Pet Treater vs Doggy Day Box for April 2025

Item: Pet Treater vs Doggy Day Box
Rating: 5
Author: Top Consumer Reviews

Friday, April 18th

2025 Dog Treat Club Reviews

Pet Treater

Mostly USA- and Canada-made treats (never China)
$15/month for 3-4 treats-and toys
$18/month for only treats or only toys
$25/month for 5-8 treats-and-toys
Items tailored to your dog's size
Free shipping
Donates to shelter pets with every order

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

If you want to spoil your dog without breaking the bank, consider Pet Treater's dog treat club. They promise great value and offer affordable monthly plans, starting at $15, that include a mix of treats and toys tailored to your dog's size. Shipping is free, your initial box is a curated collection for first-timers, and then subsequent deliveries follow a pre-set calendar. Customer reviews are positive (including fun unboxing videos), and Pet Treater supports animal shelters with each shipment. With personalized options, incredible affordability, and a commitment to helping shelter pets, Pet Treater is our #1 choice among dog treat clubs.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Doggy Day Box

All-natural treats like beef liver cookies, pig ears, sweet potato chips
Try a one-off box for $11 to $40
Subscribe for $30/month
Free shipping on all subscriptions
Satisfaction guaranteed

If you've been searching for all-natural treats that align with your dog's raw and natural diet, Doggy Day Box is a fantastic choice. This dog treat club offers a variety of treats made without additives, with an array of options like beef liver cookies, pig ears, sweet potato chips, and more. You can try a single box ranging from $11 to $40 or subscribe for $30 per month with the benefit of free shipping. With rave reviews and satisfied customers praising the exceptional variety and responsive customer service, Doggy Day Box is an affordable and trusted dog treat club that'll delight your furry best friend.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Read Full Review

Visit Club

The 10 Best Dog Treat Clubs

Pet Treater

Amazing Clubs

Doggy Day Box

Barkbox

Super Chewer

PupJoy

Pooch Perks

PupBox

Boxdog

Bullymake

Which Dog Treat Clubs Are the Best?

Have you ever wondered where to discover the most paw-some Dog Treat Clubs? Well, you're in for a tail-wagging treat because we're about to embark on a quest to find the perfect subscription service for your four-legged bestie. After all, why should humans have all the fun with monthly surprises when our furry friends can join the excitement too?

Picture this: a box arrives at your doorstep every month, filled with goodies that'll make your pup do the happy dance. What's inside, you ask? Treats and sometimes toys! The best part? You can customize each delivery to suit your dog's size, taste buds, allergies, and chewing habits.

Continue reading below

Dog Treat Club FAQ

Where do the dog treats come from?

Dog treats are manufactured globally but mainly in the U.S. and Canada. If this is an important detail for you, be sure to investigate the company before making a purchase.

Are there allergy free treats?

When looking for a dog treat subscription, we recommend using companies that offer customizable treat plans that allow you to list any pet allergies. Some customizations allow the customer to create dog treat plan that is not only free of allergies but matches diet preferences as well.

What if my dog doesn't like the treats?

Unfortunately, due to the treats being a perishable item, most companies do not accept returns. Refunds are normally available only if the item has been damaged or billed correctly. If you have a finicky eater, consider a one-time purchase before committing to a regular shipment.

What is the cost?

Treat memberships all vary depending on company and the type of subscription. Membership costs can range from $15 to $35.99 per month. Several companies offer a one-time cost, no subscription needed, package to try out the treat club before committing to a membership.

How long do the memberships last?

The duration of dog treat memberships can vary depending on the company. You'll find 1 time, seasonal, quarterly, every 6 months, or every year deliveries. Many companies offer flexible options to meet the needs of their customers.

How often does the treat club deliver?

Depending on the plan selected, Fido can anticipate fresh treats every month, quarterly, semi-annually or annually. Treats are typically sent through standard delivery services.

How wide of variety are the dog treats in each subscription?

The amount of variety differs with each company. Some companies offer treat plans with 3-4 items or an upgraded version including 5-8 items. Variety in each box can range from toys, treats, grooming accessories, and more depending on the subscription.

Are there breed and/or age specific treat subscriptions?

Companies that offer customizable treat plans allow your pets information (including age and/or breed) to create a perfect treat subscription box. Please keep in mind some companies may have only allergy free, or size only, treats but not age specific.

Continued from above...

No more trying to fit a Great Dane-sized bone into a Chihuahua's mouth. And if you've got a furry friend who can demolish a plush toy faster than you can say "fetch," fear not. Some Dog Treat Clubs offer specially-selected packages designed to outsmart even the most determined chewers in the pack.

Dog Treat Clubs aren't just a way to pamper your own pooch. They make the perfect gift for that person on your list who already seems to have it all. Forget the snoozy gift cards and fruit baskets. Imagine the joy on their face when they open a box full of fresh chews and tug toys for their furbaby.

With so many options out there, it's easy to feel a bit overwhelmed. Lucky for you, we've got some tips to help you find the perfect club for your pampered pooch or for your friend's furry sidekick:

Box contents. Naturally, you want to check out what's inside. Is it all treats, treats and toys, or some other combination? Pay close attention if you have a pup with allergies to certain ingredients (you need a subscription that's grain-free).
Value. What will you get for the monthly cost? Are the treats (and convenience) worth the price, or could you snag them just as easily at a local store for less money?
Flexibility. Can you choose different payment and delivery schedules? What if you need to skip a month or switch up the sizes of the treats and toys for your pups?
Customer satisfaction. What do other subscribers say about their experience? Does the company go the extra mile to keep their customers happy? Can you get a refund if your deliveries don't wind up feeling like much of a treat after all?

Ready to pick the perfect Dog Treat Club? The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have checked out and ranked the best ones around. So go ahead, treat your four-legged friend to months of tail-wagging joy!