Which dog treat club is the best? If you're like millions of Americans, your dog isn't just a pet-they're family. In fact, surveys show that nearly 90 million households in the US own at least one dog, and most owners say they spend more on their pup than they do on themselves sometimes. It's no wonder, then, that treat time is a daily ritual. Whether you're rewarding good behavior, sneaking in a little training session, or just wanting to see that tail wag, the right treats make all the difference.
Best Option
When you want the best for your pup (and the easiest subscription experience for yourself), Amazing Clubs makes it simple. They've been a leader in the subscription world for years, offering everything from pies to candles, and their dog treat club keeps that same gold-standard quality. If you've ever been burned by disappointing pet boxes, this one will restore your faith - because it's all about great-tasting, gourmet snacks made for dogs and backed by a company that's second to none.
Treats only, please
This club is refreshingly straightforward. Every month, you'll receive two full-sized bags of fresh-baked dog treats from boutique bakeries across the country - close to a pound of goodies in each delivery. Past selections have been as creative as Vegetable Soup Stars with Banana Coconut Butterflies or Chicken & Apple Flowers with Peanut Butter Honey Bunnies. In other words, this club sends no squeaky toys that get shredded in a day, no accessories your dog doesn't need - just high-quality snacks your furry friend will actually enjoy. And, every shipment also includes The Daily Bone, a fun little newsletter packed with canine trivia, info about that month's selections, and dog-lover tidbits.
Pricing that went down (seriously)
Here's a surprise twist: Amazing Clubs' prices have dropped since our last review. That's rare these days, and it makes their dog treat club even more appealing. The 12-month plan is now just $24.95/month, the 6-month runs $26.95/month, the seasonal plan (every 3 months) is $27.95/month, and the 3-month option is $28.95/month. No hidden fees, either - shipping is always included. Whether you're treating your own pup or sending this as a gift, you know exactly what you'll pay each month. Plus, there's no difference whether you choose to pay everything upfront or as you go - and unlike some rival clubs who say, "Oops, no, so sorry!" when asked for a refund on remaining months, Amazing Clubs doesn't "punish" you if you prepay and then change your mind.
Gifting made easy
Speaking of gifts, Amazing Clubs nails it here too. You can send a printed announcement by mail, email it directly to your recipient, or even print it yourself for those last-minute "oh no, I need something now" situations. The announcement explains exactly what your lucky recipient (and their dog) can expect, complete with your personal message. From there, your giftee will get an email every month telling them what treats are scheduled to come next; they can skip a delivery anytime (maybe they know their particular pooch will turn up his nose at a particular treat) and it'll be added on to the end of their gift subscription term.
Real-life pup approval
While there aren't hundreds of reviews for Amazing Clubs' dog treat club, the feedback it does have is stellar. Every single one of the reviews is 4 or 5 stars, and we even tested it ourselves: when we gifted this to a family member's dog, she couldn't get enough. One long-time subscriber (going strong for over two years) said, "Our two dogs love these treats! Since the dogs are small (25 lbs) and medium (50 lbs) we smash up the biscuits so the calorie count isn't as high & they last longer. I can stand by the back door & shake the bag & they come running! The newsletter is a real treat for me too." That kind of feedback is hard to beat.
Service that stands out
If there's one thing Amazing Clubs is known for, it's their customer-first approach. They've got a rock-solid reputation (including an "A+" from the BBB) and they make sure every order leaves you - and your dog - happy. Don't like a treat? Reach out and they'll make it right with a replacement, refund, or even a switch over to a different club. It's that simple, and we've found it holds true over all of the different Amazing Clubs subscriptions we've tried over the years.
Our #1 pick, paws down
Whether you're spoiling your own dog or surprising another pet parent, this subscription truly delivers month after month. When you combine fresh, gourmet treats with fair pricing, flexible gift options, and customer service that goes above and beyond, it's easy to see why the dog treat club at Amazing Clubs is our top choice.
Great
Doggy Day Box was born out of one dog mom's mission to feed her four pups only the good stuff - treats with ingredients she could actually pronounce, not a jumble of fillers and additives. If you've been struggling to find a dog treat club that's truly natural and packed with variety, this could be the drool-worthy subscription your furry friend has you searching for.
