Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Feather Bed Stores

Where is the Best Place to Buy Feather Beds and Mattress Toppers?

A crucial part of one's health that, is often overlooked, is the quality of sleep you get each night. If you're not sleeping on a comfortable mattress that caters to the needs of your body, you will likely suffer from a lack of sleep or sore, stiff muscles in the morning. This negatively affects not only your physical health but also your emotional and mental well-being.

Everyone deserves a good night's sleep to rejuvenate from a long day and feel rested upon awakening. If you aren't loving the mattress you sleep on, it may seem daunting to buy a whole new high-quality one when you look at the cost. Luckily, there are workarounds that make it so you can feel amazing in your bed without having to replace the mattress you already have.

Friday, July 19th

2024 Feather Bed Store Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Overstock Review 5 Star Rating


5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping
  • Receive 15% off with email signup
  • "A+" Better Business Bureau rating
  • Unfiltered product ratings
  • Closeout prices
  • 30-day return policy
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Overstock is an internet retailer that primarily sells furniture, but you'll also find home improvement items, decor, lighting, jewelry, and more. The company began as a small start-up in 1999 in Midvale, Utah and is now a billion-dollar online retailer that provides a huge selection of closeout merchandise to customers at below-wholesale prices. If you're looking for feather beds, mattress toppers, or nearly any other type of home furnishings, you will find it at Overstock.

Bigger selection than most

You could really buy everything you need for a full room and bedding makeover at Overstock. Their categories include mattresses, blankets, bath and towels, comforter sets, pillows, and yes, feather mattress pads and toppers. There are 24 options to choose from, but if you want to quickly narrow these down you can shop by price, delivery, materials, colors, brands, styles, product features, customer ratings, thickness, and availability.

Unbeatable prices

When you see the low prices at Overstock, it makes you wonder why you would spend more on a similar product somewhere else. Since you're buying closeout items, Overstock can offer everything in their inventory at a low cost and still maintain high quality. If you're unsure about a certain mattress topper or feather bed, it helps that you can read unfiltered, honest customer reviews on nearly every product. These attest to the comfort, durability, and delivery process of the product to help you decide whether it's worth it or not.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Plenty of helpful information

Overstock does a good job of ensuring you have plenty of information before making a purchase. You can view multiple product photos from different angles, read buyer reviews, read a description of the mattress topper, see all the important features, learn the dimensions, and see what materials it's made of. You can also compare mattress toppers with similar items that could be of interest to you.

30-day return policy

Under the return policy here, customers have 30 days to return purchases for a full refund. You'll need to create a free account with Overstock to initiate your return (you'll create this during order checkout) and fill out a form to get instructions on moving forward. However, if the bedding you purchase from Overstock doesn't give you a good night's sleep, you're out of luck since products need to be returned in new, unused condition with tags attached. This means you can't have slept on the bedding, which makes it hard to know if you'll be satisfied or not.

Product reviews tell the story

Overstock has a high "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. They have their fair share of upset customer reviews, which is unfortunate, but not entirely surprising since Overstock is such a big, widely-shopped company. Complaints vary over a range of issues or products that don't necessarily relate to the quality of the feather bed or mattress topper you would get here. They also have a lot of customers who love their products and prices. If you want a big selection of feather beds and mattress toppers at affordable prices with plenty of information to confidently shop online, this is the best place to do it.

Down and Feather Company Review 4.5 Star Rating

Down and Feather Company

4.5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping on orders over $150
  • 30-night return policy
  • Made in the USA
  • Certified organic products
  • 10-year limited warranty

Based out of Woodlands, Texas, Down and Feather Company designs and manufactures all their own products made-to-order. They source Egyptian textiles and Hungarian goose down to make all of their bedding. Their full list of products include down and feather pillows, comforters, duvets, feather beds, and pillow accessories.

Only 3 choices

Surprisingly, Down and Feather Company has one of the smallest selections of mattress toppers and feather beds of any other retailer we saw. There are only 3 choices (plus 3 types of feather bed protectors) - an 800 fill goose down mattress topper, a 700 fill goose down mattress topper, and a 25% down 75% feather-filled bed. The first two options have a couple customer reviews, but oddly enough you can't view what the buyers said about the product. All the products are made in the USA, allergen-free, certified organic, and meet high quality standards, so even though the selection is slim, you can tell you'll be getting a good product here.

