Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Company Store Review

Sunday, April 14th

2024 Feather Pillow Store Reviews

The Company Store Review 3 Star Rating

The Company Store

3 Star Rating
  • 18 feather and down pillows to choose from
  • Prices range from $30 to $449
  • Free shipping on orders of $75+
  • 30-day return policy and "Rest Easy" guarantee
  • Save 20% when you sign up for emails
  • In business since 1911
  • Acquired by The Home Depot in 2017

The Company Store has a history dating back to 1911 in La Crosse, Wisconsin, as Scandinavian immigrants looked for ways to keep warm during Midwestern winters. Even over 100 years later, the retailer carries numerous types of bedding ideal for staying cozy, sleeping comfy, and even drying off after a shower with a fluffy towel. Interestingly, The Company Store was acquired by The Home Depot in 2017 (though you won't easily find that detail on the website. *wink*).

Somewhat limited selection

The inventory of feather pillows at The Company Store isn't quite as vast as some of the retailers on our list, but you'll still have about 18 options to choose from. On the low end, you'll find the Feather and Down Pillow Inserts (Boudoir, Lumbar, Neckroll, and Square shapes/sizes), priced from $30 to $34, and the Company Essentials Firmest Feather and Down style starting at $39. There was also a sitewide "31% off one item" sale that applied to most feather pillows in stock, which made an already-affordable purchase even more so.

$450+ for an incredible night's sleep

But, there's plenty to see on the high-end side at The Company Store too. For the most luxe option, check out the Imperial German Batiste Pillow and Protector set, starting at $449. We're talking 800 fill power European white goose down, covered in light down-proof cotton (350-thread count) and with an additional cambric pillow protector (also 350 thread count) to whisk you away to Dreamland.

Highest-rated pillow is less than $200

But, if the customer reviews are any indication, The Company Store's most popular pillow is the Legends Hotel Best Down style, with nearly 800 ratings at the time of our most recent visit. Available in 4 levels of firmness and 3 sizes, it's priced starting at $159 and has white European 600 fill power down and a shell of 245-thread count. Averaging 4.4 stars out of 5, customer reviews praise this pillow for offering an excellent night's sleep, superb neck support, and being great for all sleeping styles.

Best Feather Pillow Stores

Rest easy with 30-day guarantee

At The Company Store, you'll get free shipping as long as your order is $75 or more and is delivered to an address in the continental US. With respect to returns, you'll find a generous "Rest Easy" guarantee: use your feather pillow as much as you like for up to 30 days. You can even wash it, sleep on it, and so on (just don't damage it). You'll get a full refund, minus a $2.95 shipping fee per item.

Complaints are concerning

With all of those positives, you're probably wondering why The Company Store isn't ranked higher among retailers of feather pillows. It comes down to customer feedback, outside of what we see on the pillows themselves. There's no BBB listing for The Company Store (maybe because of the acquisition by The Home Depot), and in other places we looked (like Trustpilot and Sitejabber), the feedback trends really negative: "poor quality" , "didn't survive the first wash" , and "they sent me used items" are just a few of the complaints we spotted.

Good but not great

We still give The Company Store a three-star review, mostly because we're pleased to see hundreds of reviews on most of the feather pillows they carry, and we appreciate the try-it-out guarantee. However, we can't overlook the recent comments from customers that make us wonder if this retailer's commitment to shopper satisfaction has declined since being acquired by the big-box home improvement store. We suggest looking at the higher-ranking feather pillow stores on our list first, and circle back to The Company Store if you don't find what you need there.

Where Can You Buy the Best Feather Pillows?

There's a reason why the world's top hotels and resorts feature feather pillows. First and foremost, they are renowned for their exceptional comfort. The natural softness of feathers, typically sourced from ducks or geese, provides a plush and supportive sleeping experience. Plus, the ability of feathers to conform to the contours of your head and neck allows for a restful night's sleep and relief from pressure points, promoting a good night's rest.

When it comes to purchasing feather pillows, there are several advantages to buying them online over traditional stores. Online shopping offers a wide variety of options, allowing you to choose from different sizes, fill levels, and cover materials to suit your sleeping style or your decor. You typically get detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and competitive pricing, so it's easier to find the perfect feather pillow for your comfort and design requirements.

The Best Feather Pillow Stores Compare Feather Pillow Stores Compare Feather Pillow Store Reviews What are the best Feather Pillow Stores Best Feather Pillow Store Reviews