A different kind of "treat yourself"
Each month, Doggy Day Box sends a fresh lineup of single-ingredient goodies. The variety is never boring - sometimes even a little wild. A recent box included:
If your pup loves exploring new flavors and textures, this box definitely keeps things exciting. Past shipments have even included adventurous picks like turkey heads and octopus tentacles.
Options for every pup
While the standard subscription isn't customizable item by item, Doggy Day Box has added a neat twist: you can subscribe to specific boxes on repeat. Choose from options like all duck, all beef, all feet (yep - chicken, duck, and more), or even a "mini" box that's just right for smaller dogs. That flexibility makes it easier to match your doggo's diet and preferences without losing the variety this brand is known for.
Simple pricing, no lock-in
Doggy Day Box is refreshingly straightforward. You'll pay $30 each month (plus $8. 50 in shipping fees) for the standard, surprise Doggy Day Box, and there's no long-term contract to worry about. Cancel anytime if you need to, but given how much dogs (and their humans) rave about these treats, chances are you won't want to.
Loved by dogs and their people
The feedback on Doggy Day Box is glowing. Customers talk about the quality, freshness, and value - often saying it's an incredible deal compared to what they'd spend hunting down similar treats in stores. One trainer with three dogs said it's a lifesaver for her business, while another pet parent highlighted how much she appreciates the wholesome sourcing and adorable packaging. Over and over, people describe their dogs going absolutely crazy for these treats. (Just pop over to Facebook and see for yourself - no extra charge for the cute photos of dogs with their much-anticipated Doggy Day Boxes.)
Not for the faint of heart
The only real drawback? Not everyone is comfortable handing over things like pig ears or cow noses to their pup. If you're squeamish - or vegetarian - this may not be the treat club for you. But for dogs, who are natural omnivores, these items are a hit and line up with how they were meant to eat.
One of the best dog treat clubs around
Doggy Day Box is an outstanding option if you want to spoil your pup with all-natural, single-ingredient treats that change month to month. It's affordable, fun, and proudly small-business run. The only thing holding it back from the very top is that some humans may not love the "body parts" approach - but if your pup's opinion is the one that matters most, this dog treat club is a tail-wagging winner.
Great
If your dog could grab your credit card and order something online, there's a good chance they'd pick BarkBox. This playful dog treat club is all about delivering joy in a box - or, as of recently, in a bag - to dogs and their humans. With a mission to spread tail wags, tasty bites, and squeaky fun, BarkBox has become one of the best-known names in doggy subscriptions.
A theme your dog won't "get," but you will
Every BarkBox (or Bark Bag, rather) comes with two toys, two bags of treats, and a chew. What makes this club shine is the creativity behind each month's theme. You might open up an "Italy Playcation" box complete with a plushie squirrel on a Vespa and "Mutto Bene" pasta-shaped toys, or be welcomed to "The Pupside Down" with a Stranger Things collection. Past themes like "BoopRite Pharmacy" and "Playlien" have been equally clever. Your pup only cares about the squeaks and snacks, but you'll love the playful presentation.
Customization is part of the deal
Not every dog has the same play style - or the same belly. BarkBox makes it easy to customize your subscription. Need sturdier toys? Avoiding certain ingredients? Want more of one particular treat? The "Happy Team" is known for being quick to adjust your deliveries so your pup always gets the good stuff. You'll also be able to specify what your dog likes best as you set up your subscription: does she like plushies, durable toys, or a mix? Allergies? Those are all asked as you start your BarkBox plan, plus Bark invites you to pop open a chat after you check out and let them know about any other needs, dietary or otherwise.
Prices have gone up, but so have the perks
BarkBox costs $40/month (plus shipping) on the monthly plan, $35/month if you subscribe for six months, and just $29/month with a full-year commitment. Those will hit your credit card from month to month, but you also have the option of saving 10% by prepaying for your plan (which doesn't apply if you select the ongoing $40/month dog treat club). During checkout, you'll also be offered the option of including a bonus toy for another $9/month. At the time of this review, BarkBox was still offering new subscribers on the 6- and 12-month plans a double first box with twice the goodies - no code required. And, we were happy to discover that there were no shipping fees charged on any of the BarkBox plans.
