Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Monday, February 10th
Baked by Melissa is a bakery that first started as a home baking endeavor that turned into a business. This NYC-based bakery is focused on mini cupcakes. The owner, Melissa, is passionate about her family and has recently released a cookbook so you can explore baking her cupcakes at home if you're enthusiastic about home baking. Baked by Melissa works with the community and makes regular donations to improve the planet, so you can feel good about your carbon footprint while you snack. Baked by Melissa is partnered with Girls Inc., Every Mother Counts, Dress for Success, and other non-profits to give back as much as possible.
Fun and colorful browsing experience
Baked by Melissa has a clean browsing experience that makes it simple to find what you need. The entire site is based around cupcakes, and you can either browse by flavor or check out cupcakes by event (birthday, Christmas, Baby, Thinking of You, Wedding, and more). The listings are colorful and show pictures of the packs of mini-cupcakes. You can see the titles, number of cupcakes, price, and star ratings while browsing. When you click through to the individual packages, you'll be able to see the different assortments available, gifting extras, and a brief scrolling description of each assortment (and the included flavors). You'll also get details on shipping and instructions on how to serve your cupcakes.
16 different cupcake packages
There are 16 different packages of mini cupcakes at Baked by Melissa. Some of these are boxes for gifting, like the Birthday Gift Box or Christmas Gift Box. All of the boxes include 25-100 cupcakes, and some offer multiple flavor assortments to choose from. Some pre-made packages, like the Holiday Cheer assortment, include 7 Christmas Sugar Cookie, 6 Vanilla Fluff, 6 Snowcap, and 6 Brookie cupcakes. On the other hand, the "Sending Love” package lets you choose between 6 different flavor assortments including gluten-free or vegan cupcakes. There are a minimum of 12 flavors that change out around the year on Baked by Melissa. The one difference between Baked by Melissa and other bakeries is that these mini cupcakes are truly "mini”. You can expect to get about one bite per cupcake.
Pricing from $37 to $135 for cupcake packages
The cupcakes at Baked by Melissa range from $37 to $135, depending on how many cupcakes you want. Most of the basic packages (that aren't for specific events) are $37. For example, the Latest & Greatest Cupcakes (25pc) is one of the $37 options while the Birthday Gift Box (25pc) is $47. The most costly cupcake package is the Dessert Table Cupcakes (100pc) which is $135.
Shipping from $15.95 to $24.95
Standard shipping (2 days) from Baked by Melissa was $15.95 for our area, making Baked by Melissa a reasonable choice in terms of shipping costs. If you want expedited shipping (1 day) it costs $24.95. For more specific shipping dates (like a birthday), you can schedule shipping ahead of time to arrive for a gift or specific occasion. Shipping goes to all US states including Hawaii and Alaska.
Missing a refund policy entirely
There are no listed policies for refunds or reshipments at Baked by Melissa. The FAQ covers almost everything else, but there is no mention of recourse for problems with your order. We found that Baked by Melissa does consider all orders to be "final”, so it's on you to make sure your order is correct at the time you submit payment. If you make an error, they recommend reaching out with the live chat, but they do not guarantee any help or changes. However, we couldn't find the live chat on the website. At this time you need to either call or email Baked by Melissa.
Mixed reviews and concerns about customer service
While Baked by Melissa has solid reviews on its own website, we're a bit concerned about its reputation on third-party review sites. Baked by Melissa is doing okay on Tursptilot with a 3.6-star average, but there are only 9 total reviews to back up this rating. However, the most recent reviews all praise the flavor and the on-time delivery when they shopped through Baked by Melissa. On the other hand, customers also complained that the service team was terrible. On top of this, Baked by Melissa holds an "F” rating and a 1.5-star average with the Better Business Bureau.
Try if you love mini cupcakes
While these mini cupcakes are a great gift idea for any occasion, the poor reviews and total lack of a refund or reship policy raise some serious concerns about ordering from Baked by Melissa. If you're a fan of cupcake minis, the range of rotating flavors could be a great place to try some bit-size treats from a homestyle baker. However, with the concerns about the customer service and the "F” rating from the BBB, Baked by Melissa just misses the mark in our review.
Whether you're thinking of throwing a birthday bash, looking for a way to make your wedding more unique, or looking for a sweet treat to satisfy you any time of the year, cupcakes are a great way to go. Cupcakes are the best of both worlds: all the care and love and sweetness of cake but in a personal-size commitment.
If you're looking for something that stands out from the pack (not your average grocery store cupcakes or something you have to make from a mix), your options used to be limited to local bakeries you could find in your area. Today, however, many modern bakeries offer delivery services online, so you can get cupcakes shipped from anywhere in the world right to your door.
The cupcake got its start in 1796 when Amelia Simmons put a "cake to bake in cups” in her cookbook, and according to research, cupcakes are among the top two favorite treats in the US (tied with cake). Unsurprisingly, Valentine's Day is one of the top holidays where cupcakes are a fan-favorite treat to give to your special someone. With the rise of options for dietary restrictions too (like a new trend of gluten-free cupcakes), cupcakes are still one of the most popular sweets to date.
Shipping cupcakes may sound difficult - trust us, we know the struggle of just trying to get cupcakes home from the grocery store without ruining the frosting - but these bakeries have it down to a science. Most bakeries that send cupcakes have special packaging, tried-and-true shipping methods, and expedited shipping times so that the cupcakes you order online are exactly what you see when they get to your door.
And there are tons of flavors to choose from. Whether you want a chocolate cupcake that beats your home-made box mix, a professionally made carrot cupcake with cream cheese frosting, or unique flavors like tiramisu or funfetti, these bakeries offer a smorgasbord of flavors and designs to choose from. So, if you want to try every flavor out there, or hunt down a family favorite, choosing a bakery that offers delivery services is one of the best ways to expand your cupcake palate.
If you're ready to turn your home into a sweet-lover's dream, but don't know which bakery to choose, we've got you covered. Here are some factors that can help you get the best cupcakes online:
To help you find the best service to satisfy your cupcake cravings, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top cupcake delivery services out there today. So, what are you waiting for? From classic favorites to creative creamy frosting, you're sure to discover your next cupcake delight. Bon appetit!
Select any 2 Cupcake Delivery to compare them head to head