Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Only Natural Pet Review

Sunday, November 3rd

2024 Dog Food Store Reviews

Only Natural Pet Review 3.5 Star Rating

Only Natural Pet

3.5 Star Rating
  • Specializes in organic dog food
  • Free shipping on orders of $49+
  • Discounts when you sign up for Auto Delivery
  • 60-day return policy (but you pay for the shipping)
  • "A+” rated and accredited by the BBB
  • Certified B-Corporation
  • In business since 2002

Only Natural Pets is on a mission "to create happy pets and happy people”. Since 2002, this Boulder-based company has served over a million pets and their people companions, focusing on products that are good for the planet too. Everything you'll find in their inventory has been approved by a holistic veterinarian and is made with 100% responsibly-sourced ingredients. Plus, as a Certified B-Corporation, ONP has demonstrated its commitment to upholding the highest standards of transparency, accountability, and social/environmental performance.

Unique dehydrated and freeze-dried dog food options

Only Natural Pet makes its own freshly-prepared, nutrient-dense and balanced dog food. You'll find the usual dry kibble and wet canned options, but what they carry that you might not have seen before are their air-dried, dehydrated raw, and freeze-dried raw food options. The dehydrated option in particular is a great space-saver: a two-pound bag yields eight pounds of food when rehydrated. You simply add warm water and your doggo's dinner is good to go. But, don't expect this to be a money-saver: in order to make 28 pounds of food (the biggest comparable bag of kibble), you'll be spending $76.49 for a seven-pound bag of dehydrated food. That's about $20 more than you'd spend on a rival brand of all-natural dog food, for reference.

Discounts when you auto-ship

However, if you sign up for Auto Delivery, you'll get a discount of 35% on your first shipment, and subsequent deliveries will be at a 10% savings. That applies to any dog food you might buy from Only Natural Pet, not just their own brand. And, as long as your order totals at least $49, you'll get free shipping.

Test case: limited selection for Taste of the Wild

While ONP's proprietary brand is center stage here (go figure...), you can still find some well-vetted brands known for offering high-quality dog food. That includes one we used as a test case across all of the stores we evaluated, Taste of the Wild. However, the selection was much smaller than we found on most rivals' sites: the only grain-free variety was the Wetlands flavor, and it was only available in the 5 lb. size. If we were shopping for our dogs' usual 28 lb. bag, we'd be out of luck with Only Natural Pet. But, other brands you can find in the dog food section of this store include Open Farm, Stella & Chewy's, The Honest Kitchen, Nature's Logic, Fromm, and Tripett, to name a few.

Best Dog Food Stores

Generous 60-day refund policy

How about returns? It can be tricky trying out new brands (or new formats, like dehydrated) on our furry friends, so a good return policy is always welcome - and Only Natural Pet's is pretty solid. You've got 60 days to return any product for any reason, including picky palates. But, the one catch is that you're responsible for the return shipping. You can reach out via email or toll-free number to request your refund and make arrangements to send the dog food back.

Mixed feedback but the food is usually well-liked

Only Natural Pet has the Better Business Bureau's highest rating ("A+”) and accreditation, with just six complaints filed in the last three years. The retailer itself doesn't have a lot of feedback, and what's out there is relatively mixed: on Trustpilot and Sitejabber, for instance, there are only a couple dozen reviews, and they don't average over 2 stars. Ouch. On the other hand, when you look at individual products, from dog food to supplements, you'll often find hundreds of 4- and 5-star ratings. And, when we looked at Only Natural Pet's reputation with some of the third-party retailers that also carry its products, the positive vibes were the same: dog owners tend to think pretty highly of this brand.

Better than average

Still, that mixed feedback for Only Natural Pet itself is enough to drop it in our rankings a bit. We still think this is a great place to get dog food that lives up to a higher standard, but it's going to miss the mark for lots of people searching for their tried-and-true, not-organic big brand. That plus the fact that some customers feel iffy about the company itself are the reasons why Only Natural Pet scored a lower rating from us: still above average, but not in our top tier.

Which Dog Food Store is the Best?

If you've ever seen your dog excitedly wagging his tail at mealtime, you know how much he depends on you to keep his bowl full. But what happens when you open the pantry and realize you're out of his favorite food? While a quick trip to the store might seem like an easy fix, what if you're short on time or the local pet shop doesn't carry the specific brand or formula your pet needs? That's where the oh-so-amazing convenience of buying dog food online comes in.

Shopping for dog food online has transformed the way pet owners meet their furry friends' nutritional needs. Whether you have a picky eater who prefers a gourmet recipe or a dog with special dietary restrictions, you'll find that online stores typically offer a wider variety than the grocery store (or even compared with your local mom-and-pop pet store).