From boxes to bags: what's the deal?
Recently, BarkBox switched from shipping in boxes to shipping in bag mailers. Some customers weren't thrilled with the change, but Bark has been transparent about why: tariffs and rising costs. Their response to reviews on Trustpilot explains that the goodies inside haven't changed - only the packaging. In other words, the squeaky joy is still the same, even if it comes in a bag.
Extra touches that set them apart
Bark isn't just about selling toys and treats. Their "Co-Owned by Dogs" approach literally puts pups at the center of decision-making, with a Chairdog and subscriber-led Dog Committee helping shape toy designs, treat flavors, and even causes Bark supports. In one recent year alone, they donated nearly $800,000 worth of toys and treats to shelters and rescues across the country.
Customer service is on point
Across more than 8,000 reviews on Trustpilot, BarkBox holds a 4.4-star average rating. Let's just say the humans on the "Happy Team" live up to the name. One reviewer shared that after filling out a survey saying their chewing-oriented pup needed tougher toys, BarkBox immediately sent replacements and suggested new subscription options - within hours. Downsides? Like most subscription services, BarkBox auto-renews. Some customers have had frustrations canceling on time, which is one of the most common complaints. The company holds an "A+" rating with the BBB, and their customer service team is extremely responsive about fixing issues reported there, but it's still smart to keep an eye on your renewal date so there aren't any surprises.
A dog treat club you'll both love
BarkBox is affordable, customizable, and loaded with personality. Sure, you'll want to keep track of your renewal dates, and you may have to get used to bags instead of boxes. But with fun themes, responsive customer service, and a genuine commitment to giving back, BarkBox is still one of the best dog treat clubs out there.
Very Good
If your dog thinks toys are just challenges waiting to be conquered, Super Chewer could be the subscription that finally keeps up with them. Created by the folks behind BarkBox, this club is built with the "chewsy" pups in mind - the ones who love to gnaw, shred, and test every toy's durability (and your patience?).
Goodbye, fluff explosions
Each box comes with two super-tough toys that skip the stuffing altogether, so you won't be sweeping up little white fluff clouds after playtime. You'll also get two full-size bags of hearty treats, all sourced from the US and Canada for peace of mind. And if your dog has allergies or dietary preferences, Bark will happily adjust your deliveries to avoid any problematic ingredients.
Themes that make unboxing fun for you
The toys and treats aren't just thrown together, either. Every Super Chewer box has an adorable monthly theme - think "The Simpsons" or "Deep Space" - and the goodies tie right in. Your dog might not care that their chew toy looks like a UFO or a can of Duff beer, but you'll definitely get a smile each month when you open it up.
Sized just right
No matter how big (or small) your power chewer is, Super Chewer makes it easy to get the right fit. Small boxes are for dogs under 20 pounds, Medium works for the 20-49 pound crowd, and Large is for pups 50 pounds and up. If your dog is in-between or has a smaller frame but a mighty jaw (hello, Staffies), sizing up is the way to go. And yes - you can switch sizes whenever you need, especially handy for multi-dog households.
More expensive, but worth it
There's no denying that Super Chewer is pricier than the standard BarkBox or some other dog clubs. A month-to-month subscription is $40, but you can save by committing: $35 per box with a 6-month plan, or $29 per box if you go for a full year. Each delivery is valued at over $50, which helps balance things out, plus you don't have to pay for your whole subscription term upfront (whew). Also, when we last checked, this dog treat club was running a deal where 6- and 12-month subscriptions for new customers would come with an extra toy in each box. And, since our last review, Super Chewer upped the ante by throwing in free shipping on every subscription.
The guarantee every dog owner dreams of
Super Chewer also comes with one of the best guarantees you'll find. If a toy doesn't hold up, or your dog just isn't into what they get, Bark will send a replacement - no time limit, no questions asked, no proof required. That kind of confidence is rare and makes the higher price tag a lot easier to swallow.
