Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Only Natural Pet Review

Friday, December 9th

2022 Dog Food Store Reviews

Only Natural Pet Review 4.5 Star Rating

Only Natural Pet

4.5 Star Rating
  • Just over 1,000 options in dog food
  • Free shipping on orders of $49+
  • A+ rated and accredited by the BBB
  • No-hassle, complimentary rewards program
  • Autoship program available, save 35% on first delivery and up to 15% thereafter
  • 60-day return policy on both new and opened items; customer pays cost of return shipping

With a name like Only Natural Pet, you'd be right to expect all-natural dog food and treats when shopping at this online store. Headquartered in Colorado, the company maintains a strict promise to provide items for pets that even humans could put on or in their bodies. ONP maintains a lengthy list of unacceptable ingredients (like beef tallow and parabens) that you won't find in anything they sell.

Good prices on the brands they carry

You might not be surprised to hear that Only Natural Pet doesn't carry the Purina canned dog food we used as a comparison across retailers. They do offer Taste of the Wild kibble, and it was priced the same as pretty much everywhere else: $17.99 for the 5-lb size and $54.99 for the 28-lb bag. You'll also find other well-known brands to choose from, like Orijen and Stella & Chewy's, plus Only Natural Pet's proprietary brand.

Discounts abound

How about discounts? Like many online dog food stores, Only Natural Pet offers subscriptions to keep you stocked up automatically, with a 35% discount on the first order and up to 15% off on subsequent deliveries. When you sign up for the Only Natural Pet mailing list, you'll get a 25% discount on your first order as a new customer. Just be aware that there's a maximum value of $35 off when you use this discount.

Complimentary rewards program

You'll also see some savings through ONP's free rewards program. Earn 5% back on every purchase (even if you checkout as a guest instead of creating an account), then spend your accumulated credits every quarter (January, April, July and October).

Best Dog Food Stores

Refunds allowed for up to 60 days

This dog food store offers a return policy that's more customer-centric than many of its rivals. You can return anything you order within 60 days of delivery, for any reason. That's always a welcome perk when you're trying new brands of dog food and you're not sure your pooch is going to give it the A-OK. You'll get a full refund for what you paid for the product; on the other hand, you won't get your shipping charges back (if any), and you're responsible for paying the return delivery costs.

Fantastic reputation

Only Natural Pet is a dog food store you can trust. The Better Business Bureau gives them an "A+" and accreditation, and there were only seven complaints filed there in the three years prior to our evaluation. There's not as much shopper feedback to be found in other places, but you'll see ample reviews on individual products sold by ONP. For example, their brand of kibble in the Powerfood Poultry Feast variety had over 500 customer ratings and an average of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Check out the reviews at the bottom of any ONP product that interests you and see for yourself.

Not everything is in stock

The one slight downside to shopping here is availability: on several items we selected, there was an "out of stock" notice due to supply chain issues at the time of our most recent visit to the site. Helpfully, Only Natural Pet included a link to other recommended dog food items that were comparable and available for immediate purchase.

Excellent choice for healthy dog food

Only Natural Pet is a handy place to shop for dog food and other products that will support your dog's health and wellness. Pricing is competitive, the return policy is more generous than most, and the company has a good reputation with its customers. Shop here with confidence.

Where Can You Buy the Best Dog Food?

If your dogs are like ours, you probably spot a furry little face at your bedside right on cue every morning, telling you it's time for breakfast. You go to scoop out their meal and - oh no - you're almost out of kibble! You already know that "people food" is a bad choice, because it can upset their stomachs (and encourage them to beg at the table too). What if you don't have time to run to the store? Or your local pet supply store is out of your pet's preferred dog food?

Online ordering to the rescue. From familiar brands to specialty manufacturers, most types of dog food are easily ordered over the internet. Better yet, some stores have ways of getting it delivered right to your home within a day - or even a few hours. Also, if you've got options near you and just don't have the energy to run inside, lots of dog food stores let you order online for curbside pickup.

