Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Monday, February 10th
Established in 2005, Bake Me a Wish! set out to solve a problem in New York: finding a bakery that could ship out of state. The bakery got its start with cakes, and now it has expanded its offerings to include cupcakes, cookies, brownies, pies, and cheesecakes. Bake Me a Wish!'s goal is to be the top destination for giving bakery treats to your loved ones, and the bakery is popular on news stations and TV shows. You can find features for Bake Me a Wish! on Oprah Daily, Forbes, The Sun, Windy City Times, and more.
A great gifting site for cupcakes
Finding the cupcake selection at Bake Me a Wish! just takes one click on "Cupcakes" from the top navigation bar. Once you find the treats, it's a feast for your eyes. Each cupcake package is displayed with a range of beautiful photos that show tasty cupcakes with unique decorations. You'll be able to see the flavor names, prices, and the number of customer reviews for each listing (and the total star rating). All of the cupcakes at Bake Me a Wish! are sold in multipacks, so you can get a range of flavors in one shipment. Clicking on a specific cupcake package brings up additional details like a short description of the flavors and allergy information. You can select your delivery date, add a gift message, and upgrade your cupcake package with something special like an extra order of cookies, birthday candles, or a teddy bear plushie.
Choose from 13 multi-packs
There are 13 different packs of cupcakes to choose from at Bake Me a Wish! These include normal size, mini size, and jumbo size. Packs range from a 4pc up to a 12pc and you'll find flavors like Chocolate Lovers Cupcakes, Birthday Cupcakes, Fruity Cupcakes, and a range of gluten-free options in all flavors. For example in the Gourmet Cupcake Favorites (9pc) pack, you'll find the following flavors:
There are also some additional holiday flavors like Peppermint at Bake Me a Wish! too.
Pricing from $50 to $68 for cupcake packs
The prices at Bake Me a Wish! range from $50 to $68 depending on which pack you buy. The least costly cupcake pack is the Mini Birthday Cupcakes which includes 12 treats (3 Chocolate, 3 Vanilla, 3 Strawberry, and 3 Red Velvet). The most expensive is the Gourmet Cupcake Favorites (9pc), which include 9 totally different flavors. The gluten-free options are priced exactly the same as the regular, so you don't need to worry about any extra charges if you have special dietary needs.
Shipping is costly for cupcakes
One downside to ordering at Bake Me a Wish! is the relatively high shipping cost. For our location, shipping was priced at $22.99, though this can vary depending on where you live. You can't change the shipping option either. You can only see the shipping charges after entering all your checkout details, which can be a bit of a shock when you see the final price. For us, this made a $50 order $72.99.
On Time Guarantee plus refund options
Bake Me a Wish! offers an "On Time Guarantee” for its shipments. All cupcakes are shipped with UPS, and if your order doesn't arrive on the promised date, the shipping costs will be refunded to you completely. If you're not satisfied with your cupcakes once you receive them, Bake Me a Wish! promises to offer a partial or full refund, store credit, or even overnight replacement of your cupcakes.
Tasty flavors but missing the mark with shipping
Bake Me a Wish! has earned an "A-” rating from the Better Business Bureau and shows plenty of positive feedback on their own website. Each cupcake package has received thousands of high ratings, with most of them holding a 5-star average. However, feedback from third-party platforms is mixed. Trustpilot shows a 3.4-star average rating for Bake Me a Wish! Many customers report problems with delivery including that the promised fast shipping (and the On Time Guarantee) doesn't come through. There are also reports of missing packages. However, most customers also rave about the flavor of the cupcakes and the pretty designs.
Solid choice if you want to send a gift
Bake Me a Wish! offers fun flavors and is a favorite for sending cupcakes as gifts to your loved ones. However, there are a few downsides to keep in mind. If you're flexible with when you expect your delivery, you might be happy with Bake Me a Wish! However, if you're expecting a perfect shipping experience, you'll possibly be disappointed. Plus, there are some limits to the flavors that could leave you wanting more if you're after something truly unique. Overall, Bake Me a Wish! earns a solid rating for its quality baking and gifting abilities, but it could improve flavor variety and shipping to earn a higher score.
Whether you're thinking of throwing a birthday bash, looking for a way to make your wedding more unique, or looking for a sweet treat to satisfy you any time of the year, cupcakes are a great way to go. Cupcakes are the best of both worlds: all the care and love and sweetness of cake but in a personal-size commitment.
If you're looking for something that stands out from the pack (not your average grocery store cupcakes or something you have to make from a mix), your options used to be limited to local bakeries you could find in your area. Today, however, many modern bakeries offer delivery services online, so you can get cupcakes shipped from anywhere in the world right to your door.
The cupcake got its start in 1796 when Amelia Simmons put a "cake to bake in cups” in her cookbook, and according to research, cupcakes are among the top two favorite treats in the US (tied with cake). Unsurprisingly, Valentine's Day is one of the top holidays where cupcakes are a fan-favorite treat to give to your special someone. With the rise of options for dietary restrictions too (like a new trend of gluten-free cupcakes), cupcakes are still one of the most popular sweets to date.
Shipping cupcakes may sound difficult - trust us, we know the struggle of just trying to get cupcakes home from the grocery store without ruining the frosting - but these bakeries have it down to a science. Most bakeries that send cupcakes have special packaging, tried-and-true shipping methods, and expedited shipping times so that the cupcakes you order online are exactly what you see when they get to your door.
And there are tons of flavors to choose from. Whether you want a chocolate cupcake that beats your home-made box mix, a professionally made carrot cupcake with cream cheese frosting, or unique flavors like tiramisu or funfetti, these bakeries offer a smorgasbord of flavors and designs to choose from. So, if you want to try every flavor out there, or hunt down a family favorite, choosing a bakery that offers delivery services is one of the best ways to expand your cupcake palate.
If you're ready to turn your home into a sweet-lover's dream, but don't know which bakery to choose, we've got you covered. Here are some factors that can help you get the best cupcakes online:
To help you find the best service to satisfy your cupcake cravings, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cupcake delivery services out there today. So, what are you waiting for? From classic favorites to creative creamy frosting, you're sure to discover your next cupcake delight. Bon appetit!
Select any 2 Cupcake Delivery to compare them head to head