Dogs and their 2-legged friends love this club
Bark itself has a fantastic reputation, shown in its "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and nearly 7,000 5-star ratings on Trustpilot. One glowing review there even came from someone who subscribed to Super Chewer; she said that her doggo loved everything that came in the boxes, and that customer service was super-responsive when helping tailor the deliveries to her pet's particular preferences (say that three times fast). You'll also love all of the paws-itive testimonial photos on the Super Chewer part of the BarkBox site, from Tuck who loses his ever-loving mind when he sees his box come every month, to Ripley going to town on a shark-themed toy.
A "chews"-worthy pick
Super Chewer isn't for every pup, but if your dog has the jaws of a tiny T-rex and leaves ordinary toys in tatters, this subscription is a game-changer. With clever themes, sturdy toys, tasty treats, and a no-hassle replacement policy, it's one of the best ways to spoil your determined chewer. For dogs who love to destroy but deserve the best, Super Chewer is well worth a try.
Good
Pet Treater used to be one of the brightest stars in the world of dog treat clubs, known for budget-friendly prices and cheerful deliveries that delighted pups month after month. Today, it's still affordable and easy to gift - but unfortunately, the quality and customer experience just don't match the glory days. If you're tempted by the price tag alone, you'll want to know what you're getting into before subscribing.
A mix of toys and treats
Each Pet Treater shipment is supposed to include toys, treats, accessories, or even grooming supplies, usually with 3-4 items in the regular box, 5-8 surprises in the larger "Deluxe" plan, or 2-5 toys if you opt for the "toys only" club. Most treats are sourced from the US or Canada (never from China). All of that sounds reassuring on paper. But where Pet Treater once wowed customers with fun variety, many recent subscribers say the items feel flimsy, low-value, and not well matched to their dogs' size or preferences. One common complaint is that fragile stuffed toys are still being sent even when people specifically request tougher alternatives.
Affordable pricing that's hard to ignore
One reason Pet Treater hasn't fallen completely off the map is its low cost. Pricing starts at $15/month for the regular box with toys and treats, $18/month for just toys, and $25/month for the Deluxe box. Shipping is free, and there's even a "Try It Out Now" box for $17 to $29 if you want to test the waters. It's also easy to send a subscription as a gift with the click of a button during checkout. On the surface, this makes Pet Treater one of the cheapest ways to get a regular surprise for your pup - especially with free shipping on all of their dog treat clubs.
Subscribe for month-to-month or prepay for 3, 6, or 12 months
Whether you're gifting this dog treat club to a friend or keeping it for your own furry companion, you have options for how you want to set up your payments. Pet Treater lets you choose from paying month-to-month or paying upfront for a set subscription timeframe of 3, 6, or 12 months. Be aware that all plans renew automatically unless you cancel.
The customer experience tells a sad story
Unfortunately, Pet Treater's reviews paint a not-so-rosy picture. On Trustpilot, the company has tumbled to a 2.2-star average across nearly 400 reviews. Complaints range from toys falling apart in hours, to shipping delays of weeks (or even more than a month), to customer service that's nearly impossible to reach. Some subscribers describe difficulties canceling, with reports of charges continuing even after requests to end memberships. Others say the value simply isn't there anymore, with packages containing just a handful of cheap toys their dogs ignore. The toll-free number went straight to voicemail when we checked it out, and while Pet Treater's social media accounts are active, they don't show much in the way of recent customer engagement.
A nice idea that doesn't quite deliver like it used to
We do appreciate that Pet Treater partners with shelters and rescues, donating items to animals in need. And, the low prices could still make this club worth a gamble if you're mainly looking for something inexpensive, especially as a gift. But with so many other dog treat clubs offering better quality and stronger customer support, Pet Treater has slipped from the top of the pack to barely above average.
Average
PupBox was born out of one couple's journey into puppy parenthood. Founders Ben and Ariel Zvaifler created the company for their own "furdaughter," Maggie, who quickly showed them how overwhelming - and rewarding - raising a puppy can be. From housetraining and teething to the dreaded puppy crazies, they struggled to keep up with Maggie's changing needs. Their solution was PupBox, a subscription built to deliver the right toys, treats, and training guides at every stage of development. Today, more than 3 million boxes later, PupBox is still helping new dog parents (and their doggos) feel a little more prepared for every milestone.
