Can you still rent movies on DVD?

Yes, and on Blu-ray too. Even though Netflix stopped sending out movies by mail back in 2023, several other companies have gladly stepped up to fill the void. From new releases to black-and-white classics, there are several DVD movie rental services that can get those titles right to your mailbox.

Why would I still watch DVDs when I have a streaming service?

Be honest: aren't there movies that you really wanted to watch, only to be disappointed to come up empty when looking for them on your streaming service ( ...or even pirating?... Shhh... )? DVD movie rental companies often specialize in sourcing hard-to-find titles, indie films that weren't picked up by a streaming platform, or even big-budget flicks whose studios never gave permission to any of the streaming services to show.

Are DVD movie rentals expensive?

Not at all. If you're only going to watch one or two movies a month, you'll usually pay less than $10 for a subscription. That generally includes shipping both ways.

Do I have to subscribe to a service to get DVDs?

Not necessarily. There are some companies who allow you to rent titles as you go, just like you used to do at the local video store. Expect to pay around $5 for a la carte rentals, plus the cost of shipping. You'd probably get more value out of a subscription, but it's not the only option you have.

How long does it take to get DVDs in the mail?

That depends on where the DVD movie rental service ships from. If you live in Portland, ME and the only warehouse is in Portland, OR, it's going to take some time. We've seen some companies get DVDs to customers in a few days, while others can take a week or more. It also depends on the inventory of the company: some titles may have a waitlist. It's a good idea to keep your queue or wishlist well-stocked, so that you've got something to watch while you wait.

When will I get a new DVD in the mail?

That's an important factor to consider: how does the DVD movie rental service handle returns, so that you can get a new movie? Some are super customer-friendly and let you notify them that you've put one in the mail, so that they can send the next title on your list. But, others wait until they've gotten the notification from USPS that the one you're returning is on the way... and the ones we really don't like make you wait until they have the title in hand before sending you a new one.

What if I lose the DVD?

Life happens. Most DVD movie rental services will let you keep a movie you've gotten, typically at a reduced cost ( since it's used, after all ). You don't have to tell the company that it's lost, though - just that it's a title that you're "keeping".

Do DVD movie rental services only include current titles?

Absolutely not. In fact, that's one of the reasons why these services are so popular: if you love foreign films, you're dying to rewatch a classic B&W you saw with your grandma, or you've got really niche tastes in cinema, chances are really good that there's a DVD movie rental company that offers what you want. Better yet, some services even take requests for titles to add to their inventory.

Best DVD Movie Rental Sites for March 2026

Item: The Best DVD Movie Rental Sites - Summary Reviews
Rating: 5
Author: Top Consumer Reviews

Friday, March 6th We evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

2026 DVD Movie Rental Site Reviews

Which DVD Movie Rental Service is the Best? When Netflix shut down its DVD-by-mail service back in September 2023, it left something of a vacuum in the industry. But, we can hear you say, does anyone even watch DVDs (or Blu-rays) anymore with so many movies and shows on streaming services (...and *cough* pirating sites *cough*...)?

5.0

EXCELLENT

Best Option

DVD Inbox

Hundreds of thousands of movies
New titles added daily
Offers titles on both DVD and Blu-ray

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the DVD Inbox website

DVD Inbox is the best DVD and Blu-ray rent-by-mail service on the market. You can subscribe for as little as $9.99/month (and the first month is even discounted below that), there are plans that allow for an unlimited number of titles, with no due dates or late fees. Members are superfans of the customer service here, finding nothing but helpful reps who go the extra mile to replace the occasional scratched disc or ones that get lost along the way. And, with hundreds of thousands of titles, you'll never be lacking for something new to watch. We're big fans of this DVD rental service too and give it a perfect 5 stars.

4.5

GREAT

Great

Scarecrow Video

Over 147,000 unique titles
Pay-per-rental (not subscription)
Can rent up to 6 discs at a time

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the Scarecrow Video website

Scarecrow Video may be the most unique DVD rental-by-mail option on our list: it's the only one designated as a non-profit organization and a cultural museum by WA State. There are almost 150,000 titles in the library and thousands of new ones added each year. You'll have to pay-per-rental and there are shipping fees on every delivery: this isn't a traditional subscription format. But, we're pretty sure you'll fall in love with Scarecrow's extensive library and their mission to be defenders of physical media (just like we did).

4.0

VERY GOOD

Very Good

Café DVD

Offers DVDs, Blu-ray, and 4K (for an extra fee)
Excellent range of titles
5 plans to choose from, priced from $9.99-$35.99 per month

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Café DVD website

Café DVD will knock you out with its online catalog of DVDs and Blu-rays: if it was made on disc and not just direct-to-streaming, chances are good you'll find it here. You can mix-and-match your media types if you've got both types of players, and plans are priced between $9.99-$35.99 per month (with several that allow for an unlimited number of titles each month). Some subscribers have been disappointed that the availability of titles at Café DVD doesn't line up with the catalog, waiting a long time for some movies and TV shows to come. But, we've heard good things about the overall customer service here, so we give Café DVD an above-average rating.