Pricey selection, free shipping

When you reach Down and Feather Company's website, they have a virtual wheel you can spin to win either a pillow spray, sleep shirt, pillow protector, or 10% off. If you enter your email for their subscription list, you'll also receive a coupon code for 10% off your order. When you spend at least $150 on your order, you'll get free shipping. You'll definitely qualify if you're buying a feather bed or mattress topper here since your cheapest option is $950 and it goes up to $1,572. Since there are only 3 choices, customers should plan on spending about $1,000 at a minimum.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Try it for 30 nights

The mattress toppers and feather beds from Down and Feather Company come with a 30-night comfort guarantee as well as a 10-year limited warranty. If you're not happy with your purchase by night 30, you can go to Down and Feather Company's website, provide your order number and zip code, and initiate a return for a refund.

A luxurious choice

Whether you have a twin, queen, king, or California king bed, the mattress toppers and feather beds from Down and Feather Company will work for you. Their small selection makes it easier to decide which product to choose and we are confident that all the options are high-quality. Since you can return the feather bed or mattress topper within 30 days, you really don't have anything to lose. Their customer reviews are positive and since shipping is free, this company is a good option for finding luxurious sleeping solutions. Down and Feather Company has earned a high rating from us.

Plumeria Bay Review 4 Star Rating

Plumeria Bay

4 Star Rating
  • "A+" Better Business Bureau rating
  • 30-day return policy on items in new, unused condition
  • 5-year warranty
  • Free shipping on orders over $200

Plumeria Bay is a family-owned business that was founded by a father and daughter duo in 2002. Their goal was to fill a need they saw for well-made goose down bedding. The company sells down comforters, pillows, feather beds, and bed linens that they manufacture themselves.

5-year warranty

We'll start off by stating the obvious that Plumeria Bay's website needs some work: it is outdated but still gets the job done. You can view any of the 3 feather bed options and read about the details, fabric, fills, care instructions, guarantee, and customer reviews. The beds come with a 5-year warranty, which means they are guaranteed to be free of defects in materials and workmanship during that time.

Few product reviews

It's usually really helpful when a retailer lets customers come back and leave reviews about the products they sell, but there are so few here that it's hard to get a really solid grasp on how satisfied people generally are. In addition, some of the reviews are nearly 10 years old, which tells us this either isn't a very popular place to buy feather beds or people just don't bother leaving feedback afterwards. From the 7 total customer reviews that we found, it appears that these feather beds are comfortable, come in a timely manner, and meet expectations.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Expect high quality

Plumeria Bay offers free shipping for orders over $200 and a flat fee of $10 for orders less than that. The feather beds usually ship within 2-4 weeks. The cost of feather beds range from $620 to $3,300 depending on the size of your bed and fill type. With these prices, you can expect a high-quality feather bed that hopefully lasts a long time.

Return items in unused condition

If you change your mind about your feather bed or mattress topper from Plumeria Bay, you can return it within 30 days of receipt and they'll issue you a full refund. However, feather beds will incur a 10% handling charge due to their size and the cost of shipping will be deducted from your refund. Everything has to be returned in its original, unused condition, so you won't be able to try out your topper before deciding whether or not you like it.

Good choice

Even though Plumeria Bay has a slim selection of feather beds, this is their specialty. You'll have to be a bit patient waiting for them to ship after purchase, but if you're willing to commit to a luxurious, high quality feather bed, it will be worth it. Customer service is easy to work with and the company has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. This is a good place to look for a feather bed and you'll also have the choice of 3 types of feather bed protectors as well.

Pacific Coast Review 3.5 Star Rating

Pacific Coast

3.5 Star Rating
  • 10% off with email signup
  • Free shipping on orders over $99
  • 30-night comfort guarantee

Pacific Coast has been in the bedding industry since 1884 providing comforters, pillows, feather beds, and premium European down alternative products. They boast that they are the #1 brand of down and feather bedding in the United States and the leading supplier of premium down pillows to hotels. The company is located in Boca Raton, Florida.