Developmental stages at the core
When you sign up for PupBox, you'll create a profile for your dog, including their size, age, and any allergies. The company then builds each shipment around your pup's current stage: newborn puppy (0-6 months), young pup (7-18 months), or grown pup (19+ months). For puppies, each box is filled with toys, treats, chews, and accessories geared to specific milestones like teething or housetraining, plus a training guide to walk you through that stage. Adult dogs aren't left out either - those boxes contain 4-7 items suited for older pets, along with helpful training tips to keep your best fur-end engaged.
Toy and treats galore
Every PupBox includes high-quality treats and chews made without wheat, corn, or soy (though some recipes do use oats). You'll also get toys matched to your dog's growth and chewing habits: softer toys for little pups and sturdier ones for bigger or more aggressive chewers. PupBox even encourages you to let your dog "destroy the occasional stuffed duck or monkey" as a healthy outlet for energy - but if a toy doesn't measure up to your pup's standards, the company promises to replace it and adjust future shipments.
Customized to your dog's size and needs (and to your needs too)
Boxes are tailored to your dog's eventual adult weight, with categories from "Itty Bitty" (1-10 lbs) all the way up to "Large & In Charge" (50+ lbs). You can also reach out to PupBox to make requests - like skipping a month, switching to every-other-month delivery, or flagging a need for tougher toys. Their team will work with you to keep each box as useful and fun as possible.
Plan options and pricing are on full display now
One welcome improvement since our last review is that PupBox has become much more transparent about its pricing. You can now see costs upfront:
For those who prefer to prepay, you'll get a small discount by paying upfront: $96 for 3 months, $174 for 6 months, or $312 for a full year. Just look for the toggle at the top of the pricing list. Shipping adds $4.99 per box, unless you tack on an extra treat at checkout.
Customer support via email
All plans renew automatically unless you cancel, and the company does not issue refunds (though they say they'll handle issues case by case). PupBox doesn't offer phone support, but you can reach them by email, mail, or social media. That's not the most convenient setup, but their customer service promises to replace any item you don't love.
Reputation on the upswing, but could use more subscriber feedback
PupBox's Better Business Bureau rating has rebounded to an "A+", with no complaints filed in the last 12 months. Social media channels for the company are active and show plenty of happy dogs with their PupBox deliveries, though you won't find many independent customer reviews on sites like Trustpilot or even on their own store. That lack of feedback leaves us with an incomplete picture of how consistent the experience is for subscribers.
Still room for improvement, but earns a "good enough" rating
PupBox has a great origin story, and the idea of supporting puppies (and their humans) at each stage of development is both thoughtful and practical. We love that their pricing is now more transparent, and the bounce back to an "A+" from the BBB - with zero complaints in the last year - gives us confidence that they're on the right track. Still, the absence of broader customer feedback and the rigid cancellation policy keep us from giving PupBox our top recommendation.
Average
Pooch Perks started with a mission many dog lovers can get behind: two dog moms wanted to deliver toys and treats made in the USA while also giving back to rescues helping abused and neglected pups. Every subscription box still carries that spirit of giving, with a portion of proceeds donated to animal organizations. That sounds like a win-win, but when you dig into what Pooch Perks delivers today, the reality doesn't quite measure up.
Multiple box options
Pooch Perks offers four main subscriptions. The Pampered Pooch ($49. 99) packs in the most variety, with 3-4 premium toys, 3 treat bags, 2 chews, a premium accessory, and a roll of waste bags. The mid-tier Pooch Box ($33. 99 or $34. 99, depending on the dog's size) gives you 2 toys, 2 treats, and a small chew. If you're all about playtime, the Toys Only plan runs $25.99-$26.99 depending on your pup's size for 3 plush toys, while the Treats Only box ($20. 99) focuses on snacks and chews with 3 treats and 2 samples/chews per delivery. Each shipment adds a flat $2 shipping fee.
Gifting is a possibility
You can also buy one-off gift boxes in either the Pooch Box or Pampered Pooch style, complete with a personalized note. Gift boxes ship quickly (1-2 business days) and don't renew automatically, which makes them a safer bet if you're worried about commitment. (That might even be a good idea, gifting it to yourself - you'll see why in a minute.)
