Where are the best diamond stores? Diamonds are some of the most beautiful items on earth. Whether it's from the highly volcanic journey with the pressure to create them, the effort gone into mining them, or the skill that goes into cutting them into gorgeous faceted designs, there's something about diamonds that sets them apart from other gemstones. Choosing a diamond can be something special.
Best Option
Read Full Review
Fascinating Diamonds has been offering custom jewelry since 2006, with an impressive selection of more than 440,000 diamonds in both natural and lab-grown varieties. This diamond store makes shopping easier with options like 360-degree diamond views, free returns within 30 days, and a lifetime warranty that covers cleaning, polishing, and more. With an "A+" BBB rating and a near-perfect 4.9 stars on Trustpilot, Fascinating Diamonds stands out for both quality and customer satisfaction, making it the most trusted choice for shoppers who want diamonds at fair prices.
Great
Read Full Review
Rare Carat is a standout diamond store with more than 443,000 natural and lab-grown diamonds, all ethically sourced and available in a wide range of shapes and sizes. The site makes shopping simple with 360-degree previews of the gems, fair price checks, and certification details shown right on each listing. While Rare Carat has a more limited warranty, its excellent return policy and near-perfect customer reviews make it one of the most trusted places to buy diamonds online.
Great
Read Full Review
Gems NY is an online jeweler that started in New York. The diamond store features 360-degree views, a lifetime warranty with free maintenance, and a trade-up program that gives strong value if you upgrade your piece. With an "A+" BBB rating, high customer satisfaction, and a reputation for authentic stones, Gems NY is a top choice for anyone who wants beautiful, responsibly sourced diamonds with flexible return and upgrade options.
Great
Read Full Review
25 Karats is a New York City jeweler that has been offering wedding rings and fine diamonds since 2008. The diamond store carries over 8,800 conflict-free diamonds in a wide variety of cuts, colors, and clarity levels, along with custom jewelry backed by a lifetime warranty. With strong customer reviews, a 60-day return policy, and an "A+" BBB rating, 25 Karats stands out as a trusted choice for engagement rings and other special pieces that spotlight diamonds.
Very Good
Read Full Review
Reeds is one of the largest jewelry retailers in the U.S., offering both lab-grown and natural diamonds along with fine jewelry from big names like Rolex and Pandora. The store carries over 200,000 diamonds with shapes ranging from round and oval to heart and marquise, plus tools like 360-degree views and a builder feature to help you preview stones in settings. While Reeds does not include a free warranty, customers praise it for quality designs, fast shipping, and prices that are often lower than other diamond stores, making it a strong choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Very Good
Read Full Review
Blue Nile has been a leader in online diamond shopping since 1999 and is well known for its luxurious branding. The diamond store carries over 145,000 diamonds in a wide range of shapes, sizes, and qualities, all of which can be previewed with 360-degree images so you can see every angle before you buy. With perks like a lifetime warranty, free cleaning, and a 30-day return policy that includes insured shipping, Blue Nile makes diamond shopping both convenient and reliable. Only its somewhat mixed customer feedback keeps it from ranking among our most recommended diamond stores.
Good
Read Full Review
James Allen is a well-known online jeweler that launched in 2006 and now offers over 316,000 loose diamonds along with a wide selection of engagement rings and fine jewelry. The diamond store website makes shopping easy with 360-degree views of each diamond, filters for shape, cut, clarity, and carat, and prices that include some budget-friendly options. James Allen also provides extras like a lifetime warranty, free resizing for a year, and 30-day returns, although its customer reviews are slightly mixed compared to some competitors.
Average
Read Full Review
Diamonds USA has been around since 1997 and is known for its large inventory of both lab-grown and earth-created diamonds, with over 156,000 stones to choose from in a variety of cuts and colors. Prices start as low as $33 and can go up to $500,000, making Diamonds USA one of the more budget-friendly diamond stores for shoppers who still want plenty of options. While the site could be easier to navigate and it lacks a lifetime warranty, it does offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, and many customers highlight how smooth and dependable the return process is. While we recommend that you look at Diamonds USA's higher-ranked rivals first, it's not a bad diamond store to keep in mind as a backup.
Average
Read Full Review
Shane Co is a family-owned jeweler that has been around since 1971 and offers both natural and lab-grown diamonds, along with engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. The selection is smaller than at some competing diamond stores, but the site makes up for it with helpful filters and 360-degree views. With a free lifetime warranty that covers cleanings, repairs, and even stone replacement, Shane Co gets props for its protection plans, though mixed customer reviews keep it from ranking among the top options.