5 choices

The three types of feather beds at Pacific Coast include a hotel feather bed, a baffle box feather bed, and what they call a "down on top" feather bed. They sell 2 types of mattress pads as well. This isn't a huge range of choices, but they come in twin, full, queen, king, and California king sizes. Each listing gives detailed information about the fabric, fill, dimensions, country of origin, warranty (3 year limited), and how to care for your mattress topper.

Get the most out of your purchase

If you're wondering how to choose the best feather bed or wanting to make sure you know how to care for it, Pacific Coast has a helpful FAQ page that outlines everything you need to know. Washing, care, storage, and setup details are outlined to make sure you get the most out of your feather bed or mattress topper and that it lasts as long as possible.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Inexpensive mattress toppers

The prices of feather beds and mattress toppers from Pacific Coast indicate that you are probably getting something that will be comfortable for a while, but this isn't top-of-the-line quality. The prices are definitely affordable at just over $100, but usually you get what you pay for. We wish they had customer reviews on products to indicate how comfortable the feather beds and toppers are here. Something to consider is that when you sign up to receive emails from Pacific Coast, you'll get a code for 10% off your next order and if you spend over $99, you'll get free shipping.

Comfort guarantee

Pacific Coast has a 30-night comfort guarantee to make sure customers are completely satisfied with their purchases. If the feather bed or mattress topper isn't working as hoped, you have 30 days from receipt to initiate a return and be refunded (less the return shipping fee).

Affordable, functional solution

There aren't product reviews or unfiltered customer ratings on Pacific Coast's website. It's hard to find a lot of feedback about the company, though the few things we've seen indicate that people are generally satisfied after shopping here. Pacific Coast is more well-known for their pillows, so a lot of customer reviews found elsewhere revolve around these products. If you're looking for something comfortable without having to spend a lot of money, Pacific Coast is a good place to look for feather beds and mattress toppers. Some of their competitors have longer warranties and more luxury-driven features, but that may not be necessary for everyone. If you're just looking for a quick fix to make your bed more comfortable, you might have luck shopping here.

Bed Bath & Beyond Review 3 Star Rating

Bed Bath & Beyond

3 Star Rating
  • 20% off coupons available with email signup
  • Free shipping on orders over $39
  • Free in-store pickup
  • Price match guarantee
  • 90-day return policy
  • Honest product reviews

Bed Bath & Beyond is an American chain of retail stores that specializes in selling home goods. You'll find bedding, kitchen items, dining furniture, storage and cleaning essentials, outdoor products, home decor, and much more. They operate over 1,500 brick-and-mortar stores throughout the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Puerto Rico. Bed Bath & Beyond is counted among the Forbes Global 2000 and the Fortune 500.

Sufficient selection

There are 29 options to choose from when you're searching for feather beds and mattress toppers from Bed Bath & Beyond. Most of them come in a few sizes, so if you find one you like, you'll likely be able to find a fit for a twin, full, queen, king, or California king bed. All the options are in white or off-white colors and some are gel, while others are memory foam, plush, or even temperature-controlled.

Save 20%

Bed Bath and Beyond offers 20% off any single item if you sign up to receive their emails. This is a great way to save a bit of money, especially if you're buying a mattress topper that costs a few hundred dollars. Most of the mattress toppers fall in the $101 - $200 range and all mattresses qualify for free shipping since Bed Bath & Beyond offers that on purchases of $39 or more. You could also opt for a free in-store or curbside pickup if you live near a Bed Bath & Beyond store that has your topper in-stock. If you find an item through Bed Bath & Beyond that's identical to one sold by a competitor for a lower price, they'll match it to give you the best deal possible.

Best Feather Bed Stores

90-day returns on unused items

You can return items to Bed Bath & Beyond's stores or by mail. They offer free returns on most items, which is nice. If your mattress topper arrives and isn't what you expected, you'll have up to 90 days to exchange or return it. As long as you provide the receipt and return your items in new, unused condition, you'll qualify for a full refund.