Customization available
One strong point here is flexibility. You'll pick from five different size categories, including a "Mixed Household" option for families with more than one pup. Allergies? You can request grain-free options or exclude proteins like chicken, beef, or turkey. And if your dog is a tough chewer, Pooch Perks lets you choose more durable toys made from natural rubber, rope, or nylon.
Reputation won't have your tail wagging
Unfortunately, the actual experience of being a subscriber here doesn't line up with the promise. Pooch Perks still holds an "A+" at the BBB with no complaints filed, but elsewhere the feedback is troubling. On Trustpilot, the company averages just 2.1 stars across 35 reviews, and recent comments are especially harsh. Customers report missing shipments, weeks-long delays with no updates, and unresponsive customer service. One reviewer even threatened a chargeback after being ignored when asking for a refund.
Outdated website = not a good look
Website quality is another red flag: the copyright date hasn't been refreshed since 2021, and some images look grainy or outdated. While the company's social media is still active, it doesn't erase our concerns about whether Pooch Perks is fully keeping up with its customers (or its competitors).
Strict policies won't win you over either
Pooch Perks' terms aren't very forgiving. Subscriptions can be set up month-to-month or prepaid for 3, 6, or 12 months, but there's no discount for prepaying - you'll pay the same per box either way. All subscriptions automatically renew, and there are no refunds, even if you cancel mid-plan. The only replacements offered are for defective items. That leaves you with little recourse if your pup just doesn't love what's inside.
Falling behind the pack
Pooch Perks deserves credit for offering made-in-the-USA treats, decent customization, and charitable contributions. But when late shipments, weak customer service, and strict no-refund policies are the norm, it's hard to recommend them over higher-rated dog treat clubs. For now, we're dropping Pooch Perks a bit in our rankings. There are bright spots, but too many dog owners are being left unhappy.
Subpar
Since 2014, Bullymake has positioned itself as the go-to subscription for dogs that destroy ordinary toys in minutes. Their promise is straightforward: themed monthly boxes with 2-3 heavy-duty toys plus 3 treats, all crafted to stand up to power chewers like Pit Bulls and Rottweilers. If you'd rather skip the snacks, there's a toys-only plan for an extra $5 per month, and there are lots of upgrades offered during checkout (from poop bags to calming chews and more). Allergy notes and other preferences can also be added when you sign up. Sounds pretty straightforward, right? Keep reading to see why this seemingly great dog treat club winds up almost at the bottom of our list.
Plan options and pricing are uncomplicated
Bullymake keeps its subscription structure fairly simple. You can subscribe month-to-month, or commit for 3, 6, or 12 months at a time. The longer your plan, the lower your monthly cost - ranging from $45 on the short end to as little as $29 per month with the biggest commitment. You can get the first box for just $19 on the 6- and 12-month plans, and each plan comes with a free gift in the first month. Speaking of free, shipping is included on all multi-month plans, though monthly subscriptions don't qualify. Compared with other dog treat clubs, the pricing is competitive, but the lack of true flexibility (like the ability to skip or pause) may be frustrating for some customers.
Sounds good on paper, but...
Unfortunately, Bullymake's execution doesn't match its pitch. While the toys and treats might sound like a dream come true for your pup, the company has a long track record of disappointing customers. Their parent company, CJH Equity LLC, currently holds an "F" rating with the Better Business Bureau for failing to respond to nearly 50 complaints. Those complaints are eye-opening: toys that break almost instantly, treats that upset dogs' stomachs, and a so-called "durability and satisfaction guarantee" that Bullymake seems unwilling to honor.
The cancellation nightmare
The single biggest problem here is cancellation. Dozens of customers say that Bullymake makes it intentionally difficult to stop your subscription. One person reported being promised that their plan would not auto-renew - only to have it renewed anyway, leaving them battling with both Bullymake and their bank to stop charges. Others describe a manipulative process: when you try to cancel, the company demands a "reason," then offers multiple ways to continue your subscription instead of actually ending it. During this back-and-forth, they'll keep charging your credit card. Only after multiple written requests - and declining every one of their offers - will they sometimes agree to cancel. That's not just frustrating, it's borderline unethical.