3.5

GOOD

Good

4K Bluray 4U

All Blu-ray discs (no DVDs)
3 subscription plans ranging from $17.99/month (2 discs at a time, 4 discs per month) to $57.99/month (8 discs at a time, 16 discs per month)
Free shipping both ways

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the 4K Bluray 4U website

4K Bluray 4U is a trustworthy subscription service if you prefer Blu-ray discs to DVDs. Plans range from $17.99-$57.99 per month, allowing you to have anywhere from 2-8 titles at a time and a total of 4-16 movies monthly. The selection is a bit more limited than its closest competitor's, but 4K Bluray 4U makes up for that by offering fantastic customer service.

3.0

AVERAGE

Average

GameFly

Can rent DVDs, Blu-rays, and 4k Ultra HD
30-day free trial on some plans
Can combine movies and video games in rental plan

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the GameFly website

GameFly started as a video game rental service back in 2002, and later expanded into DVD movie rentals. They emphasize higher-resolution movie rentals, such as blu-ray and 4k, rather than the older 480p dvd format. While their plans are priced competitively, we found customer service issues that should be easily resolved. If you're looking for high quality movie formats, Gamefly is an acceptable choice, otherwise you may find better value with one of the other higher-rated services.

2.9

AVERAGE

Average

FACETS

Movie rental service is an add-on to a larger membership
Over 45,000 titles across DVDs, Blu-rays, and VHS tapes (!)
Broad range from modern titles to rare and out-of-print movies

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

2.9

On the FACETS website

FACETS is a movie rental service connected to a small theater in Chicago: your membership here includes a lot of in-person benefits, but you're also able to sign up just to get the perks of checking out 3 titles per month (on DVD, Blu-ray, or even VHS). Don't let the outdated look of the website fool you: there are titles here spanning decades, but more recent releases are in the inventory as well. The subscription experience here isn't quite as streamlined as rival services', but it's still a great way to access movies you may not have heard of.

2.0

SUBPAR

Subpar

3D Blu-ray Rental

Over 20,000 Blu-ray titles
Subscription prices range from $9.99-$62.99 per month
Can receive anywhere from 1-8 discs at a time, with totals of 2-16 titles per month

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the 3D Blu-ray Rental website

3D Blu-ray Rental can't help you if you only want DVDs, but if Blu-ray is your thing, you've got over 20,000 options here. Subscription pricing ranges from $9.99-$62.99 per month, depending on how many DVDs you'd like at a time (from 1-8) and how many you'd like in total every month (from 2-16). Some titles will have a surcharge, and 3D Blu-ray Rental will charge you a fee if you inadvertently get too many discs at a time or in a month - even if it's their fault. Unfortunately, subscribers say that the customer service here isn't great.

Continued from above...

Which DVD Movie Rental Service is the Best?

When Netflix shut down its DVD-by-mail service back in September 2023, it left something of a vacuum in the industry. But, we can hear you say, does anyone even watch DVDs (or Blu-rays) anymore with so many movies and shows on streaming services (...and *cough* pirating sites *cough*...)?

The answer is a big "YES". What vinyl records are to audio purists, physical media for movies is to cinephiles. All you need is a great home theater setup (even a modest one) and you've got audiovisual quality that can't be replicated by most streaming platforms. Plus, if your WiFi goes out, you don't have to cancel movie night if you've got a bunch of DVDs on hand.

And, speaking of Internet connections, we've heard of more than a few families who've decided to go connection-free while they're home, going back to DVDs as a way to stop doom-scrolling or watching endless reels on their FYP for a few hours and spend time together.

But, you don't necessarily want to buy a whole bunch of DVDs, and your local library might not be directing much budget towards acquiring ones you could borrow. Don't worry, though: that's where DVD movie rental services come in, even in the absence of Netflix's well-known red envelopes in your mailbox. There are a number of companies that have stepped into the gap, either with membership plans structured much the same way or even offering a pay-as-you-go rental platform. Whether you want the hottest new releases or you're hoping to discover an indie film you've never heard of, there's a DVD rental service you'll love.

What should you look for in a good DVD movie rental company? Here are some key factors that can help you tell apart the ones that will be blockbusters (so to speak) from the ones that are best left on a bloopers reel:

Selection. How many titles do they have in their inventory? Are they in the categories you tend to watch? How often do they add new movies? Do they have new releases right when they come out, or will you have to wait a while?
Subscription vs. rent-as-you-go. There's a place for both DVD movie rental types, but you may already have a preference for one or the other. Choose a company whose structure is a good fit for your typical movie-watching habits.
Cost. What will you pay for your DVD rentals? Double-check to see if shipping fees are included: you might be surprised to see that some smaller companies charge a shipping fee of $8 or more per delivery; it's not automatically rolled into what you pay for the rentals themselves.
Due dates and late fees. Most of the subscription-based DVD movie rental services don't have due dates or late fees, while many of the rent-as-you-go ones do.
Customer service. This could be one of the most important criteria for picking a DVD rental company. How do they handle it when customers report that discs were too scratched/damaged to play properly (or never arrived at all)? Do they ship titles out quickly, maybe even letting you use your dashboard to tell them that one of your rentals is in the mail so that they can send a new one out right away? Look to see what current customers are saying about the overall experience with any company you're thinking of using for your DVD movie rentals.

Get in your comfy chair and dim the lights, because the film fans at Top Consumer Reviews have reviewed and ranked the most popular DVD movie rental services available today. Use our research to pick the one that's the right fit for your tastes in cinema, from avant-garde to anime and everything in between. Don't forget the popcorn!