Feather Pillow Stores Reviews

Who's better?

Bed Bath & Beyond vs the Company Store

We've analyzed the best Feather Pillow Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Here you can see how Bed Bath & Beyond and The Company Store match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Feather Pillow Stores in 2025.

Winner

Bed Bath & Beyond

  • Over 1,800 feather pillows in inventory
  • 200+ pillows for sleeping
  • Acquired by Overstock

Bed Bath and Beyond has been transformed after being acquired by Overstock, offering a familiar online shopping experience under its new surface. Although they provide an extensive selection of over 1,800 feather pillows, most are for decoration, and only about 125 options are suited for sleep. Given the recent changes, we're cautiously optimistic and recommend ordering from Bed Bath and Beyond if you find a perfect pillow, but suggest that you also consider retailers with a more stable history if you're looking for a sure thing.

The Company Store

  • 18 feather and down pillows to choose from
  • Prices range from $30 to $449
  • Free shipping on orders of $75+

Established in 1911 in Wisconsin, The Company Store initially served Scandinavian immigrants looking for warmth during cold Midwest winters, and it's been under The Home Depot's ownership since 2017. Their feather pillow selection includes 18 choices, ranging from the budget-friendly to the high-end, and many pillows have hundreds of 4- and 5-star ratings from shoppers. While they offer a generous try-it-out 30-day return policy and free shipping on orders over $75, mixed shopper feedback offsite gives us pause with respect to pillow quality and service. The Company Store isn't the best or the worst, so you might want to shop at other feather pillow retailers first.

There's a reason why the world's top hotels and resorts feature feather pillows. First and foremost, they are renowned for their exceptional comfort. The natural softness of feathers, typically sourced from ducks or geese, provides a plush and supportive sleeping experience. Plus, the ability of feathers to conform to the contours of your head and neck allows for a restful night's sleep and relief from pressure points, promoting a good night's rest.

When it comes to purchasing feather pillows, there are several advantages to buying them online over traditional stores. Online shopping offers a wide variety of options, allowing you to choose from different sizes, fill levels, and cover materials to suit your sleeping style or your decor. You typically get detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and competitive pricing, so it's easier to find the perfect feather pillow for your comfort and design requirements.

Feather pillows are also celebrated for their longevity. High-quality feather pillows can last for many years, maintaining their shape and support even with regular use. This durability makes them a cost-effective choice in the long run compared to some other pillow materials that tend to lose their shape and support over time.

When it comes to home interior, feather pillows have long been a popular choice in the world of bedding and interior design. These pillows offer a unique combination of comfort, durability, and aesthetic appeal, making them a preferred choice for many.

Interior decorators often choose feather pillows for their aesthetic appeal and versatility. Feather pillows have a timeless and classic look, making them a perfect fit for various interior design styles. They add a touch of luxury and coziness to bedrooms, living rooms, and other spaces. The plump appearance of feather pillows can instantly elevate the visual appeal of a room: a valuable addition to any interior design project.

If you're looking for feather pillows, you may be surprised that there are vast differences in quality, price, and reliability. To help determine where you should buy feather pillows online, consider the following:

To help you get a dreamy night's sleep (or the perfect finishing touches for your latest decorating project), the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have evaluated and ranked the most popular retailers of feather pillows. Happy shopping!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Feather Pillow Store FAQ

What is a feather pillow?
As the name suggests, a feather pillow is filled with at least 51% feathers, usually sourced from geese. They have a very different feel compared to regular pillows, often offering a much more comfortable night's rest. That's why you'll find feather pillows in high-end hotels and resorts.
What are the different types of feather pillows?
Feather pillows are classified by their blend of feathers and down. You can get pillows that are 100% feathers, a blend of 75/25, and so on. You can also find differences in the shell material, ranging from Egyptian cotton to 100% organic (but either way, you'll probably have your pillow in a pillowcase).
I'm a (side, back, stomach) sleeper. Is there a feather pillow for me?
Of course! Just like regular pillows, feather pillows come in a wide range of support levels. You'll have no trouble finding one that offers just the right amount no matter how you tend to sleep. Some retailers of feather pillows offer density adjustments if you get yours delivered and have a Goldilocks-type experience of "too much support" or "not supportive enough" - they'll tweak it until you say it's just right.
How do I clean my feather pillows?
The best approach is to never need to wash it, by using pillow protectors in addition to pillowcases. Why? Washing a feather pillow can make the feathers and down more brittle, due to the feathers' natural oils being stripped away. And, if you don't dry your pillow properly after washing it (in cold water, never hot), it could wind up smelling terrible. Consider putting on a proper-fitting pillow protector and pillowcase before you use your feather pillows for the first time.
How long do feather pillows last?
Good news: with proper care, your pillows should last anywhere from 5-10 years (or longer!). The more you keep them protected from moisture and body oils, the more life you can expect to get from them. That's a lot longer than the 1-2 years that most synthetic pillows last.
When should I replace my pillows?
If you've taken the steps to keep your feather pillows clean, you should only need to replace them when they no longer offer the support you need. If you're constantly fluffing them, or if you fold them in half and they don't expand back to full size, it might be time to get new ones.
Are feather pillows expensive?
They can be: you'll find super high-end pillows priced at over $400. On the other hand, it's possible to find basic feather pillows for under $20. Keep in mind that they can last many years longer than synthetic pillows, giving you a better return on your bedding "investment".
Can I return my feather pillows if I don't like them?
That depends on where you buy them from. Some retailers have extremely generous return policies, letting you use the feather pillows for up to 8 months before deciding if you want to get a refund. But, most stores expect the pillows to be in unused condition to be eligible for a return, so be sure to use a pillow protector right away in order to keep them in like-new shape.