Mixed signals from customer feedback
Here's the surprising part: Bullymake has nearly 900 reviews on Trustpilot averaging 4.2 stars. Plenty of customers say they love the toys, their dogs look forward to every box, and the subscription feels like money well spent. But even among otherwise happy subscribers, complaints about cancellation policies pop up again and again. So while Bullymake clearly has some loyal fans, the darker side of its customer service record can't be ignored.
Not a dog treat club we can recommend
Bullymake might have cracked the code for making super-durable toys that some dogs adore, but its business practices leave too many people feeling stuck, ignored, or even cheated. An "F" rating from the BBB and widespread stories of unethical cancellation hurdles outweigh the positive reviews on Trustpilot. Until this company takes real steps to improve how it treats its human customers - not just their dogs - we can't recommend Bullymake as a trustworthy dog treat club.
Weak
PupJoy once looked like the ideal treat club for dog lovers who wanted socially responsible, artisan-sourced toys and treats. It still sounds appealing: subscription boxes free of artificial preservatives, colors, flavors, and sweeteners, plus customization options to suit your pup's size and chewing style. Unfortunately, the reality is that PupJoy's reputation has gone from tentatively worth considering to downright troubling, and it's no longer a subscription we can recommend. We'll show you why.
Lots of boxes, but no joy in the experience
PupJoy technically offers a range of options, from Variety and Power Chewer boxes to bully stick assortments and even a "Build Your Own Box" feature. Pricing spans roughly $24 to $54 per delivery depending on your selections, and shipping is free. In theory, this flexibility could be great. In practice, however, customers are running into serious problems that make these options meaningless if the boxes don't arrive as promised or if what's inside is disappointing.
Recent customer feedback paints a grim picture
The most glaring issue here is the feedback from actual customers. On Trustpilot, PupJoy averages just 1.6 out of 5 stars, and the reviews are scathing. Check it out in their own words:
With feedback like that, it's hard to trust this dog treat club with your money or your pup's... joy.
Fake-sounding reviews don't inspire confidence
The company's own website doesn't help its case. The only new reviews added there in the last year are strangely worded, generic blurbs like "it works, quality products, a great service" and "Gift boxes include enjoyable toys and worthy snacks for your pet to feel special and content." Before those, you'd have to scroll back over three years to find any other customer input. That gap speaks volumes about what might be happening (or not happening) behind the scenes at PupJoy.
No transparency, no support
The red flags don't stop there. PupJoy still has no BBB listing, and their social media channels have been silent for years. When we tried their toll-free number, we were pushed to voicemail and told to leave a message - pressing "1" for customer service didn't connect us to a live person, just another recording. All signs point to a business that may still be taking orders but doesn't seem to be truly operating.
Can't recommend this dog treat club anymore
Once upon a time, we gave PupJoy a tentative above-average rating, hoping their unusual silence was just a temporary hiccup. Sadly, nothing has improved - and in fact, things look worse. Between likely fake website reviews, an unresponsive (or nonexistent) customer service team, and angry subscribers who feel scammed, PupJoy can't be trusted. Your pup deserves better than missed deliveries, duplicate toys, and radio silence when you ask for help. With so many better-run dog treat clubs out there, Pupjoy has dropped near the bottom of our ratings.
Poor
BoxDog originally caught attention with a simple idea: make all their treats in-house rather than sourcing artisan snacks from around the world. They even encourage you to take a taste test if it smells good to you. Beyond treats, each box promises carefully sourced toys, gear, or specialty items designed to get tails wagging. But while the initial concept sounded interesting, the company's follow-through now leaves a lot to be desired.
You pick some of what's in your box
With BoxDog, you can choose monthly or seasonal deliveries. The monthly plan includes 2 bags of handmade treats, 1 specialty item like a chew or skincare product, and 2-3 toys or gear items that you select (like a carrying bag your dog wears, a tug toy, or a backpack for you). The seasonal box adds an extra bag of treats.
Options are now just monthly or seasonal deliveries
Prices vary depending on your subscription preference: monthly pay-as-you-go is $45, while seasonal boxes are more expensive at $55. BoxDog seems to have dropped prepaid plans covering 3 months or more since our last review. Shipping is included on all plans.