Feather Pillow Store FAQ

As the name suggests, a feather pillow is filled with at least 51% feathers, usually sourced from geese. They have a very different feel compared to regular pillows, often offering a much more comfortable night's rest. That's why you'll find feather pillows in high-end hotels and resorts.
Feather pillows are classified by their blend of feathers and down. You can get pillows that are 100% feathers, a blend of 75/25, and so on. You can also find differences in the shell material, ranging from Egyptian cotton to 100% organic (but either way, you'll probably have your pillow in a pillowcase).
Of course! Just like regular pillows, feather pillows come in a wide range of support levels. You'll have no trouble finding one that offers just the right amount no matter how you tend to sleep. Some retailers of feather pillows offer density adjustments if you get yours delivered and have a Goldilocks-type experience of "too much support" or "not supportive enough" - they'll tweak it until you say it's just right.
The best approach is to never need to wash it, by using pillow protectors in addition to pillowcases. Why? Washing a feather pillow can make the feathers and down more brittle, due to the feathers' natural oils being stripped away. And, if you don't dry your pillow properly after washing it (in cold water, never hot), it could wind up smelling terrible. Consider putting on a proper-fitting pillow protector and pillowcase before you use your feather pillows for the first time.
Good news: with proper care, your pillows should last anywhere from 5-10 years (or longer!). The more you keep them protected from moisture and body oils, the more life you can expect to get from them. That's a lot longer than the 1-2 years that most synthetic pillows last.
If you've taken the steps to keep your feather pillows clean, you should only need to replace them when they no longer offer the support you need. If you're constantly fluffing them, or if you fold them in half and they don't expand back to full size, it might be time to get new ones.
They can be: you'll find super high-end pillows priced at over $400. On the other hand, it's possible to find basic feather pillows for under $20. Keep in mind that they can last many years longer than synthetic pillows, giving you a better return on your bedding "investment" .
That depends on where you buy them from. Some retailers have extremely generous return policies, letting you use the feather pillows for up to 8 months before deciding if you want to get a refund. But, most stores expect the pillows to be in unused condition to be eligible for a return, so be sure to use a pillow protector right away in order to keep them in like-new shape.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Feather pillows are also celebrated for their longevity. High-quality feather pillows can last for many years, maintaining their shape and support even with regular use. This durability makes them a cost-effective choice in the long run compared to some other pillow materials that tend to lose their shape and support over time.

When it comes to home interior, feather pillows have long been a popular choice in the world of bedding and interior design. These pillows offer a unique combination of comfort, durability, and aesthetic appeal, making them a preferred choice for many.

Interior decorators often choose feather pillows for their aesthetic appeal and versatility. Feather pillows have a timeless and classic look, making them a perfect fit for various interior design styles. They add a touch of luxury and coziness to bedrooms, living rooms, and other spaces. The plump appearance of feather pillows can instantly elevate the visual appeal of a room: a valuable addition to any interior design project.

If you're looking for feather pillows, you may be surprised that there are vast differences in quality, price, and reliability. To help determine where you should buy feather pillows online, consider the following:

  • Value. Compare prices across different retailers to find the best deal for the quality you want. Don't forget to look at shipping costs too.
  • Quality of materials. Look for pillows made with high-quality feathers and encased in a durable cover. Higher fill power feathers are generally better in terms of loft and support.
  • Size and firmness options. Choose a retailer that offers a range of sizes and firmness levels to match your personal sleep preferences.
  • Customer reviews. Reading reviews from other buyers can provide insights into the quality and comfort of the pillows offered by a specific store. That may also give you a window into the level of customer service offered by the retailer.
  • Return policy and warranty. Ensure the shop has a customer-friendly return policy and a warranty that guarantees the pillow's durability.

To help you get a dreamy night's sleep (or the perfect finishing touches for your latest decorating project), the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have evaluated and ranked the most popular retailers of feather pillows. Happy shopping!

Compare Feather Pillow Stores

Select any 2 Feather Pillow Stores to compare them head to head

  • Down & Feather Company
  • Macy's
  • Pillows
  • Wayfair
  • Walmart
  • Bed Bath & Beyond
  • The Company Store
  • Pillow Decor
  • United Feather & Down
  • Pacific Coast Feather
Down & Feather Company vs Macy's Down & Feather Company vs Pillows Down & Feather Company vs Wayfair Down & Feather Company vs Walmart Down & Feather Company vs Bed Bath & Beyond Down & Feather Company vs The Company Store Down & Feather Company vs Pillow Decor Down & Feather Company vs United Feather & Down Down & Feather Company vs Pacific Coast Feather Macy's vs Pillows Macy's vs Wayfair Macy's vs Walmart Macy's vs Bed Bath & Beyond Macy's vs The Company Store Macy's vs Pillow Decor Macy's vs United Feather & Down Macy's vs Pacific Coast Feather Pillows vs Wayfair Pillows vs Walmart Pillows vs Bed Bath & Beyond Pillows vs The Company Store Pillows vs Pillow Decor Pillows vs United Feather & Down Pillows vs Pacific Coast Feather Wayfair vs Walmart Wayfair vs Bed Bath & Beyond Wayfair vs The Company Store Wayfair vs Pillow Decor Wayfair vs United Feather & Down Wayfair vs Pacific Coast Feather Walmart vs Bed Bath & Beyond Walmart vs The Company Store Walmart vs Pillow Decor Walmart vs United Feather & Down Walmart vs Pacific Coast Feather Bed Bath & Beyond vs The Company Store Bed Bath & Beyond vs Pillow Decor Bed Bath & Beyond vs United Feather & Down Bed Bath & Beyond vs Pacific Coast Feather The Company Store vs Pillow Decor The Company Store vs United Feather & Down The Company Store vs Pacific Coast Feather Pillow Decor vs United Feather & Down Pillow Decor vs Pacific Coast Feather United Feather & Down vs Pacific Coast Feather
Compare the Best Feather Pillow Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Feather Pillow Stores
The Best Reviews of Feather Pillow Stores