Compare Any 2 Products

Down & Feather Company
Macy's
Pillows
Wayfair
Walmart
Bed Bath & Beyond
The Company Store
Pillow Decor
United Feather & Down
Pacific Coast Feather
vs
Down & Feather Company vs Macy'sDown & Feather Company vs PillowsDown & Feather Company vs WayfairDown & Feather Company vs WalmartDown & Feather Company vs Bed Bath & BeyondDown & Feather Company vs The Company StoreDown & Feather Company vs Pillow DecorDown & Feather Company vs United Feather & DownDown & Feather Company vs Pacific Coast FeatherMacy's vs PillowsMacy's vs WayfairMacy's vs WalmartMacy's vs Bed Bath & BeyondMacy's vs The Company StoreMacy's vs Pillow DecorMacy's vs United Feather & DownMacy's vs Pacific Coast FeatherPillows vs WayfairPillows vs WalmartPillows vs Bed Bath & BeyondPillows vs The Company StorePillows vs Pillow DecorPillows vs United Feather & DownPillows vs Pacific Coast FeatherWayfair vs WalmartWayfair vs Bed Bath & BeyondWayfair vs The Company StoreWayfair vs Pillow DecorWayfair vs United Feather & DownWayfair vs Pacific Coast FeatherWalmart vs Bed Bath & BeyondWalmart vs The Company StoreWalmart vs Pillow DecorWalmart vs United Feather & DownWalmart vs Pacific Coast FeatherBed Bath & Beyond vs The Company StoreBed Bath & Beyond vs Pillow DecorBed Bath & Beyond vs United Feather & DownBed Bath & Beyond vs Pacific Coast FeatherThe Company Store vs Pillow DecorThe Company Store vs United Feather & DownThe Company Store vs Pacific Coast FeatherPillow Decor vs United Feather & DownPillow Decor vs Pacific Coast FeatherUnited Feather & Down vs Pacific Coast Feather Pacific Coast Feather vs United Feather & DownPacific Coast Feather vs Pillow DecorPacific Coast Feather vs The Company StorePacific Coast Feather vs Bed Bath & BeyondPacific Coast Feather vs WalmartPacific Coast Feather vs WayfairPacific Coast Feather vs PillowsPacific Coast Feather vs Macy'sPacific Coast Feather vs Down & Feather CompanyUnited Feather & Down vs Pillow DecorUnited Feather & Down vs The Company StoreUnited Feather & Down vs Bed Bath & BeyondUnited Feather & Down vs WalmartUnited Feather & Down vs WayfairUnited Feather & Down vs PillowsUnited Feather & Down vs Macy'sUnited Feather & Down vs Down & Feather CompanyPillow Decor vs The Company StorePillow Decor vs Bed Bath & BeyondPillow Decor vs WalmartPillow Decor vs WayfairPillow Decor vs PillowsPillow Decor vs Macy'sPillow Decor vs Down & Feather CompanyThe Company Store vs Bed Bath & BeyondThe Company Store vs WalmartThe Company Store vs WayfairThe Company Store vs PillowsThe Company Store vs Macy'sThe Company Store vs Down & Feather CompanyBed Bath & Beyond vs WalmartBed Bath & Beyond vs WayfairBed Bath & Beyond vs PillowsBed Bath & Beyond vs Macy'sBed Bath & Beyond vs Down & Feather CompanyWalmart vs WayfairWalmart vs PillowsWalmart vs Macy'sWalmart vs Down & Feather CompanyWayfair vs PillowsWayfair vs Macy'sWayfair vs Down & Feather CompanyPillows vs Macy'sPillows vs Down & Feather CompanyMacy's vs Down & Feather Company
See the Best Feather Pillow Stores in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

House Digest on MSN

What Are Down Alternative Pillows? (And The Benefits And Drawbacks ...

Down or down alternative? Before you decide which type of pillow to buy, check out these pluses and minuses to each type to choose what's best for you.

Sat, 08 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Metro on MSN

Why it’s essential to pack a feather pillow in your carry-on luggage

A long-haul flight can be a major undertaking. At the very least, you need snacks, a big, cosy jumper, and a pair of earplugs to get through it. Many travellers also opt for a neck pillow — but ...

Sat, 08 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Forbes

The 7 Best Hotel Pillows To Enjoy Five-Star Sleep At Home

You’re not just imagining it: Hotel bedding feels much more luxurious than what most of us are used to at home. That’s partially because the best hotel pillows are chosen with versatility in mind; ...

Fri, 02 May 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Healthline

15 Hotel Pillows for Luxurious Sleep

If you’ve ever stayed in a high end hotel and enjoyed truly blissful sleep, you may have chalked it up to the luxurious linens and that dreamy pillow. And you may not be wrong. Since hotels host ...

Mon, 30 May 2022

Only the Best Reviews

Forbes

Home Sweet Hotel, Part 4: The Best Hotel Pillows, In Every Category, ...

If you're having trouble sleeping through this unusual time, the perfect pillow may be the first step toward achieving better-than-ever rest. Home Sweet Hotel is a six-part series highlighting the ...

Sun, 26 Apr 2020

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

The Secret To Getting Rid Of Those Yellow Stains On Your Pillows + ...

Plush, fresh pillows are a dream! Keeping them clean? May feel more like a nightmare. Though guidelines say the average pillow only needs a wash one every four to six months (or three to four times ...

Wed, 04 Oct 2023

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.