Who's better?

Doggy Day Box vs BarkBox

We've analyzed the best Dog Treat Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Dog Treat Club Reviews

Here you can see how Doggy Day Box and BarkBox match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Dog Treat Clubs in 2026.

Winner

Doggy Day Box

  • Monthly box of single-ingredient, all-natural treats
  • Sample selection from a recent delivery included 15 duck feet, 2 beef trachea, 5 yak waffles, 1 cow nose, 1 pig ear, 5 beef liver cookies, and 5 beef trachea cookies
  • Variety changes each month, sometimes with even more unique items like turkey heads or octopus tentacles

Doggy Day Box is a small-business subscription created by a dog mom who wanted only natural, single-ingredient treats for her four pups. Each month of the standard, "surprise" club brings a fresh variety of goodies - adventurous ones like pig ears or cow noses - that keep your dog excited and occupied. You can also subscribe to focused boxes like all beef, all duck, or even a "mini" box for smaller pups. Pricing on most club options is simple at $30/month plus $8.50 shipping, with no long-term contracts. Customers rave about the quality, variety, and customer service, though squeamish pet parents may not love the "body parts" approach of this dog treat club. With an excellent score, Doggy Day Box is a fantastic choice for dogs that thrive on natural treats.

BarkBox

  • Two toys and two bags of treats plus a chew each month
  • Monthly themes like Barkbuster Movie Night, Bark 2 School, and Howl-o-Ween
  • Customizations welcome

BarkBox is a fun, affordable subscription that sends your pup two toys, two bags of treats, and a chew each month, all wrapped up in a playful theme. You'll love the creativity, while your dog just enjoys the squeaks and snacks. Pricing starts at just $29/month, with free shipping on all plans. BarkBox is highly customizable, whether you need tougher toys or treat substitutions for allergy reasons. While some customers haven't loved the company's packaging switch from boxes to bags, the goodies inside haven't changed - and Bark's Happy Team is known for making things right fast. With thousands of positive reviews and a real commitment to supporting shelters, BarkBox is still a top pick for dog lovers looking for a treat club.

If you're like millions of Americans, your dog isn't just a pet - they're family. With nearly 90 million U.S. households sharing life with at least one dog, it's no surprise many owners admit they sometimes spend more on their pups than on themselves. That kind of devotion turns treat time into a daily ritual, whether you're celebrating good behavior, slipping in a quick training session, or just chasing that joyful tail wag - and the right treats make all the difference. With more nutritious options and creative flavors on the shelves, it's easier than ever to give your best friend something you both feel good about.

If you want to keep the treat jar stocked without the hassle, dog treat subscription clubs make it easy and fun. Whether your pup needs organic or grain-free options for a sensitive stomach or you just want to explore new flavors - peanut butter, pumpkin, even salmon - there's a box for that. Many plans also tuck in durable toys, long-lasting chews, and timely seasonal extras, so every delivery feels like a mini celebration. You'll skip those last-minute pet store runs, since curated goodies show up right at your door. Better yet, many services let you tailor the box to your dog's size and preferences so nothing goes to waste.

Dog treat clubs make an unexpectedly perfect gift. For the friend who seems to have everything, monthly surprises for their pup feel fresh and fun. Since the way to many dog lovers' hearts is through their four-legged best friend, a subscription packed with tasty snacks and playful toys becomes a present that keeps on giving - and it lands on their doorstep again and again to spread the joy. Plus, many clubs let you tailor boxes to the dog's size or dietary needs, so it feels personal. Each delivery is practically guaranteed - sometimes literally - to spark smiles, tail wags, and the occasional happy bark.

Of course, not every dog treat club is created equal, and it helps to know what to look for before you subscribe. Here are a few things you'll want to consider:

At Top Consumer Reviews, we've taken a close look at today's most popular dog treat clubs to help you find the perfect option for your four-legged best friend. Whether your pup loves crunchy biscuits, chewy sticks, or surprise toys, you'll discover the clubs that deliver both value and joy - straight to your doorstep.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Dog Treat Club FAQ

Where do the dog treats come from?
Dog treats are manufactured globally but mainly in the U.S. and Canada. If this is an important detail for you, be sure to investigate the company before making a purchase.
Are there allergy free treats?
When looking for a dog treat subscription, we recommend using companies that offer customizable treat plans that allow you to list any pet allergies. Some customizations allow the customer to create dog treat plan that is not only free of allergies but matches diet preferences as well.
What if my dog doesn't like the treats?
Unfortunately, due to the treats being a perishable item, most companies do not accept returns. Refunds are normally available only if the item has been damaged or billed correctly. If you have a finicky eater, consider a one-time purchase before committing to a regular shipment.
What is the cost?
Treat memberships all vary depending on company and the type of subscription. Membership costs can range from $15 to $35.99 per month. Several companies offer a one-time cost, no subscription needed, package to try out the treat club before committing to a membership.
How long do the memberships last?
The duration of dog treat memberships can vary depending on the company. You'll find 1 time, seasonal, quarterly, every 6 months, or every year deliveries. Many companies offer flexible options to meet the needs of their customers.
How often does the treat club deliver?
Depending on the plan selected, Fido can anticipate fresh treats every month, quarterly, semi-annually or annually. Treats are typically sent through standard delivery services.
How wide of variety are the dog treats in each subscription?
The amount of variety differs with each company. Some companies offer treat plans with 3-4 items or an upgraded version including 5-8 items. Variety in each box can range from toys, treats, grooming accessories, and more depending on the subscription.
Are there breed and/or age specific treat subscriptions?
Companies that offer customizable treat plans allow your pets information (including age and/or breed) to create a perfect treat subscription box. Please keep in mind some companies may have only allergy free, or size only, treats but not age specific.