Fair
Read Full Review
Ritani is an American diamond store that offers over 339,000 loose diamonds in natural and lab-grown varieties, with shapes ranging from round to heart. The site also makes shopping easy with clean browsing, tons of filters, and 360-degree views. While Ritani includes a lifetime warranty and 30-day returns, its recent customer reviews report concerns with shipping and quality, giving it a weaker reputation compared to other top jewelers. We recommend looking at the diamond stores that outrank Ritani first.
Subpar
Read Full Review
Jared is a well-known jeweler with over 3,000 store locations and an online shopping experience that features more than 220,000 diamonds, including both natural and lab-grown options. This diamond store stands out with plenty of preset diamond jewelry like necklaces, bracelets, and earrings available in addition to loose stones. While Jared holds an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, customer feedback on third-party sites is much lower, with many reviews mentioning quality issues and frustrations with repairs, leaving Jared with a below-average reputation overall.
Poor
Read Full Review
Kay is one of the most recognized diamond retailers, offering more than 227,000 diamonds that include both natural and lab-grown options, along with preset jewelry like rings, necklaces, and earrings. This diamond store's browsing experience includes filters and 360-degree previews to make browsing easy, although warranties are limited to gemstone coverage only. While Kay has a long history and a large inventory, customer reviews paint a negative picture, with many citing poor service and quality issues, which leaves Kay with a weak overall reputation.
Continued from above...
Diamonds are some of the most beautiful items on earth. Whether it's from the highly volcanic journey with the pressure to create them, the effort gone into mining them, or the skill that goes into cutting them into gorgeous faceted designs, there's something about diamonds that sets them apart from other gemstones. Choosing a diamond can be something special.
You might be looking for a gemstone to set into an engagement ring (congrats on popping the question), or maybe you're just looking for a piece that will stand out: a diamond necklace or a pair of earrings will turn heads like nothing else. No matter your need, finding a trustworthy store to get your diamonds or diamond jewelry is a must.
Selecting the right diamond store can be a lot like finding the right jewelry piece. You want to pick a store that's a perfect fit for you, specifically. Of course, you want a diamond store that has your back and delivers impressive inventory with top-tier customer service. Whether you're looking for a round, oval, cushion, emerald, or princess cut diamond, your chosen diamond store should have every glittering gemstone your heart desires.
The best part? Today's diamond stores allow you to shop totally online, which means you don't need to limit yourself to local diamond stores (though many still have local branches to browse or inspect items in person if you prefer). But overall, it's easier than ever to get diamonds or other fine jewelry from a diamond store right from the comfort of your home.
Online diamond shopping is so modern these days that you feel like you're almost in the store. Diamonds, rings, necklaces, and all sorts of other jewelry items are displayed in 3D and rotating images (sometimes even full videos) to show you every angle of the diamond you might want to buy. Plus, you'll get access to more exclusive stones since you'll be able to see the entire diamond store inventory rather than the pieces and loose stones that are on offer at a specific brick-and-mortar location. With other benefits like price match guarantees, wholesale prices, and lifetime guarantees, online diamond stores promise you the pinnacle experience for jewelry buying (so, you can make your special moments, gifts, and celebrations even better).
If you're searching for that perfect fit and need the top diamond store out there to meet your needs, we get it. When you're going for diamonds (no matter the karat or cut), you want the best service to match. To help you find the best fit, we've put together some factors to help you make your final decision:
Whether you're getting ready for the most important moment of your life (wedding bells, anyone?) or looking to celebrate an anniversary, or just buy something beautiful for someone you love, diamonds are still the best way to treat someone extra special. To help you pick the best place to score beautiful diamonds, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the best options for diamond stores on the market today. This way, you can focus on finding the perfect cut and setting, and celebrate the joy of a special sparkly with someone you love. Congrats!
Compare Any 2 Products
What are the benefits of buying loose diamonds?
When many people think about diamonds, buying diamond jewelry from a local store immediately comes to mind. However, buying loose diamonds is an option as well. At first glance, it may seem easier to simply walk into a jewelry store and buy a diamond ring or necklace, but the reality is that there are several exciting benefits associated with buying loose diamonds. In fact, with a closer look at the benefits of buying loose diamonds, you may decide that this is the best option for you. What can you expect when you buy loose diamonds?
Online Research
When people initially start shopping for a diamond, they focus on carat weight. While this is an important factor to consider, there are other factors that impact a diamond's true value. In addition to the carat weight, the stone's cut, clarity, and color play a role. These are referred to as the 4Cs of diamonds, and they are reviewed during the diamond certification process. One of the easiest ways to buy loose diamonds is online, and you can conveniently complete online research on all of these important factors before you make your purchase. Some diamonds used in preset jewelry are not certified, so you may not be able to determine the true value of that jewelry.
