Bed Bath & Beyond Review

Tuesday, March 18th

2025 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Bed Bath & Beyond

• Over 1,800 feather pillows in inventory
• 200+ pillows for sleeping
• Acquired by Overstock
• Free shipping on all orders in the lower 48 states
• 30-day return window

Bed Bath and Beyond, a once-familiar name associated with malls and frequent blue-and-white coupons, may surprise you. They've transitioned, acquired by Overstock, and now operate in a whole new way. Shopping for feather pillows on their revamped website is a different experience, mirroring what you'd expect from previous experiences shopping with Overstock. Unfortunately, in-person options like buying online and pick up in-store, or easy in-store returns aren't part of the deal, as there are no physical retail locations anymore.

Vast majority of feather pillows are for show

Bed Bath and Beyond has an extensive inventory of feather pillows to choose from: over 1,800 at the time of our most recent visit. At the lowest end of the spectrum are a lot of decor-type throw pillows, with lots of options under $15. In fact, most of the feather pillows here (about 1,600 of them) are specifically for decorating and not for sleeping. If you prefer just to see what's available for a good night's rest, we recommend using the filters; "type of sleeper” is one that can get you there quickly.

Decent selection of sleeping pillows

When we asked to see the results for "any” type of sleeper, we found just over 125 options. They ranged from a bargain-priced ($28.80) pillow from Canadian Down & Feather Company to an 800 loft pillow from Highland Feather starting at $189.49. But, with over 1,400 reviews, Bed Bath and Beyond's Hotel Grand Siberian White Down 500 Thread Count pillow is the most popular in the inventory. It's not a super-spendy option, with a list price of $83.99 and a sale in place that brought it down to just $64. But, as you might remember from the Overstock days, quantities and sizes can be limited here, and this pillow was only available in Jumbo and King options at the time of our visit.

Get your pillows right on time

The ability to enter your zip code for estimated delivery dates on feather pillows is a handy feature, helping you plan for on-time arrival for your bedroom decor overhaul or guest visits. Bed Bath and Beyond offers free shipping on all orders within the continental US.

30-day returns

However, if you need to make a return, it's not free. You have a 30-day window from the delivery date to initiate the process, but the shipping cost is your responsibility. There's no preprinted label, and the return shipping cost will be deducted from your refund. Your pillow also needs to reach BBandB within 45 days of when you received it.

What effects will the rebranding have?

We're cautious about giving Bed Bath and Beyond our full recommendation. The Overstock transition and rebranding, which followed BBandB's public bankruptcy and closure of physical stores, has left us somewhat hesitant with our purchases here. We felt a lot of loyalty towards the original Overstock, and we may feel more secure after things settle down. After all, assessing current customer feedback can be tricky. Is it from before the merger or after? Will it improve or decline as the transition progresses?

Tentatively recommended

Can you buy the feather pillows of your dreams at Bed Bath and Beyond? Maybe. Should you? The verdict is still pending. If you come across the perfect pillow that's unavailable elsewhere, go for it. Otherwise, for the near future, it might be wiser to purchase from a retailer with a less tumultuous recent history.