The Best Dog Food Stores Compare Dog Food Stores Compare Dog Food Store Reviews What are the best Dog Food Stores Best Dog Food Store Reviews

Dog Food Store FAQ

Like a normal person, dogs require a healthy balance of protein, fat, and carbohydrates in their diets. Carbohydrates, fats, and proteins provide your pooch the essential energy they need to do daily activities. Dogs rely on the protein in their diet to receive the 10 essential amino acids that they are unable to produce. Fats are the main source of fatty acids which provide not only an important part of the development of tissues, muscles, and nerves. Fatty acids allow your pets body to absorb fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, and K). Carbohydrates come in various forms and provide your pooch the energy it needs to do the normal daily activities. Along with a healthy diet, dogs need fresh water and regular exercise.
Dog food types vary greatly depending on the customer and pooches wants. There are vet authorized diets (prescription required), canned, dry, wet, specialized breed specific, premium, raw, human-grade, frozen, freeze-dried, dehydrated, and food toppings.
Very, most companies have dog food that can be refined to type of food, breed, age, vitamins, and allergies. You can get a brand that is breed and age specific for your puppy. Having an older dog means their dog food should have joint and muscle vitamins to provide support for an aging body. There are many options to choose from to keep your pooch happy and healthy.
Depending on the size of your pooch, your dog may need a new bag weekly or every 3 months. Some companies even offer a membership where you can sign up to receive deliveries (i.e., weekly, monthly, or quarterly) and even lower dog food prices. If you do not have a membership, delivery can fluctuate depending on the type of delivery options available and can range from 1 to 5 business days. To help with calculating how much you need, per every pound of dog food, there is 4 cups. So for a 5lb bag there is 20 cups and in a normal 20lb bag there is 80 cups.
Most dog foods will put grain free in the title or description of the dog food bag. If you are still hesitant make sure the dog food ingredients do not contain grains, which can be found in corn, soy, barley, rye, rice, or wheat. There are lots of grain free substitutes for your pooch such as tapioca, green peas, beans, legumes, sweet potatoes, and more.
Experts have recommended that it is best to transition slowly to the new pet food. When you first begin you should have the pet's food contain 25% of the new food and 75% of the old food. After a few days, without any stomach problems, you can start giving your pet 50% new and 50% old food ratios. Then for a few days use 75% new and 25% old food. After that you can fully transition over to the new food. This total process will take around 2 weeks.
Yes! Many companies have a 30-to-60-day return policy that allows the customer to return the unused food portions in the original bag with a guaranteed refund. Prescription food products require more of a process to return and in some cases, refund is not available. Be sure to read the small print if you are worried your furry friend might not like his or her new dinner.
Of course, if your pet decides they do not like the new food, or you receive a damaged bag, a refund is often allowed. Many companies offer excellent customer service through email, phone call, or on-site messaging. Be sure to read the policies of each company before placing your online order.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

From organic, grain-free, or limited ingredient options to tried-and-true mainstream brands, the selection available online can meet every imaginable dietary need and picky pet preference. Plus, if you're ready to branch out and try something new for your favorite four-legged friend, you can take your time to compare brands, read ingredient lists, and even explore customer reviews, all from the comfort of your home.

Perhaps one of the biggest perks of ordering dog food online is the ability to schedule deliveries. Many retailers offer subscription services - your dog food arrives right when you need it, without you having to remember to place an order. This autoship option is perfect if you love the idea of having one less thing to worry about. Not only do you get to avoid last-minute trips to the store, but you may also benefit from discounts and free shipping, which can save you money in the long run.

There's just no beating the convenience of online dog food retailers. You can shop at any time of day, no matter your schedule. Whether you realize late at night that you're running low on food or you're too busy to squeeze in a trip to the pet store during the day, online ordering is always an option. And if you need your dog's food fast, many sites offer same-day or next-day delivery services - so that Rover never has to miss a meal (though he may be disappointed not to get that can of tuna or other "people food” when you don't have his kibble on hand).

Is your dog a little particular? Several online retailers offer flexible return policies, allowing you to exchange or return a product if it doesn't pass the sniff test. Some even provide trial sizes so you can test out a new formula before committing to a full-size bag or case of cans. This kind of hassle-free shopping experience can be a lifesaver when you're trying to find the perfect food for your pet's unique tastes or dietary needs.

You've got a lot of options for where to buy your dog food online. Which store should get your dollars? Use these criteria to pick the right one for you:

  • Selection. First and foremost, does the dog food store carry the brand your pup loves? Do they have his preferred kibble flavor, maybe in multiple sizes, plus some other flavors within the same brand if you need to branch out? Can you get both wet and dry food, just in case you need to switch it up?
  • Price. In today's economy, we're all looking for ways to save on the products we buy regularly, and dog food is no different. Will you save money if you buy your dog food at the store you're considering? Factor in any shipping costs, frequent buyer discounts, and any other perks that might make it a better deal than taking a trip to the pet food store near you.
  • Perks. Some dog food stores go the extra mile to earn your loyalty. Are there any benefits that might sweeten the deal, like free consultations with a veterinarian or rewards programs?
  • Reviews and reputation. Look at reviews on the dog food itself, as well as those left by the store's customers overall. Does the store offer brands and flavors that are generally well-liked by pets? Is the customer service team helpful when something doesn't go according to plan, from late deliveries to food that gets rejected by a picky pet's palate?

To help you find the right dog food store for your furry best friend, the canine-loving experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular options. So, the next time your dog looks at you with those eager, hungry eyes, you can rest easy knowing that a quick click online will have his bowl filled in no time.

The Best Reviews of Dog Food Stores