Long list of customer complaints

Bed Bath & Beyond has a lousy "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau because of failure to respond to some customer complaints and a lack of resolution on others. Their customer reviews aren't helping their case at all either. People complain of canceled orders, slow shipping without tracking information, difficulty getting help from customer service, damaged items upon arrival, and a laundry list of other issues.

Try curbside pickup

We trust that the actual quality of the mattress toppers from Bed Bath & Beyond are good quality since the customer reviews on the products are mostly high. However, because of customer complaints, we recommend buying online and doing curbside pickup (if possible) so you can make sure you get what you want in a timely manner from Bed Bath & Beyond.

The Company Store Review 2.5 Star Rating

The Company Store

2.5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping on orders over $75
  • 90-day returns
  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Save 20% with email signup
  • Refer a friend and save 25%

The Company Store has over 100 years of expertise in producing down comforters, down pillows, and down-filled feather beds. They boast that their products have a lighter-than-air feel and are made of the best materials from Europe, Turkey, Egypt, and the USA.

Few feather bed size options

The four choices of feather beds at The Company Store are very basic, and all of them look nearly the same. Unfortunately, some only come in twin/king or twin/queen sizes. Only one of the feather beds has options for twin, full, queen, and king beds. Luckily, that style also happens to have the highest customer ratings.

Possibly biased customer feedback

Customers can submit feedback about the feather beds giving it a 1-5 star rating, leaving a comment about the quality, and stating whether or not they would recommend it to others. Many of the reviews were left within the last few weeks and are mostly 5 out of 5 stars - but we noticed they were also done as part of sweepstakes entry, which could have made them biased.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Save 20% plus free shipping

The Company Store offers 20% off of your order if you provide your email address to receive insider exclusives from the company. You can also save 25% on a purchase by referring a friend who makes a purchase (they'll also get 25% off). If you're spending over $75 then you'll qualify for free shipping. All the feather beds range from $89 to $679. If the feather bed you are interested in is in stock, it will ship within 1-2 business days.

Lifetime guarantee

Something impressive about The Company Store is that they offer a lifetime guarantee on their feather beds. You can return your bedding at any time and receive a store credit or exchange. The only exception to this is if there is visible staining like pet stains, food stains, or bodily fluids because they void the guarantee. They also have a "rest-easy guarantee" so you can sleep on your feather bed, wash it, and enjoy it (without damaging it, of course), and return it within 90 days if you are unhappy. You'll get a refund via your original payment method minus a $2.95 processing fee per item.

Major issues in recent years

Chances are, you might not even find a feather bed you want that fits the size of your bed here since the options are so slim. If you do, we like that you'll be able to rely on the company's lifetime guarantee and 90-day return policy. Based on some surprisingly low customer reviews of The Company Store this might come in handy. A concerning number of people claim their orders got severely backordered and they didn't receive email updates or proactive information from customer service about them. Shoppers in past years said this retailer was reliable, but they seem to have gone downhill more recently and have major problems with inventory and delivery. This would be an extremely frustrating experience after spending hundreds of dollars on a feather bed. Because of this, The Company Store has earned one of our lower rankings.

Cuddledown Review 1.5 Star Rating


1.5 Star Rating
  • 100% guarantee
  • Unfiltered product reviews
  • Bedding experts since 1973
  • Made in the USA
  • "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB

Cuddledown got their start in 1973 selling down comforters. Their product line now includes synthetic and down pillows, feather beds, sleepwear, bath accessories, blankets, sheets, furniture, and more. All of the products sold through Cuddledown are manufactured in Maine and the company promises that you'll only get the finest in home furnishings, making them the "premier source for all things cozy."

Slim selection

For a company that specializes in bedding and started out selling comforters, we are surprised that there are only 11 options for feather beds. Of the 11 options, 3 of them are feather bed "protectors" , meaning you really only have 8 options. Most of the options come in twin, full, queen, and king sizes and you can check whether or not the size you need is in-stock by clicking on it in the individual product page. You'll be able to read an overview of the product, see a list of certifications, and view a size guide if you need one.

