much as $15 each time! You'll definitely want to take that into account as you decide which plan is the best one for you.
Most specialty memberships - like cupcake clubs- gain a lot of business through word of mouth. That means they want you to be thrilled with all of the treats you get! If you get a delivery with cupcakes that didn't survive the trip or aren't 100% amazing for any other reason, you can almost always request a refund, credit, or reshipment if you reach out to customer service.
Definitely! Some cupcake clubs have been around for many years, going to great lengths to keep finding new bakeries and flavors to delight their loyal subscribers. As subscription clubs have grown in popularity, the choices have expanded too. It's never a bad idea to see what other customers have to say about a club before committing to a membership.
One of the most entertaining parts of a monthly cupcake club - besides the actual eating, of course! - is finding out more about where they came from. Most clubs include a fun newsletter that gives you more details about your cupcakes: which bakery made them, how the flavor choices were dreamed up, and maybe even recommended beverage pairings!
Who doesn't love a good cupcake? More often than not, cupcake clubs are purchased as a gift, offering tasty treats that keep the happy moments coming for months at a time. You can usually include an announcement or special message when purchasing the club for someone else.
The Best Reviews of Cupcake Clubs