Compare Any 2 Products

Amazing Clubs
Doggy Day Box
BarkBox
Super Chewer
Pet Treater
PupBox
Pooch Perks
Bullymake
PupJoy
BoxDog
vs
Amazing Clubs vs Doggy Day BoxAmazing Clubs vs BarkBoxAmazing Clubs vs Super ChewerAmazing Clubs vs Pet TreaterAmazing Clubs vs PupBoxAmazing Clubs vs Pooch PerksAmazing Clubs vs BullymakeAmazing Clubs vs PupJoyAmazing Clubs vs BoxDogDoggy Day Box vs BarkBoxDoggy Day Box vs Super ChewerDoggy Day Box vs Pet TreaterDoggy Day Box vs PupBoxDoggy Day Box vs Pooch PerksDoggy Day Box vs BullymakeDoggy Day Box vs PupJoyDoggy Day Box vs BoxDogBarkBox vs Super ChewerBarkBox vs Pet TreaterBarkBox vs PupBoxBarkBox vs Pooch PerksBarkBox vs BullymakeBarkBox vs PupJoyBarkBox vs BoxDogSuper Chewer vs Pet TreaterSuper Chewer vs PupBoxSuper Chewer vs Pooch PerksSuper Chewer vs BullymakeSuper Chewer vs PupJoySuper Chewer vs BoxDogPet Treater vs PupBoxPet Treater vs Pooch PerksPet Treater vs BullymakePet Treater vs PupJoyPet Treater vs BoxDogPupBox vs Pooch PerksPupBox vs BullymakePupBox vs PupJoyPupBox vs BoxDogPooch Perks vs BullymakePooch Perks vs PupJoyPooch Perks vs BoxDogBullymake vs PupJoyBullymake vs BoxDogPupJoy vs BoxDog BoxDog vs PupJoyBoxDog vs BullymakeBoxDog vs Pooch PerksBoxDog vs PupBoxBoxDog vs Pet TreaterBoxDog vs Super ChewerBoxDog vs BarkBoxBoxDog vs Doggy Day BoxBoxDog vs Amazing ClubsPupJoy vs BullymakePupJoy vs Pooch PerksPupJoy vs PupBoxPupJoy vs Pet TreaterPupJoy vs Super ChewerPupJoy vs BarkBoxPupJoy vs Doggy Day BoxPupJoy vs Amazing ClubsBullymake vs Pooch PerksBullymake vs PupBoxBullymake vs Pet TreaterBullymake vs Super ChewerBullymake vs BarkBoxBullymake vs Doggy Day BoxBullymake vs Amazing ClubsPooch Perks vs PupBoxPooch Perks vs Pet TreaterPooch Perks vs Super ChewerPooch Perks vs BarkBoxPooch Perks vs Doggy Day BoxPooch Perks vs Amazing ClubsPupBox vs Pet TreaterPupBox vs Super ChewerPupBox vs BarkBoxPupBox vs Doggy Day BoxPupBox vs Amazing ClubsPet Treater vs Super ChewerPet Treater vs BarkBoxPet Treater vs Doggy Day BoxPet Treater vs Amazing ClubsSuper Chewer vs BarkBoxSuper Chewer vs Doggy Day BoxSuper Chewer vs Amazing ClubsBarkBox vs Doggy Day BoxBarkBox vs Amazing ClubsDoggy Day Box vs Amazing Clubs
See the Best Dog Treat Clubs in Your State

Types of Dog Treats

Every dog owner wants to spoil their little cutie, but have you ever stopped to wonder what it is you're actually giving them? The pet treat industry is surprisingly a lot more interesting than what it may sound like. The majority of pet owners spend $20 or less on treats for their pets; 28% of cat owners and 15% of dog owners spend $5 or less on treats. In this article we will explore the different types of treats and why some are priced higher than others, including how they may effect your pets health.

The whole pet treat industry is full of secrets to learn. While you love your pet, you don't want to pay for something upmarked up to 5 times what it should be priced, only for your dog to get nothing out of it. Look at the ingredients when you buy something for your dog to ingest, and be aware that the goal of the pet treat companies is to make money, not to take care of your dog, that's up to you! Your dog will love you for giving them something they feel better eating, and you'll feel better taking care of your little cutie!

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

We've Officially Determined the Best Dog Subscription Box

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links." Sick of making constant trips to the pet store to replenish your pup's ever-dwindling pile of toys, ...

Mon, 08 Apr 2024

Only the Best Reviews

Business Wire

Best Dog Subscription Box (2024) Reviewed by Compare Before Buying

BOSTON--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Compare Before Buying, a leading online resource for product reviews, has recently released an insightful review of the best dog subscription box for 2024. This comprehensive ...

Fri, 05 Apr 2024

Only the Best Reviews

Business Insider

The 6 best dog subscription boxes for toys and treats, tested and ...

A check mark. It indicates that the relevant content has been reviewed and verified by an expert Our stories are reviewed by medical professionals to ensure you get the most accurate and useful ...

Thu, 16 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Rolling Stone

From Tug Toys to Tasty Treats, Our Dog Tested BarkBox for a Week — ...

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, Rolling Stone may receive an affiliate commission. “George, want to play?” After a long day of casual walks, ...

Thu, 25 Jul 2024

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.