Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Macy's Review

Saturday, October 16th

2021 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Macy's Review 4 Star Rating


4 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $13.99 to $440
  • 700+ options

While you might not think of a department store when choosing where to buy feather pillows, Macy's has a surprisingly good selection.

Free shipping over $25

If you're looking for an inexpensive feather pillow, Macy's prices start at just $13.99 for the Royal Luxe Quilted feather pillow. Originally priced at $42, it was on sale at the time of our review for just $13.99. You'd need to add a little more to your order to qualify for free shipping ($25 minimum spend). Over 30 customers' reviews, this pillow had a 4 out of 5 star average rating.

Wide range of prices

On the upper end of the scale, Macy's most expensive feather pillow is the Trinity by Simply Down. The original retail price ranges from $750 to $1,100 per pillow, but a promotion in place at the time of this review brought the cost down to $300-$440. This pillow features 650 plus fill power down and a cotton cover with a 300 thread count (though you'd probably have it encased in a pillow protector and/or pillowcase anyway). It comes with a one-year manufacturer's warranty and is made in the USA. We weren't too surprised not to see any customer reviews for this feather pillow, given how many less-expensive options were available: more than 750 sold by Macy's.

Best Feather Pillow Stores

Search options

Because there are so many feather and down pillows to choose from, using the filters on the side of the page is a good idea. If there's a brick-and-mortar Macy's near you, you might be able to do store pickup; just make sure you've got your local store entered on the site. You can also see just the feather pillows that are on sale or shop by brand, customer ratings or price. Unfortunately, you can't shop according to size, so you'll have to pick the right ones out on your own when you have your results list. That list can also be sorted by price, ratings, best-sellers and new arrivals.

90 day return policy

If your feather pillow arrives and doesn't meet your expectations, Macy's has a 90-day return policy. But, your pillows have to be in saleable condition with original tags, so you'll want to make sure you protect them appropriately if you want to try sleeping on them for a night or two before making your decision. Any shipping fees you paid are non-refundable, and you may be responsible for any fees to return your pillows by mail.

Solid option

Macy's is a solid option for buying feather pillows. With a good return policy, plenty of sizes and styles to choose from, and a relatively easy-to-use website, this department store earns a good rating.

Where Can You Buy the Best Feather Pillows?

If you've ever gotten the best night's sleep of your life when spending a night at a luxury hotel, you might be wondering where you can buy their feather pillows for your own home. You're in luck: there are a number of online retailers who can make your sweet dreams a reality by offering the very same pillows for purchase. But why are feather pillows so popular?

Many people prefer natural materials over synthetics, and some customers say that having feather- or down-filled pillows makes for a cooler, more comfortable rest. Plus, compared with foam-filled designs, feather pillows are more easily shaped to your head, neck, or any other body part that needs gentle support.

The Best Feather Pillow Stores Compare Feather Pillow Stores Compare Feather Pillow Store Reviews What are the best Feather Pillow Stores Best Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Feather Pillow Store FAQ

As the name suggests, a feather pillow is filled with at least 51% feathers, usually sourced from geese. They have a very different feel compared to regular pillows, often offering a much more comfortable night's rest. That's why you'll find feather pillows in high-end hotels and resorts.
Feather pillows are classified by their blend of feathers and down. You can get pillows that are 100% feathers, a blend of 75/25, and so on. You can also find differences in the shell material, ranging from Egyptian cotton to 100% organic (but either way, you'll probably have your pillow in a pillowcase).
Of course! Just like regular pillows, feather pillows come in a wide range of support levels. You'll have no trouble finding one that offers just the right amount no matter how you tend to sleep. Some retailers of feather pillows offer density adjustments if you get yours delivered and have a Goldilocks-type experience of "too much support" or "not supportive enough" - they'll tweak it until you say it's just right.
The best approach is to never need to wash it, by using pillow protectors in addition to pillowcases. Why? Washing a feather pillow can make the feathers and down more brittle, due to the feathers' natural oils being stripped away. And, if you don't dry your pillow properly after washing it (in cold water, never hot), it could wind up smelling terrible. Consider putting on a proper-fitting pillow protector and pillowcase before you use your feather pillows for the first time.
Good news: with proper care, your pillows should last anywhere from 5-10 years (or longer!). The more you keep them protected from moisture and body oils, the more life you can expect to get from them. That's a lot longer than the 1-2 years that most synthetic pillows last.
If you've taken the steps to keep your feather pillows clean, you should only need to replace them when they no longer offer the support you need. If you're constantly fluffing them, or if you fold them in half and they don't expand back to full size, it might be time to get new ones.
They can be: you'll find super high-end pillows priced at over $400. On the other hand, it's possible to find basic feather pillows for under $20. Keep in mind that they can last many years longer than synthetic pillows, giving you a better return on your bedding "investment" .
That depends on where you buy them from. Some retailers have extremely generous return policies, letting you use the feather pillows for up to 8 months before deciding if you want to get a refund. But, most stores expect the pillows to be in unused condition to be eligible for a return, so be sure to use a pillow protector right away in order to keep them in like-new shape.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

That feature makes feather pillows equally popular with interior decorators: a good down-filled pillow can be plumped, fluffed and shaped to look absolutely perfect in a model home or social media photo. In fact, there are online stores dedicated solely to feather throw pillows for home decor!

Whether you're freshening the look of your living room or replacing your flattened bed pillows, shopping online puts the best selection of feather pillows at your fingertips. But, not all stores are created equal. Here are a few helpful criteria to keep in mind as you decide where to buy your pillows:

  • Selection. The best stores carry a wide range of inventory, from budget-friendly basic styles to hotel-level luxury pillows.
  • Pricing. How do the prices compare to other retailers'? Are there any perks like free shipping or promo discounts that can make your purchase even more affordable?
  • Ease of Navigation. If a store has a great selection of pillows but their website makes it hard to find what you need, you might wind up feeling frustrated. Choose a retailer with a well-designed online store to minimize hassles.
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about their experience with the store and their satisfaction with the feather pillows they purchased?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best online retailers of feather pillows available today. We hope this information helps you get exactly what you need for a blissful night's sleep!

The Best Reviews of Feather Pillow Stores