Not sure the juice is worth the squeeze here
On paper, these prices seemed competitive - but the value of the actual items was far from convincing. Many items aren't unique or noteworthy compared with local pet stores' inventory or other dog treat clubs. Worse, some boxes in the past reportedly included products with xylitol, a substance toxic to dogs. With no guarantees about product quality or suitability, and a policy of zero refunds, each shipment from BoxDog seems like a gamble rather than a treat for your pup.
Dead social presence and poor support
All of BoxDog's social media accounts have gone silent since 2021. Their website is technically still active (copyrighted as of the year of this evaluation) but clearly not maintained - imagine seeing Valentine's Day heart cookies for sale in September and you'll get the gist. Phone support is minimal: calls go to a generic "leave a message" system. We did get an automated text when we called the number, and then got a response back from BoxDog (eventually) saying that they're still up and running despite the outdated website and radio silent socials: their reason for all of that was it's "just a lot for a small business and nothing much happened for us on social." Okay, then...
Negative feedback dominates
Trustpilot has only a handful of BoxDog reviews, and all are negative. Customers complain about misleading product descriptions, broken promises, and an unresponsive support team. One user described trying to cancel a 6-month subscription after a frustrating experience, only to have BoxDog refuse. Their advice mirrors what others have reported: do not commit unless you are fully sure about the subscription here, and even then, you're probably going to wind up disappointed sooner or later.
Bottom line: avoid this dog treat club
BoxDog started with a neat concept but has failed to deliver on nearly every front: low-value boxes, questionable product safety, practically nonexistent support, and an unmaintained website. With no BBB listing, dead social accounts, and overwhelmingly negative feedback, this is a dog treat subscription we most strongly recommend avoiding.
Continued from above...
If you're like millions of Americans, your dog isn't just a pet-they're family. In fact, surveys show that nearly 90 million households in the US own at least one dog, and most owners say they spend more on their pup than they do on themselves sometimes. It's no wonder, then, that treat time is a daily ritual. Whether you're rewarding good behavior, sneaking in a little training session, or just wanting to see that tail wag, the right treats make all the difference.
Dog treat clubs have become a fun, stress-free way to keep that treat jar full and your furry friend happy. You'll find clubs that specialize in organic or grain-free goodies for pups with sensitive stomachs, and others that spotlight unique flavors like peanut butter, pumpkin, or even salmon. Some subscriptions go beyond edible treats, tossing in durable toys, chews, or seasonal surprises that make each delivery feel like a holiday for your dog. No more last-minute runs to the pet store - you can have handpicked treats show up right at your doorstep.
Dog treat clubs also make a surprisingly perfect gift. You know that person who already seems to have everything? Chances are, they'd really be excited about getting regular surprises for their pup. After all, the way to many dog lovers' hearts is through their four-legged best friend. A subscription full of tasty snacks and fun toys is a gift that keeps giving month after month - and every delivery is guaranteed (sometimes literally) to bring smiles, wags, and maybe a few happy barks.
Of course, not every dog treat club is created equal, and it helps to know what to look for before you subscribe. Here are a few things you'll want to consider:
At Top Consumer Reviews, we've taken a close look at today's most popular dog treat clubs to help you find the perfect option for your four-legged best friend. Whether your pup loves crunchy biscuits, chewy sticks, or surprise toys, you'll discover the clubs that deliver both value and joy - straight to your doorstep.
Compare Any 2 Products
Types of Dog Treats
Every dog owner wants to spoil their little cutie, but have you ever stopped to wonder what it is you're actually giving them? The pet treat industry is surprisingly a lot more interesting than what it may sound like. The majority of pet owners spend $20 or less on treats for their pets; 28% of cat owners and 15% of dog owners spend $5 or less on treats. In this article we will explore the different types of treats and why some are priced higher than others, including how they may effect your pets health.
The whole pet treat industry is full of secrets to learn. While you love your pet, you don't want to pay for something upmarked up to 5 times what it should be priced, only for your dog to get nothing out of it. Look at the ingredients when you buy something for your dog to ingest, and be aware that the goal of the pet treat companies is to make money, not to take care of your dog, that's up to you! Your dog will love you for giving them something they feel better eating, and you'll feel better taking care of your little cutie!
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
