Pillows vs Wayfair for March 2025 | Best Feather Pillow Stores

Item: Pillows vs Wayfair
Rating: 4
Author: Top Consumer Reviews

Tuesday, March 18th

2025 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Pillows

Specializes in feather pillows used in top hotels and resorts
About 60 feather pillows to choose from
Prices range from $84.99 to $224.99
Free shipping on orders over $99
30-day returns
90-day exchanges
"A” rated and accredited by the BBB

Pillows, a family-owned business originally known as Pacific Pillows, has been delivering luxury hotel bedding to homes since 2004. Their user-friendly website lets you easily browse through their selection of around 60 feather pillows, with prices ranging from $84.99 to $224.99. You can even shop by hotel brand if you want to recreate a recent travel experience. Pillows offers frequent discounts and clearance specials, free shipping on orders over $99, and a solid return policy, with a 30-day refund or a 90-day exchange option. Their "A+" rating and numerous positive customer reviews make Pillows an excellent choice for your feather pillow shopping.

Read Full Review

Visit Store

Wayfair

Over 350 feather bed pillows
Prices range from $36.99 (for two pillows) to $1,391
Free shipping on orders over $35
30-day returns
Lots of shopper reviews to consider
"A+” rated and accredited by the BBB

Wayfair, the go-to home goods store for a variety of needs, offers a treasure trove of over 350 feather pillows, with prices spanning from $36.99 to $1391. Customer reviews play a pivotal role here, with highly-rated options from Pillow Guy, Pillow Gal, and Arsuite. Additionally, free shipping for orders over $35 and a 30-day return policy sweeten the deal. While Wayfair may lack the specialized expertise and satisfaction guarantees found in pillow-focused stores, its broad range of home products and its accreditation with an "A+" rating from the BBB make it a convenient and reliable choice for most shoppers seeking feather pillows and much more for their homes.

Read Full Review

Visit Store

Read Full Review

Visit Store

Read Full Review

Visit Store

The 10 Best Feather Pillow Stores

Down & Feather Company

Macy's

Pillows

Wayfair

Walmart

Bed Bath & Beyond

The Company Store

Pillow Decor

United Feather & Down

Pacific Coast Feather

Where Can You Buy the Best Feather Pillows?

There's a reason why the world's top hotels and resorts feature feather pillows. First and foremost, they are renowned for their exceptional comfort. The natural softness of feathers, typically sourced from ducks or geese, provides a plush and supportive sleeping experience. Plus, the ability of feathers to conform to the contours of your head and neck allows for a restful night's sleep and relief from pressure points, promoting a good night's rest.

When it comes to purchasing feather pillows, there are several advantages to buying them online over traditional stores. Online shopping offers a wide variety of options, allowing you to choose from different sizes, fill levels, and cover materials to suit your sleeping style or your decor. You typically get detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and competitive pricing, so it's easier to find the perfect feather pillow for your comfort and design requirements.

Continue reading below

Feather Pillow Store FAQ

What is a feather pillow?

As the name suggests, a feather pillow is filled with at least 51% feathers, usually sourced from geese. They have a very different feel compared to regular pillows, often offering a much more comfortable night's rest. That's why you'll find feather pillows in high-end hotels and resorts.

What are the different types of feather pillows?

Feather pillows are classified by their blend of feathers and down. You can get pillows that are 100% feathers, a blend of 75/25, and so on. You can also find differences in the shell material, ranging from Egyptian cotton to 100% organic (but either way, you'll probably have your pillow in a pillowcase).

I'm a (side, back, stomach) sleeper. Is there a feather pillow for me?

Of course! Just like regular pillows, feather pillows come in a wide range of support levels. You'll have no trouble finding one that offers just the right amount no matter how you tend to sleep. Some retailers of feather pillows offer density adjustments if you get yours delivered and have a Goldilocks-type experience of "too much support” or "not supportive enough” - they'll tweak it until you say it's just right.

How do I clean my feather pillows?

The best approach is to never need to wash it, by using pillow protectors in addition to pillowcases. Why? Washing a feather pillow can make the feathers and down more brittle, due to the feathers' natural oils being stripped away. And, if you don't dry your pillow properly after washing it (in cold water, never hot), it could wind up smelling terrible. Consider putting on a proper-fitting pillow protector and pillowcase before you use your feather pillows for the first time.

How long do feather pillows last?

Good news: with proper care, your pillows should last anywhere from 5-10 years (or longer!). The more you keep them protected from moisture and body oils, the more life you can expect to get from them. That's a lot longer than the 1-2 years that most synthetic pillows last.

When should I replace my pillows?

If you've taken the steps to keep your feather pillows clean, you should only need to replace them when they no longer offer the support you need. If you're constantly fluffing them, or if you fold them in half and they don't expand back to full size, it might be time to get new ones.

Are feather pillows expensive?

They can be: you'll find super high-end pillows priced at over $400. On the other hand, it's possible to find basic feather pillows for under $20. Keep in mind that they can last many years longer than synthetic pillows, giving you a better return on your bedding "investment”.

Can I return my feather pillows if I don't like them?

That depends on where you buy them from. Some retailers have extremely generous return policies, letting you use the feather pillows for up to 8 months before deciding if you want to get a refund. But, most stores expect the pillows to be in unused condition to be eligible for a return, so be sure to use a pillow protector right away in order to keep them in like-new shape.

Continued from above...

Feather pillows are also celebrated for their longevity. High-quality feather pillows can last for many years, maintaining their shape and support even with regular use. This durability makes them a cost-effective choice in the long run compared to some other pillow materials that tend to lose their shape and support over time.

When it comes to home interior, feather pillows have long been a popular choice in the world of bedding and interior design. These pillows offer a unique combination of comfort, durability, and aesthetic appeal, making them a preferred choice for many.

Interior decorators often choose feather pillows for their aesthetic appeal and versatility. Feather pillows have a timeless and classic look, making them a perfect fit for various interior design styles. They add a touch of luxury and coziness to bedrooms, living rooms, and other spaces. The plump appearance of feather pillows can instantly elevate the visual appeal of a room: a valuable addition to any interior design project.

If you're looking for feather pillows, you may be surprised that there are vast differences in quality, price, and reliability. To help determine where you should buy feather pillows online, consider the following:

Value. Compare prices across different retailers to find the best deal for the quality you want. Don't forget to look at shipping costs too.
Quality of materials. Look for pillows made with high-quality feathers and encased in a durable cover. Higher fill power feathers are generally better in terms of loft and support.
Size and firmness options. Choose a retailer that offers a range of sizes and firmness levels to match your personal sleep preferences.
Customer reviews. Reading reviews from other buyers can provide insights into the quality and comfort of the pillows offered by a specific store. That may also give you a window into the level of customer service offered by the retailer.
Return policy and warranty. Ensure the shop has a customer-friendly return policy and a warranty that guarantees the pillow's durability.

To help you get a dreamy night's sleep (or the perfect finishing touches for your latest decorating project), the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have evaluated and ranked the most popular retailers of feather pillows. Happy shopping!