Wednesday, January 22nd
2025 Cupcake Club Reviews
Wicked Good Cupcakes
- Pricing from $69.99 to $175 per package
- Pay once for the whole subscription
- Surprise order each month
- 2-6 jarred cupcakes in each shipment
- Up to 6 flavors per shipment
- Refund or reship guarantee
- "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB
Wicked Good Cupcakes started out with a mom-and-daughter duo who featured their idea for shipping cupcakes worldwide on Shark Tank. By putting cupcakes in a jar complete with cake, buttercream frosting, toppings, and fillings, the ladies figured out how to keep their cupcakes fresh on their way to your door. Wicked Good Cupcakes joined the Hickory Farms family in 2021 to help send its gourmet cupcakes around the world and make it easier than ever to give sweet treats as a gift. Whether you want birthday cupcakes or something more unique (like cupcakes and wine) Wicked Good Cupcakes has a treat for everyone, including gluten-free options.
Pick how many cupcakes you want and go
Signing up for a Wicked Good Cupcakes cupcake subscription just takes a one-time payment and you're all set. Wicked Good Cupcakes offers 2-, 4-, and 6-pack shipments of cupcakes, so you can decide how many you want each month. Regardless of which pack you choose, you will have a 3-month commitment and no recurring costs (making this ideal for gifting). The flavors inside are a surprise each month, and offer a mix of Wicked Good Cupcakes top-performing flavors along with seasonal flavors.
Enjoy 25 rotating flavors
Wicked Good Cupcakes currently has 25 cupcake flavors on its menu, including a fun variety of seasonal favorites. Seasonal flavors are limited in time, so these will rotate out during the year. Some of the standout cupcakes we saw included:
- Chocolate Peppermint
- Gingerbread Eggnog
- Cookies and Cream
- Salted Caramel
- S'more
Alongside these, most of the popular flavors include a gluten-free version, so you won't feel left out of the fun if you have dietary restrictions.
Pricing from $69.99 to $175 per package
The pricing at Wicked Good Cupcakes is split out depending on how many jars you want in your shipments. Each subscription lasts for three months. Here's what we found:
- 2-pack: $69.99
- 4-pack: $130
- 6-pack: $175
There are no recurring payments, so once your three months run out, you'll need to buy another subscription if you want to keep enjoying cupcakes.
Refund or reship guaranteed
Wicked Good Cupcakes offers a guarantee that they stand behind their products and sweet treats 100%. This means that if you (or someone you gifted cupcakes to) aren't happy with your order, you can call the Wicked Good Cupcakes' customer service number or email them to talk about a replacement order or get a refund. Wicked Good Cupcakes says it's up to you to decide which one you prefer. They promise quick and courteous resolutions to your concerns.
Solid ratings and praise for the sweet flavors
As one of the few cupcake subscription clubs in our review that is rated by the Better Business Bureau, Wicked Good Cupcakes already stands out from the pack. With an "A+” rating and accreditation to boot, it's clear that Wicked Good Cupcakes is a subscription service you can trust. Reviews are a little more mixed on third-party websites like Trustpilot or blog reviews where the bakery earns 3.5 stars out of 5 on average, but most cupcake lovers who tried the jarred cupcakes said the flavors were great, especially if you have a sweet tooth.
Excellent gifting subscription
At Wicked Good Cupcakes, the prices aren't bad, the flavors are super sweet, and the team offers a guarantee to resolve problems where necessary (with a refund option). While the 3-month prepay is a little limited compared to some cupcake subscription clubs that offer up to a year of sweet treats, if you want to gift an assortment of cupcakes to a loved one, Wicked Good Cupcakes is ideal. For this reason, Wicked Good Cupcakes earns a solid rating in our review and we highly recommend you check out this Shark Tank specialty.
More Cupcake Club Reviews
The 5 Best Cupcake Clubs
Where Can You Find the Best Cupcake Subscription Clubs?
Watching the latest episode of Cupcake Wars and starting to feel left out of the fun? While you can get some tasty treats from your local grocery store or go out to a specialty bake shop to get your sugar fix, it's harder to get those really good cupcakes from the comfort of your home (we get it, baking it from a boxed mix just isn't the same).
Cupcake subscription clubs also make fantastic gifts for a sweet-lover in your life. Whether you're looking to give them cupcakes from boutique bakeries, award-winning cupcakeries, or a chance to try as many frostings as they can, this gift will be a winner.
Cupcake Club FAQ
Continued from above...
These subscription-based services send you regular shipments of cupcakes right to the comfort of your home. The number of cupcakes and frequency is totally up to you in most services. So whether you want a sampler with tons of flavors or a pack of favorites for an upcoming birthday bash, a cupcake subscription club is a great way to get more sweets into your life pronto. You don't need to worry about ordering every month: once you sign up, you just need to sit back, relax, and let the cupcakes come to you.
After all, sometimes, you don't have time to hunt down your local novelty bakery. Don't worry, you won't need to run out and buy piping bags and cupcake tins to have that hand-made quality cupcake you're craving - you can join a cupcake club instead.
Cupcakes come in as many varieties as cake (just smaller). Whether you're a frosting fiend or a red velvet superfan, there are tons of cupcakes to try. With increasingly exciting flavors and combos - we've seen those maple-bacon bourbon treats on baking competitions, yum! - you've got to try them all. From classic flavors like creamy chocolate, confetti, or just vanilla or the next great flavor like key lime, s'mores, or a rum-soaked Bahama Mama cupcake, there's a cupcake subscription club out there that can deliver.
If you're excited to have a batch of cupcakes ready to go every single month but aren't sure where to start, don't worry. We've checked out all the best cupcake subscription clubs to help you find the best way to narrow the field. Here are some factors to consider:
- Cost. Cupcake subscription boxes usually ship every month, and it's important to weigh the price against the number of cupcakes you'll receive or how unique and high-quality the flavors are. Some services also offer discounts for longer commitments, like quarterly or annual plans, so keep an eye out for those.
- Variety. Not all cupcakes are created equal. Choose a cupcake subscription club that offers plenty of variety in flavors and designs to keep things interesting. Look for options with a rotating menu or seasonal additions to make sure you're not stuck with repeat flavors if you don't want them. Plus, finding a bake shop with unique flavors (like whiskey soaked cake) can really expand your sweets palate during your cupcake journey.
- Reputation. Before subscribing to a cupcake club, take a minute to check out the reviews and ratings on trusted third-party review sites. Checking out feedback on places like Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau can show you honest feedback (not curated by a company) so you can judge the quality of the cupcakes and customer service based on foodies just like you.
If you're craving something sweet, now's the perfect time to dive into a fantastic cupcake subscription club. To help you spend more time enjoying your well-deserved tasty treats, Top Consumer Reviews has done the hard work for you by researching and ranking the best cupcake subscription clubs online today. It's time to treat yourself to your favorite flavors and discover some new ones along the way. Bon Appetit!
Compare Cupcake Clubs
Select any 2 Cupcake Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Cupcake Club News
Related Cupcake Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Cupcake Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
