Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, February 16th
If you think you heard of Milk Bar on a Netflix documentary, you'd be right. Christina Tosi is the creator of this dessert shop, and she was featured on the series "Chef's Table”. She's all about capturing the home baking spirit and translating it into the goodies served up at her brick-and-mortar locations and through her online store. Milk Bar has been around since 2008 and the company delivers nationwide.
Decent selection, glitchy online store
There's a decent selection of desserts at Milk Bar, with a strong emphasis on cakes, cake truffles, pies, and cookies. There's even a whole section for gluten-free options. What's crazy, though, is that (at least during our most recent visit to the Milk Bar website) the link for cookies went absolutely nowhere. Given that cookies are the flagship product for this sweet shop, that really caught us off-guard (and not in a good way). Fortunately, we were still able to get to the cookie selection by clicking on the Desserts heading in the top navigation bar on the site, then clicking on Cookies in the dropdown menu.
Desserts mostly include cookies, cakes, and pies
Even so, you shouldn't expect a vast array of choices when buying desserts from Milk Bar. Here's how the inventory broke down at the time of our review:
Get savings if you place a larger order
You may want to fill up your cart with desserts, though, because that's how you can save at Milk Bar. First, as we browsed the site, we got a $15 off $80+ offer if we provided our email address. Then, we noticed that shipping is free on orders of $100+; otherwise, plan on spending $15 for standard and $30 to $65 for express delivery.
Too many disappointed customers
Then again, maybe you don't want to stock up on sweets at Milk Bar. Why? The Better Business Bureau gives the company an "F” rating. Even though that's only for failing to respond to a half-dozen complaints there, the reviews left on Google paint a not-so-terrific picture too. There, more than 30% of the 200+ ratings were just 1 or 2 stars. Calls to Milk Bar during normal business hours go unanswered - we also got voicemail on a typical weekday afternoon. Desserts don't arrive when expected, even when people paid for 2-day delivery. And, the nail in the coffin: when the treats come, the quality is frequently subpar, with many customers saying the desserts were crumbly when they should be moist, dried out, and generally overpriced for what they paid.
Nothing sweet to say about this dessert shop
So, let's recap. At Milk Bar, there are only around two dozen dessert options, some of which may be designated as "sold out” when you're ready to place your order. Shipping can be a bit spendy if you don't purchase at least $100 in treats, customers aren't overly thrilled with the desserts after delivery, and support from Milk Bar is hard to reach. It shouldn't come as a surprise that this sweet shop lands one of our lowest ratings.
The rise of online bakeries and dessert shops has made it easier than ever to access gourmet sweets from the comfort of your home. Craving macarons from a Parisian-style patisserie or a slice of authentic New York cheesecake? Ordering online means you can enjoy these treats without booking a flight.
This kind of dessert shopping takes the guesswork out of finding the perfect sweets for any occasion - whether it's a surprise birthday treat, a holiday celebration, or just an excuse to satisfy your sweet tooth. And let's not overlook the gift-giving convenience - these desserts usually arrive beautifully packaged, making them ideal gifts that show you care.
Desserts are the sweet exclamation point to any meal. From decadent cakes and flaky pastries to rich puddings and creamy gelato, desserts have been delighting palates across cultures for centuries. Fast forward to today, and the world of desserts has expanded in ways our ancestors could never have imagined.
Their origins are as varied as their flavors, with ancient civilizations crafting sweets from honey, fruits, and nuts, while later innovations brought us sugar-based confections and baked goods. Whether served at grand feasts or enjoyed quietly at home at the end of a long day, desserts are often synonymous with celebration, comfort, and creativity. In many cultures, sweets are intertwined with traditions, marking holidays, family gatherings, and even daily rituals with a touch of delicious indulgence.
If you're imagining something delicious coming right to your doorstep, where should you order that dreamy dessert? There are a lot of online shops to consider, and they're not all the same. Here are a few things to keep in mind that might influence which online dessert shop you choose:
There are so many great options out there for ordering dessert online, and the treat-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have reviewed and ranked some of today's most popular sweet shops. Use our research to choose the right dessert company, whether you're buying something special for yourself or ordering something to "wow” everyone at the company's holiday potluck (we won't tell anyone that you didn't make it, we promise). Just don't forget to save us a piece!
Select any 2 Dessert Delivery to compare them head to head