Expensive shipping

When looking at the small selection of feather beds, we noticed that all of them are on sale. All of the toppers were marked down about $50 or $60 with the least expensive option being $194 and the most expensive coming in at $1,784. We wanted more transparency about the cost of shipping because you have to go all the way through the checkout process to see it. Standard shipping was at least $50 for any given item, which seems sky high compared to other retailers who often offer free shipping. This was a huge deterrent for us.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Unspecified return window

All the products at Cuddledown are backed by their 100% guarantee. This means if you aren't completely satisfied with the quality of your mattress topper you can exchange it or get a full refund. However, they don't include a timeframe in which you need to send your products back, which is kind of odd. Their FedEx self-service option allows you to print a prepaid return label and send your order back, but don't be surprised when $10.50 is deducted from your refund or charged to your credit card for shipping.

Old but unfiltered product reviews

We appreciate that customers can leave reviews on the feather beds from Cuddledown. Most products have at least a few and they are generally positive. However, we did notice that the majority of reviews were left 4 or 5 years ago, which is disappointing. In that amount of time, quality, company policies, and overall customer satisfaction can change, so although the reviews are unfiltered, they aren't entirely helpful.

Surprisingly poor customer ratings

The Better Business Bureau gives Cuddledown an "A+" rating and accreditation. That was a shock, because the customer reviews out there for Cuddledown are frightening: we found many reviews from people who gave the company a 1 out of 5 star rating. A few of the common issues people have with Cuddledown include high shipping costs, incorrect order deliveries, jumping through hoops to get in contact with customer service, items damaged in transit, low-quality products, and more. This is more than enough reason for us to steer clear of Cuddledown and we recommend that you do the same.

The Down Store Review 1 Star Rating

The Down Store

1 Star Rating
  • Hypo-allergenic options
  • Lots of bed size options
  • Prices ranging from $400 to $3,500

The Down Store was born in 1973 after the founders discovered the luxury of a down comforter inside a duvet cover when they were visiting a hotel in Europe. They discovered upon arriving back in the United States that they could find nothing like it, so they set out to create custom down comforters, feather beds, and bed toppers. Their signature brands include Snowgoose and BodyCloud.

High-quality items, low-quality website

The Down Store boasts that by buying their products you can stay warm and comfortable at night while saving money on energy bills and keeping your heat down. Not only is this a healthier way to sleep, but their products are also natural and their Snowgoose line is hypo-allergenic. There are 4 options for feather beds for sale that are displayed confusingly on The Down Store's poorly designed website. Nevertheless, they are there for the ordering.

A pain to order anything here

Unfortunately, the ordering process is not as easy as it should be. Rather than adding a feather bed to your cart and buying it right away like most other stores offer, you have to either call customer service to order, send them an email, or fill out an order form on the website with your name, email, and order information. The Down Store does not accept credit cards, which is really old-school. You'll need to send them a check or money order to pay for your feather bed.

4 feather bed options

The cost for a feather bed from The Down Store varies slightly, so you should be able to find something in your budget. One of the options only comes in queen and king sizes but winds up in the $400 range. Their puffy 50/50 down/feather bed comes in twin, full, queen, king, and California king sizes and ranges from $2,100 to $3,560. You could opt for a 25/75 down/feather option for a firmer feel ranging from $1,595 to $2,590. Last but not least, their European pillow style feather bed comes in all sizes and ranges from $2,095 to $3,390.

Best Feather Bed Stores

Sparse product details

You can't click on a product and get more information about it, which is another frustration to add to this archaic website. All you can see is the name of the bed, size, weight, and price. No customer reviews, no in-depth information about material, and nothing about shipping timeframes or cost. It doesn't seem like nearly enough details when they're charging a couple thousand dollars for a feather bed.

No return information

If you're unsatisfied with your feather bed from The Down Store, we don't know what to tell you. Nowhere does the company mention anything about a return or exchange policy, so don't plan on getting your money back if you're unhappy. Your best bet would be to contact customer service and hope they work with you on a case-by-case basis. It's disappointing that they don't mention such a basic company policy on their website.