The Best Dog Food Stores Compare Dog Food Stores Compare Dog Food Store Reviews What are the best Dog Food Stores Best Dog Food Store Reviews

Dog Food Store FAQ

Like a normal person, dogs require a healthy balance of protein, fat, and carbohydrates in their diets. Carbohydrates, fats, and proteins provide your pooch the essential energy they need to do daily activities. Dogs rely on the protein in their diet to receive the 10 essential amino acids that they are unable to produce. Fats are the main source of fatty acids which provide not only an important part of the development of tissues, muscles, and nerves. Fatty acids allow your pets body to absorb fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, and K). Carbohydrates come in various forms and provide your pooch the energy it needs to do the normal daily activities. Along with a healthy diet, dogs need fresh water and regular exercise.
Dog food types vary greatly depending on the customer and pooches wants. There are vet authorized diets (prescription required), canned, dry, wet, specialized breed specific, premium, raw, human-grade, frozen, freeze-dried, dehydrated, and food toppings.
Very, most companies have dog food that can be refined to type of food, breed, age, vitamins, and allergies. You can get a brand that is breed and age specific for your puppy. Having an older dog means their dog food should have joint and muscle vitamins to provide support for an aging body. There are many options to choose from to keep your pooch happy and healthy.
Depending on the size of your pooch, your dog may need a new bag weekly or every 3 months. Some companies even offer a membership where you can sign up to receive deliveries (i.e., weekly, monthly, or quarterly) and even lower dog food prices. If you do not have a membership, delivery can fluctuate depending on the type of delivery options available and can range from 1 to 5 business days. To help with calculating how much you need, per every pound of dog food, there is 4 cups. So for a 5lb bag there is 20 cups and in a normal 20lb bag there is 80 cups.
Most dog foods will put grain free in the title or description of the dog food bag. If you are still hesitant make sure the dog food ingredients do not contain grains, which can be found in corn, soy, barley, rye, rice, or wheat. There are lots of grain free substitutes for your pooch such as tapioca, green peas, beans, legumes, sweet potatoes, and more.
Experts have recommended that it is best to transition slowly to the new pet food. When you first begin you should have the pet's food contain 25% of the new food and 75% of the old food. After a few days, without any stomach problems, you can start giving your pet 50% new and 50% old food ratios. Then for a few days use 75% new and 25% old food. After that you can fully transition over to the new food. This total process will take around 2 weeks.
Yes! Many companies have a 30-to-60-day return policy that allows the customer to return the unused food portions in the original bag with a guaranteed refund. Prescription food products require more of a process to return and in some cases, refund is not available. Be sure to read the small print if you are worried your furry friend might not like his or her new dinner.
Of course, if your pet decides they do not like the new food, or you receive a damaged bag, a refund is often allowed. Many companies offer excellent customer service through email, phone call, or on-site messaging. Be sure to read the policies of each company before placing your online order.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Want to take your life to the next level of convenience? Look for a dog food retailer that offers autoship on your purchases: you can set up your account to have your wet and dry dog food delivered automatically on your preferred schedule. You'll never run out of dog food again.

What if you're trying a new type of dog food and you're not sure your persnickety pooch will be a fan? The best dog food stores make it risk-free by allowing for returns, refunds and exchanges on packages you've opened already.

There are lots of stores where you can buy your pet's food, and it's not always necessary to get it from a specialty retailer. So, which one should you choose the next time those hungry eyes are looking at you from the side of the bed? Here are some things to look for when you're deciding where to shop:

  • Variety of options. The more brands, formulas and sizes a dog food store carries, the more likely it is to have the ones you want in stock.
  • Speed of delivery. How fast can you expect your dog food to arrive? Are there options for same- or next-day delivery if you need it?
  • Return/refund policy. Dogs can be picky. If your vet recommends trying something new and your dog says "absolutely not" when you put it in her bowl, will the retailer let you get a refund or an exchange?
  • Customer feedback. Are there reviews on the products you can use to help decide what to buy? What do shoppers say about how the company treated them when there was a problem with an order? Have there been any complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau?

TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the best online retailers of dog food on the market today. We're confident that this information will help you find the right store to get all of your kibble and cans delivered to your doorstep. Your dog will thank you!

The Best Reviews of Dog Food Stores