Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Monday, October 2nd
Not Pie offers a classic cupcake subscription service for customers who value simplicity. The company was founded by an entrepreneurial couple, Joshua and Amanda, who were inspired to help people celebrate special occasions regardless of their location.
The cupcakes from Not Pie are baked in small batches with the finest ingredients and exotic flavors. Their cupcakes are renowned for their heavenly taste and signature marshmallow frosting, which is often dipped in ganache. Past cupcake flavors have included fresh apple with caramel, triple lemon with fresh strawberry mallow, and churro cinnamon topped with fresh banana mallow.
Get a half-dozen cupcakes every month
Slightly smaller than some of the cupcake clubs in our review, Not Pie's deliveries only come with six treats per delivery. They'll all be the same flavor, whatever is featured that month. But, this club is reasonably priced for the quantity: $33 if you just want to try it for a month, $95 for three months, $130 for a quarterly plan, $165 for six months, and $330 for a full year - and shipping is included at no extra cost.
Gluten-free and vegan cupcakes available
This is also one of the only cupcake clubs in our review that lets you opt into a gluten-free or vegan subscription (or even gluten-free AND vegan treats). It's priced the same as the standard cupcake membership, and the gluten-free baked goods are usually the same flavor and design.
Can accommodate delivery changes as needed
Another benefit of choosing Not Pie for your monthly goodies is that they can be flexible with delivery dates. Most clubs ship out their cupcakes at the same time of the month, from one month to the next, but what if you're trying to have your sweets on a special occasion? Or if you need to reschedule because you're going out of town? No worries: just shoot them an email and they'll be glad to make the arrangements. That probably goes for any months you might want to skip a flavor, if mocha isn't your thing or you"re allergic to pumpkin and see it's on the menu for an upcoming delivery.
Can be given as a gift subscription
If you're giving Not Pie's cupcake subscription box as a gift, it's no problem to include a personalized gift note. You'll find that tucked away in the checkout, in the "Shipping Information" box where it asks if there's a message you'd like to send.
Peek their social media to see what's new
While you might not find a ton of feedback for Not Pie in the usual places (like the BBB and Trustpilot), pop over to their Twitter and IG to take a peek at what's been baking there lately.
Excellent choice for cupcakes
We've bumped Not Pie way up in our rankings since our last review. We really love that they've expanded their selection to include our vegan and gluten-free friends who also want tasty treats, and that they're so willing to shift delivery timeframes to accommodate important holidays or special moments. While you'll need to choose a different cupcake club if you absolutely must have a dozen every month, there's no reason not to sign up for Not Pie if six is your perfect number and you like the idea of having their signature mallow topping on most of your cupcakes.
Cupcakes have been enjoyed as a sweet treat since the late 1700s, with today's flavors ranging from classic yellow cake with vanilla frosting to unique variations such as Maple Cinnamon and Lemon-Lime Vanilla Bean or elaborate, theme-focused creations. These individual-sized cakes are popular among people of all ages and are perfect for a variety of occasions, from baby showers to potluck picnics.
If you're looking for a way to indulge in the artistic creativity of baked goods on a regular basis, a cupcake club membership is an excellent option. With various plans to choose from, you or a loved one can receive several cupcakes in different flavors delivered straight to your door.
Whether you savor the delicate notes of a white chocolate raspberry cupcake, delight in the rich flavors of German chocolate, or want to explore unusual creations like tie-dye, there are many options to choose from. Some cupcake clubs even incorporate unique and fun twists, such as delivering bite-sized amounts of cupcakes or even cupcakes in a jar..
One of the main reasons why cupcake clubs have become so popular is convenience. You can enjoy freshly baked cupcakes without having to go out to a bakery or spend time baking them yourself. This is especially good for people with busy schedules who may not have the time or energy to bake their own cupcakes. Cupcake clubs can also be a great gift idea for friends and family members who live far away or who are difficult to shop for.
Another reason why people love cupcake clubs is the variety of flavors and styles of cupcakes that you can try. Each month, you can look forward to a new selection of cupcakes that are carefully curated by the cupcake club. These cupcakes may include traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla, as well as more unique and adventurous flavors like lavender and honey or raspberry cheesecake. This variety can be especially appealing for people who enjoy trying new foods and flavors.
Cupcake clubs also provide an opportunity for people to develop their taste preferences and discover new flavors and styles of cupcakes that they may not have tried before. For example, someone who typically prefers chocolate cupcakes may discover a new love for lemon or coconut cupcakes through their subscription. This can be a fun and exciting way to expand culinary horizons and try new things.
With consumers wanting choices and so many great options to choose from, it's not surprising that cupcake clubs have become more and more popular over the past few years. However, cupcake club features vary almost as much as the flavors themselves. You may want to think about whether the company includes shipping, how many cupcakes are delivered, and what perks are included in club plans. Additionally, you'll need to decide whether you are looking for a classic cupcake experience or a more whimsical treat. A few cupcake clubs also have menu options that meet the needs of gluten-free and vegan customers.
In general, when selecting the right Cupcake Club for you, there are several factors to consider:
If you're a self-proclaimed cupcake fanatic (no shame, we are too!), you need to join a cupcake club. To help, Top Consumer Reviews has done the hard work for you and ranked the best clubs available today. You can find the perfect cupcake club membership that fits your cravings and sweet tooth needs. So what are you waiting for? Let's get this cupcake party started!
Select any 2 Cupcake Clubs to compare them head to head