Not impressed

The testimonials on The Down Store's website are mostly meaningless to us since they are all glowing and posted by the company themselves: as far as honest, unbiased feedback goes, you won't find that here. The Down Store does not have a rating from the Better Business Bureau, and based on the frequency of their blog posts (over a year ago) we imagine this company isn't thriving or very popular. They make customers jump through hoops to get information about their products and submit an order, so we don't see any reason to order a feather bed from them over another company. They've earned our lowest rating.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Using a feather bed or mattress topper will add a bonus layer of softness and provide more support for your body's pressure points (shoulders, hips, and back) to create maximum comfort. Feather beds and mattress toppers sit right on top of your current mattress and are usually covered with a fitted sheet.

There are hundreds of options for feather beds and mattress toppers available online, so the hard part is picking the one that is best for you. They range by size, fill quantity, material, brand, and, of course, cost. Shopping online lets you quickly search the features you want and compare pricing between retailers. Some companies let customers leave reviews on their products so you can get a good idea of quality, durability, and comfort before placing an order. You'll get your feather bed or mattress topper delivered right to your house so you can start sleeping better right away.

There are many companies that sell feather beds and mattress toppers, and we have provided important information for you to consider when deciding who to buy from:

  • Selection: Are there plenty of topper types to choose from that reflect the functionality you're looking for and fit your bed size? Be sure to find a company that offers a solid selection.
  • Cost: How does the cost of the bedding from one retailer compare to another? Do they carry a variety of brands that could fit different budgets? Are you able to qualify for free shipping if you make a minimum purchase?
  • Return policy: If the feather bed or mattress topper you purchase doesn't fit your bed like you hoped or isn't as comfortable as you expected, can you return it for a full refund? Does the company offer free returns or allow you to do in-store returns if you live close by? Be sure to review the return policy of a company before making a purchase.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best places to purchase feather beds and mattress toppers. We hope this information helps you find the products to help you get an amazing night's sleep and feel better every day!

The Best Feather Bed Stores Compare Feather Bed Stores Compare Feather Bed Store Reviews What are the best Feather Bed Stores Best Feather Bed Store Reviews

Feather Bed Store FAQ

Feather beds are a fluffy addition to your existing set-up. They're designed to go directly on top of your mattress, whether it's a basic foam style or even a pillow-top. As you'd imagine, they're made with feathers, usually goose down, and can give you extra softness and comfort when you settle in for a night's rest.
It definitely helps! Feather beds are similar to down comforters and are a great way to keep heat in during the colder months. The flipside of that is that a feather bed might not be a terrific option if you prefer to "sleep cool" , or if you live in a hot, humid climate.
Your first thought should be the size of your mattress: naturally, if you have a king-sized bed, you'll need a king-sized feather bed! Another consideration is whether the feather bed is baffle channel or baffle box: the first type of construction allows you to shift the feathers and down around (e.g. if you want extra padding or support by your head, feet, etc.), while the second keeps the feathers more in place. Baffle box is preferred by most people, because it requires you to fluff the feather bed less often.
You can use any kind of sheets you prefer. But, keep in mind that a feather bed adds around 6" to the height of your mattress. If the fitted sheets you're currently using have a hard time staying put, you may need to buy deeper ones to cover both your mattress and your feather bed.
To care for your feather bed, flip and fluff it regularly - as often as you change the sheets, preferably. It will last longer if you keep it covered with a fitted sheet or feather bed protector (which can be laundered). Should your feather bed get damp or wet, make sure it dries out completely or it might mildew or rot. Finally, your feather bed should not be washed at home! If spot cleaning isn't enough, you'll need to take it to a dry cleaner for professional care.
Not necessarily. You can find a budget-friendly feather bed for under $50. But, if you're looking for a well-constructed feather bed that will keep you comfortable for many years, expect to pay anywhere from $100 to $600, depending on the size of your bed and the retailer you choose.
Sometimes. The higher-end manufacturers may include a fantastic warranty of a year or longer, but be sure you follow all of the eligibility requirements (for example, using a feather bed protector, fluffing it frequently, and so on).
Most retailers of feather beds allow returns for unused products only. You may want to read customer reviews on any feather bed you're considering, to get a feel for how they hold up under actual use, before committing to a purchase. Also, some hotels use feather beds on their mattresses: if you get a great night's sleep while on vacation, ask what brand they used! You can probably buy the exact same one for your own bed from an online retailer.
The Best Reviews of Feather Bed Stores