Not all loose diamonds are certified, but some sources exclusively sell certified diamonds. These are diamonds have been analyzed by a reputable lab, such as GIA, EGL, AGS or a few others. Through the certification process, a diamond's characteristics are mapped. This includes its flaws, dimensions and other key features. In fact, the certification process covers the 4Cs of diamonds. The lab certification report for a specific certified diamond is usually readily available for you to view online when you buy loose diamonds, and this makes it easy for you to understand fully what you are buying before you finalize your purchase. Many jewelry retailers, however, may not provide the certification documents to you unless you specifically request them.
Be aware, however, that you should not assume that the gemstone that you purchase online is the same diamond that you will receive in the mail. You should always obtain an appraisal from a certified professional as soon as you receive your loose diamonds. This holds true if you buy a diamond in a setting. The good news is that it is much easier for an appraiser to inspect and appraise loose diamonds versus those that are in a setting.
Comparison Shopping
Are you concerned about overpaying for diamonds or diamond jewelry? Because of the wealth of online information that is available on certified diamonds for sale, it is easy to comparison shop for the best value within your price range regardless of whether you buy a loose stone or a diamond in a setting.
However, when you purchase a diamond in a setting, there may be a question about how the setting's design and materials impact the total cost of the jewelry. When you purchase a loose diamond that is certified, on the other hand, you will know exactly how much that specific diamond is worth. This gives you some control over both value and cost. Whether you intend to hold loose gemstones or to place a diamond in a setting at a later date, the ability to easily comparison shop will help you to avoid overpaying.
A Financial Investment
The value of both loose diamonds and diamond jewelry will fluctuate over time, but you can expect them to share an upward trajectory over a long period of time. You may assume that loose diamonds will hold their value just as well as diamond jewelry would, but this is not always the case. In fact, loose diamonds generally hold their value better than diamonds that are set in earrings, necklaces, earrings and other settings. This is particularly true when you purchase certified loose diamonds.
Why is this the case? Some of the diamonds used in earrings, necklaces and other pieces have not been certified, so you cannot truly know the value of the gemstones when you buy these prepared pieces. This means that you also cannot truly determine the value of the jewelry, and you risk the possibility of paying more than the item is actually worth. When you buy a certified loose diamond, on the other hand, you will have a record of its value before it is placed in a setting. You will be less likely to overpay for that piece of jewelry, and the value of that jewelry will be partially secured by the diamond certification paperwork.
Keep in mind that many people purchase loose diamonds to hold securely for a period of time. For example, they may store diamonds in a bank's security deposit box or in a locked safe in their own home. The value of diamonds has maintained an upward path over the years, so this could be a smart way for an investor to diversify his or her portfolio.
Access to a Large Selection
Generally, when you shop for diamond jewelry at a local store, you are purchasing the stone and the setting together. You do not usually have the option to change out the diamond. However, the ability to select the specific diamond for your setting gives you greater control over the quality of the finished piece as well as its cost and value. More than that, with the ability to mix and match diamonds and settings, you have access to a greater overall range of possibilities.
Are you wondering how significant this benefit is? A single diamond wholesaler may offer hundreds or even thousands of certified loose diamonds at any given time. With multiple reputable wholesalers available for you to shop with, you will have a huge selection to choose from when you shop for loose diamonds. Some online wholesalers offer a convenient search function so that you can easily narrow down the options specifically to those that meet your requirements for cost and price.
Your Choice of Settings
While many people choose to keep loose diamonds as a financial investment, others shop for a loose diamond with a more specific purpose in mind. For example, you may want to select the exact diamond that will be placed in a custom-made engagement ring or necklace. When you buy a loose diamond for this purpose, the possibilities are endless. A private jeweler may have some predesigned settings for you to choose from, and your selection of a specific diamond for that setting ensures that the jewelry is tailored to your budget and expectations.
Another exciting option is to work with a private jeweler to create a one-of-a-kind piece. Everything from the jewelry's metal and size to its style will be created to your exact specifications. In comparison, if you choose to buy a diamond that is already in a setting, you are truly limited to the possibilities available from that store at the time of your visit.
Diamonds are often used in jewelry that has special meaning, such as a wedding ring, an engagement ring, an anniversary ring and more. These are important pieces that you understandably want to be perfect for the individual and for the occasion. With this in mind, the ability to choose both the loose diamond and the setting is a true benefit.
Get to Know the Possibilities Today
Before you settle for diamond jewelry purchased from a retail store, you owe it to yourself to explore the exciting possibilities available to you with the purchase of loose diamonds. With gemstones available at a wide range of prices and qualities, you could potentially find exactly what you are looking for when you shop for a loose diamond today.
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
