The Best Feather Pillow Stores

Monday, October 14th

2024 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Down & Feather Company

At Down & Feather Company, their unwavering commitment to excellence shines through every aspect, from sourcing to crafting. Their feather pillows are meticulously made to order with Hungarian goose down and exquisite Egyptian linens. Prices range from $153 to $234, often with discounts. They stand out with unique benefits, including a one-time density adjustment within a year, a 30-day return policy, and a ten-year warranty. The initial cost you'll pay for your pillows here is justified by the quality and longevity, backed by plenty of positive customer reviews, which should make Down & Feather Company your top choice for feather pillows.

Macy's

Macy's might not be your first thought when searching for feather pillows, but it offers a surprisingly extensive selection, featuring over 600 options. You'll find a broad range of prices, from under $40 for budget-friendly styles to as high as $1,699 for a set of two premium pillows. Macy's provides free shipping on orders over $49 plus the option for in-store pickup, and most products come with a 90-day return window. With its terrific selection and customer-friendly return policy, Macy's comes in high on our list among stores offering feather pillows.

Pillows

Pillows, a family-owned business originally known as Pacific Pillows, has been delivering luxury hotel bedding to homes since 2004. Their user-friendly website lets you easily browse through their selection of around 60 feather pillows, with prices ranging from $84.99 to $224.99. You can even shop by hotel brand if you want to recreate a recent travel experience. Pillows offers frequent discounts and clearance specials, free shipping on orders over $99, and a solid return policy, with a 30-day refund or a 90-day exchange option. Their "A+" rating and numerous positive customer reviews make Pillows an excellent choice for your feather pillow shopping.

Wayfair

Wayfair, the go-to home goods store for a variety of needs, offers a treasure trove of over 350 feather pillows, with prices spanning from $36.99 to $1391. Customer reviews play a pivotal role here, with highly-rated options from Pillow Guy, Pillow Gal, and Arsuite. Additionally, free shipping for orders over $35 and a 30-day return policy sweeten the deal. While Wayfair may lack the specialized expertise and satisfaction guarantees found in pillow-focused stores, its broad range of home products and its accreditation with an "A+" rating from the BBB make it a convenient and reliable choice for most shoppers seeking feather pillows and much more for their homes.

Walmart

Walmart might not be your first thought for feather pillows, but it's a great option thanks to its partnership with third-party sellers. With over 1,000 choices, their user-friendly filters make shopping easy (and that will help you avoid some of the non-pillow results that sneak in there). Walmart accommodates all budgets, with down pillows for under $10 and over $200, and shipping or in-store pickup is usually free. With a generous return window of 30 or 90 days, Walmart is a surprisingly good choice for feather pillows, offering a wide selection, competitive pricing, and everything you'll need for a good night's sleep.

Bed Bath & Beyond

Bed Bath and Beyond has been transformed after being acquired by Overstock, offering a familiar online shopping experience under its new surface. Although they provide an extensive selection of over 1,800 feather pillows, most are for decoration, and only about 125 options are suited for sleep. Given the recent changes, we're cautiously optimistic and recommend ordering from Bed Bath and Beyond if you find a perfect pillow, but suggest that you also consider retailers with a more stable history if you're looking for a sure thing.

The Company Store

Established in 1911 in Wisconsin, The Company Store initially served Scandinavian immigrants looking for warmth during cold Midwest winters, and it's been under The Home Depot's ownership since 2017. Their feather pillow selection includes 18 choices, ranging from the budget-friendly to the high-end, and many pillows have hundreds of 4- and 5-star ratings from shoppers. While they offer a generous try-it-out 30-day return policy and free shipping on orders over $75, mixed shopper feedback offsite gives us pause with respect to pillow quality and service. The Company Store isn't the best or the worst, so you might want to shop at other feather pillow retailers first.

Pillow Decor

Pillow Decor, a Canada-based retailer, specializes in chic decorative throw pillows and cushions for North American customers, making it a great choice for adding creative patterns and style to your home decor. They provide a variety of feather pillows, priced between $20.95 and $45.95, and you can buy covers separately for customization. However, their customer perks are limited, shipping costs $7.99 flat, and their 15-day return policy is less than generous. Although they have an "A+" rating with the BBB, there's minimal customer feedback available. If you're primarily looking for bedroom feather pillows, Pillow Decor's emphasis on decorative pillows and its limited returns policy may not be the best choice.

United Feather & Down

United Feather & Down, a company tracing its history back to 1797, offers a limited selection of 10 feather and down-alternative pillows on their website, with prices ranging from $35.99 to $239.99. Despite having an "A-" rating from the BBB and a handful of positive reviews, the scarce feedback on pillows and small inventory raise concerns. Plus, their 10-day return window offers no refunds for items purchased with sale or discount codes, and free shipping is only available on orders exceeding $250. Ultimately, the limited choices, restricted return policy, and lack of substantial feedback make United Feather & Down less appealing compared to other retailers on our list.

Pacific Coast Feather

With over 125 years of experience, Pacific Coast Feather is well-known for their feather pillows, often found in luxury hotels. They offer a range of choices, from the high-end Hungarian White Goose Down model to more budget-friendly options like the Euro Pillow, with free shipping for orders over $75 within the lower 48 states. However, customer reviews on individual items are no longer available, and a past Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing raises uncertainty about warranty claims and refunds. Recent customer complaints indicate your purchase may even come from other retailers or different brands. Despite an "A-” from the BBB, Pacific Coast Feather's reputation keeps them from earning a high ranking with us.