Jared Review

Wednesday, March 19th

2025 Engagement Ring Reviews

Jared

• Extensive variety of 3,000+ engagement rings in different styles and price ranges
• Can design a ring from scratch
• Free consultations (online or in-person)
• Complimentary in-store pickup
• 30-day return policy
• Parent company (Signet Jewelers) holds an "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Jared is one of several engagement ring retailers in our review that are owned by Signet Jewelers, a large company with a reputation spanning nearly 100 years. Jared wants you to feel like it's a huge win if "He went to Jared” for your engagement ring at one of its 200+ brick-and-mortar locations or its extensive online storefront, but is it? We'd say no, and we'll tell you why.

Might be higher pricewise, even with a deal

It's easy to find an engagement ring at Jared that fits your budget, even before you start filtering the selection by price. Check out the Deals & Clearance section or scroll through the homepage to see current specials. When we visited, Vera Wang bridal sets were 25% off, and clearance items had an extra 30% discount. You'll still want to shop around, though: Jared's prices can be on the higher side, even compared to its sister brands under Signet Jewelers.

Nothing but true engagement rings in the selection

At the same time, we like that Jared doesn't waste our energy by showing us rings that aren't really suitable for a proposal: some of its rivals include promise rings and fashion jewelry in their engagement selection. When you ask Jared to show you all 3,000+ engagement rings and then organize them from low-to-high price, the first entries will probably be settings that are on clearance. That's what we're talking about! On that end of the price spectrum, the settings we saw at the time of our visit were all priced around $460. You can also find simple-yet-elegant solitaires for just under $500. Displaying Jared's rings from the highest-priced styles, you'll also find a simple-yet-VERY-elegant solitaire for $50,000 on the dot, as well as a handful of rings by Pninia Tornai and Vera Wang in the $20K range.

Use filters for easy browsing

Make use of Jared's filters to quickly find the engagement ring you want. If you need a ring in a hurry, use the "Get It Fast” filter. Have a specific metal color, setting style, or budget in mind? The filters make it easy to narrow down your choices. You can also see prices and different metal color options as you browse. Use the "compare” button or the heart icon to save your favorites. It's straightforward and user-friendly.

Complimentary consultations

Unsure about which ring to buy? Jared offers free consultations with their ring specialists. Just click the "connect virtually” button and follow the steps. You can book a 60-minute session if you're looking for guidance on choosing an engagement ring. You can also start a design process or set up service and repair appointments. You have the option to chat live anytime or schedule an in-store appointment at a Jared location near you.

Flexible delivery options

When it comes to delivery, you can have your ring shipped to your nearest Jared store for free. You can also opt to have it sent to a UPS Access Point (for orders of $5,000 or less) or directly to your home, but items over $1,000 will require a signature. If you're in a rush, you can shop your local store's inventory online and get same-day delivery by placing your order by 1 PM local time.

Easy returns and exchanges

Jared offers a 30-day window for returns and exchanges. Exchanges must be done in person at a Jared store, but returns can be processed either in-store or by mail using a pre-printed return label provided by Jared, which is insured for the full purchase price.

Warranty coverage falls short

A major downside to Jared is its limited warranty protection. For engagement rings, Jared includes a complimentary lifetime guarantee on diamonds and gemstones, but the metal of the setting is only covered by the additional "Forever Cherished” plan, and you'll have to add that to your cart at checkout (with pricing determined by the engagement ring's price). Without this plan, you're out of luck if something goes wrong with your ring.

Quality issues and customer complaints

Jared faces significant criticism regarding the quality of its jewelry, especially engagement rings. Common complaints include rings breaking, stones falling out, and poor overall craftsmanship. Customer service often fails to resolve these issues in a way that leaves anyone feeling very satisfied. Despite Signet Jewelers' high BBB rating, Jared's reputation in particular suffers due to numerous negative reviews.

Look elsewhere for engagement rings

While Jared offers a wide selection of engagement rings and some appealing services, the quality and customer service issues make it our last-place choice. You're better off exploring other jewelers on our list that have better reputations for the quality of their rings and for their overall customer support. Jared gets a lower rating, and even that feels like we're being kind, given the consistent negative feedback this retailer has received.